Is Chicago Deep Dish Actually Pizza?

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the long-standing debate over whether Chicago-style deep dish pizza qualifies as \"real\" pizza. It traces the culinary origins of the style, the internal disputes over who invented it, and the legal and cultural arguments used to define what constitutes a pizza.
Pizza, it's the number one food on the planet.
I'm having a relationship with my pizza.
OK, maybe not literally, but we can all
agree that it's in every human being's top five, right?
Like, who can say no to pizza?
I have the last slice.
Actually, you're only entitled to half.
Seems simple enough until you remember
that according to some, pizza comes in both New York
style and Chicago style.
But does it really?
Well, today we're going to attempt
to answer the question, is Chicago style pizza real pizza?
But before we get started, be sure to subscribe
to the Weird History Food channel
and let us know in the comments below what
other pizza-related controversies you
would like to hear about.
Fingers crossed we can get to the bottom of this,
because if we can't, the globe may never be the same again.
Pizza, we've all had it.
Dough, sauce, cheese, and a selection of toppings.
It's pizza.
You know it, you love it, you're probably
getting hungry just from watching this video.
Italian in origin, American by popularity.
It's a food for the ages.
But Chicago style, what is that exactly?
Pizza that wears a Cubs hat and won't stop talking
about Michael Jordan's glory days?
Well, frankly, there's multiple versions of Chicago style.
But its main characteristic is that the ratio of sauce
to cheese is inverted.
The cheese is below the sauce.
And typically speaking, Chicago style pizzas are a deep dish.
While there are folklorish elements to this story,
Chicago style pizza is so new, culturally speaking,
that we actually do have some rough genealogy
of where it came from.
Believe it or not, Chicago style deep dish pizza
was first served at Pizzeria Uno,
founded by Richard Ricardo and Ike Sewell in 1943.
The pizzas were cooked in a pie pan
with dough constructed from scalded milk, butter,
and sugar.
This wild experiment took off.
And the rest was history, sort of.
The truth is that Pizzeria Uno's recipe
was the bedrock of the business and was
pretty successful in its day.
But it was cook Alice May Redmond
that later evolved the recipe with olive oil and a secret dough
conditioner to make the texture more pliable and malleable.
This allowed her to get deeper pizzas
and have more stiffness to the crust.
In fact, some pizza historians insist
that the Redmond additions were what truly
made Chicago style the mainstay that it is today.
To make things even more complicated,
there's yet another contender in this complex debate
over credit.
You see, while most acknowledge that Pizzeria Uno is
the inception point and that Redmond definitely
did evolve the recipe, others claim
that Uno's other chef, Rudy Malnati,
was the true creator and evolver of the recipe.
Malnati supporters, which we'll call Malnatiacs,
insist that he was the one who took what had been established
and added more sauce, cheese, and toppings
to make the iconic deep dish pizza we think of today.
Rudy's sons, Lou and Rudy Junior,
also worked at Pizzeria Uno and eventually spun off
and founded Lou Malnati's Pizzeria in an attempt
to carry on their father's legacy
and push back against what they felt was the continuing
stealing of due credit.
The real question is, are any of these people
the true heroes of the pizza rebellion?
Who can say?
Each faction has its detractors and proponents.
What can be said for sure is that the jury is still
out on if Chicago-style pizza is pizza at all.
I don't understand you people.
I mean, all these picky little points you keep bringing up,
they don't mean nothing.
By the time the 70s were rolling around,
the idea of the Chicago-style pizza
was finally starting to really catch on.
In fact, there were two chains that popped up
selling Chicago-style, Nancy's Pizza, founded by Rocco Palese,
and Giordano's Pizzeria, founded by brothers
Efren and Joseph Boio.
But the Boio brothers weren't happy with just continuing
to sell Chicago-style as it was.
They felt the need to push things even further,
and they started creating stuffed pizzas.
And Rocco Palese, who was apparently not terribly
original but could recognize a good idea when he saw it,
decided to follow suit.
To that end, he created a stuffed pizza
based on his mother's recipe for scarchetta,
which is an Easter Italian pie.
While these dishes had their moment,
they never quite reached escape velocity.
But the cat was out of the bag.
Chicago-style pizza was fully entering
the cultural consciousness.
And by all indications, it was here to stay.
And that's when the pushback started.
To really understand the divide between Chicago
and everything else, you have to simplify things.
New York-style pizza is, well, pizza.
Chicago-style, on the other hand, is a style of pizza.
Italian immigrants brought the idea of pizza
over from the old country.
And you know what it looked like?
Pizza.
Chicago-style pizza is an interesting evolution,
departure, and arguably improvement
on the source material.
But it's inarguably not the original.
And that's where the debate stems from.
The critique of Chicago-style is that it's
too similar to other types of Italian cuisine
and that it borrows too many of the core attributes
of other popular dishes.
A common refrain being, it's not pizza.
It's lasagna with a crust.
Even Jon Stewart eventually got in on the debate
in a now iconic rant.
It's a casserole.
And the critics have a point.
Deep dish pizza is basically a casserole.
But you know what?
Casseroles are delicious.
So who cares?
What do you care if a delicious and savory delight
happens to be called pizza?
No one freaks out because a scoop of ice cream
pressed between two wafers is referred to as a sandwich,
even though it doesn't involve any bread.
So why is the pizza thing such a big deal?
Well, the answer is that pizza is taken very seriously
in the United States.
Americans value it, plain and simple.
Like it or not, it's one of the culinary lifebloods
of the nation.
People, in fact, care so much about the whole,
is Chicago pizza really pizza thing
that a Thrillist article was written
about this exact topic, attempting
to get to the bottom of the case once and for all.
Simply put, they took the issue to court.
Not literally, but they hired a lawyer named Nicolette Ward
and quizzed her on the legal qualifications of what
is and isn't pizza.
And here's what the article had to say
about her interpretation of what pizza is.
Ward notes that legally, the minimum threshold of pizza
is crust, tomato, salt, and oil.
And the maximum is that but with one kind of cheese
and some garlic.
So wait, toppings aren't included
in the maximum definition?
Really?
Does that sound right?
No, it definitely does not sound right.
But she is a lawyer.
So apparently, you have to listen to her.
I graduated top of my class at Yale.
And that means that the people who
think Chicago-style pizza is pizza are technically correct,
which, as Futurama taught us, is the best kind of correct.
You are technically correct, the best kind of correct.
That being said, while Chicago-style might technically
be pizza, it's doubtful anyone in their right mind,
when asked to mentally picture a pizza,
would think of a Chicago-style deep dish option.
Like, you just don't see it.
No one is arguing that deep dish isn't
tasty, fun to eat, or even sometimes
preferable over New York.
Sometimes the mood strikes you, and you just
want a Chicago-style pizza.
But be real.
New York pizza is pizza, while Chicago pizza is like pizza.
Nonetheless, the argument that Nicolette Ward puts forward
is sound and can't really be denied.
Crust, sauce, tomato, and oil, Chicago-style pizza
is definitionally real pizza.
Well, case closed.
It's settled.
Great job, everybody.
Pizza is one of the most popular dishes around.
It's eaten all over the world.
It's loved by people of all walks of life.
It's an undying classic that will no doubt
be here well after you and everyone else on the planet
has perished.
You could even make the case that the sun
will go cold before people will stop enjoying a tasty slice.
What you can't argue, though, is that Chicago pizza isn't pizza.
It very much is.
Sure, it might not be the type of pizza you like,
or the kind of pizza you think of when
asked about your favorite late night snack.
But empirically, it is pizza, as pizza as New York style
is to the original Sicilian style that
made its way over from Italy.
And that's the beauty of cuisine.
It's always evolving, and it's always
changing to reflect the people that serve and eat it.
And what Chicago-style pizza tells us
about the American experience is, well, who knows?
But the fact that people are still
debating if it is or isn't pizza close to 100 years
after its inception proves that it
has longevity and durability.
Those two qualities alone are reflective
of the people who created it, and that's
something to be deeply proud of.
Pizza extends to the upper echelons of global culture,
but its roots are in the immigrant, the downtrodden,
and the less fortunate.
And that's what's inspiring about it.
Sure, carbs and sauce and cheese are delicious,
but it's also pizza's humble origins
that earn it the respected love from people
from all walks of life.
To debate what is real pizza is as American as America.
When I look at your deep dish pizza,
I don't know whether to eat it or throw a coin in it
and make a wish.
But at the end of the day, we are all Americans,
and we all love pizza.
So what do you think?
And what's your favorite style of pizza?
Let us know in the comments below.
And while you're at it, check out some of these other videos
from Weird History.
