In this conversation, Dave Russell discusses with Oliver:
Why the miner-to-gold spread is a structural trigger, not just a chart signal
How government debt dynamics are degrading fiat currency and forcing capital reallocation
What a breakout in mining stocks relative to gold would confirm about the broader precious metals cycle
Why this rotation out of stocks and bonds is a structural story, not a short-term trade
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Michael Oliver argues that a systemic government debt crisis and the devaluation of fiat currencies are driving a sustainable, explosive rally in gold and silver. He predicts a massive capital rotation into hard assets, potentially triggered by a stock market correction, as the traditional bond market fails and the Federal Reserve is forced to expand the money supply to prevent a total collapse.
Today I'm joined by Michael Oliver, he's the founder of Momentum Structural Analysis.
Michael's been involved in financial markets for over 50 years and his distinctive approach
to technical analysis focuses on momentum rather than on price.
Michael's analysis covers stocks, bonds, commodities and currency and today we're
going to be asking him what his analysis is telling him about gold, silver and the wider
financial markets.
Michael, welcome back to the channel.
Good to be back Dave.
This is always really interesting to have you on but particularly at this moment in
time we seem to be at a point of inflection in the markets, I don't know if it's a
point of weakness, there are so many factors that are converging at this moment in time
around the globe and they're playing themselves out and we're actually starting to see metals
break out or at least I believe we're starting to see metals break out.
Do you concur with that?
Yes, I do.
I think the phenomenon which is very bizarre, I've never seen it in market history really,
what happened in the last day of January and the first trading day of February this year,
the biggest drop I've ever seen in the monetary metals, it didn't even look natural.
Major tops in those markets, they made tops but they don't do what that did.
But since then, if you look at the action of gold and silver, they've really been
teasing in terms of going down because every time they make a new low below let's say
that early February low, it's marginal, then they go up again.
And then they come down, they take out that low and it's marginal and they go up again.
In other words, they don't take out a low and keep going.
So somebody has been buying gold on approaches around 4,000 and somebody has been buying
silver either side of 60, upper 50s, lower 60s since February.
So though most people like to interpret it as negative, it really is more of a solid
situation.
Most of the damage was done in 48 hours.
But there've been a lot of rallies, about two, three, within the context of that now
six-month range.
And they don't take hold and sustain, they come back down.
No doubt this rally will be viewed that way by most people as well.
Like, oh, another rally, let's sell it.
Via our momentum analysis work, we argue this rally will take hold.
This is not a teaser.
We'll see.
But our signals were rendered last week, basically when silver moved up above about 58.
And it's now up 66 or something.
But anyway, I think this rally will be different in that it will sustain.
And once it proves itself as sustaining, whoa, that's going to really cause a lot of people
to scratch their heads.
People have gone bearish.
Anyway, it's going to be interesting.
And I think it's beginning again.
I think we're starting the next phase of the gold-silver advance, which should be far more
explosive and vertical than the first one we just saw.
And have you any particular targets in mind in terms of interim?
Or what are we talking about here?
There will be a wobble on the way up.
Now, we put that in our weekend report.
I mean, in this rally in silver and gold, for example, we've got some levels above,
not nearby here, but we think they'll come in and try to sell it there, the doubters.
But it's not going to work.
But we still think they'll try one more time.
I think that what's about to happen is going to be very hard to define targets.
Because the game that's in play here is much more than, oh, we're going to bull market
gold and silver.
We've had those before, right?
Let's examine those.
This is different.
We've got a monetary crisis, a government debt crisis that we've never had before.
It's been building and building decade by decade.
Doesn't matter who's president or prime minister, it still gets worse and worse by the decade.
And now we're at a point, as Jamie Dimon described it several months ago, he says,
we're now facing a government debt crisis.
We're going to have to deal with it.
And it's not a topic of conversation.
You turn on financial TV and you don't hear three talking heads talking about their concern
with the government bond crisis.
Japan went through it.
We know that.
Not went through it.
They're still in it.
It's impacted the yen.
And we've even come in now, the Federal Reserve has come in and helped bid up the yen.
So the Japanese don't dump so many of our bonds.
It's sort of a mutual game.
So we're printing money to help them print money, in effect.
Gold and silver know this.
They're not driven by, oh, a headline today, oh, a headline tomorrow.
It's this underlying, ongoing degradation in the value of fiat money.
And now in the perception and value of government debt markets, this is a big event.
And yet it's not the main topic of conversation, which is good.
So really what we're seeing at the moment, anyway, is going to be a movement out of
certain asset classes and into precious metals.
Now, that money is going to come from the bond market, or it's going to come from the
stock market, or it's going to be cash that's sitting on the side.
Where do you actually see this money coming from initially?
Or are we at this point in time where it could come from any one of a number of angles?
Each of those is a good candidate for a flow of money.
Because remember, in the old days, the last 50 years, the rule of portfolio allocation
was 60% stocks, 40% bonds.
Meaning, hey, if the stocks look uncertain, go over to bonds.
It's safe.
It's a good place.
It's an alternative.
Well, clearly, the bond market is not very much of an alternative right now, the government
bond market.
It just keeps oozing and oozing and oozing down, rising in rates.
And the Fed has been buying bonds since November, according to Williams, the head of the New
York Fed, said back in November, we start buying bonds to provide, quote, liquidity.
They've been buying bonds to support that market.
But now, all of a sudden, with the Japanese contagion, they feel pressed to help the Japanese
keep their fire from widening.
Because we can't let our house get on fire.
Meaning, the Fed's mandates are unemployment and, quote, inflation, as they narrowly define
it.
But the real mandate they have that's unwritten is, you got to save the government bond market.
The house will burn down if you don't.
So they're print, print, print, regardless of their two supposed mandates.
And they've been doing that.
And now, even more so, to help the Japanese print.
So what's driving assets up is continued increase in the size of the money supply.
So you punch up, for example, an M2 chart on the Federal Reserve site of St. Louis,
the money supply chart, go back decades, look at that thing.
It's a beautiful, upward-curving, ballistic bull market in the quantity of dollars.
And if you go back to when your granddad built a house, it was $4,500.
When your dad built a house, it was about $45,000.
Right now, the median home is $450,000.
What does that tell you?
Well, it's a reflection of the degradation of the money in it.
Similarly, if you look at the S&P 500, which everybody's cheering, go back to 2000, the
dot-com high, measure how much the S&P has gone up since then, how many multiples, gains,
and then go to the M2 chart, and you'll find that the S&P has merely matched
the increase in the money supply.
Wow, big deal.
So has the price of a lot of things match the increase in the money supply.
But at some point, what happens is, in the bear markets and stocks, you go back to 2000 to 2002,
2007 to 2009.
When the money started to flow out of there, where did it go?
You can look at the charts and see.
It went into T-bonds, 2000 to 2002, went into T-bonds in 2007 through 2009.
Oh, there were jiggles the other way, but people were buying bonds.
And they were buying gold as well.
In fact, you can go back to 29 to 32, that big bear market, 80% drop.
Gold wasn't legal then, but the gold miners went off the page on the upside.
And co-op stake mining was up like 1,000% during that Great Depression.
So I think what we're facing now, as you mentioned, is a shift in assets,
asset class flow, the money flow out of those assets.
Right now, we haven't shaken the stock market, though.
Everybody's still happy and comfy.
And that's the one thing you have to smile about is, oh, my portfolio is up on the year.
Oh, good.
We can retire, dear.
If all of a sudden, and we think it's going to happen, you shed 10%, 20%,
you've entered a bear market by our metrics at that point.
You're going a lot further, in other words.
But that's when the average investor is going to frown and feel pain,
because it's the only thing he's had to smile about.
And therefore, at that point, he's definitely going to want to think about, where do I put it?
And so that's when you could get more flow, extra flow into the monetary metals,
when you shake loose that stock market.
And I think we're on the edge of that in the coming month or so.
Do you have any specific kind of trigger for this?
They say you're on the edge of it, and that might actually be part of the vulnerability
of the markets at this moment in time,
is that there are so many of those potential triggers building.
Do you have anything you're specifying?
Yeah.
When we look at the S&P 500, which is like the Nasdaq 100,
it's very heavily weighted by about 10 stocks in the upper front of the index.
In the case of the S&P, it's less tech-oriented than Nasdaq 100,
but it's still front-end loaded with all the names anybody on the street could name.
Right now, the S&P is trading 7,700 area.
Now, when we run our momentum studies using long-term trigger levels that say,
you don't want to go there because if you do, you've broken your major trend.
And when you look at a price chart, you'd have to go down a long way
before most people would say, oh, I've broken the trend.
But when we look at our momentum charts, it tells us, you better not drop 10%,
roughly speaking.
We've got some specific trigger numbers in the next couple months,
and they adjust up quarter by quarter, month by month.
These sell trigger points.
Yeah.
Break structure.
But around 7,100 is an area you do not want to see if you're long the stock market.
What happens there?
Well, it'll do a price chart of the S&P, and you said, well, no big deal.
We sat there for six months at 7,000, couldn't get through it.
One month, you traded up to 7,000, but most of the other months were like 69.80, 69.90.
This is back early in the year.
And we blew through that.
You do not want to come back and sit on top or even get near
the top end of what looks like price chart support, meaning the old highs.
Because momentum will be blowing major bridges out from under it.
So when you look at a momentum chart, you'll say, uh-oh.
Price is usually a lag metric.
Let me put it that way.
But we think that probably is going to occur, which will just merely facilitate,
hasten the money flow into the monetary methods, which, as we know in the West,
especially in the US, the Americans do not invest much in gold.
American investors, they're extremely light in their gold position.
You commented earlier there, I think it was the 1929 to 32 era, and you spoke about the miners
in particular and said that during that period, they went up nearly 1,000%.
And that was obviously as a proxy for owning gold, really.
In terms of what the miners are doing, the miners seem to have,
while they were doing well towards the end of last year and January, February of this year,
they obviously had a significant sell-off.
They seem to have woken up again.
Are they a leading indicator for you?
Oh, yeah, yeah.
Let me put it this way.
When you look at the miners' day-to-day or gold day-to-day or silver, you're making a mistake.
You need to treat it as an investor.
Look at month-to-month, quarter-to-quarter.
If you go back a couple of years and look where the miners were point-wise,
dollar, let's say, GDX, the gold ETF, gold miners' ETF.
And how much is it up right now?
Even though it's well off its high, the high we made in February for the miners,
they're up more than gold.
Despite all the sharp zigzags that seem to say, oh, they're dogs, they act like,
they're actually gaining consistently over gold.
But they're also, if you, I don't have it right here.
We put it in our weekend report, but a spread chart between the gold miners,
include the silver miners in that category, like XAU index in Philadelphia,
it goes back to the 1980s.
And if you go back and plot how much, what was the value of XAU in terms of ounces of gold?
Well, back in the 1980s, 90s, 2000 through 2008, so multiple decades,
XAU's value to gold went up and down, but it was on average,
25% of the price of an ounce of gold.
Divide XAU price into gold expresses a percent.
It oscillated from 35% highs to lows about 17%, 18%,
but on average, about 25% for decades.
In starting in 2008 through 15, which was a bear market in gold, 2015 low,
that spread collapsed to 4%.
Okay.
An old reality was 25% average price.
It goes to four.
I mean, what do we, we don't need gold miners anymore.
I guess we get gold out of the air.
Okay.
But that spread was off the page undervalued relative to that, which it does.
And yet for 12 years, since actually 2014,
that spread has gone sideways between 4% and about 8.5%.
Right now it's pushing up again toward the top end of that range.
You can do the same thing with GDX,
the popular gold ETF and gold miners ETF in the US.
It also has 20% silver miners in it, by the way.
And plot it, it has the same exact picture, just a different level,
that it's built a base that if you were just an average technician,
you'd look at that action and say, that's a base.
Repeated refusal to go down,
but with a ceiling that you could draw with a crayon.
You're approaching that ceiling again,
and I think you're going to go through this time.
Our argument is based on various factors of that spread action.
Not only are the miners going to explode relative to gold value
once they break out of that spread and go back perhaps to more normal relative valuations,
which is to say double or triple their current valuation to gold.
But when that happens, expect verticality in all the monetary metals,
gold, silver, and the miners, just with miners going up more than gold.
Silver, by the way, is doing the same thing to gold.
Silver is vastly undervalued.
One ounce of silver divided by an ounce of gold is vastly undervalued.
While silver has broken out of its 50-year price range, barely,
if you go back to 1980 when silver was 50 then,
gold was also making a bull market peak then, it was 850.
Silver was 6.5% of the price of gold.
Right now, silver is about 1.5% of the price of gold, vastly undervalued.
And its spread action says, I'm about to explode.
MSA is making this argument.
When those two spreads fully break out, especially miners versus gold,
you want to be in the miners.
Yes, gold is the mama, but you want to have your money in miners.
They're going to go up a lot more.
But you'll also see verticality in price in the monetary metals when that occurs.
That happens to be about in time with what we just talked about a minute ago,
the shift in the intermediate trend of silver and gold back to the upside
that we saw starting a week ago.
If this spread also breaks out, miners versus gold,
then that's a second pounding of the table that says, put your seat belt on.
I think that's where we are.
OK, so even getting back to that miners versus gold,
getting back to the 23% to 25% range, you're saying that there should be
enough performance in the miners by a factor of three,
but you could have this verticality in terms of price.
Yeah, go ahead.
Yeah, that kind of verticality in terms of price
suggests a significant monetary event.
Yeah, in other words, rather than looking at AI and semiconductors,
which I think have topped, in fact, we pretty much nailed it
in NSA reports a couple of months ago when it was topping.
Aside from looking at that, look at the T-bond market.
Punch it up on your screen and keep it on there.
OK, keep it in one quadrant of your screen.
Its price continues to erode.
Now, it made a low, a collapse low back in 2022.
Well, 2020 to 2022, T-bond futures, this 30-year bond futures,
went from 190 in price to 117 and a half.
Wow.
Much of that occurred in about six months in 2022.
Since 2022, price action of T-bond futures has done this sideways,
trying to base, trying to get something going on the upside,
meaning a drop in yields.
They can't do it.
They've had three waves of effort to do that.
And several months ago, back when price was 114,
we said, that's it, this base is not going to hold.
The low end of that base was just below 108, by the way.
Right now, where are we trading?
We've been down to 108 again.
We think we're going to slip through that.
Now, the problem is, this is the part of the debt market
that the Fed does not control with the push of a button.
You know, they can influence short-term rates,
but they don't have much effect, if any, on the long-term bond.
And they can't afford not to, because it's too dangerous for it to catch on fire.
So they have to print, print, print.
And that is the lifeblood of money, of gold and silver,
is the degradation of the thing that you're measuring them by.
Dollar, a yen, a euro, et cetera.
So that will accelerate.
Now, that's one thing you got to watch.
You mentioned a big event.
Yeah, that's a prime one.
But also, private debt is very bad right now.
It's not being talked about much.
But commercial real estate debt is in dire straits.
There's a lot of credit card debt that's at extremely high levels.
You know, pass-a-do, et cetera, et cetera.
Mortgages are more and more pass-a-do delinquent.
And yet, this isn't a topic of conversation.
But unlike 2008, where we had a couple banks fail,
and a lot of real estate-related loans imploded, mortgage crisis,
this time is far bigger than that.
It's not just mortgages.
It's private debt.
It's corporate debt.
It's government debt.
And gold knows this.
And it knows what the central banks will do about it.
So previously, and in previous cycles, effectively,
what you had is you had a, let's call it a,
you had a problem in one area,
but had a tendency to infect the other areas.
It had this knock-on impact into those.
But what you're suggesting now is there's an infection
in so many different areas, and there's a vulnerability,
and there's a weakness.
The one thing that I really like about your analysis, Michael,
is you're not just purely looking at the charts.
Your analysis is underpinned by an understanding,
a very strong understanding,
of the fundamentals and the market dynamics as well,
which always makes for really interesting conversations.
One of the things at this moment in time that,
obviously not the only one that sees it this way,
but that I see as a massive vulnerability
is what's going on with the Japanese yen.
And effectively, what's happened there
through all the smoke and the mirrors
is that the US is trying to effectively
protect the bond market there
and do whatever they can.
But Japan is kind of stuck in this,
and the US are stuck in this
ever-decreasing Goldilocks scenario
where they need the yen to be not too hot,
not too cold.
And the bond for that, I kind of see
as decreasing all of the time,
which is setting up this time bomb into the future.
When you look at this from a momentum structural analysis
and you look at a yen chart,
I'm not even too sure if it makes too much sense anymore
to look at the charts,
but do you see kind of the writing on the wall?
Do you see a clock that's running out of time?
The yen looks like, when we look at it,
regardless of what it's called
and the fundamentals of it,
just looking at the charts,
momentum charts, let me stress,
annual momentum in particular,
meaning we measure month-to-month action
in the yen futures
relative to a 36-month moving average,
which is like a three-year average.
So it's either above that average or below.
Well, obviously, it's below right now.
But when we measure it and plot it,
it looks like a basing action for real.
And the recent plunge
that took out the prior low a year or two ago,
which took it out in recent months
and therefore caused the Japanese to panic even more,
looks like that might've been the low.
Now, it doesn't mean the governments
are gonna succeed in their debt problem,
but this yen problem might somewhat abate,
but that means the dollar could weaken
relative to the yen, which is what, okay, now,
when we plot the dollar index,
which is a popular vehicle that people look at
as far as what's the value of the dollar,
well, it's not the real value of the dollar.
All the things that the dollar index measures
is primarily dollar versus euro
and dollar versus yen.
Those constitute over 70% of the entire dollar index.
If you look at most currencies in the world,
they're going up versus the dollar.
Dollar's going down.
Euro has had a pullback recently,
but it's been going up over the last several years
has gone up in price versus the dollar.
The main culprit that has kept the dollar index
from collapsing, and we think it will collapse,
meaning when measured against the euro and the yen,
is the yen, because it's been the one
really negative major component of the dollar index,
hence has helped keep the dollar index looking,
oh, to most people's eyes, okay.
Our momentum work in the dollar index is,
no, even this silly index is not okay.
It's broken major structures.
And this holding action we've seen for the last,
actually over a year now, the dollar index,
it's gotten very narrow, congested.
When it breaks down, the dollar index will be weak.
The dollar will be weak.
And so rather than the yen being the weak issue,
the dollar will be the weak issue.
That still doesn't help abate the bond crisis,
but it will shift the focus,
which will surprise a lot of people, I think,
that the U.S. dollar is weak,
measured by that mistakenly weighted index, let's call it.
Are you worried for financial markets
or for what this could signify,
suggest for the average investor
or the average amount of investors?
And for the average person who's not even in the market.
Yeah, well, remember 2007 through nine,
even the guy wasn't in the stock market was hurt badly.
You know, lost his job, his wife lost her job,
lost his home, et cetera, et cetera,
even if he wasn't in the stock market.
I think the financial repercussions
of this long building crisis is gonna be widespread.
Not just U.S., by the way.
Europe, Japan, et cetera.
When we look at stock markets,
we measure the U.S. stock market as being a bubble.
We measure the Japanese, the Nikkei, as being a bubble.
Some other bull markets around the planet
have gone up with the U.S. market in general,
in sync with it.
Europe, for example, to a lesser extent,
in terms of dimension.
And even the Shanghai composite.
But if you look at the Shanghai,
which I think is deteriorating right now,
and I think likely if it does, we will too.
They're part of the world, after all.
Don't treat them separately.
But it's not a bubble.
The Shanghai market price is a double and a half
where it was in 2009.
Whereas the S&P is a dozen fold where it was in 2009.
Or the NASDAQ 100 is like 20 plus fold
where it was in 2009.
So we've had verticality unlike a lot of markets.
So I think the U.S. and Japan,
particularly stock markets, will be vulnerable.
That's going to hurt people.
And we know what happens when the stock market breaks.
That's when all your data points go negative.
By data points, I mean the stuff the Fed likes to talk about.
Like, oh, the job market looks reasonably steady.
Well, if we go back and look at 2000 top
to the bear low in 2007 to 2009
and overlay a chart of unemployment data,
unemployment didn't give you a warning.
It told you after the fact, said, oh, we're in a crisis.
But it didn't tell you ahead of time.
So for them looking at that as some kind of leading indicator,
it's totally not.
It's lagged to the stock market.
And therefore, that means the average guy
is going to get hurt.
Yeah.
Do you see then what comes next as being either
what Japan has kind of suffered for a number of decades,
but being more widespread like other countries,
the US and Europe or whatever, suffering the same thing?
Or do you actually see this as being only resolvable
by a Bretton Woods type of event?
No, I don't think governments are going to solve it.
I think this one is the bigger one,
bigger one than we've ever seen in terms of negativity,
especially once the stock market breaks,
which will then bring all the other data points with it.
I think a lot of changes will occur in things we take as norms.
So for decade after decade,
we've had like a two-party system in the US,
you know, Democrat, Republican.
The same is true in a lot of other countries,
but they're starting to fragment more
because there's a sense of growing desperation among some,
and it'll increase in terms of the population perception
that this isn't working.
This needs to change.
What do I mean by this?
Well, maybe, you know, we don't like this party anymore.
Like the GOP, for example, is no longer what it was,
Republican Party, what it was 10, 20, 30 years ago.
It was a Reagan party.
It was a conservative party.
It was a Barry Goldwater party.
Those guys have retired and left the party.
Some of them have even quit their congressional seats
and have become a Trump party,
but even the Trumpers are now split.
There's quite a few advocates,
major advocates for Trump during the election time
that have now totally gone the other way
and said, he needs to be gone.
He's totally not what I expected.
So that party's fragmented.
The Democrat Party is fragmented.
And I bet that each of those two parties
or neither one of them are majority parties anymore,
where the Democrats are going to get 52,
Republicans 48, et cetera.
They're going to fragment so badly,
it wouldn't shock me to see third parties ascend.
Like in some countries in the world
where it's not the two major parties,
it's often the third party
that helps one of the majors take office.
Not such kind of change we could see.
Another one would be,
maybe we don't need fiat currencies anymore.
Maybe that didn't work.
It's only been around one long human lifetime,
after all, on that paper.
Or the Fed really hasn't been doing a good job.
They've been causing this boom-bust cycle pattern.
And you might not have a Federal Reserve
in a couple of years, wouldn't surprise me.
These are the kind of changes
that are seemingly off to the side,
but they're really part of the core issue.
And because after all,
politics does influence markets.
Okay, so it's not separate.
And now more heavily so than ever in history, probably,
that where government's intervention
and buying of companies, et cetera, et cetera,
they've become a market factor.
So you asked me what could change it.
I think these are the kind of things
you could look off left and right and say,
my, all of a sudden,
this thing I thought would be here forever isn't here.
Or this is questionable.
And I think, therefore,
the market forces we're talking about
will generate this rethink.
I'm not gonna predict how it's gonna come out,
but I think there will be a massive rethink.
And tell me this.
I mean, I agree with most everything that you've said there.
But here's a question for you.
If we talk again in six months or in 12 months
or in 18 months, two years,
are we gonna be saying,
just having the same conversation
and just saying, but it's got worse?
Or are we gonna be having a,
I told you so conversation?
I would say, I told you so.
And you will have told him so.
I think these events will unfold very rapidly.
And I think that when certain technical events occur,
oftentimes, that's when you suddenly hear,
oh, that's the reason for that.
I hadn't been thinking about that
or hadn't been focused on that.
All I've been looking at is AI.
I think it's gonna be very speedy.
And I think one of the major triggers will be,
and this is hard to link to that why it will cause it,
but it will reflect it or predict it,
is the explosion in the miners versus gold.
So when that spread breaks out,
I'm arguing they will explode
and that will not happen in a vacuum.
But it's not because just some technical breakout.
You'll have peripheral headlines suddenly,
bam, right in your face.
And people will then say, oh, gee, now I understand.
You know, I wish I'd bought those a couple years ago.
I wish I bought that March break, et cetera, et cetera.
I think it will unfold very rapidly.
And I think by the end of the year,
we will say, yep, it's underway.
This is it.
In a big way.
Tell me this, Michael,
where can people find out more about what it is that you do?
Because I thoroughly enjoy these conversations
and I look at your analysis and it's fantastic.
So I want more people to be aware of it
and get access to it.
Well, it's olivermsa.com, olivermsa.com.
It's our website and peruse it.
We talk about our unorthodox methodology
to a pretty good extent to understand what we're doing,
why we're doing it.
And request some sample copies and be fine.
Fantastic.
I recommend everybody has a look at that
because as I said,
not only is Michael's technical analysis
fantastic, but it's underpinned by a really strong,
decades long understanding of the fundamentals
of financial markets,
which really gives it its credibility and its power.
But for now, Michael Oliver,
Momentum Structure Analysis.
Thank you for joining us on the channel again.
Thank you for having me back on.