Lecture 8 (The Greek Polis: Sparta)

Historical Identity
26 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 19, 2026
This is an educational series entitled "The Foundations of Western Civilization," presented by Thomas F. X. Noble, professor and historian at the University of Notre Dame, Indiana. This series covers the dawn of civilization in Sumer to the present day.
Produced by The Great Courses
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis lecture examines the classical Greek *polis*, focusing on its physical and social composition. It specifically analyzes Sparta's highly conservative society, detailing its rigid social hierarchy, military-centric education, and political institutions designed to maintain stability and control over subordinate populations, contrasting this authoritarian model with the more volatile Athenian system.
Hello again, and welcome to Lecture No. 8 in our series on the Foundations of Western
Civilization.
The last time we talked about the Greek Dark Ages and the Greek Archaic Period, you perhaps
will recall my saying that during the Archaic Period, or during the period from about 800
to about 700 BC, the first faint stirrings of the Greek polis, the classic Greek political
institution, are visible.
In today's lecture, we're going to talk in particular about Sparta.
In the next lecture, we will talk in some detail about Athens.
So what we're going to try to do is understand the classical Greek polis.
The plural of that word, by the way, is polis, not polises.
We're going to try to understand the polis as a political, as a social, and as a cultural
entity.
Today, and in this lecture, I'm sorry, and in the next one, we'll speak in particular
about the polis of Sparta and then Athens as political and social entities, and we'll
then turn in a series of lectures to the polis as a cultural phenomenon.
Now, a few very preliminary considerations may help us to sort of enter on this discussion
of a polis and what a polis is and what it represents.
First of all, for example, physical characteristics.
What exactly was a polis?
You may think, well, it's a city.
That goes without saying.
That's self-evident.
But it's not quite so simple.
We can express what a polis was by means of a formula.
We can say asti plus kora equals polis.
Now, what that means is this.
Asti is the Greek word for city proper, and it actually refers to the urban core, the
urban center of the polis.
Kora is a Greek word that means region or district.
What this refers to is the agricultural hinterland that surrounded a polis.
So a polis is always an urban core, asti, and a rural hinterland, kora.
So for instance, in Athens, you have Athens plus Attica makes the Athenian polis.
In Sparta, you have Sparta and Laconia, which makes the Spartan polis.
So we always have to bear in mind that there are these two elements and that they have
a very important symbiotic relationship.
Now, inside the urban area itself, the polis of the Greek world had certain features in
common.
There would be great variation, but there were certain features in common.
An agora.
Think of agoraphobia, the fear of public places.
Well, an agora in a Greek city, in a Greek polis, was the marketplace.
An open market was, yes, where products were exchanged, people bought things, people sold
things, but also where people encountered one another, where they talked to one another,
where they shared gossip with one another.
In a sense, the life of the polis was really played out informally, in many ways, in the
agora.
There would almost always be temples, temples dedicated in the first place to the god or
goddess to whom that city was most particularly dedicated, and then for other cults that were
important to the people in that place.
There would also be either a building or a public area, could be the one, where the public
life of the polis was played out in more formal senses.
This is where assemblies met, where legislative institutions met, perhaps where courts of
law met.
In other words, different from the agora, where informally the public life of the city
was played out, the institutional center was where formally the life of the polis was played
out.
There were also, then, entertainment facilities.
Generally, these were of two kinds, theaters.
Many of the surviving Greek polis will show us the remains, sometimes, as for example
in Athens or in one or two other places, very impressive remains of the ancient theater,
and then sometimes also stadiums.
You may recall our saying last time that the Greeks were very much, very enamored of competition,
and that that started with athletic competition that began with the Olympic Games and then
eventually extended itself to games played in many Greek cities.
So not surprisingly, many of the Greek polis had stadiums.
Some polis also had natural fortifications.
Now these could involve, for example, walls around the city, but often there was a high
point.
Cities very often were built around or even on a high point.
In Athens, for example, we have the Acropolis.
Now this is a stone butte that sticks up right in the middle of the city, several hundred
feet above the level of most of the urban core down below it, and this was a place
where, for example, temples and important buildings could be built so that people would
go there in ritual procession, but it was also a place to which people could retreat
if the city were ever attacked by any of its neighbors.
Not every city had an Acropolis.
Athens doesn't have the only Acropolis.
We always think of the famous Athenian Acropolis, but there were, in fact, Acropolis in a number
of Greek cities.
Corinth had one.
So usually there was also some provision provided for defending Aristotle, who wrote a great
deal about Greek government.
We'll have occasion in later lectures to talk in much more detail about Aristotle.
Aristotle believed that people naturally lived in polis, by nature.
We associate with one another.
You may have heard the old statement, Aristotle said, man is a political animal.
In point of fact, that's not quite what Aristotle said.
What Aristotle said is, man is, by nature, a creature who lives in a polis.
Now, of course, what you do in a polis is politikai, is, in a sense, politics.
But that really means city-ics.
We don't quite have that word.
I mean, I need it right now, but I don't have it.
So politics, you see, is what you do in a city, and that's what Aristotle said is natural
to us.
We come together in communities, and we regulate our affairs.
Aristotle was very much interested, as a philosopher might well be, in the fact that over the Greek
world there were a large number of these polis.
We know something, something, historically, about nearly 200 of them.
Aristotle and a number of his pupils, he was running like a research institution, studied
the constitutions of more than a hundred of these polis.
Aristotle reserved it to himself to study the constitution of Athens, and in some later
lectures we'll have occasion once in a while to draw on some of Aristotle's observations
about Athens.
So he studied Athens.
He had his pupils sort of write theses, we might almost say, about a large number of
the other Greek polis, because Aristotle was very interested in discerning what was common,
what was different, were there any underlying, any fundamental principles, you see.
Alas, all of these other works vanish.
We have, thankfully, Aristotle's treatment of the Athenian constitution, but all of these
other studies of the other Greek polis have vanished.
So we know a little from other sources, from histories and chance references in plays and
all sorts of things.
We know a little something about these other cities, and we know that the variation could
be considerable from one city to another.
They were by no means alike.
If we were really interested in the polis, and if we really wanted to explore that subject
in great detail, we'd have to assemble everything we've been able to learn about all of these
polis and compare them and contrast them in all sorts of ways.
We don't have time to do that here.
What we're going to do instead is focus on the two most famous, and in many ways the
two most distinctive, of the Greek polis, Sparta in the first place, and we'll turn
to that in more detail in just a second, and Athens, to which we'll turn in our next lecture.
But I don't want to leave the impression that all Greek cities were either like Sparta or
like Athens.
That's not true.
Sparta's earliest development is shrouded in legend.
By now, that's not going to surprise us.
The origins of everything, it seems, are shrouded in legend.
The Spartans told a story.
Supposedly, a mythical lawgiver by the name of Lycurgus, on the command of the gods, gave
Sparta a constitution all at once in about the year 750 BC.
Well, there are several things wrong with that.
First of all, for instance, we do think Lycurgus is a real historical person.
We do think there was such a person at Sparta, and that he may very well have been an important
reformer.
He may very well have played a significant role in the elaboration of the Spartan system.
But it's also clear, it seems, that the Spartan system emerged over a long period of time
and slowly, and probably, in fact, reached its culmination at about the time when the
Spartans conquered the Mycenaean.
Perhaps you'll recall, in the last lecture, we had said that the pressures of the early
archaic period, or this transitional period, could be met in the Greek world in various
ways.
You could colonize and export your population, for instance, you could engage in trade, or
you could conquer additional land.
And the Spartans, in particular, chose that option.
They conquered their neighbors to the west, the Mycenaean.
So it seems that some aspects of the Spartan system, however old they might have been,
however many sort of embryonic features they may have contained, were really sharpened,
were hardened, after the conquest of the Mycenaean.
Now, that takes place in the 8th century B.C., so the tradition remembering that somewhere
in the 8th century B.C. the Constitution was made is not bad.
Remember we talked about how close Greek tradition on the date of the Trojan Wars is.
We talked about handing things down orally over long periods of time.
Traditions are not false because they're traditions, and legends often have much in them that is
true.
It's sorting out what is true and what is false, in terms of facts, that is tricky.
But when we discuss myth, when we discuss legend, if we are seeking only those few kernels
of truth, we're going to miss the whole point.
Because myth and legend are meant to tell stories that tell much larger truth than the
tiny and humble facts which they contain.
But the Spartans thought then about their past was that a great lawgiver had given them
their system at once.
Now that's worth pausing to think about for just a minute, because in that regard the
Spartans are not unlike a lot of other people.
The Athenians, for example, also thought their laws were given to them by a person called
Theseus.
Now, they never quite, the Athenians didn't, associate their whole system with Theseus,
the way the Spartans did with Lycurgus.
But we might think about Moses, to whom the law is attributed, and yet clearly the law
evolved over a long period of time.
Much later, the Romans remembered a figure called Pompilius as having given them their
law.
There is a tendency always to imagine a founding father, not a founding mother, and that is
interesting as well.
To imagine a founding father, or perhaps founding fathers, think how frequently we Americans
speak of the founding fathers, and how much legend and myth is attached to what they did.
And sometimes we're interested in the facts, and sometimes we're interested in the larger
story, the big picture.
Well, the Spartan system then is revealed to us by a number of ancient writings.
We actually have quite a lot of source material.
We don't have Aristotle's constitution of Sparta, but we have a lot of writings about
Sparta, and we know a lot about the system.
It was in many ways quite a peculiar system.
We might very well think, in the modern world, that a particularly successful political system
is one that is designed to accommodate change.
In other words, one that can incorporate contention, institutionalize contention, diffuse contention,
and move forward.
The Spartan system, on the other hand, was designed not to accommodate, but to prevent
change.
This was one of the most conservative political systems created in human history, and created
such by design, and not at all by accident.
The first feature of the Spartan system that we want to think about, as we proceed along
to try to understand it as a political system and as a social system, because these two
systems complement one another in important ways.
The first feature then that we want to talk about are the social classes at Sparta.
Who were these Spartans?
The first and the most important class of people at Sparta were called the homoioi.
That means the equals.
The equals.
All adult Spartans who were male.
Adult meant above the age of 18.
If you were 18 and a Spartan, and male, you were an equal.
Now these people had very wide opportunities for participation in the Spartan system.
They had substantial rights of political involvement, of political speech, of voting on key issues.
This is interesting and important to us.
However conservative, however traditional, however stodgy the Spartan system was, it
accorded earlier a wider degree of political organization, at least within the equals,
than virtually any other political system had done before this time.
One could actually ask, was Sparta in some sense democratic?
One could say that Sparta was a quasi-democracy, at least among the equals.
Whether or not Sparta was democratic is something that may come into a little bit sharper focus
for us in our next lecture when we're talking about Athens, and we can perhaps develop one
or two comparative insights on the two cities.
So the equals first.
Second, a group of people called the perioikoi.
The perioikoi.
An oikos is a house in Greek.
Peri means around.
These were the people around the house.
Well, not actually around your house, or anybody else's house, meant the dwellers about.
We would say resident aliens.
Resident aliens.
There's a good deal of scholarly controversy over who exactly we are to understand by these
resident aliens.
I won't go into great detail on this.
Some have suggested that they may have been the indigenous population of Laconia who were
there when the Dorians came.
Remember our Dorian invasions around about the 12th century BC?
Some have suggested they may have been people who migrated into Laconia from surrounding
regions.
Some have suggested they may have been people who fell out in political contention in Sparta
in earlier times.
It's very hard to say.
They were people who lived in Sparta, who were protected by the Spartan system, who
had certain rights, who had certain opportunities, but they could never be Spartan citizens,
and therefore they could never participate politically in the Spartan state.
Finally, a very interesting class of people, the Helots.
The Helots were state slaves.
Essentially, these were the conquered Mycenaeans, those neighbors to the west of Sparta whom
the Spartans conquered as a way of sort of relieving the demographic pressures in their
own area.
Now, what is very distinctive about the Helots is that they did not belong to individual
Spartans.
They belonged to Sparta.
Slavery is an old institution.
But in most places, slaves belonged to individuals, as individuals.
In Sparta, the Helots, in a sense as a corporate body, belonged to Sparta as a corporate body.
And it is clear, it seems, that some aspects of the Spartan system were really designed
to keep those Helots in place.
Now, if we turn then from the main social classes at Sparta to the institutions of the
Spartan system, how was the place set up?
How did it operate?
There were in the first place two kings, one, two.
Very interesting.
The idea being that one was a check on the other.
Now over a very long period of time, these kings always came from two families, sons
succeeding to father, generally speaking, occasionally again brothers and others entered
into the line of succession, but kings drawn from two families.
One was usually at home, functioning as in some sense the chief executive officer of
the Spartan state, and one was generally in the field with the Spartan armies.
They didn't send out both kings with armies, and usually they weren't both at home.
Very interesting that these kings had an absolute veto over each other.
If one of them decided to make a decision, the other king could veto it.
There were two deliberative councils at Sparta.
Now, was this the origins in a sense of bicameral legislatures?
In a way, in a way.
But it's very important to understand what these two deliberative bodies at Sparta were
like and how they worked in conjunction with each other.
The assembly at Sparta was an assembly of direct participation, I say direct democracy,
by all the equal.
If you were an equal, you were a member of the assembly.
You weren't elected, you didn't represent anybody, you didn't represent a territory.
As an equal, you belong.
The assembly could propose laws, it could propose going to war, it could propose concluding
a war, it could propose striking a treaty with someone.
But it could not finally legislate by itself.
What it could do in a sense was set an agenda.
That agenda was then in a sense forwarded on to the council.
The council is really the body that guarded the Spartan system, that really made it work.
The council consisted of the kings, two kings, five ephors, and I'll come back to these ephors
in just a second, judicial officers basically.
And then all equals above the age of 60.
All equals above the age of 60.
Now, that's very important and I want to explain that, but a question may have come up in your
mind right now, and it is, this is the ancient world.
This is a long time ago.
Who in the world was 60?
Ah, good question.
Figuring life expectancy as an average of the ages at death of all those persons who
belong to a society will give you one number, which starts in antiquity, for example, is
a fairly low number, probably in the high 20s.
And as we come forward in time, gradually move, for example, in the United States, it
moves to a fairly high number.
In some parts of the undeveloped world today, it remains a depressingly low number.
But if you reckon life expectancy at certain moments in the lifespan, the numbers change
pretty dramatically.
If you lived to be 20 and you were male, your expectation of life was very low.
It was easy to live, well, easy, that's an exaggeration.
It was likely, it was possible to live well into your 60s.
If a woman lived to be 30 or into her early 30s, she was very likely to live a long time.
Childbirth was the great killer of women in the pre-modern world.
The point is, of course, that enormous numbers of babies and adolescents died.
These were societies which could not solve all of the problems that occur at the moment
of birth and all of the problems associated with the diseases of youth and adolescents.
That's where large numbers of people died.
So if you had a large number of people who died at 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 50,
and you average it up, you get a small number.
If you put all of the ones in one category and then think about the people in the other
category, you get a very different number.
So it's not so shocking that there were lots of men at Sparta above the age of 60 to operate
in the council.
Now, back to Spartan politics.
All the equals could propose things to a body made up of the kings of the E4s and the equals
over 60.
They finally said yes or no.
Now, they didn't really have the initiative in the legislative process.
That did come from the assembly of all the Spartans.
But they could stop things they didn't want.
They could stop things they didn't want.
That was their great power, right?
Now, once you had been a member of the Spartan system to the age of 60, you were not likely
to go off on tangents.
You were not likely to have a lot of new ideas.
You were not likely to entertain happily new ideas.
Now, I mentioned E4s a moment ago.
Who were these E4s?
There were five of them.
The word basically means overseers, inspectors in a certain sense.
Their job was to assure that any law passed by the council or any verdict passed by an
Athenian law court was in conformity with the laws of Sparta.
So here was yet another break on the system.
There was another check on innovation.
There was also the cryptaea.
The cryptaea.
Think of the word crypt.
You see?
Secret.
A crypt is a secret place.
Cryptography is secret.
Writing, for example.
The cryptaea was the Spartan secret police.
These were generally young men, usually between about the ages of 18 and 20, whose job it
was to sort of go around and in the first place keep an eye on the helots, but in the
second place to snoop on ordinary Spartans and just to make sure that they were behaving
themselves.
That, then, was the basic Spartan constitution.
Now, it depended on a very curious, very interesting, a very rigid social system, which we called
the agogae.
Now, the agogae means the upbringing, the training, the leading along.
So this is the social system, the agogae, that generated the political system of which
we've just been speaking.
Babies were inspected at birth and healthy ones were returned to their parents to about
the age of seven.
This occasions a pause.
The idea of exposing babies at birth.
The idea of infanticide.
Now, there are lots of famous instances in antiquity.
You may think, just for a moment, of the play Oedipus Rex.
Remember, Oedipus is displayed at a crossroads and left there.
He's found and the story goes on.
In antiquity, exposing a baby was not actually infanticide.
Babies...
You stop and think of the familiar images from literature.
They were exposed in market squares.
They were put on the doorsteps of temples.
They were put on the steps of temples.
They were put at crossroads.
They were expected to be found.
Oedipus was found.
He was raised.
He lived to a ripe old age until various other things sort of intervened in his life.
So, exposing babies in antiquity is certainly not a practice I would want to recommend.
Certainly not one that we would wish to praise.
But it was not the same thing as killing unwanted children.
All right.
So, babies were inspected and if they seemed healthy, they were returned to their parents
until the age of seven.
At the age of seven, boys were enrolled in military brotherhoods to which they belonged
for the rest of their lives.
In a sense, you were sort of put in a military unit and you now were a member of that unit
for the rest of your life.
From seven to 18, they underwent rigorous physical and military training.
Then, as I mentioned a moment ago, from 18 to 20, many of them, not all, but many of
them served at least a brief period of time in the Secret Service.
They then entered a regular army unit and remained a member of that unit to the age
of 60.
Now, there were exceptions made if a person were wounded, if a person were physically
impaired as life went along.
But you could, in principle, have to serve actively in the field to the age of 60.
Marriage at Sparta was not companionate.
It was not co-residential.
That is to say, husbands and wives, generally speaking, didn't live together.
Men lived with their military units.
Marriage at Sparta had one fundamental purpose, to make more equals.
That was the purpose of marriage at Sparta.
And that means, of course, that the institution didn't generate family ties, family loyalties,
bonds of family affection, and so on, as we might expect to see in other societies.
The Spartans lived very simply.
Men lived in barracks, basically.
They ate very simple food.
They prided themselves on their simplicity.
They prided themselves on not being gabby and talking too much.
Their land is called Laconia.
What does laconic mean?
It means you don't have much to say.
And in much Greek literature, there are wonderful stories about Spartans who didn't have much.
The Spartans didn't like book learning.
Now, there's a very interesting point here.
A notion that recurs quite a number of times in Western civilization, amongst other peoples
and in other places.
There was a notion that book learning made men effeminate.
It weakened them.
It softened them.
Now, there is a wonderful irony there, because if it was thought to be the case that book
learning made men effeminate, that sort of implies, doesn't it, that lots of women read
a lot of books, and then somehow that this was a characteristic of females, and yet in
most of these societies, women were actually denied opportunities to acquire a lot of book
learning.
Prejudices get built in very, very funny ways, and then operate in very funny ways.
But there is the notion, remember we talked about the struggle between brains and brawn?
If you've got too much brains, you don't have enough brawn, and at Sparta, you want
brawn.
So enough with the brain stuff.
Spartans used iron money in big bars of small denomination.
The whole point of this was to avoid hoarding, to avoid accumulating.
What do you want money for?
Now, the Spartan system, as I've suggested a couple of times, was designed fundamentally
to hold the helots in check.
Now, without the labor of the helots, the Spartan system simply would not have worked.
How would all of these men have been in military service, in effect, from the age of seven
to the age of sixty, if they had to work in the fields or carry out other pursuits?
So the helots made Spartan life possible.
Now, of course, Spartan's idea was that this gave them the freedom to ward off attack,
to ward off invasion, to keep foes at bay.
By about 550, the Spartans had pulled most of the cities of the Peloponnesus, southern
Greece, southernmost Greece, together into the Peloponnesian League.
Now, this was not kind of a Spartan version of the United Nations.
The members of the Peloponnesian League were under absolutely no circumstances Sparta's
equals.
Sparta basically dictated to the Peloponnesian League what its plans would be, what its policies
would be.
So, essentially, Sparta exercised some control, some control over the constitutions of member
states.
The Spartans did not want a democratic regime.
They thought they were too unstable, too tumultuous, and they wanted to control the foreign policy
of the states of the Peloponnesian League.
They didn't want any military adventurism amongst their neighbors that might have implications
for themselves.
The Spartan system was still fundamentally in place when the Romans conquered Greece
in the second century B.C.
By then, alas, there was a relative handful of equals left.
Contemporaries, interestingly enough, had a tendency to admire Sparta.
They admired its strength.
They admired its simplicity.
They admired its...
Now, there is for us an interesting puzzle and an interesting challenge in that admiration
that was accorded to Sparta, and it's just this.
Most people, I think, would like to live in stable political systems, and then many people
have been tempted toward authoritarian kinds of regimes that seem to them to promise stability,
even if such regimes reduce dramatically the rights of individuals.
There is a tug, there is a pull, there is something that demands from us a kind of a
grudging admiration for systems like the Spartan, and in antiquity, the Spartan system
was much admired.
No one, I think, would say that the Athenian system was stable.
Curiously, it was also not as much admired in antiquity as it would be subsequently.
So, having gotten some understanding of Sparta, we'll turn in our next lecture to the most
famous, and in many ways the most interesting, of the Greek poleis.
