In this Hot Question, retired FBI Special Agent Scott Payne explains how his teenage involvement in Satanism later collided with his undercover work inside a violent white supremacist group. Payne says his fascination with witchcraft and evil began around age 13 and ended after he saw what he describes as a demonic figure while pretending to be possessed. Terrified, he walked to church the next morning and never returned to devil worship.
Years later, undercover as “Pale Horse,” Payne infiltrated The Base and found himself in the Georgia woods on Halloween night during a ritual goat sacrifice. He describes members killing the animal, collecting its blood, and using the ritual as part of an extremist ideology built around violence and belonging.
Payne says the same forces that once drew him toward darkness as a teenager, power, identity, and the need to belong, were also present in the people he later investigated.
Well, I think I read somewhere that you get into Satanism.
Like, again, that I don't care, that I don't give an F.
I was applying it to everything.
As I'm laughing like the demon, I was facing the back of the couch.
But as I'm laughing like the demon, I roll over.
And as I roll over, what I see is a watery image in red.
And it was a demon or the devil.
But it was a demon looking at me.
And it was smiling.
His fingers were all, like, crooked with long fingernails.
And as I was laughing, acting like I was being possessed,
I rolled over and saw it.
It was looking at me, smiling, going like this.
Pale horse, pale horse, you got to wake up.
You got to wake up.
You got to...
You remember us talking about a sacrifice?
I go, kind of.
I mean, I vaguely remember something about it.
We got a goat.
Well, I think I read somewhere that you get into Satanism or something.
Oh, you did, did you?
Yeah, I think I read that somewhere.
That's a nice transition.
How do you go from being in a good Christian Baptist family,
playing at churches, to getting into that?
Again, looking back, I can see what happened.
My parents got divorced when I was about 13.
It all started around 13.
But I just remember them asking me.
They'd come up to me like,
Hey, are you okay with this?
You all right with this?
And I'd be like, yeah, I don't care.
I don't care.
Actually, in my head, I was saying I don't give an F.
You know, in my head, I'm like, I don't give an F.
But that I don't give an F started going into everything that I chose to do.
And I had a friend introduce me to witchcraft and Satanism.
For the listeners, they may not even remember a VCR tape.
But you know, when you could go to Blockbuster or pick a flick and rent movies,
please rewind, be kind, rewind.
Yeah, I remember that.
But I would go to the horror section and I'd go A to Z and watch every single movie they had.
And I started doing like these little skits, if you want to call them that,
where like I would pretend to talk like Freddy Krueger, but worse.
And I would act like a demon.
And I was an idiot.
I was losing my friends.
I had a bad attitude.
And I'm talking about my friends that in the book I put in there.
We called ourselves the Brew Crew.
But we spelled it like Motley Crew.
And that was our high school group.
And we're still tight to this day.
Matter of fact, I'll be seeing them in a couple of weeks.
But they were starting to move away from me.
They're like, man, you got to let that stuff go.
We love you, but we can't.
You can't put up with this stuff.
And I would do, I was just evil.
Like, I'm not a huge hunter.
I will hunt if I need to.
For some reason, I don't have a problem hunting birds and stuff.
And I love fishing.
But during that phase, I shot everything that came into my yard.
And I was out of cruelty.
I was going through some, I was going through some stuff, right?
What was the draw?
Evil.
Power.
Yeah.
You got power out of that?
Well, you think you do.
You see what I'm saying?
You're like, it can corrupt.
It can corrupt.
And it's a lot like what I saw in my law enforcement career.
You just want to belong.
You want to fit in somewhere.
And yeah, I was pretty evil.
So that's really why I don't do it now.
I don't have a problem.
I have roommates.
My best friends do it.
We'll cook it up, whatever.
But as far as me pricing it out and learning what all I got to do,
I'm like, I'll just go to Kroger.
I was about there.
But I was doing things like I had a Volkswagen bug, oddly enough,
for my first vehicle.
So you got to get that worked on in a different place, right?
I don't imagine you driving a Volkswagen bug.
A lot of headroom.
I think it was a 1970.
1970 white, white bug.
That was my first vehicle.
So no wonder you got into it.
You take it.
The place we took the car to get fixed or worked on was a Christian shop.
And it's openly Christian.
Christian music and everything.
And man, I would play like, it would be like maybe Halloween or some supposed
satanic band from the 80s.
And I would set the cassette so when you cranked up the car, it would be right
at a very horrifying part of the song or something.
And I would do that just out of pure spite and evilness.
So, as the story ends, one night I was doing this skit.
We were drinking, no hallucinogenics, nothing like that, just beer.
And I was spending the night at a house and my buddy and his girlfriend were on
the bed and I was on the couch.
And I was acting like a scene that I'd seen in one of the movies where it was
a demon possession.
So, I'm acting like my voice is fighting the demon voice.
And then I would talk in the demon voice and then I would talk in my voice and
be scared and be like, no, no.
And at the end, it culminates, the scene culminates with me laughing like the
demon because the demon wins and it's now possessed me because I saw that in
the movie.
And like again, that I don't care, that I don't give an F, I was applying it to
everything.
And as I'm laughing like the demon, I was facing the back of the couch, but as
I'm laughing like the demon, I roll over and as I roll over, what I see is like
a watery image, but it's red.
It's like, you know, you see the ripples and it's a watery image and red and
it was a demon or the devil, but it was a demon looking at me and it was
smiling.
His fingers are all like crooked with long fingernails.
And as I was laughing, acting like I was being possessed and rolled over and
it was looking at me smiling, going like this, saying, come here.
And I screamed, I screamed a very high-pitched loud scream and from just
here on the couch to hitting the light switch right there, that quick, I was
pale white.
I was pouring sweat, panting, breathing and my buddy Ricky jumped up and he
goes, what?
Because his girlfriend screamed like, what the?
And he goes, what is it?
And I looked at him and I said, if I ever do that again.
I said something to the effect of, if you have my permission, you can take a
bat, crack me over the head with it.
And he had been telling me, you know, but the room just got super calm and it
was like, it wasn't even Ricky.
It was like, it was like the spirit looked right at me and said, because it
just calmed down.
He looked right at me and went, I told you didn't I?
And I was like, yes, you did.
And I didn't sleep that night.
I walked to church.
I didn't have my car.
I hitched a ride over.
What did it look like?
The demon?
Yeah, I saw red, so it was a red background, red image and the demon was
red, but you can see the outline of the demon and you can see the face was
kind of stretched and horns and just the finger, man.
This black.
Yeah, just looking at me smiling.
Come here.
And that was it.
That was it for me and devil worshipping.
I was done.
That was it.
So I started, so yeah, I grew up Christian.
I remember when I went to get baptized and they asked you, they say, you've
been saved.
I said, yeah, they said, well, when were you saved?
I said, which time?
And they said, what do you mean which time?
I said, man, I went to a Christian school my first seven years and like
every week or every couple of weeks, they'd bring in a new preacher and
they'd go hellfire and brimstone and they'd do an altar call.
I felt guilty at every one of them.
I got saved every time there was a preacher that came there.
Maybe I needed to be done twice.
You know what I mean?
He's still a little dirty.
So Halloween evening, it was weird because it had been like it hadn't been
cold that year yet, but that's the night the cold front blew in and it
dropped to like it went from like 60 to 20.
So I'm not a former Navy SEAL.
That was a little fast for me to to acclimate.
I even went to Walmart and bought some base layers.
I'm like, I did not know it was going to get this cold.
So we do I do hand-to-hand combat.
That's the thing I brought to the table, but you know when the lawyers at
headquarters are like what you're teaching them.
I'm like, no, I'm not doing the Patrick Swayze rip the throat out thing.
I'm not teaching them how to do that because it's real man the real Roadhouse
but I said, I'm just going to do some ground escapes, you know, somebody's
in a full mount or you're in full guard whatever and we did that we did
some carbine training and then that cold front blew in and we're out there
and we're just messing around got tent set up fire going and I go to charge
my phone and you know how it is when you're frozen and you hop in that
warm truck and start kind of after you made after had a one or two to you
know, you get in there get that toasty and kind of not off a little bit.
So I nodded off and I woke up to my door beating pale horse pale horse.
You got to wake up.
You gotta wake up.
You can't you ain't gonna believe this.
You can't believe this.
I'm like what the hell jump up like what and I go come out here.
You got to see this.
I'm like, yeah, they go.
You remember us talking about a sacrifice.
I get kind of I mean, I vaguely remember something about we got a goat
and I'm like what they had gone.
I'm at probably not even a mile down the road.
You pass it coming in to the property.
Dude's got three goats.
They went out there in their flecked arm with the balaclavas, which was
their look when I got introduced when I got introduced or accepted into
the base.
I was issued my balaclava and I was issued the base patch, which was
three eyewise rooms, which signifies birth death rebirth.
So the three three rooms so they go out there with their balaclavas
all flecked on camoed out a ours ak-47s jumping this dude's backyard
and he heard him or so they started making noise.
Everybody beds down.
This dude comes out with a flashlight.
I'm like, it's a wonder.
Nobody got killed, you know, so they still this goat or Ram.
I don't know the difference.
It was a big goat with horns and I get out and one of the one of the
other dudes in the group.
Who's who's Monica with Dima?
He says man, this goat shitting all over the bed of the truck can't go
back had a had a Chevy Colorado SR 2 or ZR 2 SR.
Anyway, nice truck at all kinds of stuff to it.
Small block diesel.
I think either way it's crapping all over the bed of the truck and I
go, well, I'd be crapping all over the place to have a bunch of
Neanderthals and flecked on just jerked me out of my backyard, you
know, so I see eyes and eyes and as a member and he's the one that's
going to be pretty he's going to lead the block tonight on Halloween
night and he he's over there loving on the go talking to it and I'm
like, this is weird.
I walk over and I go.
Hey, is it bad that I feel sorry for the goat?
He said don't let the go here.
You say that because his name's Gar.
He named him Gar because his middle name is Garfield named after his
grandfather Garfield who my understanding was also a white
supremacist.
So now the goats name is Gar and he says listen, we don't need any
negative vibes.
This goat needs to know it's going to Valhalla.
We're going to sacrifice this goat.
It's going to Odin tonight.
This is a good thing and and we don't need any negativity, you know,
we don't need the other guys here and calls like that and I said, okay,
man, I'm just gonna take that baseball and push it down and never let
it back up, you know, and I go over.
Because we're getting ready and the rules were hey, no weapons down at
the holy spot.
So we bench everything and I go to my truck and I go into my listening
device because if I'm out, there's a cover team out.
You might not be right around the corner, but I'm covered until I go
to bed.
But because I was staying on that property all days, I had 24-hour
coverage.
They were running shifts, you know, somewhere down the road, maybe an
abandoned place with a generator in it, whatever.
I don't know, but they're all set up and monitoring and I go to my
listening device and I go, hey, I'm pretty sure we're getting ready to
go down here and kill this goat and I'm like, I'm racking my brain
trying to think of anything.
Should I stop this?
Should I not stop this?
But I'm giving you guys the opportunity.
If you can come up with a reason for me not doing it or you don't want
me doing it.
You need to let me know and I stared at my device and I waited and I
waited and I waited and I didn't hear anything and I went I leaned
into the device and I said, well, I guess we're going down here to do
a sacrifice.
So we go down in the woods, decent little walk, scary, scary the first
time I did it.
I'm at first I'm walking down there.
I'm like, I'm actually getting butterflies right now, man.
I'm like a demon start flying.
I don't know.
I'm start trying to kill everything.
But we walk down and we get to the holy spot and we all get in a circle.
What's the holy spot?
It's just a patch of the land down there where that's where we're going
to do our rituals.
I mean like tiki torches set up a little square area.
They may even draw like a whatever but that's where we would hold our
blots and he just started Luke TMB just started referring to it as the
holy spot or maybe we all did because that's where we're going to do
our ritual.
And again, it's not true pagan.
They're twisting it to their white supremacy beliefs just like Christian
identity was twisted by neo-nazis.
They call it Christian identity is taking the Bible and twisting it to
white supremacy, which is not the Bible and not Christian.
So we get down there.
We're all in a circle around the goat somehow ended up at the back of
the goat and eyes and is doing the spiel.
He's doing the block and he's saying that on this sacrifice.
We're going to start the wild hunt the wild hunt in Norse mythology is
essentially Odin and a bunch of other gods going out in the middle of
night and laying the smack down to all their enemies.
The white supremacy version is this sacrifice is going to signify the
beginning of the wild hunt and that's us cleansing the world of darkness
ie non whites anti-fashion.
So he does the block and he comes over to sacrifice the goat and he's
got it's bigger than a machete.
It wasn't a sword.
I mean if I went back and looked at it, maybe it is a machete, but it
was something that looked bigger than a machete to me.
Big blade though, and he's a stocky kid and I'm holding the goat and
he's in and he's he's practicing.
He's like when somebody people getting impatient somebody like just do
it this way to make a couple practice when you just do it man.
He rears back with all his mind.
He comes down and I'm holding this good.
He hits it right on the back of the neck and I guess picturing the head
was going to chop off or something.
It goes dunk and all you hear is back and I went I don't think it broke
a hair.
I don't know if the blade was dull or if the back strap of the goat is
so thick but in that split second in my mind, I'm like, oh, this is
going to get bloody man.
This is going to be I'm just picturing something nasty happened and
then somebody's like do it again.
It's going to take two swings and then somebody says does anybody got
it?
I think pestling says does anybody have a pistol?
Well, remember nobody supposed to bring a weapon down there zoom.
Nat says I got one to which me and TMB.
I didn't mention this TMB ran a tight range to I was happy with how safe
him and him and pestilence were running firearms training.
It made me feel safer, you know TMB and I both were like what the one
dude who shouldn't have a weapon the most uncoordinated unsafe who had
been up for over 48 hours straight.
I think he worked third shift in Austin, Texas and drove on Adderall
non-stop all the way to Rome, Georgia.
And here we are night one.
He goes.
I got mine Luke takes it from him.
He hands it to Eisen.
We're all still in the circle on our knees eyes and chambers around
starts to point towards the goat and then turns away with his finger on
the trigger.
And that's when the instructor in the came out.
I was like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
He goes like a man.
Look at what you're shooting at.
We're on a daggum circle.
What are you doing?
So he's all right, he looks boom goat drops minutes go by you hear stuff
like yeah, man, you know going to Valhalla whatever man if you're Jewish
God all this stuff white power and it's still kicking still kick and I
go over guys and I said once you put another round in it because I think
it's dead.
I said, yeah, but I mean, you know for the love of the goat and all
wounded arriving in Valhalla happy, right?
Not twitching.
Yeah.
Yes.
Yeah.
It is a boom this and you hear somebody say, oh, it's definitely dead
now.
So I think I'm done.
No, we're not done.
Now.
They take a knife and cut the throat of the goat gar.
They fill this cup up with all his blood and Eisen has brought acid.
So now everybody's still in the circle, but I got a flashlight and I'm
shining it for I'm shining it for Eisen and he's tearing the tab off.
Not everybody did acid.
I didn't of course, but he's tabbing and then they chase it with the
blood tab it chase it with the blood and we're going around the circle
and I remember Luke TMB getting kind of nervous because he's like he's
already taken the tab and chased it with the blood and he's like he
goes.
Hey, I had a couple of beers before this.
I've never done this before.
Is it okay?
If you have beer, what happens if you have beer?
He's just going on.
What happens if you have beer?
Yeah, I look at I go.
It's a little late.
You're on it now.
No matter where you're watching the Sean Ryan show from if you get
anything out of this at all anything.
Please like comment and subscribe and most importantly share this
everywhere you possibly can and if you're feeling extra generous head
to Apple podcast and Spotify and leave us a review.