Mysterious Features at the Red Pyramid Reveal Ancient Engineering!

mysterious nature
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA recent study published in Nature's Heritage Science Journal identifies man-made water management structures—including dams, a reservoir, and a canal—near the Red Pyramid of Sneferu. While some debate exists regarding whether these aided construction, the evidence strongly suggests they functioned as a sophisticated flood defense system to protect the monument.
Hello everybody and welcome to Ancient Architects. Please subscribe to the channel for regular
content on ancient architecture as well as all the latest news from the world of archaeology.
Last month in Nature's Heritage Science Journal, a brand new study was published with claims that
apparently shed light on some strange landscape features close to the Red Pyramid of Sneferu,
features that are believed to have been built some four and a half thousand years ago.
The new study got media headlines around the world, the observations that were published
look to be fair and valid, yet some experts are worried about where the study is leading.
So, what's it all about? In the new paper, the authors identify man-made water management
structures in the Red Pyramid landscape of Darshor, such as giant dams, a reservoir and a canal,
features that look to be flood defence measures in and around the pyramid.
Okay, that does sound quite reasonable, and so what's so controversial?
Well, as we know from the authors' previous work on the Step Pyramid,
they believe the Egyptian pyramids were built using what they call hydraulic engineering,
harnessing the power of water to aid construction. And whilst they may well have come up with a solid
explanation for the man-made features seen in the Darshor landscape, for some, claiming these
structures could have been used to aid construction is a step too far. I'll come back to this later
in the video. But in my opinion, that doesn't mean we should dismiss the paper as pseudoscience.
I do agree that the features are unlikely to have been used in the pyramid's construction,
but I do agree with the interpretation that these structures functioned together and they
worked as a comprehensive flood defence system. Because really, that isn't controversial at all.
Nobody denies that the Egyptians knew how to harness and manage water, how to engineer the
landscape, and how to protect their monuments and settlements from destructive floods.
At Giza, we find numerous water channels and gullies. We see man-made canals and basins
branching off from the nearby Khufu or Aramat branch of the Nile, the most western branch that
ran in front of the Egyptian pyramids but has now since dried up. We find drainage channels cut
beneath the three pyramid causeways, and I've suggested in the past that the lowest courses
of the Khafre and Menkaure pyramids were cased in granite, simply to protect them from flash floods.
We also know from the famous Diary of Mera that stone was brought from Chura to Giza by boat,
and that was via the Khufu branch of the Nile, and this links to Giza's man-made channels and basins.
The Wall of the Crow, this enormous wall to the southeast of the main pyramid field,
also clearly acted as a flood control and water diversion barrier, to protect the workers' village
that archaeologists uncovered on the other side of it. So, the architects and builders of the Old
Kingdom understood how to shape the landscape, and this was to both harness the water of the
River Nile to aid construction, but also to protect both the structures and the people on the plateau.
Over the years, a great deal of work has been done at Giza, but water management and landscape
engineering for Darshor is still not fully understood. Darshor, of course, being home to
the Bent and Red Pyramids. We've always known that a wadi came close to the Red Pyramid,
but what the researchers of the new paper have done is reinterpret two specific structures that
are found within the wadi, both of which are clearly seen on satellite imagery and historic
aerial photos. Yes, I say reinterpreted because the structures were already well known, but they
were long believed to be either natural ridges or man-made ramps for transporting stone.
From re-examining the satellite photos, the researchers believe the so-called stone transport
ramps actually exhibit a form, size and shape better associated with dams, and because they
are both found inside the wadi, which would have been wet in the Old Kingdom, it adds more credence
to their explanation. Between the two dams, the researchers have also identified what they
believe to be a reservoir, as well as what they believe to be a carefully positioned diversion
canal and what may be an early example of an advanced triangular spillway.
The wadi, known as Wadi Darshal, is found to the southwest of the Red Pyramid,
and it's easily seen on Google Earth, as are the linear features interpreted as dams.
As far as I'm aware, the features are yet to be fully investigated on the ground,
but it's thought that they date back to the early Old Kingdom, and if so, their scale and
engineering design leads the researchers to believe they were connected to the building
of the Red Pyramid, the first true pyramid to be built in Egypt. Of course, right now,
the age of these features is mere guesswork, because for all we know, they could have been
made any time before, during or after the building of the pyramid.
So, let's take a look at the linear features. Each of them extends for about 600 to 700 metres
across the full width of Wadi Darshal, and they're anchored into the opposing sides of the valley,
having broad trapezoidal profiles resembling earth and rock embankments.
The positioning, form and style of these features therefore make these hard to interpret
as roads, with dams being a much more realistic explanation. Each structure is between 15 to 30
metres across at their bases, with the highest being around 6 to 7 metres above the present
valley floor, although over the years, of course, these would have been eroded, and also much of
surrounding landscape is buried below the sand. Therefore, the structures could go down a lot
deeper and hence they're taller. As stated, the linear features don't follow the natural direction
of travel through the valley, but instead cut directly across the natural drainage route,
precisely where dams would be built to slow or hold back flowing water.
In the past, some scholars believed that the westernmost feature was merely a natural rise
in the landscape, and others believed they were trackways for the transportation of limestone,
being as both point directly towards the Red Pyramid. And for some, these options are still
on the table. So why would you build two dams next to each other? Well, as we know the Old Kingdom
Egyptians were genius engineers, and so if these are dams, it can't be an accident that two were
built close together. It must be by design. It's a sophisticated flood defence system.
The researchers believe the two dams perform different yet complementary functions.
The structure upstream may have worked as a check dam. What this means is it would not
necessarily have been built to store large quantities of water. Instead, it may have
slowed flood water coming from the west and allowed stone, sand and sediment to settle.
Cleaner water could then pass to the second structure, which may have been the main
retention dam. The space between the two dams may have formed a basin or reservoir, capable
of temporarily holding water and reducing its force. And this would protect downstream channels
from erosion, whilst preventing them from becoming clogged up with sediment.
And we know that flash floods were a problem in Old Kingdom Egypt. At Giza, the original
valley temple of the Menkaure Pyramid looks to have been destroyed by floodwaters in the Old
Kingdom. And the channels beneath the causeways, as well as the Wall of the Crow, are yet more
evidence of flood management strategies in action. The proposed reservoir between the two dams
covers around 8.5 hectares of land and could hold at least 230,000 cubic metres of water.
The actual volume is likely to be much greater, maybe twice as much, because we don't know how
deep the sand is in this area. Together, the two dam structures may have slowed the waters from
flash floods, trapped sediment and regulated water, before it either continued downstream or
entered purpose-built cisterns or man-made canals. Looking at this topographic map,
and we can see that a natural channel does run towards the dams, aka the reservoir from the west.
And by cutting a man-made canal to the west of the pyramid, as shown on this diagram,
the Red Pyramid is safe from floodwaters. And it's all thanks to this landscape engineering.
Another interesting aspect of this ancient engineering lies in the centre of the western
most dam, where satellite images and aerial photos reveal a large zigzag or triangular section.
If this was a road or transport ramp of some kind, this feature makes absolutely no sense.
But it does make sense in its proposed use as a dam.
The researchers identify it as a possible duck-bill spillway, a triangular overflow
structure designed to release more water than a straight barrier of the same width.
It's a feature to regulate the flow of water. Apparently, such a feature allows for the
discharge of a large volume of water, without causing the water level behind it to rise
dangerously. We don't know how frequent or infrequent flash floods were, but there is
evidence that desert runoff from torrential rain was a very real problem. It was even witnessed
on the Giza Plateau in more modern history, when Carl Richard Lepsius was on the plateau
for a severe rainstorm in 1843. He noted high energy runoff waters running across the plateau,
capable of washing away tents and equipment, including iron crowbars.
So, at Darshor, by creating two dams, a reservoir and a canal, you're basically creating a flood
management system to protect the bold pyramid project of King Sneferu. And this in itself is
not controversial, because we know the Old Kingdom Egyptians did actively engineer the
to control water, as noted at Giza. But this study is considered controversial by some because
of the authors, whose previous work that was published in the journal PLOS ONE, put forward
evidence in favour of a hydraulic lift being used to build the step pyramid of Djoser,
an idea considered to be pseudoscience in some circles. In basic terms, to the authors,
the dry moat surrounding the step pyramid, and also the internal architecture itself,
allowed the builders to raise blocks of stone up high by harnessing the hydraulic force of water.
And so, from this previous study, it makes sense that the authors would look to other
pyramids for evidence of water being used in construction. At the Red Pyramid,
they propose the dam system and this diversion canal that passes within 40-50m of the pyramid,
may have allowed for boats carrying workers, animals and raw materials to get up close to
the construction site. In the study, there are no bold claims on how the pyramid was built,
nothing like a hydraulic lift, and the claims are far more respectable and believable.
And I do think their landscape observations are credible and worthy of further on-site
investigation. It does make a lot of sense. But I don't think that these features were built to
aid construction. I think the landscape was engineered to protect the building site and
also the finished structure from floods, to keep it as dry as possible to maintain its longevity.
If I'm reading it correctly, intense rainstorms create large amounts of desert runoff water,
and the landscape is engineered to direct this water into the canal and reservoir.
But with severe rainstorms and flash floods being random occurrences,
it would be hard to factor these man-made landscape features into any kind of building project.
For all we know, the canal and reservoir could have been dry for years,
only filling up sporadically after a storm. So, I don't think the features we see were associated
with the construction process, but I do think they were directly related to flood defence,
which in itself is a fantastic discovery. We already know from the study at the Giza Plateau
that the ancient Egyptians of the Old Kingdom did engineer the landscape to mitigate the effects of
flash floods, that they were well aware of the hazards of nature. So, the building of dams,
spillways, reservoirs and canals is certainly not out of the engineering capabilities of the
Egyptians. It does feel a bit of a stretch to say that these features aided construction,
but of course everyone is entitled to their opinion. I think we're looking at a flood
defence system for the Red Pyramid, something the authors themselves also propose, and due to the
condition of the pyramid today, minus the missing casing stones, it looks like another Old Kingdom
success story. Thank you very much for watching this episode of Ancient Architects. If you enjoyed
the video, please subscribe to the channel, please like the video and please leave a comment below.
