Toyota Land Cruiser vs. Lexus GX | Which Is the Better Off-Roader? | Off-Road Comparison Test

SUV review
33 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the Toyota Land Cruiser and Lexus GX, both built on the TNGA-F platform. While the GX offers superior power, luxury, and on-road composure, the Land Cruiser excels in technical off-roading due to better approach angles and robust body protection. The choice depends on whether the user prioritizes a refined daily driver or a rugged, customizable off-road rig.
Guys, I texted you last night.
I'm wearing tan.
Now I gotta go change.
The Land Cruiser traditionally lined up
with the big boy Lexus LX,
but in its newest iteration,
it's been hit by a glancing blow from a shrink ray,
and now it's sized to go head to head with the GX.
What also makes this comparison really fun
is the fact that these two vehicles,
even though one's a Lexus and one's a Toyota,
they're actually really close on price.
This Land Cruiser first edition,
of which there are only 5,000 being built,
it runs all the way up to almost $77,000,
while for the Lexus,
which is basically as built up as the GX will come,
that's only 80 grand.
So when they're that close,
we get to compare them on equal footing,
which is something we don't often get to do
between these two companies.
Today, we're going to put these vehicles
through four off-road tests
that should highlight the differences between them.
The ziggurat, the hill climb, the pipes,
and finally, a high-speed run through a sandy wash.
We'll kick things off here at the ziggurat,
which provides a great way to demonstrate
the suspension flexibility for these vehicles,
and gives us an opportunity
to discuss a key mechanical difference between them.
So we've got the GX up here on the ziggurat,
and this is supposed to be more of a test
of suspension articulation,
but it turned out to be a test of approach angles as well.
Now, these two vehicles, very similar in size,
both have 112.2 inch wheelbases
on the same TNGA-F platform
that is going under basically all of Toyota's new trucks.
But the difference is the GX, three inches longer,
and all of that seems like it comes in the nose
because it only has a 26 degree approach angle.
So we actually had to be pretty careful getting it up here.
So differences in the front suspension
between these two vehicles,
the Toyota has a much more lo-fi solution,
just your old school disconnecting front sway bar,
but here in the Lexus, a high-tech solution,
an electronic kinetic dynamic suspension system,
which basically means that they can take
that front stabilizer bar, make it loose off-road
to give you articulation,
and make it tight on-road to make it more comfortable.
So as you can see, the GX got up about two steps
and then a little bit more before that rear tire came up.
So now it's time to get the Toyota up
and see if it can beat it.
So now we've got the Land Cruiser up here,
and as you can see, it went just about as far as the GX,
although that nose is a little bit shorter,
so it got up here with considerably less drama.
While we had both vehicles up here,
we took a look at the underside as well,
and in the Land Cruiser,
we could see that it's a lot more built up.
You have this really big, nice skid plate
that goes from the front all the way through
to basically the middle of the truck,
and it covers up the transfer case,
covers up a lot of the important mechanical bits,
and on the GX, a lot less shielding,
and you also have, instead of a rock rail here,
which is pretty tough,
these sort of like plastic side steps
that we're very afraid of hitting on anything
because they might break off.
So in the Land Cruiser,
it seems like you can send it a little more without worrying.
So here at the Ziggurat, it's basically a tie.
These two went up about the same amount
and showed the same amount of suspension articulation,
although it was a bit easier to load in the Land Cruiser,
but now it's time to head on to our next challenge,
the hill climb.
As we're headed to the next obstacle,
this gives me the chance to tell you
about the other benefit of the e-KDSS system,
and that would be on-road driving.
So the GX basically drives a little bit better
than the Land Cruiser in pretty much every way,
and a lot of that is because of that system.
The front end feels a bit more planted,
it's more comfortable on the road,
body roll is much better controlled,
and that's not to say that the Land Cruiser drives badly,
because for something on a truck platform,
I think the Land Cruiser also drives quite well,
but this e-KDSS system helps the GX feel more composed,
and on the skid pad,
even though it has a more aggressive all-terrain tire,
it even pulled a higher number than the Land Cruiser did,
and I think a lot of that comes down
to that front end stability.
Now you might think that one of these being a Toyota
and the other one a Lexus,
that there would be a big difference on the inside.
However, these two interiors feel pretty similar,
and that's because they have a lot of the same features.
Both of them have leather upholstery,
both of them feel really well-finished and built,
and they have the same things
like heated and ventilated front seats,
and even a cooled center console box
that doubles as a mini-fridge while you're on the go.
The Lexus, it might have a larger screen,
but the bottom of that screen
is always reserved for the climate controls,
which means that the two screens
feel effectively about the same size,
and ergonomically, I actually prefer the Toyota's setup
with buttons for that,
and a better-placed wireless charging pad.
Overall, though, I still give a slight advantage to the GX,
but the fact that this is another close competition
speaks really highly of the Toyota.
For all the similarities that these two have,
roughly the same weight we found on our scales yesterday,
and same wheelbase, very different philosophically
when it comes to what's under the hood.
So here in the GX, a twin-turbo V6,
and on the Land Cruiser, a turbo four-cylinder
with that hybrid system.
Now, even though both of these powertrains
make very similar power figures,
how they deliver that power could be just very different,
and that's what we're here to figure out at the hill climb,
how they do in these low-speed situations
where throttle dexterity becomes super important.
So, let's send it.
I have it in four-low right now.
We've locked the center diff,
and we've locked the rear diff,
and I am doing all the throttle control.
So here we go.
You know, for all the issues that we had
with the front clearance,
this suspension is actually on this hill
showing some pretty good articulation.
I can sort of feel the wheels coming off,
but I feel like the other ones
are really doing a good job of keeping contact.
This, wow, this engine is so, so smooth.
I've basically planted my foot here
right at, like, mid-throttle,
and it's just moving up evenly, evenly, evenly.
The torque output is super, super smooth.
There's no peakiness, and even though I'm at super low RPM,
I just crawled right up this hill.
After kind of having a hard time
getting it up on the Ziggurat,
I was a bit worried about this hill climb,
but my fears were completely misplaced.
This thing is just all-around light work.
So, we've switched over to Land Cruiser,
set it up in pretty much the exact same way, four-low,
but this time disconnected the front sway bar,
center and rear diffs locked,
and let's see how she does.
So, like the other hybrid systems in Toyota's trucks,
everything here happens before the bell housing.
So, electric motor and gas engine, both in combination,
sending that power to the transmission together,
so it really comes out like one power source.
And you really have to nail the blend here
because you need to be able
to get really smooth output of power.
I'm in sort of the same throttle position here
that I was in the GX, and it's pretty good.
I gotta be honest with you,
it's hard to kind of tell exactly where the gas engine ends
and the electric power begins.
Maybe 30% throttle to 40% here,
just holding it real consistent,
and the torque output seems to be following that just so.
I'm crawling up the hill at just a really consistent rate.
Oh, man.
Just like the GX's powertrain.
Really impressed by the one here in the Land Cruiser
as well at low speed.
No problem up that hill.
Both of these rigs just showing off today.
So, yeah, all the concerns that you might have
about a hybrid powertrain up here
kind of dispelled really quickly.
Impressive in the Land Cruiser and impressive in the GX.
I know I use that word so much,
but these two, they're really doing it for me so far.
And now we're on to our next obstacle,
which should provide a much larger challenge, the pipes.
Okay, so we are here at the pipes,
which presents a very stern test,
I think, for these two vehicles.
They made it up the hill super easy,
but this one, this might be where they run into some trouble.
Now, both of these vehicles have decent ground clearance,
eight inches in the Land Cruiser, 8.9 inches here in the GX,
but because of the GX's big nose,
it has a much worse approach angle than the Land Cruiser does.
So 31 degrees in the Land Cruiser,
only 26 degrees here in the GX,
and I think that that is why the GX
is really going to struggle with this obstacle.
Fans of the Edmunds channel,
you'll remember that we were last out here
with a Mercedes-Benz G550 Professional,
and it made it over both sets of pipes.
It made it!
But that vehicle, it had the running boards removed,
and it also had 9.5 inches of ground clearance,
which is significantly more than both of these vehicles.
So, a little nervous again.
Both of these vehicles have a very cool
multi-terrain monitor system.
So when I'm in four low here,
it brings up this nice camera view right here,
and as I roll up here to the start of the pipes,
there's a section where the pipes go straight,
and you really need to make sure
that your tires are dead onto them.
So the nice thing is that as I roll up here,
I have this little guide here
where I can see where the tires are,
but if that's not precise enough,
I just hit this button right here,
and it takes me to another view
where I can actually see sort of through the car
and see exactly where the tires are.
So I also have this nice view down the left
and down the right, so as I'm going up here,
I can literally just see through the vehicle
where my tires are and make sure
they're on both of those pipes
and get it exactly where we need to be.
Now, the system has one shortcoming.
It is that, as you can tell right here,
I can't really tell how close the nose is exactly
to this next obstacle,
and so this is where we're gonna have to stop
and call in a spotter to make sure
that we have enough clearance
to get up onto this next part.
Here we go.
The GX's extra ground clearance
should have given it some advantage on this obstacle,
but we were constantly worried about its long nose,
those pesky running boards,
and the unshielded portions of the underbody.
While we were able to eventually find a line
to get the GX through the pipes,
it was a slow and stressful enterprise
for all involved.
The Land Cruiser's superior approach angle and shielding
were both on display here,
and it took only about half as long to clear the pipes
as it did in the GX,
and it did so with a lot less stress
thanks to the rock rails and bigger skid plate
providing ample protection.
Even though both rigs completed this exercise,
it's pretty clear which vehicle I'd choose
if I had to do it again.
This is a very clear win for the Land Cruiser.
Here on these off-road shoots,
we gotta bring a lot of gear
and we gotta take it from location to location
as we're moving around,
and that helped us to notice that here in the GX,
it's got a pretty high load-in height,
but we come over here to the Land Cruiser,
and things, they get even worse,
and that's because it's got a hybrid powertrain,
and the only place to really put that battery
where it's gonna be safe
is right here under the cargo floor,
and as a result, this load-in height is even higher,
so if you're a shorter person,
getting anything heavy up into this cargo area
is gonna be really difficult.
Now, this is a problem only on the Land Cruiser for now,
but the GX, it's gonna have the same problem
when it gets its own hybrid powertrain later this year.
Okay, now we finally get to go a little bit faster.
You know, it was fun driving those things at low speed,
but out here in the wash,
this is where the day is gonna get really fun.
Now, both of these vehicles, like we said before,
make similar power,
and they both deliver it very well at low speeds
in the low range,
but now we're in four high, we're in the wash,
and we're gonna see how these things do
when we need them to give
a little bit more high output consistently here
to really get us through this soft sand.
We are here in the GX first with its twin turbo V6,
and let's see how she does.
Oh, this is awesome.
So yeah, we're in four high,
multi-terrain, so that can set the sand,
give me some looseness out of the rear here.
Oh my goodness.
It set the sand,
disabled a lot of the traction control here
so I can really let the rear hang out,
and the fun part is that the engine
is definitely up to the task.
I'm not even locking it into a gear,
I'm just letting the transmission sort of do its thing,
and it is very squirrely,
power output super consistent even here at speed.
If I wanna use the throttle
to really get through these turns,
I can just here and then counter-steer
all the way back through.
Ooh, yeah.
Oh, your hands gotta be ready with this thing.
Oh my goodness.
How fun is this?
This sand wash is fairly well driven on,
so there's some pretty deep ruts,
and it just doesn't really seem to matter at all,
because this thing just basically powers
right through everything.
Again, even though these two
really make sort of the same power,
this thing was 1.6 seconds faster than 60
at our test track,
and it just, oh man, it just loves to throw down.
I've said it plenty of times today,
I will say it again, I love this engine.
I love it so much.
Does get much worse fuel economy
than you're gonna get with the hybrid and the Land Cruiser,
but fuel economy's not everything, right?
And the extra cost, I think I'd pay it.
I think I'd pay it.
This thing is an absolute animal.
Oh my God.
Land Cruiser time?
All right, now it's time to see what the Land Cruiser can do.
First things you notice,
the steering does not quite feel as precise
out of the front suspension.
That also might have to do with the tire.
More aggressive tire on the GX,
weirdly, like a much more aggressive tread on it.
That's allowing me to sort of get down in the sand.
This thing feels a bit like it's skidding over the top,
so I end up having to work a lot harder with the wheel
to sort of get it to turn.
Powertrain performance seems good though.
For all the concerns about it
with that lower zero to 60 time and problem with output,
it's still allowing me to sort of get the tail out here
when I really want it to.
There's just one sort of problem with it really,
and that's it kind of feels like turbo lag.
Like the powertrain and the GX just feels more responsive.
It always feels ready to sort of get up and meet you
when you really want to deliver that power
and get the back end sliding out.
In this one, you sort of have to be a little bit predictive
with your inputs, both the steering ones and the throttle.
And so you just end up, you know,
not feeling quite as connected to the experience
as you do in the Lexus.
That's not to say that this thing is doing poorly out here
because I mean, look at my face, still having a ball,
but just lacks a little bit of the sharpness
that the Lexus has.
Still though, plenty of juice to get the tail out.
You just gotta really be careful
and ready with your hands to catch it.
This is not a real job, is it?
Now, even though one of these is a Lexus
and the other one is a Toyota,
out here in the off-road environment,
they both perform very well today.
I would say they show that they're both up
for any kind of overlanding adventure
that you can throw at them.
I much prefer the GX on the wash
where I think it's powertrain delivery really shown,
but on the pipes, the Land Cruiser showed
that its superior approach angles
might give it better dexterity in tight spaces
where clearance is really important.
What it comes down to for me though,
is kind of everyday livability.
And in that regard, the GX is clearly ahead.
It goes better, as we showed at our test track.
It also stops better.
The Land Cruiser has some really bad ABS
and it also has a nicer interior.
Yes, you're getting a Lexus interior at that price.
And even though the Toyota interior is very nice
for a Toyota, I'm still probably gonna give the Lexus
the edge in that regard.
And for those reasons, for me,
if I'm taking one home today, it's probably the GX.
However, if what you're looking to do
is take one of these and build them up
to make them even more capable,
the Land Cruiser is a much better canvas for that.
The GX, the Overtrail and the Overtrail Plus
are really the only ones that are gonna come
with the off-road goodies you need,
while on the Land Cruiser,
they're gonna come with a lot of them standard.
And if you go down to a 1958,
you get the cool round headlights
and it starts at about 55,000,
which leaves you a lot of room
for all the upgrades that you might want.
Thanks for watching.
