Crusade of Joshua: a Historical Investigation by Parable

What Was The Life
13 followers
Aug 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the historical authenticity of the biblical general Joshua. By analyzing archaeological evidence at Hazor, comparing literary parallels with Moses, and debating dating methods like pottery typology, the program explores whether Joshua was a real leader who led the Israelites into Canaan or a mythological figure created for religious and cultural identity.
I'm going on an adventure.
There's only one way to figure it all out.
Unzip the archeology.
Make it naked.
And get naked.
Joshua fit the battle of Jericho.
Jericho, Jericho.
Joshua fit the battle of Jericho,
and the walls came a-tumbling down on him.
Joshua fit the battle of Jericho,
Jericho, Jericho.
Joshua fit the battle of Jericho,
and the walls came a-tumbling down.
Joshua, you know the tune, but do you know the man?
Did this great biblical general even exist?
Here's the story, and it starts with Moses.
Moses!
The Bible says Moses led the Israelites out of Egypt.
They wandered in the desert for 40 years.
Moses died. Joshua took over.
Moses is dead.
Go now and cross the Jordan River.
You will lead the people to take possession of the land
I swore to their ancestors I would give them.
In a series of great battles, he conquers Canaan,
the land God promised the Israelites.
Now what does that mean to you?
Well, without Joshua, there'd be no conquest.
And no conquest means no Israel.
No Israel, no Judaism, no Jesus.
No Jesus, no Christianity. You get the picture.
So who was this guy?
General, saint, villain, myth.
We've got three clues to find our man.
One, archaeology.
Two, literary sources.
Three, believe it or not, the miracle.
First things first,
if you want to know Joshua, forget Jericho.
The real story, the real battle,
and the real archaeology is somewhere else.
We're going to one of the most amazing archaeological sites
in the Holy Land to start our search for Joshua.
We're going to Hazor, that's H-A-Z-O-R or H-A-E-Z-O-R.
It's mentioned in the Bible as one of the cities,
one of the main Canaanite cities that was destroyed by Joshua
when he conquered Canaan, when he conquered this land.
Now, there's a big debate.
The biblical city of Hazor emerges
from the dust of antiquity
as archaeologists uncover silent remains of its glory.
I got it. Look, look at it.
Workers carefully chip away at crusts of time.
Some of these ruins belong to the 18th century before Christ.
It was Joshua who conquered Hazor,
capital of Canaanite kingdoms.
Canaanite inscriptions still remain on some of the stones.
Hazor was lost, won, and lost again by the Israelites
who left remains of their everyday life
intact after many centuries.
Solomon rebuilt the town,
and today the biblical city of Hazor is making history again.
The Bible says Joshua 11.10,
And Joshua at that time turned back and took Hazor,
and smote the king thereof with the sword.
For Hazor, before time, was the head of all those kingdoms.
Was Joshua real? Was he a mythical figure?
Did he really conquer this land?
A lot of people say he's totally a mythical figure.
Hazor wasn't destroyed by Joshua.
How do you figure it out?
Well, you dig at Hazor.
Just look at it.
Professor Amnon Bentor is our guide.
Professor, what do we do?
I'll tell you, I'm already arguing
with Professor Amnon Bentor,
and we haven't even started the interview.
And you've been here, this is Hazor.
This is one of the biblical sites that's been excavated.
No. No?
No.
Hazor is not mentioned in the Bible?
It is, but you just said it is one of the biblical sites.
No. So what do you mean?
It is the biblical site.
It's the biblical site, I'm sorry.
I stand corrected.
It is the biblical, and you'll tell us, well, okay, what?
I'll tell you why. Why?
No problem. Yeah.
There's no other site.
If you want conquest, okay?
Conquest. Yes, Joshua. No Joshua.
If you want to tackle conquest...
The conquest of Canaan by Joshua.
...by the Israelites, it's Hazor.
This is the place.
Now I don't say you have to agree about everything.
You don't have to agree about the conquest.
You don't have to agree,
but this is the place to have the argument.
This is it.
That's why I'm having this argument with you here.
Imagine Hazor more than 3,000 years ago.
A great palace, pagan altars,
soldiers, priests, families, children, a king.
Hazor, head of the Canaanite kingdom in the Galilee.
To conquer this land, Joshua needed to lop off that head.
As the Bible says, Joshua's army reached Hazor
and they smote all the souls that were therein
with the edge of the sword, utterly destroying them.
There was not any left to breathe
and he burnt Hazor with fire.
The Bible says Joshua burnt this Canaanite city.
But what's the evidence?
In ancient days, there was a wooden floor here?
Yes, there was. I'll show it to you.
Not this one.
I'll show it to you.
Are we going?
Yeah, we're going.
You want to see wood?
Come, I'll show you.
You see the base?
This stuff.
Why did they...
All the walls are lined by basalt slabs.
Wow.
Look at this basalt.
Can I take a piece?
Come here, come here.
You see the line of little stones?
Yeah.
Above it, do you see the black line?
I see the black line.
This is the burnt wood.
Wow.
You see it?
I see it clearly.
That's it.
That's the burnt floor.
We're talking about a big fire.
A lot of wood, a lot of olive oil,
because we have at least 20 huge pithoi.
Pithoi meaning jars.
Huge jars, each one of them more than 200 liters,
which were all burning,
because we have the lines of burnt oil
still seen on the outer face of the jars.
And we have what we don't have now.
Unfortunately, very, very strong winds.
The combination of strong winds, oil, and wood
would create temperatures that are double
the temperature of a normal fire.
A normal fire is 600, 700 degrees centigrade.
We had a fire here that was at least
1300 degrees centigrade.
Wow, so it would kind of melt everything, right?
If you'll come and look at the mud brick,
you'll see that the mud brick melted.
It looks like lava.
Look at it.
Here?
Yeah.
To be able to melt them like this.
You need more than 1300 degrees centigrade.
1300.
So this is just-
This is an unbelievable fire
in which this palace perished.
Okay, but things don't get destroyed in-
By accident.
By accident, right?
No, somebody torched it.
Somebody torched it.
Yeah.
Okay.
Does this bit of melted mud brick
authenticate the biblical story?
Our first piece of evidence in the search for Joshua.
Kings of Canaan, please help me stop the Israelites
before they burn Hazor and slaughter all our people.
Sincerely yours, King Jabin of Hazor.
In your hands, evidence to the destruction
of the palace of Hazor in the middle of the 13th century.
Does this bit of melted mud brick
prove Joshua burned Hazor over 3000 years ago?
You dig at Hazor and you find the ash,
where and when the Bible says it should be.
But did Joshua do it?
Not everyone thinks so.
I'm on my way to meet Carl Ehrlich,
professor of religious studies at York University.
We're trying to find Joshua, the man behind the myth.
But Ehrlich thinks we might be looking for the wrong man.
He wonders, is Joshua actually the same guy as Moses?
A sort of literary clone.
There is a character named Joshua
who we encounter in the Hebrew Bible.
A character who arguably is modeled
on that of Moses, literarily.
Although some people perhaps would argue
that the character of Moses and the Moses traditions
are modeled on Joshua.
It's one of these chicken or egg questions.
Part of the suspicion you have
is their details are too similar.
Moses leads the Israelites across the Reed Sea
where the waters part.
Joshua leads the Israelites across the Jordan River
where the waters part.
Moses encounters God or an angel of God at the burning bush
and is told to take off his sandals
because the ground upon which he is standing is holy.
Joshua encounters an angel of God outside Jericho
and is told to take off his sandals
because the ground upon which he is standing is holy.
No, I can see, I'm a hockey fan.
I'm a hockey fan and I can see that in the future,
PhDs, people will get their PhDs on the following.
They'll see that there were two,
these two legendary hockey figures,
one named Bobby Orr and another named Wayne Gretzky.
And they couldn't possibly be real people
because they both grew up skating as little kids
on ice rinks in Canada.
Sometimes truth is stranger than fiction.
Hockey sticks.
They both had, you know, they both,
they clearly are the same figment of somebody's imagination.
Maybe there was some Wayne Gretzky.
Maybe there was some Bobby Orr.
But they couldn't both be hockey players
who were the greatest.
Somebody made them up.
And since we have no archeology, the actual skates,
they probably didn't exist.
Somebody is going to have a PhD in Gretzkology.
Moses and Joshua, the same person?
It's a literary theory.
Here's the logic.
Joshua needs authority.
So borrow some from Moses.
And you do this by making their stories mirror each other.
Archeology can't prove it one way or the other.
Oddly enough, we're on more solid ground.
We find more archeology
when we turn our attention from men to gods.
The Bible says Joshua smote his enemies
with the edge of the sword.
And what do we got here?
We've got Canaanite gods.
One of them, a god or a worshipper of gods
with his head lopped off.
But this guy's head was taken right off
by somebody with a very big sword.
Who did that?
Well, they say they don't know if there was a Joshua or not.
One thing that they do know is that the Bible says
that when Joshua came through Hazor,
he burned it, he destroyed it.
He went after the Canaanite gods.
This is exactly the kind of stuff
that Joshua and the incoming Israelites did not like.
They cut these things down.
They toppled them to the ground.
And then guess what?
That's exactly how the archeologists found them.
Toppled to the ground in a destruction lair.
That was different than other cultures
because polytheistic culture, pagan culture,
was accepting of many gods.
But here you had a revolution according to the Bible.
A revolution, one god.
A god that didn't tolerate the worshipping of stones,
of standing stones and of gods and goddesses.
So we have plenty of evidence of gods,
but our man, Joshua, is a shadowy figure.
The Bible's full of his stories,
but most of his exploits wouldn't leave
any evidence for us to find.
Here's Joshua's problem.
He's famous because he won battles.
And that means destroying things.
He didn't build things for us to find,
he knocked them over, or burnt them,
or put them to the sword.
Joshua 6.21.
And they utterly destroyed all that was in the city,
both man and woman, young and old,
and ox and sheep and asses with the edge of the sword.
Other stories give us better clues
as to whether or not our man existed.
The Bible says Joshua conquered 31 cities,
including Hazor, Jericho, Jerusalem,
Lachish and Megiddo.
Many of these places can still be found today.
Professor Finkelstein studied a number of them.
He says there's no way Joshua conquered all 31 cities
because 3,200 years ago,
some of these cities didn't exist.
When we come to Joshua,
we see one that many of the sites
mentioned in the book of Joshua
regarding the conquest of Canaan
in the supposedly, in the 13th century BC,
had not at all existed at that time.
It didn't exist at the time of Joshua.
I mean, there is no eye at the site of Ai,
and there is no Arad at the site of Arad, 13th century.
I'm speaking about 13th century.
If you take the list of conquered cities in Joshua 12,
or in the stories themselves,
and you compare the list, you know,
to what we know today from archeology,
you get two completely different stories, completely.
The archeology says one thing.
I mean, most of the places were not inhabited
in the late Moses age.
But is Professor Finkelstein looking in the right time?
Consider this.
Future archeologists search for evidence
of World War II in 1945.
No problem.
What if they get the date wrong and look in 1925?
Misjudged 20 years, World War II disappears.
If we want to find Joshua,
we need to know where and when
to look.
Difficult questions.
But here's an easy one.
How does a broken pot and a miniskirt
help us to date Joshua?
We're looking for Joshua,
but how do we decide which year to find him in?
Well, we use a broken pot and a miniskirt.
One of the most important means to assign a date
is pottery typology.
Pottery changes over time.
Pottery changes rather quickly
because it breaks, because it's cheap to make.
So once it breaks, you make a new one and fashion.
It's like future archeologists will be able to tell by-
By models of cars.
By cars.
By cars, by dresses.
One year, all the women go with short dresses.
Another year, they go with long dresses.
But then they go to short dresses again,
and that confuses future archeologists.
No, no, no, but then you put it together
with something else.
Short dress, the long dress with this type of car.
You have to match it all up.
And once you get the starting point,
you go with it, okay?
Both Professor Bentor and Professor Finkelstein
try to solve parts of Joshua's puzzle
with bits of broken pottery.
But reconstructing the past is a humpty-dumpty task.
All the king's horses and all the king's men
don't always agree on what goes when.
Think about it.
We're trying to tell a story,
a tale of heroes, villains, battles, and conquests.
But our clues are bits of smashed pottery.
3,000 year old smashed pottery.
And if that sounds tough,
how can we tackle Joshua's miracles?
The book of Joshua says walls fall when a trumpet sounds.
The sun stands still.
The river Jordan parts.
But consider this question.
Do some of the things we call miracles
have natural explanations?
We've got these stories
that include aspects of the miraculous,
of the superhuman,
that the archeological record cannot
comment on one way or the other.
March all of your soldiers around the city
once a day for six days.
Have seven priests carry seven rams,
horned trumpets in front of the Ark.
A very unusual fight.
On the seventh day, blow the trumpets
and the whole army must utter a war cry.
Then the city walls will collapse
and the men can charge straight in.
Do you think he was a real person?
Do you think he actually conquered Jericho?
Probably not, but you never know.
Or if he conquered Jericho,
it certainly wasn't the way it's depicted
in the Hebrew Bible.
And there's a certain logic.
You know, we just experienced this tsunami
that killed a quarter of a million people, okay?
Walls of water came on people.
Now, it could be that if we didn't have,
you know, all these news and photographs
and everything, that people later would say,
walls of water, a quarter of a million people, impossible.
No, it must be mythological.
Why do you assume that it didn't happen?
Jericho is an earthquake zone.
They marched around, they tooted their horn,
an earthquake came.
You can argue about why did it come?
Was it just a coincidence?
Why couldn't it happen?
Don't you see what you're doing?
In your attempt to preserve the literal text of the Bible,
you have just added something
that is not mentioned in the Hebrew Bible
and doesn't appear.
An earthquake.
There is no mention.
All kinds of weird things happen
around Joshua's time, according to the Bible.
The sun stood still, the Jordan River got blocked up.
That happens constantly.
It's been documented scientifically.
That the sun stood still.
No, that the Jordan River gets blocked for days on end
because of earthquake activity
and because of rocks falling into the thing.
So in other words, you're a Velikovskian.
You have a catastrophic idea.
Oh, for those who don't know, that's a big insult.
Immanuel Velikovsky, 1950s academic who said,
comets caused the biblical plagues.
Scientists called him a crackpot.
Since then, scientists have come to accept
that comets have caused catastrophes,
like wiping out the dinosaurs.
So could other natural disasters be at play
in Joshua's tale?
Is there any way we can explain some of Joshua's miracles
based on natural phenomena?
Dr. Charles Pellegrino is a scientist
with a taste for disaster.
Sodom and Gomorrah, Pompeii, Atlantis.
The Bible says when Joshua conquered Israel, Canaan,
the Jordan River stopped flowing and he crossed over.
They came to Jericho, they blew their ram's horns
and the walls came tumbling down.
Skeptics come and say, this is mythology,
I don't even have to investigate it.
You come and say, sorry, it's geology.
Yeah, we know it's a tremendous earthquake zone.
A couple times a century, there's a quake,
which also affects Jericho even today,
and you get these landslides.
And for up to a day or two, the river no longer flows
because there's an artificial dam along the Jordan Valley.
And here you have an association
with the tumbling of Jericho's walls
that the river stopped flowing.
Let's sum up for a moment.
We've looked for Joshua in miracles,
in literary theory, in archaeology,
and it's time to return to where we started, Hazor.
Does Professor Bentor think Joshua is the culprit,
the one who burnt Hazor?
Why can't it be that simple?
Because you may have all kinds of alternative explanations.
Such as?
Such as X destroyed Hazor.
Mr. X?
X, give me whoever you are.
Egyptians, Assyrians.
And the Israelites, 500 years later,
say, you see, we did it.
It was my granddad.
Because in order to be sure of what you are saying,
we need to find a sign here saying,
I, Joshua, conquered Hazor,
just like it says in the Bible.
Since I believe this is never going to happen,
it will be, from now on, a matter of common sense.
You said it will always be a matter of common sense.
What does your common sense tell you?
The Egyptians never claimed that they destroyed Hazor.
The Philistines never claimed,
and they don't claim anything,
but the Philistines were never here.
It was too inland,
and we never find even one Philistine portrait here.
The Canaanites, which Canaanite city
was capable of destroying Hazor.
So who is left but a conglomerate of people,
Bedouins of various kinds, if you wish,
who destroyed Hazor,
and many, many, many years later,
they were called Israelites.
It is an option, logical, but I cannot prove it.
Did Joshua lead those Israelites?
Most evidence speaks to Joshua's role
as conquering general, righteous destroyer.
But evidence of his creation surrounds us.
From Joshua came Israel.
From Israel, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam,
and so much of our world's culture.
You can argue myth or man,
but there's no denying Joshua's legacy.
