https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePi8DI-kh54&pp=0gcJCfkLAYcqIYzv

WAN NEWS
12 followers
The GB Mums react to Karoline Leavitt's resignation, paid leave among civil servants for transgender surgeries and AOC's decision to freeze her eggs.
#gbmums #parenting #politics #trans
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedGB Mums explores the intersection of motherhood and current affairs, discussing the pressures of balancing careers with parenting, the ethics of egg freezing as a corporate benefit, and the controversy over civil service leave for gender reassignment. The panel also debates the financial burden of school uniforms and the role of government intervention in school dress codes.
Well hello, welcome to GB Mums. This is the programme on GB News where mums get together
in the studio and we talk about news stories that have an impact on us as mothers. We sort
of see news and current affairs through the lens of being a mother. I'm Emily Carver.
I'm Olivia Rutley.
And I'm Linda Doobley.
Fantastic to have you on the show Linda and Olivia of course. We've got a lot to discuss
today actually because civil servants are fighting plans to scrap trans reassignment
leave. Now that offers 13 weeks of paid absence if you're undergoing a gender procedure. Now
the controversy over this is that they're thinking about scrapping it. But 13 weeks
of paid leave, should you get that for undergoing gender reassignment, that's on top of paid
sick leave as well that you're entitled to. And that is more than some women get for maternity
leave in a lot of cases. We're also going to be talking about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez,
AOC, the New York congressman. She's recently announced that she's embarking on a round
of egg freezing. And she's not just announced it, she's sort of broadcast the moment I think
where she actually jabs herself is what you have to do in terms of the procedure. So we're
going to be having a little look on that. Is it right to broadcast such a thing? Should
she be freezing her eggs? Is this the future? She's 36 years old. What's going on there?
Caroline Leavitt, also the firebrand, Donald Trump's firebrand press secretary has actually
resigned from the position. She wants to spend more time being a mum to her two young
children. She's just come back from maternity leave after having her daughter at the start
of May. I don't believe she had very many weeks at all off on maternity leave before
she was back in such a tough job. And also school uniforms. Yes, September is upon us
well very shortly. And they're going to limit three items with a school logo to try and
help people save money. What's the point of that? Do you think that's a good idea? Do
you think actually parents are expected to spend far too much money on uniforms as it
is? We'll get into it. So why don't we start with Caroline Leavitt because it's quite interesting
her story. Obviously, she's been very successful in her job. Only 28 years old, Olivia. And
she had one child. She immediately went back to work. I think she was working like seriously
days after she had the baby. Then she had a second baby and I think she was off for
seven weeks straight back into that job. I mean, could you do that? Oh, my goodness. No,
I definitely could not do that. I mean, whatever you think of Donald Trump, Caroline Leavitt
is a force of nature. She is formidable and she has done a brilliant job holding down
a very tough job for longer than, I mean, any of her predecessors in recent history.
Anthony Scaramucci managed 11 days. And now she's gone. It is a huge, huge loss to the
White House. Now, I wonder how much of this is she wants to take a step back for now,
but she has plans for the future and how much of it is just genuinely that she doesn't feel
that she can balance those two things. I think part of it is we complain about a lot here in
Britain, a lot. But actually, on things like maternity leave, we have a much,
much more reasonable system than in America. Because I was pregnant with my second child
when I worked for Fox News. And I think you get two weeks. At the time, you got two weeks off,
but I got 10 because I had a caesarean and therefore I had a post-operative situation
to recover from. But it's always difficult going back to work. But you've outlined that,
Olivia, very, very clearly. The thing about her is that I think that she is a very strategic
woman, obviously, that plans a great deal. And I think she's planning to return.
Do you? Yeah, definitely.
I mean, I was still in nappies, I think, at about six weeks. It's quite a recovery.
It's a huge recovery, huge physical recovery, huge mental recovery. I mean,
I went back to work when Wolfie was eight and a half months and I was
sobbing about the idea of losing my tiny baby.
Yeah, it's very difficult. When I had my first one, I was a news presenter at Sky.
And that's manageable because you know that you're in the studio all the time.
Therefore, when you get a nanny, and I had to have a nanny to help me,
you know what your hours are because they're all worked out on a rotor for months in advance.
But I went back to work after eight weeks and he did not sleep through the night until 10 weeks.
And that was very, very difficult.
10 weeks is quite good to be fair.
No, no. Well, let me tell you, the reason he slept a lot is because he was 10 pounds when
he was born. And he fed a great deal from the get-go. So because he fed a lot and his
stomach was always full, that's why he slept early. All my kids slept early.
I'm really hoping for a big old baby this time.
It makes a big difference.
With the next two, I had caesareans because they were worried I'd always have big babies.
But they always slept through the night very quickly. And so I went back to work very quickly.
I think if you can get some sleep, you've got enough child care, you've got a supportive
partner, then yeah, you can do it. But it requires a lot of mental discipline.
You can do it. I mean...
But do you want to?
Do you want to, exactly. I mean, I can imagine her children are almost exactly the same age as,
well, my son or daughter is due in November, but almost exactly the same.
And you do, I mean, as Wilfie starts to get older and learning new words every day,
and I hate leaving him at nursery thinking, what am I going to have missed? What will he
have picked up in the 10 hours that I've been gone for?
And I can imagine if you have a job like Caroline Leibovitz,
that would be a lot harder to contemplate.
Yeah, because when you're at home, you're not really at home.
You're thinking about what on earth Donald Trump is going to say next.
But I mean, she said, I've felt in my heart that I cannot be the best mum
for my two young children, that my two young children deserve,
while devoting the constant time, energy and attention required
to be White House press secretary.
I mean, fair enough. I mean, a lot of people are trying to, as you say,
is this all part of a grand plan?
Has this got to do with what happened on Air Force One,
where Donald Trump was taken away in a different decoy plane,
and then some of the staff were left on Air Force One?
Is there safety fears?
But it could just genuinely be that she has been struggling emotionally.
I think I would do the same.
Not that I've ever been in a job like that,
but I think I would probably do the same thing.
I would have the first two, get them to a certain point,
and then there would be a period of time
before they start primary school.
Is it called grade school in America?
I can't remember what the name is.
But anyway, you then can consolidate things,
you can be with them for a couple of years,
and then you could go back to work, do a bit more work.
And what I would do if I was her, I'd have another two.
You see, I think it's really interesting how, you know,
women these days, and perhaps the tide has started to turn on this now,
but I think when we were growing up,
it was very much sort of, get your career in,
get over those early hurdles in your career,
and then have your children a little bit later.
And now people are waking up to the fact that it isn't always possible
to have children late into your 30s, into your 40s, etc.
And what people used to do, I mean, my cousin has done this,
and I think it's quite a good idea,
started very young too when she was 23 and 24 or something.
And now she's sort of training and hoping that she can get her career going
now that the kids are in school.
Well, we'll have to see if it works out,
and then I think she'll probably go on to have another couple.
I think everything's turned round now.
And I say to my daughter, who is 26,
and she's approaching the ideal age to conceive,
and she's got a long-term partner.
I say, think about it, Kitty.
Think about having the babies.
She's qualified.
She qualified only this month as an architect.
You've qualified, you've done the seven years.
Think about having a family and then go back or restart your career.
But how easy is that?
Because that's the fear, isn't it, for a lot of women.
They've got to a certain point.
They found something they actually quite like doing.
Well, it's all difficult.
And then how do you get back into it after four years, five years out?
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, so difficult.
I think it just depends on the career as well.
Say if it was medicine or something like that,
things will have moved on.
In tech, things definitely will have moved on.
So it's very, very difficult to manage.
But there's no escaping the fact that 26 to about 33 is more or less the ideal age.
By the time you get to 35, to be blunt, your egg production is falling off a cliff.
Sorry.
No, it's true.
It's one of those biological realities that medicine can't really prevent.
But on that point, we're going to move on to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
She's the very famous Democrat New York City Congresswoman
who's always all over social media.
Anyway, she seems to be documenting her journey now in terms of egg freezing.
Now, she's 36 years old.
And when she posted this, everyone had an opinion, it seemed.
Some people saying you shouldn't be normalising this at the age of 36.
You know, why aren't you cracking on and having babies?
You have a partner, et cetera, et cetera.
Is this a good message to be putting out there?
Or is this a bad message to be putting out there?
But I think there's been some reports that she has actually split
now with her longtime partner, her fiancé.
So maybe that's the reason why she's doing it, which is totally understandable, Linda.
Absolutely.
So I'm much, much older than you girls.
And I do remember covering the first story on the woman
who had a successful delivery from a frozen embryo in this country.
And it was a massive moment for celebration for the scientists
who were behind the research and for the medical team involved.
And I think it is massively helpful to some women.
So if you've just lost your relationship
at precisely the wrong point in your life,
and you know that that point is 35 or 36,
then I think freezing your eggs, yeah, that's a good idea.
And we also hear cases of women with ovarian cancer
when they're very young, when they're teenagers,
or other forms of cancer where the treatment involved
will make them infertile so they can freeze their eggs too.
But the problem is that all slips into an area
where women start thinking of it as a lifestyle choice.
I think I'll get my career on track,
and it doesn't matter, I can freeze my eggs,
and then I'll just unfreeze them later.
And nearly every single doctor, obstetrician,
medical professional I've spoken to says that's a really bad idea.
You mustn't treat it that way.
It's not made for that kind of decision.
Yeah, I mean, I think it's a fantastic technology
or whatever you want to call it,
medical procedure that can give women an option
when they wouldn't otherwise have it.
I don't know, what do you think, Olivia?
Well, I thought Linda summed up very much.
She did, didn't she?
That's what I thought, actually.
She did, yeah.
But I do think it's worrying how it is definitely creeping in
as a lifestyle choice.
I actually have a friend who works
at a big, big investment bank, making lots of money.
And they offer, as part of their package,
egg freezing for women.
And I just think that is so shocking.
It's pernicious, isn't it?
And I said this to her, and she said,
well, they're not telling us that we have to do it.
Well, no, but it's sort of, you know,
this is what we want from you.
Give us your best years,
and then we'll give you back your fertility at a later date.
And as you say, that's not how it works.
There are some cultures, I mean,
this top banking culture, I think, is a good example of this,
where egg freezing has become a sort of rite of passage.
And also, she's now pregnant, my friend.
And the expectation is that she takes
sort of three months maternity leave,
which I know by American standards is quite a lot.
But by British standards, it's very unusual.
And it means, you know, putting your child into a nursery.
And we're not really set up for nurseries.
It's all a bit unsettling.
It is unsettling.
I was trying to think of the name of that book.
Is it The Handmaid's Tale?
Yeah.
It kind of reminds me of that.
You just fiddle so much with the way nature wanted things to happen,
that you end up in a very skewed society.
And I think that's the danger here.
Yeah, I feel two ways about it,
because I think, unfortunately, there are a lot of women
who just haven't met someone.
Yeah, absolutely.
You know, and people can say,
oh, women should have children sooner.
They should make sure that they have one
before their biological clock goes and whatever.
But there are women out there who are really trying.
To meet someone who they could settle down with
and have a child with, but it just doesn't happen.
I mean, it was ever thus, Linda.
But I do sense that perhaps it's harder these days
to maybe find a partner.
Yeah, I'm not even sure when I had my first child
that I was in an ideal situation at all.
In fact, I may not have been, looking back on it.
But I just thought there's one thing in life
that is non-negotiable to me.
And that is having children.
I know that's the thing I want.
I've had a good career.
I've covered all sorts of big stories, blah, blah, blah.
You know, I knew I could carry on doing that
with the right level of support.
But the one thing I would not negotiate on
was having children.
I was going to have them, come what may, if I could.
I think a lot of women these days
want to be in the perfect situation
before they have a baby.
There's so much emphasis on how much having a child costs.
And yes, that's true.
But you know, people make do
with what they've got in the end.
You know, if you have a child,
you're going to somehow make it work.
I think we all have so much control
in so many areas of our lives now
that I think women find it very, very hard to accept.
And I think I'm one of those women
that you can't choose when you have a baby.
Even if you don't have any particular problems,
it can take longer than you were expecting.
We started trying when I was 29.
I didn't have a baby until I was 31.
It's not long in the grand scheme of things.
But it's weird for women not getting that control.
And so I think lots of women think,
well, 35, that's a sensible age to have a first baby.
And then when it actually happens when they're sort of 38,
you think, well, are you going to have a second?
And then you are in difficulties
having the second one at that age.
The good thing about having a baby,
I'm told, when you're younger,
is you kind of,
I don't know how to put this in a delicate way,
you kind of get one through the pipeline first.
Open things up a bit.
And then you know that everything works.
And then your chances of having the second
or the third are much greater.
Whereas if you leave it and you leave it,
and one fertility expert told me years ago,
if you find that you're having trouble conceiving,
don't wait for the explanation.
He said, go straight to IVF.
If you wait three or four years,
and you were at three years,
but if you waited much longer-
I was only 10 when I had a miscarriage,
so I was-
So that's early, yeah.
So the thing is, act on it.
Don't go in for lots of investigations
and lots of scans.
This is what people do.
They investigate absolutely everything.
No, no, no.
He just said, you know,
after about two or three years,
act immediately.
Well, shall we move on to our civil service?
Because this is quite interesting.
I mean, the big question here is
whether you should get paid leave,
13 weeks currently,
if you're undergoing a gender reassignment procedure.
13 weeks of paid leave
civil servants have been having.
I don't know how many people
this actually impacted in reality,
but 13 weeks on paper,
and that's on top of any sick leave you've taken.
And of course,
very generous holiday allowance
when you're working in the civil service too.
And people have pointed out, haven't they, Olivia,
that this is more than a lot of businesses
will give you for your maternity leave.
Well, absolutely.
I know that the maternity leave policy
in the civil service is a lot more generous,
but if you work for a private business,
which are paying the maternity leave
from the salaries of those people
who are working in the civil service,
then you're likely to get a lot less than this.
I mean, in my mind,
gender reassignment is a completely optional.
I know people will disagree with me perhaps,
but I think it is an optional thing
that you're going through.
And I don't think you should get any more time
off for gender reassignment surgery
than you would get for a boob job or a nose job.
It's cosmetic surgery, essentially.
You've chosen to have it.
You can take your sick leave,
but 13 weeks of paid leave.
I mean, one thing if it was a private business
choosing to do this,
and they could do what they like.
But this is taxpayer funded.
That's point number one.
But also, I think maternity leave is designed
so that you can at least give some time
to the really important thing,
is that you're raising a child.
You have to be.
So you've got some time
where you can at least get your baby
into a, hopefully, a sort of routine.
You know, it's the biggest disruption,
I think, and I don't want to characterise it
in a negative way,
but it is the thing that changes your life.
So getting used to a baby
and getting your partner used to the baby,
it requires every second of that maternity leave.
But the same is not true
for this gender reassignment surgery.
It is surgery.
You probably do need some time to get over it.
And they should have that time,
but there's no way it should equal maternity leave.
13 weeks.
Or whether it should be paid?
I think...
Should it be paid?
I think part of it could be paid,
because you could see it as post-operative.
You could see it in that light.
But you're right, it is taxpayer's money.
And you're choosing to have the surgery.
It's not like a surgery that you need
and you'll get seriously ill if you don't.
Well, they would argue that you do need it.
They would argue that it's not a choice.
I would argue that it's a choice.
Well, it's certainly a choice
whether to get reassignment surgery, that's for sure.
I mean, it's an interesting one.
The civil service LGBT plus network is up in arms about this.
They're saying that they no longer want
to promote the civil service as an inclusive employer.
Yes, all employers want to have this inclusive employer badge
that they can tell everyone that they're an inclusive.
So I don't really know what's going to happen here.
So they're trying to scrap it
to replace it with some kind of other policy.
But now there's a battle.
And I wonder who will win out.
But 13 weeks, I don't know how many transgender people
going through gender assignment work at the civil service,
but it's an absolutely massive employer.
So there probably are quite a few.
There probably are quite a few across the workforce.
I mean, probably part of the problem here
is that civil service policies are far, far too generous.
In general.
Anyway, in my mind.
I think the civil service maternity policy
is six months fully paid and three months half paid.
Any private business that offers that, you need to check that.
And then, you know, the pension contribution,
I think it's still, they put 10% into your pension
and you can choose what you add to it.
So I think when the policies are so generous,
13 weeks for gender reassignment surgery doesn't seem so crazy.
But in the context of what people in private businesses get.
Oh, yeah.
And I think we should remind ourselves how lucky they are.
I mean, when you're talking about small to medium enterprises
and they have someone who says,
right, can I just tell you why I'm pregnant?
It is a massive problem.
Really big.
Well, absolutely.
Yes.
And then you've come back and you're pregnant again.
Yeah, yeah.
Awkward.
Very quick.
How much does...
Don't look at me.
No, not you, not you.
You had a bit of a gap.
How much maternity leave do you think people should get in general?
I don't know because I've never really taken it.
Yeah, because you were straight back at it.
I mean, it's hard because as a woman,
obviously, I think it'd be wonderful to have a whole year off paid with your baby,
wouldn't it?
You can carry on breastfeeding right till the end, et cetera.
But do you think six months?
I mean, I think as a woman with children,
yeah, I think six months paid would be great.
But I do understand how if you work in a sort of five-person company and...
You can't do it.
You can't offer that because also it will stop those employers employing women of 30-odd
because they'll just think what if they have a baby
and our whole business model will be in really, really big trouble.
So I think it's up to the employer and then the employee should get to decide whether
or not they want to take on those terms.
One thing I do think is that the maternity leave contract should be in a job offer.
You should see when you're accepting the job what maternity leave you'll be getting
because that is very, very unusual.
Most of the time you have to dig into the employee handbook,
which you can't see once you arrive.
No one really wants to ask in the interview process.
And no one wants to ask in the interview process how long they can take off.
The second job, my second child was born when I was a foreign correspondent
and I went into New York to meet the notorious Roger Ailes who ran Fox News Channel.
Can you imagine if I'd asked him what my maternity leave might be?
Some people do it.
Some people say you should be able to.
No, no, no, no.
I think it should just be readily available because then you can make the decision based on...
Yeah, no, no, no, I agree.
I mean, he didn't really expect me.
I was two years into a three-year contract and I got pregnant and I'm sure he was horrified.
But actually, I will say this, they were totally, totally supportive of me.
And that's one of the reasons why I went back to work so quickly
was because of that support.
It was really, really incredible.
Yes, I feel like for employers it's a bit of shock to this shock
and then you get over it, work out how it's going to go in terms of covering things.
Right, well, should we end by talking about school uniforms?
It's going to be August the 14th when this goes out,
so it's not very long until the new school term starts.
Yeah, the government are trying to find ways to make it cheaper for everyone
in terms of the school uniform.
A new law coming into force means parents in England
should have to buy fewer branded items of school uniform,
which the government say will save them money.
So uniforms will be limited to three items that include a school logo,
like a blazer, jumper or sportswear,
plus a tie for secondary schools.
So it's the logo emblazoned items that are the expensive thing, Linda.
Yeah, so I know that I used to worry about this.
The expense was colossal.
Because in those days, I sound so ancient,
but in those days there was one shop,
one special shop that sold the uniform and you had to go to that shop.
And things were very, very expensive.
I think the idea that you have three items of clothing
with the logo is a good one.
And then you say, look, the school colour is navy.
We insist on a navy sweater.
We insist on white shirts.
We insist on charcoal grey trousers or skirts.
And that's that.
And I think that that is manageable.
And I think many of the big supermarkets now do a great line,
particularly Marks and Spencers, for example.
I don't know whether I can mention something like that.
And other shops, of course.
But I look at their lines and I think, wow,
that must save people some money
instead of going to the special shop that I used to go to.
So I completely, completely see where you're coming from.
I think there could be a danger.
The whole idea with school uniforms,
and I completely accept that they are very, very expensive.
The whole idea, though, is that everyone is dressed in exactly the same
and that makes it a leveller.
And I know that at my school, for example,
we had a strict school uniform,
but it was a very kind of mixed in terms of social background school.
You had, it was a very good state school
and you had, you know, people who grew up on council estates
and we had the daughter of Tony Blair went to high school.
So you've got a real mix there.
And I know it was a girl's school
and I know that if there had been this law in place,
three branded items and everything else you can get from wherever you like,
it would have become a, she's wearing a Asda shirt
and she's wearing a Chanel shirt
and the rich kids and the poor kids.
Chanel shirt!
You wouldn't be surprised.
And the rich kids and the poor kids become more separated
because they look more different.
Because one of the big advantages of a school uniform
is it is a great equaliser.
It shows unity and it's a great equaliser.
So I see your point completely,
but it has become in this era
where people are really under the gun when it comes to money,
it is a real problem for some families,
especially when they've got three or four kids.
One thing that could come to the fore more
is the school uniform shop
where you hand down the uniforms through the generations.
And certainly at my daughter's school,
that was very well frequented
and I used to go there all the time.
I couldn't get exactly what I wanted,
but we used to pick up stuff.
I mean, I come from a background,
like you, I went to a Catholic school
where the nuns would make me kneel on the floor
and make sure that my hem hit the ground.
We had that in life.
We just rolled us up as high as possible.
But I mean, the government says
this is going to save families up to £50 per child.
I'm very pro school uniform.
I intend to send George to a school
where they have a solid uniform,
but I don't think that it will.
I'm sure it will break the bank.
I can't believe that I was forced to wear
those little sports knickers.
They weren't even shorts, little brown knickers.
We had green.
I'm sure those are a thing of the past.
Yeah, they probably don't do them anymore
because there's all these concerns over,
I don't know, perverts and things.
But I think what's really interesting,
my daughter went into the sixth form of her school
and in my sixth form,
you only had to wear navy or white.
This is my secondary school in the sixth form.
And I said to her,
well, Kissy, what are you supposed
to be wearing to school these days?
She said, it doesn't matter, mum,
as long as it's corporate.
Corporate?
She had a very, very strong-minded headmistress.
Well, they were in blazers and work gear and a briefcase.
Briefcase?
Oh, yeah, yeah.
My husband's school was like that as well.
It's so funny seeing photos.
Oh, I've got a briefcase.
I used to have a bright pink backpack.
Oh, yeah, they were cool.
With a little monkey hanging off it.
That's very cute.
Kipling or whatever it was called.
Yeah, that's right.
Yeah, that's what I wanted. Hideous.
I think this is just massive overreach from the government.
I think schools should be able to make up
their own minds about this.
And yeah, I'm sure lots of schools would think,
and lots of schools already,
I think three quarters of schools already follow this guidance
and already say that you only have to have
three branded items of uniform.
I'm sure.
Yeah, and I think if you are a mum
who particularly wants to send your child to a school
with a strict uniform policy,
I think I would want you to do that.
I want every single item in blue.
Yeah, then you should have the option to be able to do that.
We used to spend a fortune, particularly,
this is, I'm thinking, a month or so.
Yeah, and the blazer was the most expensive item
in the whole kit.
Yeah.
And you used to be so disheartened,
you can't roll in at the end of the day,
and there would be this rolled up,
scrunched up school blazer
pushed to the bottom of the rucksack.
And you think, oh, please.
And nothing's changed since then.
I used to eat my sleeves.
Oh, so did I too.
I used to stick my thumb through.
Anyway, on that note, oh, sorry,
did you have something to add before we wrap up?
I was just going to say, I just remembered this.
Our school blazers were really expensive
and I had one from year seven to the end of year 11.
Oh, it was huge at the beginning
and by the end I was sort of unable to walk.
That shrunken jacket.
Yeah, exactly.
And the oversized look to begin with.
Well, thanks guys.
Mums, Olivia Rutley there, Linda Jubilee,
fantastic to have you on GB Mums this week.
We'll be back next week with more
and in the meantime, do get in touch.
What would you like us to be talking about on GB News Mums?
