What's happening on WD 1856 b?

A Door to Mysteries
791 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the fascinating characteristics of WD 1856b, a gas giant orbiting a white dwarf. As the first intact planet discovered in the \"forbidden zone\" of a stellar remnant, it challenges current understanding of planetary survival and migration. The planet is distinguished by its anomalous temperature and a methane-rich atmosphere that defies existing astronomical models.
Planets orbiting things that aren't normal stars are usually weird outcasts.
I've made 3 different videos about pretty much the same 6 confirmed exoplanets orbiting neutron
stars, especially PSR J1719-1438b, a planet so strange I've memorized that designation by heart.
This is an exotic planetary mass core of an object that used to be a sun-like star,
made of crystallized carbon, also known as diamond, and oxygen,
taking just 2 hours to orbit its pulsar. I consider this to be the strangest exoplanet
found so far, and have a full video about it if you want to know more.
But planets around white dwarfs, while not usually as strange as pulsar planets,
do still have some pretty weird things going on with them. Like Aura, the only planet around a
white dwarf with an official name, which is 2500 AU away from its parent star, a distance that,
if it were orbiting the sun, would put it somewhere in the inner Oort cloud. Yet Aura
has temperatures comparable to Earth, because of its large mass creating and trapping internal heat.
White dwarfs are, for those who may not know, the degenerate cores of stars around the size
of our sun, or even a bit larger, that ran out of fuel and expelled their outer layers,
leaving an object behind roughly the radius of Earth, but stellar in mass.
And this video will be about yet another weird planet around a stellar remnant,
in a pretty interesting system. WD 1856-534b, which for the purposes of this video I'll just
call WD 1856b. This planet is a gas giant orbiting the white dwarf star WD 1856,
which is about 60% the mass of the sun and somewhere around 8-10 billion years old.
As of the time of making this video, WD 1856b was suspected to be the coldest planet ever
directly imaged, with an estimated temperature of negative 124 degrees Fahrenheit, negative 86
Celsius, between the temperatures of Mars and Jupiter. However, that number comes from a 2025
paper, while from what I can tell, a different 2026 paper found a significantly higher temperature,
which is one of the main reasons this planet is suspected to have a unique and interesting
formation history. This planet has been observed by James Webb and found to be very different from
any exoplanet we've seen so far, with a never before seen composition as well as a violent
history. We'll get to these unique characteristics and what causes them after going over a few more
general ones. WD 1856b orbits the white dwarf WD 1856, as I've already mentioned,
but it's also worth noting that this is a triple star system. WD 1856 is orbited by a very distant
binary pair of red dwarfs, 32% and 33% as massive as the sun respectively, which orbit one another
roughly 1000 AU away from the white dwarf, which is the most massive member of the system.
WD 1856 is estimated to have been a white dwarf for about 5.4 billion years,
though the object itself is somewhere between 7.4 and 10 billion years old. The planet's mass is
currently unknown, though the 2026 paper suggests a mass between 4.3 and 10.9 Jupiter masses,
while the 2025 paper suggests it has a mass somewhere less than 6 Jupiters. Either way,
this is a pretty big planet. It's also extremely close to its star, on an orbit taking just 1.4
days to complete. This is especially interesting because this means WD 1856b is only about 3.1
million kilometers away from the white dwarf, which when this star was a red giant, would have
been inside the star. It's not possible for WD 1856b to have survived this close to the star,
as it would have been destroyed when it was a red giant, so the only possible explanation here is
that it formed further away from the star, and sometime after it became a white dwarf, migrated
to its current orbit. WD 1856b is actually the first intact planet ever found in this so-called
forbidden zone around a white dwarf, where it would have been destroyed during the star's red
giant phase. I say intact because there's several other white dwarfs with debris disks potentially
created by destroyed planets, but that's a subject for another video. Anyways, so far WD 1856b is a
pretty interesting planet, but not necessarily a super strange one. We've seen many planets around
white dwarfs before, and even some close-in objects orbiting in this forbidden zone. This
planet was the first of its type to be discovered, but that's not what sets it apart. The interesting
part about WD 1856b is that it transits, and because of that we can tell what's in its atmosphere,
and it's unlike any gas giant we've seen before. WD 1856b was also the first transiting planet
found around a white dwarf. When a planet like it transits, it blocks starlight, some of which
gets filtered through its atmosphere, allowing us to see the size of the planet as well as what's
in its atmosphere. However, the transit method is a bit different for white dwarfs, mainly because
WD 1856b is physically wider than its star, specifically about 8 times wider in radius,
though obviously the star is more massive. Despite this, it was still possible to find
the radius of the planet, that being roughly 95% the radius of Jupiter. This is the next
interesting thing about WD 1856b. Despite being potentially up to 11 times more massive than
Jupiter, it's smaller than it in radius. The radii of gas giants don't usually increase much with mass
because the added gravity pulls the atmosphere downward, but this thing being marginally smaller
than Jupiter is somewhat odd. The next weird thing comes from the 2026 paper about this planet,
linked in the description. Earlier I mentioned this planet's temperature was estimated to be
about negative 124 degrees Fahrenheit. However, this paper found a much higher effective temperature
of 260 Fahrenheit, 127 Celsius, moving it from warmer than Jupiter to warmer than Earth.
This is a problem as WD 1856b almost certainly formed alongside its star, meaning it must be
the same age. Even with a high mass, this planet is still far too old to be this hot.
It doesn't get enough light from its star, and it's old enough to have cooled down from its formation.
This is where this planet's migration history comes back into play. As mentioned already, WD 1856b did not
form where it is today, and that's a pretty well established fact. However, its higher temperature
might actually give us some clues as to what happened to it. There are two potential ways WD 1856b
reaches the orbit it's currently in. Option one is the gravity of the two red dwarfs in the system
over time through the cosine mechanism increased the eccentricity of this planet's orbit until it
fell closer to the star and experienced tidal circularization. The second option is potentially
more interesting. In the second scenario, WD 1856, when it was a red giant, may have swallowed and
destroyed another giant planet in the system, and through gravitational interactions, that planet
ejected the red giant's gas envelope, allowing WD 1856b to survive the red giant phase.
Importantly, both scenarios would produce different environments for the present day WD 1856b.
Tidal circularization, for example, would tidally heat the planet,
in a way the second scenario, common envelope migration, wouldn't. So, WD 1856b's present
day environment, being significantly hotter than it should be, is perfectly explained if,
shortly after the star became a white dwarf, this planet was shoved onto eccentric orbit,
which then circularized closer to the star, caused by the gravity of the two red dwarfs.
This is probably the less exciting scenario than a second planet being destroyed,
but it's one the evidence is pointing to right now. And if this is the case,
it provides a really good explanation for the existence of other examples of planets
on extremely short orbits around stellar remnants. However, this is still pretty exciting in its own
right. This planet was thrown so close to the white dwarf it was nearly ripped apart,
and tidal forces heated it up to presumably hundreds of degrees, and even millions of
years later, it's still recovering from this violent event, to the point where the aftermath
is still readily visible to us. There's also the question of what happened to any other planets
in the system during this time, if any others existed, which is still unanswered. It's also
worth noting that for these numbers to work, this tidal circularization event would have had to
have happened 3 to 5.5 billion years after the star became a white dwarf. Because it's estimated
the star has only been a white dwarf for somewhere around 5.4 billion years, there's a chance this
So, WT1856b's anomalously high temperature can be explained pretty easily. What's harder to explain
is the composition of its atmosphere. Because it transits, its atmosphere can be observed by James
Webb, and some really interesting things were found. Specifically, this planet's atmosphere
is highly enriched in carbon, to a staggering degree. WT1856b's atmosphere is composed of 7%
methane. For comparison, Neptune, which has a famously methane-rich atmosphere,
giving it a blue color, has just 1.5% methane concentration in its atmosphere.
So, not only is there over 4 times more methane in WT1856b's atmosphere percentage-wise,
but this planet is also somewhere around 140 times more massive than Neptune,
assuming an average of 7.6 Jupiter masses between the 4.3 minimum and 10.9 maximum.
That exact number is probably not accurate, but it's in the general ballpark.
Point is, WT1856b has a ridiculous amount of methane. And unlike the high temperature,
we currently don't have a good explanation for what's going on here.
It's highly unlikely for WT1856b to have the same composition throughout, as if 7% of the entire
planet was methane, that would imply there's 170 Earth masses worth of methane on this world,
or more methane than the entire mass of the planet Saturn,
which for somewhat obvious reasons is unlikely to be true.
A more plausible idea is that only the upper atmosphere is enriched in methane.
But the question now is what exactly is doing the enriching, and we really have no idea.
Currently, we don't have good atmospheric models for what should happen to planets
around red giants and subsequent white dwarfs, so we have no clue right now as to what could
be causing this. Maybe tidal forces from this planet's migration dredged up denser materials
from the core. Maybe it used to be more massive, like a brown dwarf, which do have a lot of
methane, and lost a ton of mass during the red giant phase. Those two explanations,
neither of which have been properly proposed and remain complete speculation with no evidence,
both have problems of their own that don't make them a perfect fit.
The first option is unlikely to work on such a large planet, and would still require this to
have formed with an anomalously high amount of methane. The second scenario would give
this planet a different composition than what we actually see.
Point is, WD-1856b is actually a bit of a mystery right now. We do, however, know that it had a
violent and exciting history with some form of high eccentricity migration. That could be a piece
to this puzzle. However, it's worth noting that this is the exact same type of migration most hot
Jupiters go through to get to their current orbits, and we haven't seen a hot Jupiter with
composition like this, so it can't be the entire solution. And that's why WD-1856b is one of the
stranger exoplanets we've found. There's definitely an explanation to its weird methane rich atmosphere
somewhere, but right now we have no clue as to what it could be. And it continues the trend of
the strangest exoplanets being found around stellar remnants. Things are rarely normal
around dead stars, and WD-1856b is yet another example of that. I guess you have to be pretty
weird to survive the death of a star, and such an event won't leave a planet unscathed.
The study of planets around white dwarfs and other stellar remnants is still extremely new,
and luckily WD-1856b is in a unique position to continue being observed and characterized,
and we can actually find more information about it, unlike the other non-transiting planets around
stellar remnants. The study of this world is far from over, but what we already know is pretty cool.
WD-1856b survived the death of its star, and was then flung onto a close orbit around the dead
remains, something that heated it up through tidal forces and it's still recovering from today.
Something else also produced an exotic atmospheric composition not seen on any
other exoplanet so far, with an extremely surprising amount of methane. There aren't
many exoplanets that are simultaneously this interesting and also actually able to be
characterized. So hopefully we find out more about WD-1856b and what weird things are going
on with it soon. Thank you for watching, if you enjoyed check out my other videos
about exoplanets and space exploration.
