Are license plate cameras a privacy threat?

Fox - 10 Phoenix
29 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe use of AI surveillance and Flock cameras in Arizona has sparked a debate over privacy and police oversight following reports of misuse. While these tools are effective for tracking criminals, a lack of state-level regulation has led to officers using the data for personal reasons, prompting calls for stricter legal guardrails and criminal penalties for abuse.
AI surveillance cameras or flock cameras as you've heard a lot about recently raising new questions
across the country and right here in Arizona about police oversight privacy and what happens
to the data they collect. And the question is who sets the rules for how that information is used.
Fox 10's Jacob Luffy has been looking into this all week and he found one lawmaker
who's been trying to pass new guardrails in the statehouse. Jacob. Yeah in just one week two
Arizona officers have resigned over alleged misuse of this technology. One agency has
scrapped its program entirely. Others are now investigating and a state senator Kevin Payne
tells me he saw the need for stronger oversight months ago. Introducing a bill he says would have
put more guardrails in place but lawmakers didn't pass it. Right now we're in the wild west and I
thought if we could get a little bit of guardrails up there that would be a big plus. Back in January
Republican State Senator Kevin Payne introduced Senate Bill 1111. It looked to provide guardrails
for law enforcement agencies who use automated license plate reader technology. The bill in
part would have required training for every user tracked every search including who accessed the
data when and why and made intentional misuse a classics felony. If you're going to abuse the
system you need to get more than fired you need to go to jail in my opinion. Payne says the bill
written with broad law enforcement support failed on the senate floor in March. Now the fallout is
spreading across Arizona. Goodyear and Surprise are investigating possible misuse. The Pinal
County Sheriff discontinued his agency's program saying fourth amendment rights must come first
and officers in Apache Junction and Chandler have resigned after using the technology to search for
family members. With Apache Junction police chief saying Monday he supports tougher rules. Right now
it's not a crime. In my opinion should it be? Absolutely. I would love to see that if this was
accessed intentionally for personal use it should be a crime. As law enforcement agencies re-examine
their policies a bigger question remains. Is the problem the technology itself or how it's being
used? Former assistant U.S. attorney Josh Colesrud says it's both because the concern he says isn't
When you see the flop cameras it's a little different because your behavior is stored in
a supercomputer somewhere and it's shared with every law enforcement agency in the United States
and any one of those law enforcement agencies could just type up your name or license plate
and discover every pattern that you have in your life. But Colesrud says that same capability can
be a powerful tool for investigators. Something he's seen firsthand while tracking patterns of
human and drug traffickers and that's where he says the balance gets difficult. Do the LPRs or
flop cameras help prevent crime? The answer is yes. Emphatically yes. But it comes with a cost.
There's also a huge potential of misuse with that type of power. Now state senator Payne tells me
he's going to try to build on that failed bill and introduce a similar one in the future but
tonight we're also putting that question to you. We've asked do you believe the safety benefits
of these cameras outweigh the privacy concerns? Now right now you can see on your screen yes
you're saying the benefits are worth it that's at 30 percent no concerns are too high at 70 percent
and some of you or I guess none of you saying only with more guardrails that is at zero percent.
Now if you want to weigh in you can head to fox10phoenix.com slash poll then click Fox 10
News to vote. Again we'll have more of those results later in this show. Jacob Luthi Fox 10 News.
All right Jacob thank you.
