9 Questions Insurance Adjusters DON'T Want You To Ask

Auto Insurance
2 followers
3 Video Views·Aug 8, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video provides a strategic guide on nine specific questions to ask insurance adjusters during personal injury, car accident, or slip-and-fall claims. The goal is to expose the internal metrics, authority limits, and negotiation tactics used by insurance companies to help claimants secure larger settlements more efficiently.
I'm going to tell you nine questions that insurance adjusters do not want you to ask
in personal injury claims, slip and falls, car accidents, and much more.
You'll see how asking these questions may get you a larger settlement in a shorter amount
of time, and we're starting right now.
The first question that adjusters don't want you to ask is, what is your average claim
payout?
Adjusters at insurance companies are tracked by their average loss payouts.
That's the average amount they're paying out per claim.
In a car accident injury case, Guy Coe was sued for bad faith, and claims documents were
revealed that shows that Guy Coe was ranking their insurance adjusters in different percentiles.
Now, Guy Coe adjusters in the third and fourth percentile were paying out the most on average
per claim, and claim documents showed that for these adjusters that were paying out in
the upper 50% of claims, their supervisor was ordered to suspend, to stop their settlement
authority until there was improvement noted.
The adjusters that were paying out in the top 50% of claims at Guy Coe then have to
ask their supervisors for authority.
Adjusters don't want to have to ask their supervisors for authority because it takes
extra time, and then they can't settle claims as fast.
I've had adjusters tell me that they're not ranked based on how much they pay.
They're ranked based on how soon they reach out to the injured party after the accident
and other things like that.
The bottom line is that some adjusters are better negotiators than others, and yes, they
are ranked in different percentages in the insurance company that they work for.
The second question adjusters don't want you to ask is, is your settlement authority double
your first offer?
I spoke with an adjuster who worked at one of the largest insurance companies in the
United States.
He told me that his ultimate settlement authority was two times his opening offer.
That means if his opening offer was $10,000, the most he could settle for was $20,000.
Now, I don't suggest asking this question in the beginning of the claim.
You should only ask it if their final offer is not twice their initial offer.
The third question adjusters don't want you to ask in personal injury claims is, where
can I find more about how you settle personal injury claims?
In a state like Florida, the injured person or their attorney can file a civil remedy
notice of insurer violation.
All these claimed violations are kept online in a website that you can view.
You can even search by the individual insurance adjuster.
Now, you go to the section of this form where it says, name of individual responsible for
violation if any, and you put in the adjuster's name.
It's then going to show you the past times that people or their attorneys have filed
complaints for civil remedy notices against these adjusters.
In other words, these are times where the injured person or their attorney is saying
that the insurance company was not acting in good faith.
I'm going to give you an example of an actual civil remedy notice filed by an Uber passenger
in an accident.
The Uber passenger's attorney claimed that he had surgery to his lower back and the medical
bills were over $200,000.
Uber's insurance company, Progressive, responded by offering $2,500.
And Uber's insurance company, Progressive, said that the injured person, DeSantos, already
received a fair offer from the at-fault party's insurance company.
And Progressive claimed that it asked the Uber passenger's attorney for prior records.
In any back injury or neck injury case, expect the insurance company to want to see your
prior records.
And if you fell at a hotel or theme park like Universal Studios, you can search by the name
of the place where you fell.
Now, it has to be the legal name.
For example, Universal Studios would be NBC Universal.
And you can then get an idea of how they handle past claims.
The fourth question that insurance adjusters don't want you to ask in car accident and
personal injury claims is how much authority did you request to settle this case for?
In order for an insurance adjuster to settle a case, they need to get authority.
At some insurance companies, these adjusters already have authority without having to ask.
But at other ones, they need to ask for authority.
I heard that one of the largest insurance companies in the United States cut down their
adjuster's authority from $100,000 to $10,000.
This means that in order to settle a personal injury case for any amount above $10,000,
they have to ask their manager for approval.
To get approval from the manager, the adjuster has to complete an evaluation.
This form gives you a good idea of the things that adjusters look for when deciding how
much to pay you.
Now, this form that you can see here is an updated evaluation form that the Hartford's
attorneys complete to keep the adjusters advised.
Now, even if the adjuster tells you how much they requested settlement authority for, it
doesn't mean you're going to get paid this amount.
I represented a man who was on a moped in Miami Beach, Florida when a taxi made an improper
U-turn in front of him.
They crashed.
My client had a deep bone bruise to his upper arm, the humerus.
The adjuster for the taxi's insurance company told me that she had requested that her insurance
company offer the $125,000 policy limits.
Unfortunately, she then only offered $18,000 and we sued and ultimately settled for $25,000.
And in this case, my client did not have a serious fracture and he didn't have surgery.
So the $25,000 was fair value for the case.
The fifth question that adjusters don't want you to ask in personal injury cases is, what
can I do for you to pay me more money in my case?
Adjusters want to settle cases fast.
They don't want cases lingering and staying open.
Now, adjusters are overworked.
Just look at what a third-party administrator for Walmart said.
Surveys of workers' compensation adjusters show that even at a caseload of 130 files,
adjusters consider themselves in a reactive mode being overwhelmed with phone calls, data
entry, and email requests.
Generally speaking, the adjusters are not going to tell you how to increase the value
of your case.
They're not going to tell you, hey, you should get the 911 call.
Maybe you'll hear my insured admitting fault in it.
They're not going to tell you, although you sent me the hospital bill, we still need the
ER physician's bill because that's a separate bill and that's going to add value to your
case and result in a larger offer to you.
If you're claiming that you have a head injury or brain injury, they're likely not going
to tell you, hey, you should treat with a neuropsychologist.
That may add significant value to your case.
And if you're injured at an accident at a hotel or theme park or mall, they're not going
to tell you to go to Google or TripAdvisor and look for reviews that show other people
complaining of the same hazard that caused your injury.
In this hotel slip and fall case here, you can see the insurance adjuster telling me
the reviews have been considered and she offered me $205,000.
She was referring to the reviews that I had sent her showing other people complaining
that the area was slippery and had issues.
The sixth question that adjusters don't want you to ask is how much can you offer me to
settle my case?
You will never know how much the insurance adjuster could offer you to settle your case.
The one exception is if they're paying you the policy limits, the policy limits are what
they are.
The policy limits are the most they have to pay you under the insurance policy.
In some cases that I've settled for fair value where my client wanted a very fast settlement,
after the settlement, I've asked the adjuster, if I would have sued, would you have offered
me more money?
And the adjuster will say, I would have asked my manager and they probably would have offered
$5,000 more or so.
But ultimately, it's the client's decision when to settle and some clients want a fast
settlement.
The seventh question that adjusters don't want you to ask in personal injury claims
is how often do you settle a case in less than three moves?
That means three counter offers on their part.
Insurance claims involve negotiation.
If you're not dealing with an insurance policy limit settlement, insurance adjusters rarely
settle a case in less than three moves.
I know an insurance adjuster who worked at one of the largest insurance companies in
the United States and he told me, his supervisor told him, never ever settle a case by making
less than three offers.
Insurance companies know that some people don't realize negotiation is part of a personal
injury settlement.
When negotiating, you need to be patient and never drop too much at one time.
And please, whatever you do, do not tell the adjuster that you want a certain amount.
Tell them you need a certain amount.
It's a lot stronger of a negotiation position.
When I say that insurance adjusters don't settle cases in less than three moves, that
means typically if you were to demand $100,000 to settle, they may come back with $20,000.
You then come down to $75,000, they come up to $40,000, you come down to $60,000, they
come up to $50,000, and perhaps you meet somewhere in the middle.
But don't expect an insurance adjuster to settle your case for fair value in less than
three moves.
The eighth question that insurance adjusters don't want you to ask in car accidents, slip
and falls, and personal injury claims is do you like to settle for less money?
Insurance companies want to settle for as little as possible, but don't take my word
for it.
Let's look at an actual document in a case where bad faith was alleged against GEICO.
The GEICO regional claims manager said BIALP, that means bodily injury, average claim payouts
dropped by 1% and UN, that's uninsured motorist insurance, average loss payouts, average claim
paid out, improved by 5.2%.
Nice job on both.
You can see that this claims manager was happy that the average loss payout that GEICO was
paying out had decreased.
In other words, the injured people were getting less money and GEICO was saving money.
Remember, insurance companies run on profit.
The more profit they make, the more their shareholders benefit.
The ninth question that insurance adjusters don't want you to ask in injury claims is
are you going to fight my case?
Just because you call an insurance company or a claim is reported and they tell you that
there's a claim number, or even if they tell you they've accepted liability for the accident,
that does not mean they're not going to fight your case.
They may accept liability for an accident, but they'll argue that your injuries are not
related to the accident, so what good is that for your personal injury claim?
Or they'll argue that your injuries aren't as bad as you're claiming they are.
You know an adjuster is not fighting your case when they're offering you fair settlement
value for their case, but until that happens, do not think that just because you're dealing
with a sweet insurance adjuster who says thank you every time you send them a medical record
or bill, that does not mean they're going to pay you fair value for your injury.
I have dealt with some of the nicest insurance adjusters who would thank me for sending medical
records and bills, and thank me for my time every time I spoke with them on the phone,
and then they ultimately denied liability in the case, I sued them, and we ultimately
got fair value for my client.
Watch these videos here to learn how to get the largest settlement in the shortest amount
of time.
Subscribe to my channel.
And I'll see you next time.
