Hakeem Jeffries Pressed On Medicare For All
OPINION: House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries drew backlash, including from fellow Democrat Ro Khanna, for rejecting the idea of medicare for all. #HakeemJeffries #RoKhanna #Healthcare
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video discusses the internal conflict within the Democratic Party regarding \"Medicare for All,\" highlighted by House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries' refusal to co-sponsor the legislation. This sparks a broader debate on the merits of a single-payer system versus a market-based approach, focusing on costs, accessibility, and the ethics of healthcare as a human right.
Democrats in Congress seem to be struggling to come to a consensus on Medicare for All.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries was pressed on the issue by NBC's Kristen Welker,
who pointed out that the congressman has not sponsored Medicare for All legislation
since becoming the Democratic leader. Here was his response.
Do you personally support Medicare for All?
No, as you indicated, I haven't co-sponsored the Medicare for All legislation that has been
introduced over the last several years. I do think we need to figure out how to fix
our broken health care system and then build something better.
That clipped through scrutiny from progressives who accused Jeffries of being out of touch
with what Democratic voters want. Congressman Ro Khanna made it clear that he completely
disagrees with his party's House leader. Medicare for All is arguably the most
important priority. It would save money and it would save lives. It needs to have a vote
on the House floor. The majority of the House Democrats are going to support it.
It is one of the most important policies if you actually believe in saving lives
and in helping increase wages for working class Americans.
Well, Jeffries is not going to endear himself to any Democrats, if there are any who remain
fans of him. He seems scared to me. He doesn't have the vibes on his side.
If he were to endorse Medicare for All, they wouldn't even believe him,
so there's not really an incentive for him to do that.
It was a strangely bad interview and very bad answers because, first of all, Medicare for All
polls very well with the public at large. Among Democrats, it has absolutely overwhelming
support. It's like 85-90% in some polls. Secondly, as we kind of alluded to in the introduction,
Hakeem Jeffries had sponsored Medicare for All legislation when not in his current leadership
position and never really explained, at least in the clips of the interview I saw, why he's not
doing so anymore. There was finally a point in that interview where he said,
oh, we're focused on November 3rd, not January the 3rd. It's a terrible answer because it just
implies we care about winning the election, not about what we will actually do for people
if and when we get the majority. So a very peculiar performance and not a good one,
and one that a lot of people on the left are, in my view, rightly irritated by, at least.
He could say he supported it and then he learned that if we had it, it would bankrupt the entire
country and there would be rationing of care and you'd be waiting in lines for forever.
Is he auditioning to be a Reason magazine columnist?
It wouldn't work at all, but I guess he's not going to say that. I don't know what
Ro Khan is going on about it's going to hire wages. What does that have to do with wages?
Because you'd spend less of your wages on health insurance, I guess.
Or it's going to save money. I mean, again, our health care system is very bad
and there are a lot of middle managers in health care and health care insurance industry
who gobble up a large amount of money. The health providers, the service providers,
the doctors, et cetera, their profits would be shrunk. I don't have any problem with that,
but we all still have to pay for the health care. So if there's more people getting whatever,
again, the government just provides you whatever health care you need.
As it should, Robby. Human rights.
Okay, somebody has to pay for this. We all have to pay for this.
General taxation.
Right now we're doing it already for old people and for very poor people. And so now we're just
going to do it for everyone. So that's going to cost astronomically more than now.
Why is it going to cost astronomically more than now given that we're taking the middlemen out of
it? It is true that the rate of, that there would have to be taxes raised to pay for it,
and people need to be more honest about saying that. But the point is that you and I and our
friends here in the studio with us wouldn't have to pay the health care premiums that we pay now,
nor would our employers.
But we would have to, there would also have to be like rationing of care,
or there would have to be decisions about who gets, because some things are just,
look, there's a finite amount of people who can do brain surgery, or heart surgery,
or spinal surgery, and we have to, well, okay, your case is more compelling. You get it. You,
yeah, you've had enough already. You're done. I mean, the market solves this by just, well,
can you pay for it? And does the doctor want to do it? Then you get it.
Yeah, well, therefore, if you can't pay for it, then you don't get it. That's the problem with
the market thing, right?
Yeah, I think that's a more just outcome than we're all just, we all just wait in line forever,
and whatever the government decides.
Hold on. You think it is a more just outcome to have one's ability to avail of health care
be dependent upon one's wealth?
Certainly, yes, because you are responsible for your own life, your own destiny, your own
well-being, your own food, shelter, clothing. You go out and work to ascertain those things,
and then you are entitled to have the things that you, to provide for yourself and your family based
on the effort you put into it. The socialist idea that everyone is entitled to the same exact
standards regardless of how much they actually work toward bettering themselves is one I reject.
But if we were to take your doctrine and apply it across the board, there would be no social
security, no unemployment assistance, no welfare of any kind because everyone is dependent on
themselves, and the consequence of that would be that there would be people who, for any multitude
of reasons, end up not able to take care of themselves in that way and therefore end up in
penury or work.
Well, this is how insurance works, right? You can, yeah, we can't all, you can do everything
right in life and have some calamity befall you or get in a car accident that is beyond what you've
provided for, so that's how insurance works, right? That's not going to happen to everybody,
but that'll happen to a couple people, and so we can all mitigate against the risk of that
happening. You pay, you'll pay some of your, what you earn into an insurance fund that is then
used to cover, it could be you or it could be somebody else, and that's how the system works.
But that principle is exactly the way the National Health Service in Britain works and other forms
of universal health care work. It is true that you or I, I mean, I hope both of us will have
decades of blissful good health, but if one of us is ill, the cost of that will not be borne
individually, the cost of illness is borne by the nation at large, which pays via general taxation
for the provision of health care, thus alleviating both the disparities in income level and the
distress caused by people who are under, who are then placed under financial pressure under this
system to get health care whenever they may not have the finances to do it. Right, but it should
be freely chosen, I would say, your level of coverage that you want. You know, if we have some
kind of, I still don't think it should be a national program, but, you know, the way your
local government provides you fire and police or, you know, a couple, some sort of catastrophic, like,
you know, they're not checking what plan you're paid into if they pick you off the side of the
road once you've been in a car accident, you know, something of that nature, fine. But that's not
really what we're talking about when we're talking for Medicare for all, we're talking about a complete
nationalization of the health care providers, which I think would be disastrous. What about
two-thirds of the public think it's a great idea, so let's do it. Anyway, President Trump
up next is again sparking some online backlash with a photo he posted to True Social, stay with us.

