Can The Internet’s Weirdest Mascaras Give You Better Lashes? | Beauty Or Bust

Cosmetics and Beauty Ways
136 followers
16 Video Views·Aug 17, 2026
I tried three of the weirdest mascaras on the market and put them to the test against my favorite everyday mascara. I rate each mascara on ease of use, formula, and longevity, and at the end decide if the mascaras are worth the money.
…
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe host of \"WTF Beauty\" tests three mascaras with unconventional applicators against her favorite, L'Oreal Lash Paradise. She evaluates them based on ease of use, formula performance, and longevity. While she finds the innovative applicators generally frustrating and impractical, she discovers that some of the formulas themselves are high-quality and effective.
I'm freaking out.
This is WTF Beauty, where we try out the internet's weirdest, wackiest, most WTF products to let
you know if they're worth your money.
Today, we will be testing out weird mascaras.
By weird mascaras, I mean mascaras that have some sort of non-traditional, supposedly innovative
applicator.
I've gathered three of what I think are the weirdest mascaras that I've seen out there,
and I'm going to put them to the test against my normal, everyday, love-of-my-life, cult,
favorite, lash-paradise mascara from L'Oreal.
The three weird mascaras I'll be trying out today are the L'Oreal Paris Unlimited Mascara,
which has a bendable wand, the Rude Mighty Mascara & Comb, which has a comb applicator
instead of a wand, and the Beauté Notion Immaculash 360 Black Mascara, which has a
dual wand applicator.
In order to judge these mascaras for you guys, I'm going to be evaluating each on three different
things.
How easy the weird applicators are to use, how well the formula boosts my lashes, and
how well the formula wears throughout the day.
Before we dive in, I just want to get one thing straight.
I have four different mascaras to try out.
I have two eyes.
So I'm going to start by testing out two mascaras, wear those throughout the day, and come back
another day, do the remaining two, and then at the end I'll take a look back at each one
and decide what was good, what wasn't, and why.
Now that we're all on the same page, let's get to testing these out.
Just to quickly show you guys what I expect out of a mascara, I am going to do my L'Oreal
Lash Paradise Regular Mascara on an eye first, just so we can see what my lashes actually
look like with some mascara on.
So I'm going to pit the other L'Oreal mascara against Lash Paradise.
So I'm going to go in with the Unlimited Mascara first, and this is the mascara that has the
bendable wand.
Okay, so this mascara is shaped like a fruit, or like a nail polish bottle.
I just think it looks really funny.
I mean, the actual brush I really like.
It's kind of wider on the end and then more narrow at the tips, so I think that would
make it easy to get in on the little lashes.
I just don't know that this bend is going to do anything.
I don't know.
I feel like it makes it awkward.
If it's bent, I'm going to hold it like this and push it up into my lashes, but if it's
just normal, you're also going to hold it like this and push it into your lashes.
I feel like this doesn't do anything.
Here goes nothing.
I don't really know how to get in the inner corner with this.
I think I'm going to make it straight and then go in on the inner corner like that.
Yeah, that's much more easier.
Oh my God.
Whoa.
Okay.
So far, I'm like, I kind of love it.
I did not see that coming.
I did not foresee this turn of events.
I'm going to go in the bottom lashes with it bent as well.
In terms of formula, I immediately noticed lengthening as well as a lot of separation
in my lashes.
I thought it lengthened my lower lashes even more than my Lash Paradise, and I thought
that it also feathered out the outer corner of my lashes really well.
The only thing where it didn't really work was getting into the inner corner.
I have the two L'Oreal formulas on my lashes, but I still have two other mascaras to try
out.
So I'm going to be back in another day, and we're going to go through this all again with
them.
All right.
We've made it to round two of this test, and I have two more mascaras to try out for you
guys today.
On one side, I'm going to be using the Rude Mighty Mascara in Comb, and on the other,
I have the Beauté Notions Immaculash 360, which I am positive I am mispronouncing by
now.
Do you hear that?
A nails-on chalkboard type of sound.
I'm not convinced that I'm not going to go blind trying to use this.
So it looks like this mascara works like a click pen, so I'm going to just click the
bottom and try to get the product to come out.
Here.
I don't know if it's broken.
I'm starting to panic.
Oh, wait.
I see it.
Ew.
So it doesn't even say how much to use.
Okay.
Well, I'm just going to do one more click for good luck, and something tells me I'm
going to need it.
I'm going to do my bottom lashes.
I have some thoughts.
Oh, my freaking God.
No.
Like, did anyone test this product before they put it out?
Just a thought.
Never in my life have I encountered an experience like this.
I'm freaking out.
Like, I don't even know if there's a point for me to wear it throughout the day.
Like, with the way it's shaped, there's no way you can get those small lashes, and if
you try, you will end up looking like this.
It'll transfer onto your lid, onto your lower lid.
It'll transfer onto your skin because it's just too big to get into those little nooks
and crannies.
The only thing, the only, only, only thing I can give this credit for is that I think
it did lengthen my lashes.
But in terms of getting to the roots of the lashes and getting in those small lashes,
it's a literal maddening nerf.
Oh, and also, on the box it says, no mascara will ever be as precise.
Moving on to the Immaculash 360, I think this is the one I'm most intrigued to figure out
what's going on because I think it could be really good, but it also looks terrifying.
Oh, it's like, weirdly creepy.
I don't like that at all.
So it says, for the top lashes, place the smaller brush on top of your lashes near the
lash base, then press the button down to close the wand around the lash, and then move the
brush up along the lashes to coat with mascara.
So just because I'm having a lot of difficulty getting the sandwiching action in my inner
corner, because, like, do you see how they don't really meet exactly at the end?
And that's where I would get those lashes in.
I'm gonna go in just with, like, one end and try to use it to get those.
Okay, okay, I figured it out.
I think this is kind of genius in a new way to, like, package and design a double-ended
mascara, but I do not think it works well at all as, like, a double-wand sandwiching
360-degree mascara.
I think it's really awkward to have to, like, position it, press down, keep it clamped,
but also, like, move it, but I think it's kind of neat that it is, like, basically what
a double-ended mascara is, but it's just in this one wand.
Otherwise, I see a lot of length, I see volume, it's really black.
I feel like it has a promising use if you use it the way I was saying instead of the
sandwiching motion.
All right, so these are my lashes for today.
I'm gonna wear these formulas throughout the rest of the day, and we're gonna see how well
they last.
All right, guys, I made it through two days of testing out these weird mascaras, and I
have collected my thoughts, and I'm gonna let you guys know what I think about each
of them.
So, let me just cut to the chase.
Not one of these weird applicators did anything other than irritate me and make my experience
using mascara more difficult and not enjoyable.
However, just because the weird applicators aren't worth your money doesn't mean that
the actual mascaras aren't good.
I actually found two mascara formulas out of this little experiment that I really love.
First, we have the L'Oreal Unlimited Mascara.
In terms of application, I'm going to give this one a three, just because the unique
part of the wand actually made it a little more difficult to use.
In terms of formula, perfect, nailed it.
I actually immediately loved the effect of this mascara more than the Lash Paradise that
I compare every formula to.
And in terms of longevity, my lashes still, as you can see, held the curl perfectly.
I have no smudges.
I didn't notice any flakes throughout the day.
I mean, the formula has held up flawlessly throughout 10 hours of wear.
Next, we have the Rude Mighty Mascara and Comb.
This was definitely the weirdest application, and I should have trusted Tati because this
was the worst mascara I've ever tried, and I'm going to give it a one out of five.
The real only saving grace it had was that I noticed some lengthening from this formula,
but that was kind of all taken away given the fact that it not only smudged on me throughout
the day, but also it didn't hold my curl as well as I wanted it to.
Last but not least, we have the Immaculash 360.
The way that you had to sandwich your lashes between these two wands was almost impossible
for me to do.
That could be a personal issue, but I just found it kind of pointless.
However, this formula was really great.
I especially love this formula on my lower lash line.
I thought it made them so long and separated without looking too spidery.
Lastly, for longevity, I'm going to give this one a five out of five.
It held my curl the whole day.
It didn't smudge.
So, moral of the story, weird mascaras, not worth your money, but the formulas can actually
be pretty great.
I did go in with a Q-tip and really clean up the rude cosmetic side, the rude side,
the rude side.
You know what?
It is rude.
True to the name.
