NY Strip Steak Chicago Style | Wagyu Steak | Pellet Grill

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
1 Video View·Aug 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
I'm serious I may never do a steak any other way other than this absolutely perfect.
Hey what's up everybody welcome back to G-Rod grills my name is Gerardo and this is my channel.
If you're into backyard barbecue on a variety of different grills whether it's pellet, charcoal,
electric then you've hit the right place so please consider subscribing because that's
exactly what this channel is all about. Today I'm going to be doing a Chicago style wagyu
strip steak and it's going to be absolutely fantastic. I'm going to be doing it on my
Pit Boss 440 using the Pit Boss charcoal pellets. Are you ready to get going? Let's go!
All right here we go we got ourselves a beautiful wagyu New York strip steak.
You can see all that beautiful marbling all over and it's going to be absolutely delicious.
I'm going to keep this nice and simple I'm just going to do salt and pepper on top and
I'll show you the rest right after we're done here. I want to make sure you get both sides
nicely covered so we'll flip her over and do it again. Beautiful there you go so far nothing
different right this looks great already. Here's the thing for Chicago style we need an awesome
black crust all the way around which I'm going to be doing over direct flames using my Pit Boss
flame sear. Typically for Chicago style you would use a melted butter or an oil of sorts to help
create that crust but today I'm going to be using mayonnaise. I know before you get on me saying hey
G-Rod what the heck are you doing putting mayonnaise on a wagyu steak you should be enjoying
the flavor. I know trust me you won't taste it and the crust this is going to build is incredible.
It's a great alternative to using butter or oil and in my opinion it actually works even better.
You can leave me any angry comments below if you'd like but I'll tell you what at the end of this
I'm going to be eating a perfect steak with a fantastic crust. And there you go nicely covered
in mayo this is going to give us the fat we need to create that wonderful crust we want in the
Chicago style steak and it's going to be super awesome. Nothing else to do here I'm going to let
it sit at room temperature while I get the grill ready and up the temperature and I'll show you
that in a second. Okay here we go so now we're going to set this up I've had this running for
about 15-20 minutes or so at 350 degrees so it's nice and warmed up in there. Now we're going to
get it going getting ready for searing. What I'm going to do to make things easier on myself is I'm
going to take this off that way I can slide this grate nice and easy side to side as I need to.
We're going to be using very high heat here to start off I'm going to be setting this to high
I'm going to do that right now. Now I'm just going to close the lid let it heat up for about
another five to ten minutes and then we're going to be ready to sear.
All right so I've had this heating up here for about five minutes or so we're ready to do a sear.
Now really important because this is set to high that you've cleaned your grill I cannot stress
that enough I cleaned this this morning it needs to be spotty clean so you don't get any sort of
grease fire. Right now we're going to sear for about two to three minutes per side I'm going to
keep the lid open just so that I can watch for flare-ups or anything like that it is Wagyu so
it does have quite a bit of fat or marbling throughout so it is possible that we get some
good flare-ups and you can see some of the fire still starting to come up so we want to make sure
you sit here and watch to control it. All right see how we've got a nice little charred crust
there we got a nice little crust on this side here so what I'm going to do is I'm going to
turn this heat down to about 350 degrees I'm going to this is why we took the other one over
slide it over and close the grate now the next step here is I'm going to put in my meter probe
and this is going to tell me once we're at the temperature I want it medium rare so I'm going
to go to about 125 to 130 degrees and I'm going to take it off and I'm going to let it rest we're
going to close the lid now and it's going to cook at indirect heat now at 350 degrees until it's
ready to go I'll see you back when it's done. All right here we go I don't know hopefully you can
see that it's beautiful steak I've got a pad of some compound butter here on top I'm just going
to move that a little bit over so you can maybe see a little bit better but perfect little crust
on the outside oh it smells so delicious well let's cut into this baby all right let's see
just going to cut right down the middle absolutely gorgeous but you can see that
perfect medium rare crust on the outside like no other but wall to wall pink let's have a little
taste of that all right let's bring it a little bit closer and then let's have a taste all right
all right all right I'm so excited just going to go ahead and cut a few strips here
put a little bit of salt over top just because that's how we do things around here
I don't know if you can see this that crust fantastic it looks charred but you know it's
delicious I don't even know what to tell you I may not do a steak any other way than this one
that mayo can't taste the mayo but you can certainly taste the crust on the outside and
oh the juices I'm telling you if you haven't done it this way you need to mayonnaise this thing is
I don't know it's some sort of voodoo condiment because it is absolutely fantastic and of course
it is wagyu beef so it's super tender to begin with but wow the flavor is just incredible again
the char on the outside fabulous those charcoal pellets although it's not the same as cooking on
charcoal but it does give it a little hint of different flavors so which is nice now I know
I did this on a pellet grill you don't have to do it in a pellet grill if you don't have one if
you have a charcoal grill absolutely key thing like I said earlier make sure you keep it clean
so you don't have any flare-ups or any huge grease fires especially if you're using wagyu
beef you're gonna get you know there's a lot of fat drippings that come down into the coals and
that's gonna give you big flare-ups get it nice and close to the coals sear it you know two three
minutes per side so you get that beautiful dark color put it indirect immediately after that
300 400 degrees and just let it come to 10 to the temperature that you want
this is perfect for me medium rare wall-to-wall pink 100 I think it finished at about 140 degrees
absolutely perfect that's all I got for you today if you like what you saw make sure you hit that
like button hopefully you're learning something and if you want to see a little bit more of this
make sure you hit that subscribe don't forget to ring that bell so you don't miss out on any content
until next time I'll catch you in the next year on grills
