Lecture: Greek City-States

Historical Identity
26 followers
2 Video Views·Aug 19, 2026
Lecture: Greek City-States
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis lecture examines the ancient Greek city-state, or *polis*, as a community centered on reason, justice, and the pursuit of a \"good life.\" It explores the physical layout of these cities, the philosophical role of *logos* (reasoned speech), and a comparative analysis of monarchy, oligarchy, and democracy, emphasizing that government should exist as a service to its citizens.
Hey, hello, World History students and welcome to our first lecture for the Greek and Roman Unit 2.
And today we're going to be looking at Greek city-states.
And so you should have your outline that I gave you in class, or if you lost it,
there's a place on Google Classroom where you can print a new one.
But as you listen to this lecture, please track some of the main points on your notes
and be ready to discuss those tomorrow in class.
So let's jump right in. You'll notice there's always three parts and then a so what conclusion.
Here we go. So first off, let's talk about city-state.
So in ancient Greece, it was pretty much organized similar to Samaria,
where there was not a united Greek empire. Not yet.
We're going to get to Alexander. But each city, individual city, like the again,
the Mesopotamian cities of like Ur and Uruk and Eridu and stuff like that.
They were like their own governing entity, their own countries.
So they were independent, but they were united by their culture.
And they're especially united by their language.
The fact that they all spoke the same language.
So thought of themselves as different states or different countries.
But again, they had to worship the same gods, a lot of the same religious practices.
And then, of course, the same language.
In fact, the term they used for barbarian kind of meaning an outsider or really means somebody we don't understand
because barbarian meant somebody who doesn't speak Greek.
So as long as they spoke the language, again, they were kind of into the circle,
even though they weren't a united empire or giant united nation as the country of Greece is today.
And it was interesting because you had all these different city states
and they used all sorts of different types of government models.
There were monarchies, there were oligarchies, there were democracies,
they were kind of mixes in between.
And we're going to be looking at those different types of government in this lecture.
The nice thing was with all these different types, it was almost like a bunch of experiments
where they were constantly trying to come upon what they saw as the best type, best form of government.
These are just some of the most famous or prominent ancient Greek city states.
Athens is probably being one of the most famous that we'll be talking about.
They were notoriously a democracy in which people had the right to rule.
Sparta would become the other powerful and it's also one of the more well-known city states
because of movies like The 300 and The Battle at Thermopylae.
They were an oligarchy in which they were ruled by a council of elders and generals
because they were a highly militarized society.
And I won't go into each one of these, but again, a lot of monarchies.
And each, you kind of see like you'd have flags.
Each city state kind of had their own emblem representing their independent nation,
even though it was pretty much a city and some of the surrounding farmland around it
that constituted that city state.
Okay, just a map to kind of give you a picture of the region.
This is the Aegean Sea just off the Mediterranean.
You have Greece there on the left, Asia Minor, or what we call Turkey today on the right.
You can see up in the top right corner of Asia Minor, the city of Troy,
where we talked about the Iliad last week.
And you can just see the number of city states.
Kylie, Denson, you can see they were largely a naval nation
because they could island hop all over that Aegean Sea
and you got different city states located on each island.
I guess I can't point to it, but Athens is down on that peninsula.
But anyway, but you should see the diversity of these different city states.
And again, they're on the eastern side of the Mediterranean Sea
where modern day Greece and Turkey meet today.
Okay, so key aspects of the city states.
There's five city, central city kind of locations slash institutions
that you want to be aware of.
As different as the different city states were, they would have this in common.
Typically, they had what is called an Acropolis,
and that was a fortress or kind of the center of the government and the religion.
It was usually a high place.
It was usually a place of fortification so that in times of danger,
the invasion or war, the people could go there for protection.
Again, often the center of religious sacrifices and religious festivals.
The government a lot of times used the Acropolis
because it was a fortress to where it's kind of like a bank,
basically Fort Knox where they would keep all the wealth of the city state.
And then you have the Areopagus.
This was where the meeting place.
So this is kind of where you would kind of like the Facebook,
but a physical Facebook where everyone could get together
and discuss the politics or discuss the issues of the day
where if it was a democracy, you could vote
or at least where different debates or announcements or proclamations could be made.
Then you had the Agora or the Agora.
That was the marketplace.
So that's your downtown.
That's where, again, the trading and the businesses would set up
and commerce would take place.
Then you had a gymnasium.
Again, we talked about Arete and how that encompassed all the different aspects of life
including physical health.
And so Greek city-states tended to all have gyms like many modern nations today
where people go and just exercise and train
because they believed as much as school was important for the mind
and work was important for commerce,
you needed to take care of your body.
And so they usually had a gymnasium or gymnasia.
And then you had an amphitheater,
and that was an outdoor theater where plays could be produced.
Theater was extremely important.
It was kind of the number one form of entertainment
where something could be acted out like the Iliad potentially if it was turned into a play.
But almost every Greek city-state we find that they had these outdoor amphitheaters
where, again, a lot of times for religious festivals,
the city would gather to watch various plays.
Here's just a map of what we're discussing there.
A foot map, you can see the city wall
and you can see various gates leading into the city
and the roads heading off in other directions
where then you had the Acropolis,
those lines that are kind of all dashed where it says Acropolis.
That's indicating that there's a mountain there, that it's steep.
And so that is that raised fortress area, the Areopagus.
That actually is going down almost like a bowl
where people then could gather together
and almost like it, kind of like an amphitheater,
but where people could see each other and, again, have those debates
and have those moments of voting and political gatherings.
And then, of course, the Agora, you have the gymnasium.
So this is just one example,
but this is what was repeated time and time again
in these various ancient Greek city-states,
also known as the Polis, which we'll talk about in a moment.
Just a 3D cartoon rendering of what you might have.
Again, the city-state wouldn't only be the walled city.
It would include the farmlands around it
because there's no way you're going to feed everybody.
You had most of the members of a city-state
would actually oftentimes be farmers
and then some who actually lived within the city walls.
And if you were lucky, you had access to the ocean
and you might have a port as depicted in this illustration.
And, of course, that high-raised region in the back,
that is your Acropolis, your fortress.
Okay, so let's talk about something called the Polis.
That's an ancient Greek word, Polis,
and it just stands for the people.
If you know the word politics,
that is derived from the getting together
or the organizing of people.
And so when you have a city-state,
they would often refer to the Polis.
And while the Polis could kind of refer to the city itself,
it more specifically meant the people,
the gathering of the people who live in that,
or community might be actually a good way to name it.
It's the community of the people
who run and organize or live within that particular city.
So it kind of means city in a way,
but it more specifically refers to the community of people.
And the Greeks really thought hard
about what the nature of this gathering
or how people should be organized.
They kind of had a logical track
that started with the most basic Polis,
or I won't say the Polis,
but the most basic relationship or organization
of human beings was man and woman.
You had to bring men and women together
because then that's how you had children.
You would get offspring and you'd get procreation.
Then they said, well, you can't just have
just men and women and their children.
You wanted to have a village.
That would include the extended family.
And that provided not just, again,
one person and one person and their children,
but you'd have protection.
You'd have better help in terms of
division of labor and producing food
and having a culture.
And then the Polis took it a third step farther
where you wouldn't just have one extended family
forming a village,
aunts, uncles, cousins, and all that,
grandparents and all that beyond the nuclear family,
but then you'd have multiple families
agreeing to live together.
And that would form usually a city-state
or a Polis.
And they said what you got from having those multiple families
was this element of justice.
And when they say that it produced justice,
it meant that you might have a way
to get along in your marriage.
That's hard enough, right?
And then you have a way to get along
within your extended family, a little trickier.
But even then, families are going to bump up
against families and you're going to have to interact
with another family.
And that's where the Polis came in.
A Polis was an organization of those multiple families
so that they could partner together
in making sure justice was served,
that they treated each other right,
that people were not being abused,
not taking advantage of, basically coming up with laws
and justice systems and a form of government
to basically help human beings get along
and partner together in terms of
protecting each other
and helping each other live a better life.
That's what a community is.
And so that's what they saw the purpose of the Polis.
Marriage was great, produced offsprings,
villages were fine, protection, food and culture,
but you needed a Polis, you needed a government
in order to have true justice
and help all these different
entities of human beings
learn to get along, because that was what
was ultimately going to allow you to live a happy life.
And the Greeks, being humanists,
seeing the potential
and the opportunity and the goodness
of being a human being, they were very much thoughtful
of how do you live a good, happy
life.
A key aspect of the Polis is the fact
that human beings, among all the
other animals, had the ability of speech.
They said what really brought
the Polis together, what really
brings people together, is their ability
to communicate. Why would we be able to
talk if we weren't supposed to
live in community?
And the Greek word for that was logos,
or logos, and that was our ability
to think
and then express our thoughts
as words. So that was the other key thing, is that
the fact that you can speak
shows you that you have the ability to think
and to reason. We talked that they really value
reason. Well, the outward expression
of mankind's reason, at least
in its best form, is our ability
to talk and interact and use
our words. They also
said that it was the power of words to
declare justice and injustice.
It said on the previous slide that the whole point of having
a government is to help us to get along
and make sure we're protecting
each other and not abusing each other
because we all have competing interests
and competing families and competing priorities.
But it was then our words that
allowed us to say, that is right.
No, that is wrong. That is just.
That is unjust. And so
our ability to speak, and I talked
about earlier how the Greeks valued
rhetoric. They
said, really, it was our ability to speak that we know
good and evil. That if we're just silent,
if we weren't able to communicate, the ability
to really manifest
what is right, what is wrong, what is good,
what is evil, wouldn't be able to do it.
But that human beings and how we speak, we
declare right versus wrong.
And so the polis,
it has a very, again,
powerful thoughts. It wasn't just, oh, we live in a city
together. Oh, we're going to trade together. Oh,
we have to have some laws so we don't kill each other.
That's getting close. But they said,
no, it's when we live together in a polis
and we talk back and forth and we debate,
we negotiate, we
compromise. We say, you know, what is the right
punishment for what just happened here? Or what does
this person really deserve? What is the right price
for this? How should it? And you debate
and you manage and you create something
together through all of your mutual
logos, your mutual
rationalities. But that was a great
moral project
that that was kind of the greatest moral project
of human beings to create
a moral order. So they didn't just see the polis
as a city. They saw it as human beings
living together at their highest
ability to
coordinate and debate and to
find truth. Not just alone,
some scientists in a lab, but no
as social creatures saying, hey,
what is the right way to live and the right
way to get along?
And then kind of just extending that,
again, they really saw government
as a moral project. They really
saw that the way we organize ourselves
and protect ourselves and live together
is a reflection of and even an impact
on our soul, on our character.
And that they would say, you know,
you need a good government
because the government is going to affect people's
character. And that if you have a corrupt
form of government, a corrupt polis,
not based on logos, not based
on reasoning and proper
speech, then you're going to create citizens
who are wicked. And then
they would say vice versa, but you also then need to
cultivate your inward virtue
because only people of internal
virtue could then help produce that
moral government. And so they saw it as this two-way
street that were mutually reinforcing.
Good people make good government,
but also good governments make good people.
Bad people make bad governments.
If you pick the wrong government structure,
you're going to start producing bad people.
So they saw it as, again, a very
kind of a moral mandate to say what is
the proper way to govern these
city-states, the polis.
And I've already stated it once, but
we get this because this is in the Declaration of Independence
in the United States where we say
the government is for the people, by the people
and of the people. And if the government
ever betrays its calling
to protect our rights, we say we should be able
to change our government. We should be able to alter or
abolish it. Go read the Declaration of Independence.
But that's a
principle that our founding fathers took
from these Greek polis where they
said, you know, Aristotle, the
grand student of Socrates and the student of
Plato, he said the polis exists
for the sake of a good life. The whole
point of having a government is that that government
should be aiming towards helping people
have a good life. And so
they put in a lot of energy and a lot of debate
saying, well, then what is the right
kind of polis in order to create
the best life? And that's just
our final point here. Types. Types
of governments. And again, the debate that we'll
be talking this week, which one is the best?
This is one of the great contributions
of ancient Greece when we, in terms
of, they spent a lot of time thinking about
the nature of man. They spent a lot of time
thinking about what is
then the right way for mankind to reason
their way, not only towards scientific
truth or not only towards historical
truth. You know, we've talked about
Thucydides and Hippocrates
and Socrates. But
what is the best way to run a government?
And so we have three
specific types that we're going to discuss.
Leave the thinking to us. We
have the oligarchy, which is the rule by a few.
We have the decide together, vote it.
That's the democracy. And then
you have a crown representing monarchy.
And so the question is, oh,
the purpose of political organization
or the polis or cities
is which one's going to make us
most happy? So I would just look at each
type and the kind of the pros and cons. Oligarchy.
That's a rule by the few. A lot of
times this would be the elders. Sometimes this would
be the very wealthy and powerful. I mentioned
that in Sparta, this was the military generals
because the military
was the most respected and
powerful members of that society.
But it's a rule by a few. Kind of think of it as a wise
council.
The pros of this approach is that
it usually tended towards wise leadership.
That
the people who got on to this
oligarchical rule, they usually were experts
in some sort of field. They had something to
commend them to that
position. They'd earned it through merit somehow.
And so you would have some sort of wisdom
to the leadership. It also
potentially offered advancement. That again,
you might have the goal of one day, if you're
just a common citizen, to becoming part
of the oligarchy. So kind of a motivation
or a goal. And just
the idea of council. The idea that there wasn't just
one mind
trying to develop
and make decisions, but that there was at least
a council of a certain size
corroborating, sharing
ideas, and coming up with the best decisions.
The cons of the oligarchy
were greed.
Again, this kind of small percent.
It would be 1%, 10%,
whatever minority percent of the
population is in control. They could
potentially use the government, use the polis
and the laws for their own benefit
and kind of enrich
themselves. It could kind of become an
emphasis on money. What that means
is that rather than having people
in this position
of ruling based on their
merit, maybe it's just because they're rich.
So again, maybe they're not wise.
Maybe they're not virtuous. Maybe they don't make good
decisions, but they bought their way onto it.
And that could end up
being a corrupting influence for that city
state. And then of course, jealousy.
In that, you could have the
common people or the majority becoming
jealous and embittered and potentially
rebellious towards
that ruling minority
over them. So it kind of fosters
a have and a have not
potentially mindset.
And then for each of these types,
the Greeks, and particularly Aristotle
had...
Actually, let me say Plato,
but maybe I'm wrong. Aristotle or Plato,
they said, when it becomes bad,
what do we call it? When it's corrupt,
when it doesn't go right, what does this type of government
become? Well, an oligarchy, which is
supposed to be kind of a rule by the few
wise, merited ones,
it becomes an aristocracy.
When they say aristocracy, they basically
mean the rule by the very rich and powerful
and what's
implied there is they're in power forever.
And that if you're born into the
aristocracy, you
get to rule, not because you deserve to or
you're good at it, but just because of where
you were born. And if you're born out of it,
then too bad.
You're never going to be able to
move your way into it.
And that the two sides were basically the
few, the aristocracy, their whole
goal in ruling is to keep everybody else
out of the positions of power.
Watch out for oligarchy. If it's not run right,
it can turn into an aristocracy.
A lot of people point to something medieval
or even late colonial Europe
where, again, people had titles
and power and authority in government
simply because of the money and their
position at birth. Second type,
democracy, demos, the Greek word
for people, so rule by the people.
And again,
the form of democracy that they looked at
was direct democracy, so that city-state
was relatively small compared to some of
our cities today, so that people,
whoever was defined as a citizen
could actually vote and directly make
the laws and directly run the city.
It's not like where they would elect representatives
and those representatives ran the government.
No, the people themselves would gather at the
Areopagus and they would vote
on laws and decisions and policies
to be carried out. During war, it would be
the average citizens choosing what
to do in the next stage of the war.
So we usually call it, sometimes,
direct democracy, and
you can see, as I described that, that's not what we
have here in the United States. We do not have a direct
democracy here, but that is what
when they had this set up in ancient
Greece, that's what they were talking about.
The pros of this, right there, equality,
everyone gets to participate, liberty,
everybody is free to
again participate and
has an equal say in terms of
what's going on, and they can
create the opportunities that they want,
if they want something, a policy change, they can
present that at the Areopagus
and try to make a vote on it.
It has high participation. Everybody's involved.
Everybody can
partake of the decision-making.
Sometimes that can be a little chaotic,
but again,
it oftentimes led to an engaged,
it can lead to an engaged
and
I was going to say intelligent, but an engaged
and thoughtful
people who
care about their community and what's happening to it.
The cons is
it could become frivolous.
It could become where the people just are
voting themselves what they want.
In other words, if we vote for
the government to give us more money, we vote for
the rich to pay for all these
things for the poor. We vote for
something that's just a really bad
decision, because again, when you have
everybody's voting, do they even know what they're talking
about? Are they experts? Should they really be the
one? Should we be listening to everybody
in making these decisions? It could also
lead to complacency, where
they just assume that
because they have the power
to vote, they have the liberty to engage,
but they don't take it. They don't
engage in it, and so just the very few
who are engaged run everything,
and basically it's the idea that nobody
votes. I have the right to vote, but I don't use
it, and they take it for granted.
You can have factions, so that's where you get
basically, you might think of political
parties, where you get different groups organizing,
and those groups become very
come into a lot of conflict
with each other, and they begin to smear each other,
and people begin to, rather than see each other as
fellow Spartans or fellow
Athenians,
they see themselves as, oh, you're a Republican,
you're a Democrat, you're an enemy,
you're a pro this, you're a con that,
and they could almost turn into street warfare
if it devolved bad enough.
Then you get this idea of demagogues,
and a demagogue is somebody who, through the power
of emotional speech, could
sway the masses,
where, again, they vote for policies,
they vote for decisions,
not because it actually makes rational
sense, or they truly believe it, or even
understand it, but they were very persuaded
by that powerful speaker,
and this was a huge problem in ancient
Athens, and I'd say you could consider
mass media today in our own ability
to vote, and how much
our voting is not based upon
our actual
understanding of issues, potentially, but
what do we want personally?
Frivolity. I'm not going to participate
because I just don't care. My life's good.
It doesn't matter if I vote. Faction.
I'm voting for it just because my party agrees
with it, or I'm voting for it because
it just makes me feel good.
What they said, their words, I have an
emotional response, and so
I'm going to vote for that
person or that idea. It sounds
good. And the corruption,
they said, of a democracy was anarchy,
that when you had too many people
with too much power fighting in
faction and without good policy and without
true wisdom, nobody's in charge.
It's chaos, and we're going to be reading
Plato's Republic in which
he's going to address this issue. And again, another way
of saying anarchy is just mob rule.
Whatever the 51% want, whatever they're
fired up about, there's no wise counsel,
there's no checks and balances on their power,
just whatever the majority of people want,
it's going to happen. Just imagine
them running a classroom, not on
a teacher direction, but running it on,
what do the students want? How do they feel today?
Let them all decide just on a raw vote.
Imagine what they might do to the teacher. Imagine
how much they might actually learn. Imagine what they might
do to certain classmates that aren't popular.
It could get ugly really quick.
And that's one of the dangers they saw in democracy.
And finally, you have
monarchy, mono, rule by
one.
And so this was a very prominent one
within ancient Greece, and obviously, probably
the most prominent throughout human history.
The pros of a monarchy is
speed. Decisions can be
made very quickly.
Maybe you've ever, as a family, you're
trying to make a decision, and the parents,
hey, what does everybody want? What does everybody want to eat? Or what do we
want to do today? Well, if it's too
democratic, it takes a really long time, because
everybody has to make their argument, and then things have to be
decided, and nobody can agree.
If it's just dad or mom saying,
this is what we're going to do, and you're going to like it,
you know, like a monarch, then things,
whether you like it or not, at least they happen quickly.
And at least you have a clear direction
in terms of where you're going. You're
united underneath that one direction.
Everyone knows, hey, they're the leader.
We're going to follow them.
There's strength in that.
There's strength in having an example to follow
and having somebody you can look up to
as your leader. And it also
kind of, along with unity, brings
loyalty, because not only
when you think of yourself as a member of that community,
you look to that person, and that person's a
figurehead, whether it's Queen
Elizabeth or Alexander
the Great or whoever your king is, and you say, okay,
I identify with that person, and it brings
kind of a loyalty and a strength and a speed
and a direction to the community.
The cons, well, oppression.
What if you don't like that one person? What if they have
all the power, and they're abusing it?
What if they aren't
doing what's in the best interest of other people,
or they're a poorly equipped ruler?
There's fear, because if you cross
that monarch, you're gone.
You could be punished or killed
or exiled if they don't like it.
And then there's just kind of
a de-emphasization
of the individual. So where there
is strength and unity and cohesive
direction, you're looking at the
larger body, you're not looking at, well, what
about the individual people? What about their dreams?
What about their desires? What about their happiness?
Are individuals being,
are they
having a good life, or are they being
kind of swallowed up in the dreams
and direction and the edicts of that
one ruler?
And the corruption that we would say, a bad
monarch or a bad monarchy
would be what we call tyranny
or a despot or despotism.
So notice, there's an argument to be
made for all three forms, and that's something
we're going to talk about in class, but that's why
it's such an interesting and complex issue,
and that one of the Greeks would have said,
this is a key part of human life.
You know, I've got to be a nice person
and not lie and not cheat and not steal
and achieve arete, but we as a
community, what is our arete?
What is the best way in which we can organize
and govern ourselves together?
Alrighty, you made it. So what?
The Greek city-states. Well, one,
it's important to study politics and
government because it's a key
part of our lives. We've had such a great
government here in the United States for so long,
we kind of just think, oh, living life
is easy, living life is natural, right?
This is just how it is. No,
we as Americans have been given
a certain polis. We have been
given a certain structure in which
we've organized ourselves that,
frankly, works really, really well.
That's this whole idea of Western civilization,
not taking it for granted, and we need to kind of
look into politics
and government, just like the example of the
ancient Greeks, because it was their work
and their rational thought and investigation
into these things that created a model
from which our founding fathers
bequeathed to us what we
enjoy today here in the United States.
Also, just emphasizing
the polis is a part of nature.
It's not something human beings, hey,
I know, let's have a government, but there was something natural
about, again, men and women producing
offsprings, villages of
extended families, and then
different families. How are they
going to get along? Are they just going to kill each other,
warfare, raiding, or
is there an actual natural way they can use
their logos, use their reasoning,
their communication skills, just talk to each other
to form a way in which they can coexist
that will bring each of them the maximum
amount of happiness.
The Greeks kind of basically thought of it
as there's an explanation for the
movement of the stars, there's an explanation for
a natural explanation for disease,
there's a truth to all history,
they believe there is a natural law to government.
If we can discover the best form of
government, it will bring maximal
happiness to human beings.
And quite frankly, I think
we're living to appreciate
we've achieved something very close to that
here in the United States, and it's worth
knowing so that we can preserve it.
And finally, just the idea of what I've already
said again and again, the polis, government
only exists for the
goodness or the happiness,
i.e. the justice of the
people. That the polis,
it's not like, oh, there's a government and people
have to fall into that form.
The Greek idea of a polis, which again
now becomes kind of a western and an American
idea is, it only exists
to serve the people and their
happiness. And if it's not doing that, it should be changed.
And that's why you debate and look at the pros and cons
of the different forms, because
the government is a service to
the people, the polis of the people.
Okay,
we'll be discussing those topics this week in class
and just bring in your notes
so you actually have something to say and a starting
point from which to engage
in the material. All right, see you soon.
