The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
For more of these videos, get yourself a level three membership subscription!
J. Loveless et al, Complete Criminal Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2022). D. Ormerod & K. Laird, Smith, Hogan & Ormerod’s Criminal Law (Oxford University Press, 2021).
English criminal law is a system of laws and principles that govern the punishment of individuals who commit crimes in England and Wales. It is based on a combination of statutes and common law principles.
The theoretical elements of English criminal law include concepts of punishment, evidence, defence and prosecution, and criminalisation. These elements shape the foundation of the criminal justice system and guide the application of criminal laws.
To establish criminal liability, certain elements need to be proven. These elements include the actus reus, which refers to the physical act or conduct of the accused, and the mens rea, which refers to the mental state or intention behind the act. Various defences are recognised, such as incapacity, compulsion, and mistake.
English criminal law covers a wide range of specific criminal offences, including murder, manslaughter, sexual offences, non-fatal offences, and property offences. Each offence has its own elements and requirements for establishing guilt.
It is important to note that the information provided here is a general overview and should not be considered legal advice. The application and interpretation of criminal law can vary depending on the specific circumstances and jurisdiction.
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Hello everybody and welcome back to the Law Academy. Now this is an introductory revision
lesson for Level 3 members on the Law Academy YouTube channel. If you want access to the rest
of this content go and pick yourself up a Level 3 membership over on the Law Academy. Now what
you'll have access to is every single one of these revision lessons that we are going to be doing for
every single subject in English and Welsh Law, as well as every other ordinary lesson that has
been released on the channel already prior to its formal release to the public. In addition to this
you will also be helping us keep this content openly available to everybody. So not only will
you be getting access to all of these revision lessons and everything else, but you will also
be helping us to maintain the creation of more lessons in the future. This video is a free video
to get an idea of the kind of thing that we're going to be doing with these revision lessons,
and this is going to be an introduction to the criminal law. We're going to talk about a number
of different aspects of the criminal law, criminal theory, and ideas relating to criminalization.
And we're going to begin over here by asking the question, what is a crime? And it's interesting
to note because despite the fact that the criminal law is one area of law that is seen to be,
at least colloquially, best well known or most well known to the public in the public space,
when we think about this question, what is a crime? The answer to this question is something
that is debatable and has attracted many scholars over many, many years. The question of what
is a crime is one that is difficult to determine. The Oxford English Dictionary suggests that the
idea of a crime is some kind of act or an omission that is considered to be unlawful. That is
to be the general definition of a crime. In addition to this, there is an additional element,
according to some theorists, which suggests that the unlawful nature of the act is sufficient to
warrant the intervention from the state. So fundamentally, the state gets involved in the
conversation in relation to determining whether or not something is a crime and whether or not
somebody should be punished for their criminal actions. This is considered to be the general
definition of a crime, but it's not necessarily one which is accepted entirely, or even necessarily
within the law itself. Now, one citation that we can make is in relation to certain pieces of
legislation, which, for the purposes of the legislation, define crimes inside their own act.
So, for example, section 2432 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations Consolidation Act
suggests that, quote, a crime for this purpose means an offence punishable on indictment,
or an offence punishable on summary conviction, and for the commission of which the offender is
liable under statute, making the offence punishable to be imprisoned either absolutely,
or at the discretion of the court as an alternative for some other punishment.
This isn't actually quite a nice definition of a crime, but it is only limited to the Trade Union
and Labour Relations Act, but it is quite nice. It is suggesting that a crime is an offence which
is punishable on indictment, or punishable on summary conviction, so either punishable through
Crown Court or through magistrates, and the commission of which the offender is liable
under the statute, in question being the Trade Union and Labour Relations Act, and there is also
the view that once an individual has committed a crime, once they have been found guilty of a
criminal offence, they can be imprisoned, and of course when we think about this more generally,
there is a little bit more to it, and then there are other punishments that are attached to it.
But fundamentally, the question of what is a crime is something that is heavily debated,
and so when we think about debates relating to crimes, there are a few different conversations,
a few different modes of inquiry that we can actually go down. The idea of what makes something
a criminal offence is something that is debated in and of itself. For example, we can take a look
at these three considerations, and we can come to some various conclusions in this regard. On the
one hand, what are the key necessary and sufficient factors in the process of criminalisation? Does an
act or an omission need to be committed in order for there to have been a crime? For the most part,
the answer to this question is yes. When we think about what a crime is, the actual act or the
failure to act is a key and central element. For those of you who are going to carry on studying
these revision lessons, this is known as the actus reus of an offence. We'll get to it in a future
lesson. Does the act or omission, however, have to commit some kind of harm? Does there have to be
some kind of harm committed in order for this to merit and to warrant this idea of criminalisation?
Does the act or omission in question require the breach of some kind of system of morality? Does
there have to be a breach of public morality? Does there have to be a breach of individual morality?
Does knowledge of wrongdoing actually matter? If so, does it matter in all contexts? Do all crimes
require a victim? If so, what is the relationship that is had between the state and that of the
victim themselves? Many also take a view of paternalism, a maternalistic outcome, when it
comes to the understanding of the criminal law, paternalistic outlook at least. In a great many
different cases, the criminal law looks to protect those who may be victims of crimes, or to support
those who have been victims of crimes as a sort of post hoc justification. And so this gives
the criminal law as a general entity something of a paternalistic role, a paternalistic view,
the general idea that by limiting autonomy of society's actions, justification can be brought
on the basis that what you are doing is protecting those in society who need that protection most,
people who are vulnerable within society, people who may have certain mental conditions that make
them more vulnerable in society, and so as a result of which you are limiting acts that are
able to be committed in order to protect those in society who are of that most vulnerable collection.
This is a generally accepted view, at least to an extent, and the power that we give to the state
is something that can be justified on the basis of this paternalistic outcome, the belief being
that a good society is one which allows for the greater protections of those in that society
who need it most. But fundamentally this is something of a theoretical conception,
and this brings us to the last point on this particular revision lesson, which is in relation
to this idea of criminalization and criminal theory. Now what I've done here is I've cited a
number of different points that I'm going to be drawing attentions from around this last point
here, and this is all broadly encapsulated as part of criminal theory, although to an extent you could
make the argument that all of this PowerPoint presentation or this mind map presentation
is somewhat criminal theory in its general format. Now what we're going to do is divide our
attention when looking at the theoretical principles underpinning the criminal law
into two main elements, i.e. two main theories. On the one hand you have this theory known as the
harm principle. We'll talk about what the harm principle is, and then afterwards we will talk
about this second concept, this idea known as legal moralism, the idea that criminalization
may be justified on the basis of upholding morality. But firstly what is this idea of
criminalization? What do we mean when we think about criminalization? Well if you were to ask
the question what does criminalization mean, it is fundamentally the process by which certain
conduct is made criminal. Given that criminalization entails the restriction of an individual's ability
to perform a certain action, the justification for criminalization is an important issue.
How does one justify the criminalization of conduct? How does one actually suggest that
we are going to be limiting society's ability to do and perform these actions?
Well why? Under what basis should we be doing so? Well the harm principle and legal moralism
give us answers to these questions. The harm principle simply tells us that we can justify
criminalization on the conduct that, at least in its general format, that conduct can cause some
kind of harm. This is a general view of the harm principle. According to philosopher John Stuart
Mill, quote, the only purpose for which power can rightfully be exercised over any member of a
civilized community against his will is to prevent harm to others. This is essentially both encapsulating
the view of the harm principle on the one hand, but it is also encapsulating the importance of
justifying criminalization on the other. Because what Mill is saying here is that power is used and
exercised over members of a civilized community and is done against their will. That's what
criminalization essentially entails. And so a particularly high bar ought to be met in order to
ensure that there is not just this willy-nilly imposition of authority by the state. The state
steps in only in these most important and most egregious cases. Now this also ties into
another theoretical view which is suggesting that the criminal law ought to be a system of last
resort. That people should ought to essentially try to solve problems using other elements of law,
sociology, psychology, or politics before reverting to the criminal law as the final solution.
One could understand the attraction of the harm principle when we think of quite obvious cases.
Murder causes harm. So too does various different or any sexual offence. But the state criminalizes
conduct such as murder in order to protect individuals from harm. The harm is caused by
the commission of the act itself. The harm to the victim themselves as well as the harm to
those who are subsidiary to the victim, those who are around the victim. In addition to harm that
can be caused more generally in society as a result of allowing things like murder to take
place. But can the harm principle explain the nature of criminalization in all circumstances?
Given that there are more than just murder and sexual offences in the criminal justice system,
can harm principle be used to justify every single kind of offence? Can we for example suggest that
harm principle is acting in a way to when we're talking about for example an individual driving
without car insurance, which is a criminal offence. It is a criminal offence and I guess to an extent
you can conceptualize an understanding which would fit into the general conception of the harm
principle. But it's not so clear-cut compared to that of for example murder cases. Does the
variation in punishment account for the variation of harm that is incurred? Because of course driving
without insurance is a much lesser of an offence than the commission of murder. Another point of
reference is this idea of quantifying harm. The philosopher and the legal theorist Joel Feinberg
suggests that while the harm principle could be useful in our understanding of criminalization,
not all conduct which causes harm may be criminalized. He suggested that there should
therefore be additional factors that we need to consider when we are thinking about the strict
application of the harm principle. The harm principle in its generality is not enough for
there to be a real cohesive understanding of criminalization, including things like the
gravity of the harm, the magnitude of the risk, as well as the relative probability of the harm being
caused. Finally then, let's think about this idea of subjective harm. One issue that can be considered
in this relation is that not all acts can be considered harmful to everybody. So we can all
agree that committing murder is a harmful thing and that will cause harm in various different
circumstances, but just for example selling an energy drink to somebody who is 15 years old,
is that something that causes harm, given the fact that it is illegal for you to sell an energy
drink to somebody who is 15 years old, but it is not illegal for you to sell an energy drink to
somebody who is 16 years old. It may be difficult to see where the harm is at this point and so
what the criminal law essentially does is draw arbitrary lines as to where things may or may
not be harmful or not harmful. Why is it for example harmful and therefore criminalized for
an individual to be drinking alcohol at the age of 17, but as soon as they turn 18 it is no longer
a harmful use of that substance. All of which are obviously elements that relate to the generally
subjective nature of things like age of majority, age of consent, all of these things that are
age related of course is essentially drawing a line at a point and having to justify that line,
which is not always necessarily an easy thing to do. Now the second line of argumentation is this
idea known as legal moralism. Now what legal moralism tells us is that criminalization may
be justified on the basis that the particular acting question violates some kind of moral
standard or moral principle. So something is not necessarily a crime because it causes harm,
but it is a crime because it is immoral and immorality is therefore criminalized. Now
you could even have a sort of merging of these two ideas together and suggest that the harm
principle and legal moralism are compatible with each other. This is completely true,
they are or at least they can be compatible with each other. The concept of these two are not
necessarily mutually exclusive. You could say for example that murder is wrong and therefore
criminalized because it is immoral. It is immoral because it causes harm and so therefore what you
have done is encapsulated the harm principle into this idea of legal moralism. Now legal moralism
is very very interesting given the fact that there have been and there is quite a lot of substantive
law that concentrates on this idea of legal moralism and this idea of public morality. Now
one of the things that is very very interesting as a point to reference here as a sort of critique
is that should the upholding of this idea of public morals be considered under the remit of
the criminal justice system? What about acts which were perfectly legal but 30 years ago were
considered to be immoral? Things like homosexuality and we'll get to that in a second.
What about acts which are considered immoral but which are not taken up by the criminal
justice system? If I cheated on my significant other most people hopefully would suggest that
this is an immoral thing for me to have done. However it is not something that the criminal
law is going to come and prosecute me for and so as a result of which how can we make this
essentially operate? Well two offences developed in and around the 1970s focused on this idea of
public morals and these two offences, the first being conspiracy to corrupt public morals,
the second being conspiracy to outrage public morals, were put on full display in two important
cases from the 1960s and the 1970s. The first of these was the case from 1962 of Shaw versus the
Director of Public Prosecutions. Now in this case the defendant had created a number of magazines.
Included in these magazines were personal adverts for prostitutes. Now for those of you who are
relatively young, presumably if you're studying law at university right now, you probably won't
remember that magazines used to have personal adverts in them. We didn't have internet back
then and so you would advertise things not using pop-ups on social media but instead using the
space in various different magazines and newspapers. Given the fact that the defendant made
money from selling the advertising space and given the fact that he had sold the advertising space
to individuals for the purposes of prostitution they were charged and convicted with two
particular offences. The first being breaches of section 30 of the Sexual Offences Act from
but the second being the conspiracy to corrupt public morals. Now Shaw would appeal that conviction
on the basis that conspiracy to corrupt public morals was not an offence in the law of England
and Wales at the time and so they could not be convicted of such an offence given the fact that
there was no precedent for the establishment of said offence. But on appeal this was dismissed
and the conviction in fact was upheld and therefore as a result of that creating a new
criminal offence, the criminal offence of conspiracy to corrupt public morals. This was then challenged
in 1973 when another case of similar factual circumstances was referred to the Court of
Appeal. This case being Nullar versus the Director of Public Prosecutions. It was also a case where
these magazines contained the ability for individuals to advertise rather than advertising
prostitution they advertise as what is defined in the case as quote homosexual practices. Essentially
gay men are going and putting advertising space for them to meet other men and just meet each
other and do homosexual practices essentially is what was defined there. Again the defendant
was convicted for conspiracy to corrupt public morals. The issue again was whether or not this
was an offence which was recognised by the law of England and Wales and again this was a case which
was dismissed on appeal reaffirming the creation of the offence in Shaw versus the Director of
Public Prosecutions. Now it should be noted that these cases in legal moralism are particularly
controversial and they were scrutinised in fact not these cases specifically but the idea of
prostitution, homosexual practices and public morality more generally was criticised
in the Wolfenden Committee Report on Prostitution and Homosexual Offences in 1957.
Essentially the committee here held that the criminal law should not have a role in the
enforcement of public morality. Given the fact that morality is a subjective endeavour
and given the fact that this is something that is likely to change on a consistent basis the
regulation of public morality of the criminal law is something of a controversial question and so
fundamentally the debate and discussion that you can have here is what do you think about the
concept of criminalisation? What do you think about the extent to which criminalisation
can be justified on the basis of harm principles or legal moralism or on any other theoretical
conception of the criminal law? It is not just these two but it could be any other theoretical
conception of the criminal law as well. Now I hope everybody has enjoyed this video. Like I said at
the start this is an introductory lesson for Level 3 membership. For anybody who wants to get access
to the rest of these lessons, the rest of these revision subject lessons as well as all of the
other lessons early, do go over to the membership page, click the join button on the channel and get
yourself a Level 3 membership. You'll get access to all of these lessons, all of the earlier lessons
or all the other lessons early as well which I believe is like something like 100 lessons
and you will be helping us keeping this content available for everybody. So thank you and I'll
see everybody in for another lesson in the future.