*New customers in AZ, CO, CT, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MO, NC, NJ, NY, OH, PA, TN, VA, VT, WV, or WY. Must toggle on this promotion in your bet slip and wager $5+ cash on any market (min. odds -500) within 7 days of account opening to receive $100 in FanCash. Promotional FanCash expires 7 days from issuance (at 11:59pm ET). Terms, including FanCash terms apply-see Fanatics Sportsbook app. Use FanCash on bonus bets, profit boosts, team gear on Fanatics.com and so much more.
A scoreboard malfunction just gave us the craziest baseball play of the year, maybe
the last couple years.
It's brought to you by Fanatic Sportsbook, and it's between the Toronto Blue Jays and
the Boston Red Sox.
We're in the seventh inning of a two-run game.
The Red Sox leadoff hitter gets on with a single.
Next hitter comes up, nice piece of hitting, gets it down, and now we've got first and
second.
2-0 pitch to our third hitter, and he's going to put that one in play.
Was it caught?
Was it stopped?
There's outs, there's outs.
One out on the play.
One out on the play, but a pause of confusion.
Not a lot, just a little bit, because did he catch it on the fly?
Did he not?
That's the situation.
And no, okay.
He picked it, hit the dirt, they threw to second to get the force out.
Here's another look.
It's a nice play by Vlade on the ground, submarine throw.
They get the force out at second.
But after that play, the scoreboard reads two outs, even though that was only one out.
Because what they saw for a split second was that maybe Vlade caught that on the fly.
That's the first out.
You can see the base runner stop.
Do I have to go back to first?
Did he catch that on the fly?
And then when he throws it to second base, that's the second out, and we've doubled up
the lead runner.
That's what the scoreboard operator or system that runs it, they thought that for a split
second.
Now, so it reads two outs.
Now, the very next pitch is put in play, and on the top right here, you can see that they
change it mid play.
So had the first pitch of the next at bat been just a ball, a strike, a foul ball, had
it not been put in play, this would have been fixed, and we would have no confusion.
But that's not what happened.
The first pitch was put in play while the scoreboard was wrong, and the two runners
in green here, they thought there were two outs.
They were looking at that scoreboard, so they just take off as if there's two outs.
There were not, which gives the Blue Jays a very easy double play, like, hey, hey, throw
it over there.
Throw it to Vlade.
Let's get out of this inning.
Vlade says, yeah, yeah, yeah, throw it to me, throw it to me.
Bam.
Umpire says out, and they leave.
That's just a blunder by the Red Sox.
You can see their coaches pretty disappointed in their players.
There's one out.
God damn it.
You've got to be kidding.
You can see him looking at the first base coach like, what's going on, dude?
What are you, what happened?
****, man.
And the first base coach is like, uh, one out?
I was all over it.
Now, Siegler, the runner who scored, he's confused.
Wait, what?
What?
What are you guys saying?
I didn't score?
What's going on?
Looks to the dugout control room and says, there was one out.
Yeah, you guys botched it.
It's all right.
But yeah, you botched it.
Now the Blue Jays players, it looks like they thought the same thing.
You see the pitcher and the catcher.
As soon as this ball is caught, they celebrate in tandem, mind you.
But maybe Woods Richardson saw the runners because he does kind of turn his head.
He maybe sees that the runners are just way gone.
Like there's no salvaging it because a little afterwards, after the dual celebration, which
we all agree is awesome.
The catcher says, add a baby.
Yeah.
Give me that.
Add a boy.
And then there's a pause and they're like, no, get him at first.
Right?
Yeah.
So maybe they were, maybe they weren't fooled.
And I don't know.
What do you guys think?
Do you think they thought there was two outs or do you think they saw the runners being
so far gone?
Or do you not care about this part?
Who knows?
I think they kind of knew.
The coaches on the Blue Jays were all over it, tracking the ball, tracking the runners.
And then they're all going to be like, yeah, get him, get him, get him, get him, get him.
Yep.
Amazing.
Great job by us.
Really bad job by them, but great job by us.
Right?
Got to give yourself a compliment.
Now the umpire comes out and he confuses everyone.
Okay.
So what we have here is we have a time play, meaning when the third play, when the third
out was made at first base with the runner not tagging up, the runner that was on third
base also did not tag the cross home plate before the third out was made at first base.
Do a rules check.
What?
So that just confused everybody like, what is going on?
It did not confuse one person.
The runner who scored on the Red Sox, Anthony Sigler, he's all over it.
He says, they doubled you off.
If they were to double there, would it matter?
But they tried to, they doubled you off.
So okay, Sigler is correct.
The first way for none of this to happen was the scoreboard doesn't get it wrong.
The second way none of this happens is that the first pitch while the scoreboard is wrong
doesn't get put in play.
The third way that none of this happens is if the Blue Jays throw it to the correct base.
You had a base runner on first and a base runner on third.
Now the ball is hit in the air all the way to the outfield.
These guys just take off, right?
And the first out is made up here, out number one.
Now when that ball gets thrown out number two, out number one on the play, out number
two in the inning, when the ball gets thrown in, if they throw this ball straight to third
base and tag up the lead runner and get the third out here, none of this happens.
There's no confusion.
They did not do that.
They threw the ball to this base and they got the trail runner.
Now there was a way for them to salvage this.
They could have played for the fourth out.
This is the next way we avoid the mess and confusion.
They get the third out here.
They throw it across and they step on this bag and now they've doubled up both runners
and you play for the fourth out.
You may be thinking, I've never heard of this, playing for the fourth out.
Well, it actually does happen a ton now because of replays and challenges and teams are playing
for the fourth out more and more.
Here's a bunch of examples.
There's two outs in this inning.
They throw it to second.
They get called out, but they want to make sure this runner doesn't score in case replay
review says, nah, he was actually safe at second.
So they played that through for the fourth out.
They're like, we're going to challenge to play at second.
And the umpires were like, well, if you challenge to play at second, it doesn't matter because
he's out anyway.
Good job by the defense.
Here's another example.
I think this is the one that might be in most people's memories because it was a great throw
by Freeman.
Third out at first base, but let's just make sure and they get Duda who was rounding and
being like, what?
And then replay did show he would have been safe at first.
Thank God they played for the fourth out and tagged him out.
This is common teams know about this.
You're out.
We've got other examples.
Another Mets game.
Mets are doing everything.
Another heads up play by the Mets on this one because they get the last out at home,
but catchers thinking they're going to challenge that.
They're going to review it.
Let's just get this guy too.
They play for the fourth out.
And in this one, he was safe.
So thank God they did it.
Got the fourth out safe there.
The run scores, but you're out to recap.
The scoreboard did malfunction.
The next pitch was put in play.
The Blue Jays didn't get the lead runner.
The Blue Jays didn't play for the fourth out.
What's the next thing they can do?
Well, they can appeal the play, but there are some rules to when they can do that.
Rule number one, they have to appeal before the next pitch.
They have to appeal before the next play.
They have to appeal before the defense leaves the field.
Now Sigler again is all over this.
He's trying to get his teammates to understand.
He says, okay, it's the same ---- when like you got like when somebody's tagging up,
but they're saying they left early, but they're checking it out first.
Then you just go and then they get them out right there.
They can't review that play now.
That's correct.
That is actually the second one, the before the next play.
We've seen teams exploit this where one run will score,
but they're like, he might've left early.
We don't want them to double him up.
So they'll just send the next base runner in motion.
And then they'll, instead of appealing the play,
they'll try to get this runner out.
And then that doesn't erase the run.
That's a play we've seen before.
Obviously the next pitch we've seen before that we've seen before.
I've never seen this third one.
That's what's happening right here.
So we went into the archives to find how many times
has this actually happened in major league baseball?
We found a handful of times this has happened.
Some recent, some old.
This one's from 1989.
Yankees are playing first and third.
The bunts on the runners were going on the pitch.
So they're not tagging.
Out is made.
Neither go back and tag.
They opt to get the out at first.
You can see the second baseman saying throw it to third.
Instead, he throws it to first.
And that first baseman isn't standing on the bag,
which gives the runner more time to cross home plate
before that out is made.
And then they run off the field and they never appeal.
So the Yankees actually got a run on that play without tagging up.
Now this one comes from 2009.
And Max Scherzer actually pitched in this game.
And he's on the Blue Jays right now.
Hot shot back to Dan Heron.
They throw it to second to double up the runner at second.
The runner on third is going home.
If he just steps on second base here and doubles off that runner,
the run would not count because he hasn't crossed home plate yet.
He opts to not step on the bag and instead goes to tag the base runner,
which gave them enough time for that runner to score and count,
which is bizarre.
So that put a run back on the board.
2022, this happened.
And the confusion here wasn't a scoreboard malfunction was,
did he catch it? Did he not catch it?
He ends up catching it.
And the bizarre one about this is the third baseman.
He was so close to doing everything right.
The umpires get together and they decide,
no, yeah, that run's going to score because when he's going for the second out,
if he steps on the base, he gets the lead runner out.
They double up the lead runner instead of stepping on the base.
He tags the trail runner.
So they never double up the lead runner.
That one cracks me up knowing what we know now,
but I don't, I can't really fault the players that much.
He's like, actually, yeah, the run scores.
That's a signal run scores.
And then the most impactful one, the 1980 playoffs,
we had another situation.
Did he catch it? Did he not catch it?
They called it a catch.
So Pete Rose scores.
He does not tag up and they don't double them off.
They double off the runner that was at first for the double play.
So they're pissed off about it.
The Phillies, because they don't know at this point that the run counts.
Schmidt's like, what are you doing?
He didn't catch that ball.
And he didn't.
He didn't.
This is a bad call and like kind of just bad baseball.
This ball gets trapped.
No replay reviews.
Then umpire had a great angle.
He's like, nah, out base runner.
You can see Schmidt.
He's looking.
He's like, uh, and he says, no, he didn't catch it.
That led to the game tying run in the eighth inning of a playoff game.
So this has happened before and it's happening now.
As long as he crossed home plate before the out at first.
And Siegler is pretty confident.
He's like, I just said, I, I got there before that.
They got you out.
I scored.
So let's take a look at the timing play here.
There he is on third.
There's the ball in the air and he touches home plate right there.
And the out at first base that he has to score before it happens happens now.
So well before, well before he got in there and they're loving it.
Now the Red Sox are like, so we didn't get fooled.
We were smart.
And he's like, yeah, we were trying to exploit some *******, uh, rules.
Yeah.
We were just being cool.
Exploiting rules.
Now Scherzer, like I said, was in that game in 2009.
He knows all about this.
He was all over it, but he also knows the next part.
He says, what fucked it up is that the home plate umpire waved it off.
Home plate umpire says, no run, no run.
Points at home plate says, no, no, no, no, no.
He waved it off.
Showed you before the umpires, when they say run,
they point at home plate to say that run counts.
Now this is what the Blue Jays don't like.
And they're arguing because Schneider is saying,
but we don't get a chance to replay because you waved it off.
You can't just stop the play.
And they're like, well, we, well, you guys stop.
You can't stop it then.
Well, no, you guys would have to appeal it.
They're probably telling him that something like you would have to appeal it.
And he's saying, oh, I'm reacting.
I'm reacting to what the call is.
I'm on your guy's time.
Your man waved it off.
So they come back from replay review and this is what the ump says.
After calling New York, getting it all straightened out,
the run is going to score.
Jason Kelsey looked like loves it.
And so does Siegler.
I told you I knew.
Yep.
He was all over it.
That's what he meant to do.
Big brain, big brain.
Oh yeah.
I wasn't confused.
Not once.
All right.
Maybe once.
Now Schneider still has some questions.
He's still got some complaints because he's saying,
so you're saying all of my players were off the field before he waved off the run.
Well, that's absolute dog ----.
And it is.
Look, he waves off the run right there.
The Blue Jays still have three players still on the field.
Now, if the umpire was to do the signal of run scores and point down,
maybe Schneider and the coaches would have been very alert and said,
Hey, stay on the field, stay on the field, stay on the field, stay on the field.
Appeal at third.
Maybe.
The way I'm understanding it, that would happen.
The only thing I'm confused at is the ball seems to be dead already
because the umpire is throwing a new ball out.
But when he waves it off, Vladdy has the ball still there.
Can the ball leave the field?
Or could Vladdy have thrown, Vladdy could throw that back into fair territory.
There was a, Vladdy, Vladdy, Vladdy, throw the ball in, throw the ball in.
If he had signaled the run.
So the Blue Jays are saying, you waved it off.
So why would we appeal when you said no run?
So in the end, I think the Blue Jays were kind of on top of this,
even though it seems like nobody was besides Siegler and the Blue Jays.
And that is why Scherzer unofficially protested the game.
If you understand what happened after watching this video,
leave a comment and say, thanks, Jimmy.
I'm so smart now because of you.
If not, watch it again.
But I hope that, uh, thanks for watching.
Brought to you by Fanatic Sportsbook.
Take your swing every day with long ball jackpot to compete for a piece of a 50K
fan cash pot.
Over 7 million in fan cash has been awarded since the start of the MLB season.
Winning hits different at Fanatic Sportsbook.