Folklore in Excalibur Everyone Missed

Myths and magic
3 followers
4 Video Views·Aug 10, 2026
Did this 1981 dark fantasy film do the impossible? Hold onto your magic swords: it’s time for an Arthurian legend deep dive.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis analysis explores the 1981 film *Excalibur* and its adaptation of Thomas Malory's *Le Morte d'Arthur*. It examines how the filmmakers condensed vast Arthurian lore into a cinematic epic, altering character roles and incorporating linguistic and mythological elements from Irish and Tolkien-esque influences to create a sweeping narrative of humanity's evolution.
These are the five stages of watching Excalibur.
One, two, ooh, Patrick Stewart.
Three, okay, I'm into it.
Four, wait, now they're looking for the grail?
Five, what the hell in Maron did I just watch?
I'm IE Neverday, and at the end of this video,
I will be grading 1981's Excalibur on its folklorical accuracy.
Along the way, we'll learn about magic swords, magic spells, magic Johnson.
Wait, no, he's not in that.
And we'll take attendance at the round table
to find out if all of the shiny boys in the movie
align with actual knights from Arthurian legend.
Let's take a look.
Before Peter Jackson brought the Lord of the Rings to the big screen,
director and producer John Borman gave it a shot.
He brought on an Italian architect, Rospo Pallenberg,
to help him condense Tolkien's three-volume epic into a single three-hour movie.
Needless to say, this project never materialized.
But the newfound writing team of Borman and Pallenberg
next set their sights on the OG sword and sorcery fantasy epic romance,
Le Mont d'Arthur, or The Death of Arthur,
which was compiled slash composed by Thomas Mallory in the 15th century.
This work takes a lot of the Arthurian lore that came before
and packages it all into a single continuous narrative,
which follows the conception, life, and death of King Arthur,
while also highlighting the exploits of his knights.
Hence, it's been argued that the original title for Le Mont d'Arthur
was The Whole Book of King Arthur and of His Noble Knights of the Round Table.
That is certainly a better descriptor of Mallory's nearly 250,000-word work,
which is about half the size of The Lord of the Rings for those keeping score at home.
But arguably, and please feel free to argue about this in the comments,
Mallory's work is narratively denser,
by which I mean there's more happening with fewer poetic detours.
I'm looking at you, Tom Bombadil.
What's more, Borman was able to squeeze a story
spanning three generations of royal Pendragon warriors
into a two-hour and 20-minute film.
Is it a perfect film? Of course not.
The battles at the beginning in particular feel small,
like there are ten guys fighting another ten guys,
and I am convinced Nigel Terry's performance as Arthur
could be seamlessly dropped into Monty Python and the Holy Grail.
But hey, that polished aluminum armor looks mwah.
And while Ian McKellen denies basing his Gandalf performance
on Nicol Williamson's performance as Merlin,
the similarities are plain to see.
But the inspiration goes both ways.
For example, having the Lady of the Lake repair or reforge Excalibur?
That wasn't in Mallory's story.
Mallory's version features two distinct swords that are both called Excalibur.
The sword Arthur pulls from the stone,
and the sword given to him by the Lady of the Lake.
After Arthur breaks Excalibur No. 1
during a fight with King Pelennor of Questing Beast fame,
the Lady of the Lake just gives him a new sword, Excalibur II.
The movie streamlines this,
reconciling the two sword stories by having it be the same sword throughout.
First, Merlin summons Excalibur from the Lady of the Lake
for Arthur's father, Uther Pendragon,
who shoves it into a stone before croaking.
Arthur pulls it out, breaks it during a fight with Lancelot,
tosses the broken Excalibur into the water,
then the Lady of the Lake does a quick underwater repair job,
and bada-bing, bada-boom, Excalibur is back in action.
Okay, maybe that's not exactly streamlined,
but this approach succeeds in keeping the titular sword
central to this generation's spanning story.
And it's likely Bormin and Pallenberg were inspired by their previous work
on The Lord of the Rings,
in which the elves famously reforge a legendary sword for the King of Men.
What's more, the elves are resigned to their fate.
They know that the magical days of old are behind them,
and that the age of men, for better or worse, is upon them.
A sentiment that Merlin shares in 1981's Excalibur.
And I quote,
The one god comes to drive out the many gods.
The spirit of wood and stream grow silent.
It's the way of things.
Yes, it's a time for men and their ways.
End quote.
Now, obviously the tension between Celtic paganism and Christianity
has always been central to Arthurian legend,
because if these stories are as old as people claim,
the original King Arthur wouldn't have been a Romano-Britonic Celtic warrior
battling the invading Saxons, or Saracens in Mallory's text.
He would have been a Britonic Celtic warrior battling the invading Romans.
But the way Merlin talks about a time for men here sounds rather Tolkien-esque.
True, in Mallory's work, Merlin does warn Arthur that despite all of his wizard magic,
he, Merlin, is gonna end up getting trapped in the earth
courtesy of a powerful witchy woman.
Which absolutely comes to pass.
Granted, in the text, it's Nimue, the second incarnation of the Lady of the Lake,
the first one gets her head chopped off,
who does the Merlin trapping.
While in the movie Excalibur, it's Arthur's half-sister Morgana,
a.k.a. Morgan le Fay, who traps Merlin using the charm of making.
Speaking of the charm of making,
kudos to the filmmakers for turning to Old Irish for these words.
Does it make sense to be speaking Old Irish?
Sort of.
Maybe.
Old Irish is the most ancient of the Goidelic or Gaelic Celtic languages.
It gave rise to modern Irish, Scots Gaelic, and Manx.
But to be clear, the Celtic places where the Arthurian legends are set
and or have strong connections to,
namely Wales, Cornwall, and Brittany,
those are Brittonic slash Brythonic Celtic places.
The Welsh, Cornish, and Breton languages are on a separate branch
from their Irish, Scots Gaelic, and Manx cousins.
Both branches grew out of Common Celtic or Proto-Celtic,
but still, it was kind of an odd choice to have Merlin, a Welsh wizard, speak Old Irish.
Unless the implication is that Merlin is Irish himself,
which, look, we don't really have time for a tangent like this,
but I'd be remiss not to mention that in Arthurian lore,
Merlin and Uther Pendragon go to Ireland and steal a stone circle
that later becomes known as Stonehenge.
Anyway, we also know that early medieval Irish scribes
were exchanging stories with their Welsh counterparts,
in that some Old Irish narratives were absorbed into quote-unquote British stories.
For example, the 14th century chivalric romance
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is based on the Old Irish story
So, perhaps by putting the most powerful of Merlin's spells in the language of Old Ireland,
Borman was giving a nod to the Irish slash Gaelic influence on Arthurian legend.
Or, you know, maybe he was just paying homage to the country he was filming in,
since all of 1981's Excalibur was filmed in Ireland,
specifically in Counties Kerry, Tipperary, and Wicklow.
All this being said about the words of The Charm of Making,
the charm itself isn't actually a thing in Arthurian legend.
In Mallory's text, the magical stuff just sort of happens.
No incantations necessary.
Poof! Uther looks like Ingrane's husband, the Duke of Cornwall.
And poof! Merlin and Sir Ulphius look like a couple of the Duke's knights.
Hey, that wasn't in the movie.
Poof! Merlin's in a rock sandwich.
In the text, it's made explicit that Merlin deserves to be in that rock sandwich,
because he's a huge creep.
Quote,
End quote.
Translation, the Lady of the Lake tricked Merlin into mansplaining his favorite stone,
and then used an enchantment to keep him trapped under it forever.
Which isn't all that dissimilar to how Morgana tricks Merlin in the movie.
As for the Dragon's Breath, that one belongs squarely to the realm of movie magic.
Merlin does not conjure any fog or smoke in Le Monde d'Arthur,
nor does Mallory describe any mists of Avalon when Arthur is taken by ship to that otherworldly island.
The closest thing I could find was a dream Arthur has,
in which he sees a, quote,
dreadful dragon do battle with a, quote,
grimly boar all black in a cloud.
Yeah, it's not much to go on.
Indeed, what really seems to be going on here is that Dragon's Breath looks cool on screen.
And it should be noted that in Homer's Odyssey,
Athena envelops Odysseus in a mist that enables him to sneak undetected into a castle
so he can talk to a queen.
But we don't have to go all the way to Greco-Roman mythology for such inspiration.
In Irish mythology, the sea god and otherworldly ruler,
Manannán Mac Lear,
raises a magical mist, the Fëthfiada,
to keep the homes of Ireland's divine tribe,
the Tuatha Dé Danann,
hidden from human eyes.
This is after the Milesians,
i.e. humans representing the arrival of Celtic culture in Ireland,
force the Tuatha Dé Danann underground.
The Tuatha Dé Danann retreat to their she or fairy hills,
also known as barrows.
Hence the chapter in Tolkien's Fellowship of the Ring,
Fog on the Barrow Downs.
It's all connected.
Because we know Bormann and Pallenberg were intimately familiar with the Lord of the Rings.
Bormann even corresponded with Tolkien about producing the aforementioned movie adaptation.
And we know Tolkien studied Irish mythology and based his elves,
at least in part,
on the Tuatha Dé Danann,
the divine Irish tribe destined to be replaced by humans.
So in a sense,
while the movie's dragon's mist isn't accurate to the source material,
it is at least somewhat accurate to the source material's source material.
Now, I, Liam, need someone to explain to me
why the scabbard of Excalibur isn't included in this movie.
Because in Malory's text,
this scabbard or sheath is arguably more powerful than Excalibur itself.
With the scabbard,
Arthur cannot bleed from injuries endured.
Without it, blood city.
So what does Morgan le Fay do before the Battle of Camlin?
She steals the scabbard,
thus making it possible for her son Mordred to kill Arthur.
Speaking of the Mordred versus Arthur showdown,
I know where Bormann got the look for this scene.
True, cinematographer Alex Thompson deserves a lot of the credit,
and he got a lot of it.
Excalibur was nominated for precisely one Academy Award when it came out,
and that was in the cinematography category.
It did not win.
But in this scene in particular,
set on this corpse-strewn battlefield
with the glowing orange sun setting in the background,
that's pulled directly from N.C. Wyatt's The Death of Arthur and Mordred,
an illustration he made for the 1922 edition of the 1880 book The Boy's King Arthur.
The Boy's King Arthur being an abridged version of Malory's Le Monde d'Auteur.
Wait, so did Bormann and Pallenberg base their Excalibur script
on an abridged version of the source material?
Not exactly.
Although it might have been helpful to look at.
Because in that 1880 reworking,
editor Sidney Lanier was able to trim Malory's nearly quarter-million-word epic
down to a 90,000-word novel.
And he brought the focus more squarely on Arthur,
his lineage,
and a core group of his knights.
Which, sure, in a general sense,
Bormann and Pallenberg applied that same approach
when condensing Malory's work into a 25,000-word script.
But a quick perusal of all three of these texts side-by-side
reveals that the movie Excalibur is really doing its own thing here.
Especially on the Knights of the Round Table front.
Pop quiz.
Name as many of the Knights of the Round Table as you can from memory.
Go.
What are those big names that pop out at you immediately?
I think Sir Lancelot, it's safe to say, is near the top of that list.
And in recent years, Sir Gawain has gained more name recognition,
thanks to 2021's Green Knight.
Sir Percival, he certainly gets a lot to do in the movie,
including finding and recovering the Holy Grail.
No big deal.
But wait a minute.
While Sir Percival and Sir Bors,
whom Arthur only mentions in passing in the movie,
are part of the trio of knights who take part in this successful grail quest,
it is Sir Galahad, son of Lancelot, who achieves the grail.
That's in Malory's version and in the 1880 abridged version,
which I will quote here.
Now, Sir Galahad rode many journeys in vain,
and afterward, meeting with Sir Bors and Sir Percival,
they knew many wonders and adventures.
Still, in a certain day, they came down into a ship,
and in the midst thereof, they found a table of silver
in the Holy Grail, all covered with white samite.
And the Holy Grail wrought many miracles,
comforting them in prison, feeding them, and healing the sick.
And it befell them that Painan, king who had cast them in prison, died.
And the people by one accord chose Sir Galahad to be king,
and he reigned there a year.
And on a certain morning, Sir Galahad, having risen early and come unto the palace,
saw before him the Holy Grail, and a man kneeling,
and about him a great fellowship of angels.
Then Sir Galahad knew that his hour was come,
and he went to Sir Percival, and kissed him, and commended him to God.
And he went to Sir Bors, and kissed him, and commended him to God,
and said,
Yeah, sounds like this Galahad fella is kind of a big deal.
Can you remember who played Sir Galahad in 1981's Excalibur?
Nobody.
They cut him, and they gave all of his glory to Percival.
Which, to be fair, was a super smart move on their part.
Because in the oldest known Grail quest legend,
the 12th century Percival, the Story of the Grail by Chrétien de Troyes,
it is Sir Percival who achieves the Grail.
Then in the 13th century,
writers switch things up and start naming Sir Galahad as the true Grail Knight,
demoting Percival to sidekick.
So really, Borman and Pallenberg just switched things back.
And while they were boosting Percival's profile,
they probably figured Sir Bors is redundant.
But if we remove Sir Bors,
who will volunteer to champion Queen Guinevere
in a trial by combat with Sir Lancelot off brooding?
Sir Percival.
And then the filmmakers thought,
Wait, we forgot to include Arthur's earliest and most loyal knight,
Sir Bedivere, who famously hesitates to throw Excalibur into a lake
when Arthur asks him to, but then he ultimately does,
thus allowing Arthur to head on over to Avalon.
Who could possibly take over for Sir Bedivere in this crucial role?
It's Sir Percival.
Who is this guy's agent?
I want to hire them.
But the same does not apply for Sir Tristram's agent.
Poor Sir Tristram.
He's mentioned north of 2,000 times in Malory's Le Morte d'Auteur.
Meanwhile, in Borman's Excalibur, he's a no-show.
And lest you think I'm being too harsh on this movie
or how the filmmakers handle the lore, let me be clear.
I think Excalibur is a major storytelling accomplishment.
If my critique sounds nitpicky,
that's only because this film offers so many nits for us to pick.
Think about the world's most popular film about Arthurian legend.
Arguably, it's Monty Python and the Holy Grail.
That movie, for all its comedic glory and attention to detail,
I gave it an A- in folklorical accuracy,
reimagines just a tiny sliver of the available lore.
It shows the quest for the Grail already in motion.
Whereas in Excalibur, there is so much going on narratively
that the Grail quest portion almost feels like an afterthought.
One day, Arthur's just like,
you know what, I think we need a holy chalice for the palace.
The filmmakers made a choice here.
Choosing breadth over depth.
Then again, those Grail quest scenes do go pretty deep.
But my point is, it wouldn't be fair to judge Excalibur purely on the finer details
when that's not what the filmmakers were focused on.
They were focused on telling a single sweeping medieval epic fantasy romance
set over a period of several decades in a sub-three-hour movie.
And during pre-production, Borman specifically was thinking big.
Real big.
To quote his autobiography,
I began to formulate the idea that the Grail cycle was a metaphor
for the past, present, and future of humanity.
In the early chapters, the Uther Pendragon period,
man is emerging.
As law and order are imposed, Arthur gradually forfeits his connection with nature.
The only way to cure the king and save the land is to find the Grail,
the feminine symbol of wholeness and harmony, to find again a oneness with nature.
Does Excalibur succeed in conveying this metaphor?
I don't know.
But what I do know is that with Excalibur,
Borman and his team achieved something that
Peter Jackson and his team would go on to achieve with the Lord of the Rings.
He successfully condensed the seemingly uncondensable.
As for its folklorical accuracy grade, I'm giving 1981's Excalibur an A.
And if you enjoyed this video, please subscribe, leave a like, and comment.
When a man lies, he murders some part of the world.
As always, I'm Iene Everday.
I've got books for sale in the description.
Thanks for coming out.
