Flock Camera program paused in North Branch, Minnesota

Fox - Fox 9
42 followers
10 Video Views·Aug 10, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
A lot of cameras have increasingly become part of the conversation among communities,
among cities, among counties, among state law enforcement agencies.
You know, the stats show you that there's some 120,000 of these license plate reader
cameras now nationwide, every state but Alaska, contracts with about 40% of the law enforcement
agencies in the US.
And it's even spawned a popular app now called D-FLOC, which is a way to create a database
of where all these cameras are.
People are concerned about the surveillance society in North Branch that has led the city
to put FLOC cameras on hold for now while they figure out what to do.
So let's bring in the mayor of North Branch, Kevin Shiver.
Thanks for being with us today.
You bet.
Good afternoon.
Thanks for having me.
So I understand your city had installed three of, what, seven planned FLOC cameras.
And at this point now, those three that are installed, it begs over them.
And you're just stopped while trying to figure out what to do.
Correct.
So back in March, April, and May, we had several city council meetings with those type of conversations.
We had a public hearing back in April.
There wasn't a lot of participation back then.
We did ultimately approve a contract, I think it was our May 13th council meeting, for seven
cameras to be placed throughout the city coming into our city.
And I think about a couple weeks after that, I had posted an article from one of our local
newspapers where a neighboring county sheriff did a nice 15, 16-minute video showing kind
of their access to the FLOC system, what it looks like.
One of the newspaper editors had volunteered his license plate.
And so I had shared that, and it kind of started a firestorm in our community because a lot
of the people that have opposed FLOC were not following what we were doing for their
council meetings.
And so over the last couple months, there's been a lot of community Facebook conversations,
very passionate, very heated at times.
And we got to the point where I felt like we needed a second public information session,
an opportunity for our residents that didn't participate the first time around to ask questions,
to voice their opinions.
And so that's what we ultimately held last week.
And so, and then at that point, decided to put this on hold for now.
I mean, what is the process going forward?
What does that look like for North Branch to try to figure out where you go with the
FLOC system?
Yeah, so there's a lot of concern about mass surveillance, government overreach.
Conversations were intensifying through public comment.
I got a lot of, as you can imagine, got a lot of messages and emails, phone calls.
And as we got closer to our second public information session last week, I could just
see that there wasn't gonna be any type of immediate resolve for the privacy concerns
that several residents brought forth.
So I had been in conversations with our city administrator and our chief of police.
And the morning of the, and talking about, maybe we should just kind of put a pause in
this.
Well, the morning of our public, our second public information session, that's when I
learned about the city of, I'm drawing a blank on the-
Winona, maybe?
Winona, yes.
Thank you, appreciate that.
Yeah, so Winona, all eight of their cameras, FLOC cameras being cut down.
And that right there was definitely kind of a solidification point for me.
And I thought, we're gonna have to just put this on pause to allow our residents to be
able to have those conversations where they can exhale and feel like we can have a good
back and forth.
How long do you think then this process will take before you reach some kind of resolution
on whether you go forward or take them out?
Yeah, so I can't speak for the whole council, state statute.
We all have to vote together.
We do have a council meeting this Wednesday evening to at least vote on a pause as we're
trying to look at our contract and understand what options do we have as a city.
I think we're unique because we did approve the contract, we started to install them.
But then with all the intensity of the conversations and all the concerns, I felt like we
needed to pause.
A couple of the other council members felt the same way last week.
Ultimately, I wouldn't be surprised if we just move forward with canceling the FLOC
contract that we have.
It comes to a point, I think, where as a community, we have to have those conversations.
And we're not in that much of a hurry that we have to put so many people on edge that
we have to worry in our own community about somebody cutting down those camera poles and
damaging the cameras.
That doesn't help anybody.
That makes sense.
This is a program, again, as I mentioned, some 120,000 of these cameras, license plate
reader cameras nationwide now.
And law enforcement agencies love them.
I mean, they are a huge investigative tool when they're trying to track a suspect or
find somebody that there might be a warrant out for, or a stolen vehicle, carjacking,
etc.
But major pushback from the public about the surveillance.
We have cameras already in, security cameras, whether it's public buildings or everyone's
got ring doorbell cameras or something, a variety of that.
Or there may be businesses have their own security cameras.
There's so many cameras out there already.
What do you think about the license plate reader cameras that suddenly pushes people
kind of over the edge?
I think it is a combination of everything you said that our society is the advancements
in technology in the way that whether it's private residents or ring doorbells.
Some of the cameras we have along freeways for the interstate or maybe some that we have
to protect certain high traffic parts of our community.
And it feels to me like our community and maybe our society in general is saying we've
kind of exceeded that limit, enough is enough.
And they don't have control over that.
You can't control what other people do with their homes.
They're trying to just make sure that their homes are protected.
But when it comes to our community, I heard from enough people.
And yes, the Facebook group that I have alluded to was pretty prominent in their conversations
over the last couple of months.
But I also heard from a lot of people that mentioned, I'm not crazy about another camera
kind of tracking us on the roads.
But if it helps catch somebody that's being abducted, if it helps us catch maybe a missing
person that has dementia, then to me it might be worth it.
But then they also said, to be honest, I don't understand what those flat cameras are really
doing.
And I heard that from people that were willing to support the flat cameras, as well as people
that opposed it very verbally.
And at that point, I felt like we needed to pause and have more conversations, which we
did last week.
And as I thought about it more, and our council has to talk about it this week, it just feels
like maybe we've reached a threshold in our society that it's just too much.
A tipping point, perhaps, because you already know that apps on your phone, if you've allowed
location data sharing, that they're tracking movements.
And social media sites track what you're buying.
Or you may say something in your home, and you might have a smart speaker that picks
it up, and suddenly it's showing up.
It gets to be a lot, and it seems like maybe this is the thing that has kind of pushed
it over the edge, as you have mentioned.
So it's a very interesting conversation.
There's always that debate between what freedoms do you give up for the sake of public safety?
There's certainly something we heard after 9-11 with the Patriot Act.
What is that balance between public safety and freedom?
So what happens now for you guys then?
What do you think is next?
Well, we'll have a conversation on Wednesday.
For sure, there'll be a recommendation to pause while we figure out what our contract
terms allow us to do and don't allow us to do.
There could be an elevated action to just say, hey, let's just go ahead and cancel it,
and let's deal with the Flock Corporation.
But I think part of what I mentioned last week, we had 50 to 60 people at a council
meeting, and so much so that it spilled into the hallway.
And that was a lot of people, and I was very proud that they came out and spoke their piece.
I didn't exactly agree with everything, but they don't agree with me with everything either.
But that's the point of having these community conversations, is to make sure that we understand
what do we value in our community, especially when it comes to public safety.
And that was my call to action for those residents too, is let's continue this conversation.
Let's have a bigger overarching conversation on what public safety looks like for North Branch,
and what types of tools and resources do we support for our police department?
Yeah, well, Flock has certainly touched a nerve in a way that other
law enforcement technology has not that we've seen recently.
Mayor Kevin Schieber, North Branch, thanks for taking time with us today.
It's a very fascinating issue, and I know it's going to continue to be an issue for a while.
You bet, thank you very much for having me.
All right, thanks so much.
