Indian journalist Lalit K. Jha joins PragerU CEO Marissa Streit to discuss why Americans should pay closer attention to India. He explains how India’s religious and linguistic diversity, economic growth, and democratic system make it fundamentally different from China. Jha also discusses China’s use of Pakistan as a proxy, India’s complicated role in BRICS, its relationships with Israel, Iran, and the United States, and why America and India share more common interests than many people realize.
It was not a war between India and Pakistan. In fact, it was a war between India and China.
Today, Pakistan has become a proxy to China. It has become a hub of terrorism.
Lalit, why would China want to flare up a war between Pakistan and India?
Because the speed at which India is growing,
if China has a threat to anyone in this world from today,
it's two countries, United States of America and India.
Is it reasonable to expect that President Trump is going to put tariffs on other countries
if other countries put tariffs on the United States?
President Trump's main goal is to protect the interest of his people.
Simply for Prime Minister Modi, his main goal is to protect the interest of his country, his people.
Modi has to do India first and President Trump has to focus on America first.
Both Prime Minister Modi and President Trump
will come out with a solution which is win-win for both the countries.
Lalit, thank you so much for sitting with me. I've been wanting to talk about India
because it's obviously a very, very significant country in the world.
Almost 1.5 billion people live there.
What's interesting about India is that unlike China,
India's economy is actually ascending, not descending.
And so I think many more people need to pay attention to India and I'm sure you would agree.
But before we get into the geopolitics, let's talk about India in general.
Give us a quick, brief history for those who haven't paid attention in class.
So if you're familiar with the globe,
India's boundary lies with the Himalayas in the north and the Indian Ocean in the south.
On the west, on the east side, you have Bangladesh and Myanmar.
And the west, you have Pakistan and followed by Afghanistan.
This is the broader geographical location of India.
India is 1.5 billion, only 1.5 billion people.
It is the world's largest populated country.
It's the 7th largest in the landmass.
The most important part is the diversity that it has.
It has 28 to 30 official languages.
On an average, every Indian speaks 3 languages.
You'll come across people speaking 4 or 5 or half a dozen languages fluently as well.
Religion-wise, it has the world's largest Hindu population.
World's second largest Muslim population lives in India.
One of the top 20 or largest population of Christianity in the world also lives in India.
In India, Buddhism, Sikhism and Jainism were born in India, right?
So it's a unique, diverse country.
Multi-ethnic, multi-cultural, multi-religion,
where people live in harmony with each other.
That's what India is all about.
How many languages do you speak?
Four.
Including English?
Yes.
Wow.
Hindi, English, Maithili.
Three of the fluent languages.
Would you call it a city or a state?
Which state are you from?
I come from a state called Bihar.
It's in the foothills of the Himalayas.
The Gangetic Plains starts from there.
And the southern part of Nepal is there.
And you're here in the United States in the capacity of a journalist, right?
So you're covering US news for people in India.
What language do you cover it in?
I write in English and then it's got translated into other languages as well.
Majority of the publications are in English.
Not majority, but the mainstream publications are in English.
They go into print there.
And then it's translated into other languages, vernacular languages as well.
Hindi, Urdu, Punjabi, Marathi, Gujarati.
You know, if you look at the world's top 20 languages,
six or seven would be from India.
Wow.
Okay.
So how does a guy from India, a place next to Nepal,
become a journalist that then gets shipped to the United States
to follow news here in the United States to then be reported back in India?
What's your background?
I've been a journalist throughout.
I came to this country when my wife moved here as a research scientist.
And we landed up in a place called North Dakota, Grand Forks, North Dakota,
where I started doing some freelance.
I was working as a journalist for one of the major Indian newspapers
called the Hindu newspaper.
I was a city reporter there.
Then I came here and I started doing freelancing in Grand Forks, North Dakota.
Then I moved from, after six months, I moved to New York,
covering the United Nations and doing freelancing for multiple Indian publications.
After three years, I got an opportunity to move here in DC
and report as a correspondent for Press Trust of India.
It is India's largest newswire services.
And I worked there for around 17 years.
After that, I started my own venture.
Last six months, I've joined another wire services
from India called Indo-Asian News Service, which in fact was my first job in India.
Wow. Lalit, to be honest, I interviewed people from around the world
and I learned very quickly that the concept of freedom of speech and freedom of press
is not something that is available to every country.
As an American, I just thought, whoa, it's freedom of speech.
Everybody can speak.
Not that I didn't know that certain countries don't have freedom of speech,
but you kind of never know how far freedom of speech can actually go.
Does India have freedom of speech?
Yes, to the same extent and many times more than that, more than here.
When I came from India to US, the same profession, being a city reporter
in Delhi to a city reporter for Grand Forks Herald,
I didn't find much difference in covering the news, right?
Because the basics of covering the news as a reporter remains the same.
The freedom that you got in India to go out and talk to people,
talk to politicians, talk to elected representatives were the same over here as well.
So I didn't find much difference and I haven't found much difference
as a reporter covering in India and covering the US.
Oh, interesting.
So, I mean, you can say negative things about India.
You can say positive things about India.
There is no penalty.
There is no censorship.
It's open.
It's very, very open.
In fact, those on the other side of the table will tell you that many times
we journalists abuse that freedom of speech, freedom of press as well.
But that's what it is.
Yeah, sounds a little better than the UK right now, to be honest.
So tell us a little bit about India's current status.
I mentioned that the economy seems to be booming.
Can you just describe that to us as Americans?
Why is the economy doing well right now in India?
I associate India also with extreme poverty.
And so how do you reconcile those two facts that there is still extreme poverty,
but the economy is booming at the same time?
Yeah, because the population of 1.5 billion people, 300 million people are the middle class,
which is the population of America as well.
And the same number is the people living below the poverty line.
So the population itself reflects over that.
There's a huge opportunity to grow.
When Prime Minister Modi came in the last 12 years, he has done a lot of economic reforms,
removed a lot of rules and regulations,
which has freed up the people to do a lot of things they want to do.
You know, when you go for the payment system itself,
now everyone is having a bank account.
Everyone is using a cell phone to make the payments over there.
Even the poorest of the poor have a cell phone today.
And they go out and buy vegetables, buy tea with even 10 cents.
And they don't use cash.
They use the payment method, mobile phones to make the payments.
So he has unlocked a lot of potential of India, but it's still a long way to go.
What we see today, India's potential has to go down 10 times more than what it is today.
You mentioned rules and regulations.
And, you know, I'm from California.
So we actually have more rules and regulations than we've ever had before.
So I guess it's the opposite of what's happening in India.
What examples can you give from India where actually
freeing the consumer from rules and regulations has actually helped the economy?
Maybe some of the folks in California can learn from you guys.
True.
I'll give you a different example for US and different example for India.
For instance, constructing a road, maybe in California.
There would be some rules like if you cannot construct a road for more than one mile,
you have to get 10 or 15 permits.
And that might take you around two years, three years sometimes to get
those rules and regulations being cleared to construct the road over there
or to have some repair work done.
In India, for example, when Prime Minister Modi came in,
every state had their own taxation system.
Now under him, he has worked at this.
Entire country has one tax, which is called a GST system.
A truck travels from Kashmir to Kanyakumari,
there will be one kind of tax to pay over there, one system of taxation.
The kind of things he has brought in more, telecommunication as well,
there's one kind of services to be provided across the country.
He's also working on having elections on simultaneously,
one part, one time in the country, all those kinds of things.
Hundreds of rules and regulations, which were prevalent from the British era,
hundreds of years old, they have been removed and they are still being removed from there.
When I think about rules and regulations in India,
I think of those stories about the buildings that are basically falling apart
because nobody could fix them or reconstruct them because of all the rules and regulations.
We used to hear about these stories here in America all the time.
Is that an example of the type of economic freedom and the removal of
rules and regulations that have now allowed the economy to unleash itself?
Yes, those are the thing.
He has also given a boost to the economy through giving people to start their own startups,
own companies at a small level, giving massive amount of funding to them.
Now, since India has a huge middle class, they spend a lot on the consumer good.
One of the important things of which people have not realized how
India's poverty has been elevated is the role of the middle class, pooling of resources.
If you go to any major cities, every family will have kind of a maid home
who comes, do their work and then go back home.
These people normally come from villages and she would normally work on two or three homes
every day to get their meals done.
But when she comes and interacts with these middle class families,
she understands the importance of education.
She gets paid and that's how the poverty alleviation happens.
That's how also they get inspired by sending their kids to schools, colleges
and many times the middle class families also fund their education system as well.
You mentioned the location of India, which many of us, I'm sure, are aware of.
I don't know how many people are aware of the fact that Pakistan was essentially
annexed out of India in 1947, I believe, during a war effectively.
And also, in addition to that, you have 220 million Muslims living in India.
Can you just describe the conflict with Pakistan?
Both India and Pakistan have nuclear weapons.
There is every once in a while a bit of a flare-up.
I don't know if it was just Donald Trump that got involved and helped mitigate the flare-up,
but that's what some people heard.
Can you just summarize that whole issue for us?
Look, in 1947, India got independence and at that time, two countries were created
because of the divisions that the Britishers were able to
implant within the communities over there based on religion.
Dividing a community based on religion is never a good idea.
That's what they did.
So, India became two countries.
One was Britishers gave Hindus in India and the Muslims were given Pakistan and other side,
which later on became Bangladesh kind of country.
But our founding fathers, India's founding fathers, after 1947, the next few years,
they created a unique constitution where everyone, every religion was given equal space,
equal treatment kind of thing, which is called secularism or Sarvdham Sambhava.
On the other hand, if you look at India's population,
which the Muslim population was in India at that point of time, it's always grown
because the kind of ecosystem we had provided, our leaders had provided
to every religion which has been in this country, in India.
On the other hand, if you see in Pakistan, at the time of independence,
Pakistan had around 10 to 11 percent of Hindu population.
It has now come down to one or two percent.
Something is missing now.
Something is missing where there has been large-scale persecution of not only Hindus,
but other religions of the world.
Non-Islamic faith has been persecuted in Pakistan as well.
And you know, religion cannot, many times, cannot be a uniting factor as well.
If religion, if Islam was a united factor, then in 1971,
Bangladesh should not have been a separate country.
The country became, Bangladesh came out of Pakistan because of linguistic diversity, right?
They were Urdu speaking, they were Bangladeshi speaking.
So, Bangladesh became a separate country of the world, right?
On Pakistan, as one of the former Pakistani ambassador to the US has said,
Pakistan is a country for an army, right?
It's army which rules the country, right?
And the sole motive so far has been to how to take India head-on,
how to defeat India in public forum, how to malign India.
That has been their sole goal.
The Pakistanis, why?
For the leadership of Pakistan.
Why? Why do they care to take down India?
I mean, India is so much bigger than them.
It's for you to ask what Pakistani, why they do it.
But this has been a trend in the past 75 years.
If you see the trend of what Indian leaders have done,
every Indian leader has tried to maintain a good relationship with Pakistan.
They have gone out of the way to establish the relationship.
If you think the Prime Minister, current Prime Minister, Prime Minister Modi,
he took the risk of a life to fly with a chopper to a wedding at a very short notice
to former Prime Minister's family members, Nawaz Sharif.
He went to Pakistan to improve relationship with the leadership.
He invited the leaders of Pakistan to his own swearing-in ceremony.
He took multiple steps.
He opened up a lot of businesses for Pakistan.
But what he got was backstabbing, right?
Immediately after these six months, the terrorists were funded.
Terrorists came to our country and tried to attack our country, right?
The predecessor, Atal Bihari Bajpayee, he also went to Pakistan to have a good relationship.
Within six months, they encroached upon our territory,
did the Kargil massacre, Kargil war happened over there.
So we don't know what is in their mindset of Pakistan.
But you know, that has not served them well.
If you look at what Pakistan economy and Pakistan as a country was in 1960s,
where the world used to send their officials to learn how the local administration works,
how the local development works.
The moment they started a negative energy with all passion to take revenge against India,
look at it where Pakistan is today, right?
It has become a hub of terrorism.
Majority of the world terrorists, which have been sanctioned by United States
and United Nations, live in Pakistan, right?
These are all facts.
The problem with the world is today that even United States,
they look at India through the lens of Pakistan.
All these years, India has been telling United States and the rest of the world that,
look, these are terrorists, right?
You should ask them to stop being terrorists.
But the world thinks that, okay, India is saying like this,
just because it doesn't want to have a good relationship with Pakistan.
It's not the case.
India being a neighbor, it knows better than the rest of the world
how Pakistan and its leadership behave.
Look, I want to make a distinction here between people of Pakistan
and ISI and Army of Pakistan.
People of Pakistan are quite good.
They're all energetic, honest people, hardworking people.
Our religion, our culture, food, the way we think,
most of us think are similar to each other, right?
The food that we eat, the festivals that we celebrate, the dress that we wear,
the way we think, almost the same.
But it's a small group of leadership of Pakistan
who is bent upon destroying the relationship between India and Pakistan.
And they're in control in Pakistan,
and then they have their proxy terrorists that are causing all kinds of havoc to India.
Not only havoc to India, but the rest of the world as well, right?
Today, Pakistan has become a proxy to China.
The last time we had a war with Pakistan last year,
it is being publicly reported,
most of the arms and munitions and intelligence
that Pakistanis were getting were from China, right?
It was not a war between India and Pakistan.
In fact, it was a war between India and China.
Wait, wait, wait.
Why would China want to flare up a war between Pakistan and India?
That's true.
They want to, because the speed at which India is growing, right?
India today is the world's fastest growing economy, right?
If it grows at the same speed at the next 10 years, right?
India will be on the verge of taking over China or going much ahead of China.
India being a democratic country, right?
No other democratic country in the world has grown up at this speed,
this scale ever in human history.
So if China has a threat to anyone in this world from today,
it's two countries, United States of America and India.
So that's why they would not like India to grow up
and India to also have a good relationship with the United States of America.
So you made the point that, of course,
there's a difference between the Chinese people who we love
and the leadership, right?
The CCP, the Communist Party of China.
Are you saying that the CCP is using terrorists, Islamists
to flare up issues between Pakistan and India
in order for them to weaken India and gain more power?
Are they promoting this kind of Islamic terrorism?
Look, my sense is China would not like,
this is my own personal view and opinion,
China would not like India to emerge as a strong power.
The speed at which India has been growing economically,
you know, in the U.S. itself, in the Western world,
there has been China plus one approach for all the business companies, right?
If you see in the last five years,
large number of U.S. corporate sector
have been looking at India moving away from China, right?
So they would not like that to happen.
They would like to have internal disturbances
or Indian economy turmoil,
or something that which will let the board members
of these corporate companies think
that is India a right place for them to invest, right?
So these are the multiple factors.
China is using Pakistan as one of the tools to do that.
So how do you explain that,
let's say China is getting involved and trying to weaken India
because India is becoming stronger economically
and the number of humans that simply India has is very challenging,
I'm sure, for China to compete against.
We all know that China is having struggles
with their birth replacement rate.
How do you explain then the BRICS nations, right?
So you have this alliance,
which the United States is not part of.
Oftentimes we see BRICS as, in many ways,
adversarial to the United States.
Iran is in it, and Russia, and we know that India is in it.
India is our friend in the United States,
but sometimes we feel like our friend is hanging out
with some of the people who really don't wish us well.
That's not like that.
Look, BRICS is not a bilateral relationship.
It's not a relation between India and China, right?
Everyone knows the kind of relationship India and China has, right?
BRICS is a multilateral forum in which multiple countries are there,
in which Russia, South Africa are also there, right?
And India has a good relationship with them.
BRICS came out for some reason post-Cold War
when Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was there.
They created it, and it's also serving a different role.
In fact, BRICS, if you see, is the only major multilateral forum
where the United States is not part of it, right?
If you see, China has been trying to push the BRICS nation
currency, which is not a dollar currency.
India is not doing that.
For like the petrodollar, for example?
Yeah.
So India is in between there, right?
So if you can say that why India is with China and this country,
with this grouping, the same Indians can also say why
US is inviting Pakistani leaders to the White House for dinner.
Well, you know very well they are promoting or supporting
terrorist organization, terrorist activities within India.
But if you see the long-term picture of BRICS,
BRICS is doing quite a reasonably good work,
and India is playing a role where America's interests
are being protected over there.
Not by purpose, but by the way that India operates.
What do you think India's leadership's view of Iran is,
especially with the current war against the United States and Israel?
Look, India has a unique challenge.
1.5 billion people, their energy needs has to met.
India has to get that energy from anywhere in the world, right?
What happens if there is shortage of energy in this country, in India, right?
Gas prices go up, inflation will go up, right?
India has 300 million people living below the poverty line.
People don't know the roads.
It's a democratic country.
The top priority for the current government is to get energy,
to not let energy crisis happen in this country.
So they're going out of the way to make sure
that there's a constant supply of energy to people of India at reasonable cost.
Sure, they have to be India first.
India first.
And that's what Prime Minister Modi is doing.
When it comes to Iran, look,
Iran and India has a cultural relationship of its two civilizations,
which have been there for thousands of years working together.
But in the past, Iran has not supported India at all.