New York City is moving forward with Mayor Zohran Mamdani's plan to open government-owned grocery stores. The promise? Lower food prices. The reality? Taxpayer-funded construction, ongoing subsidies, and a plan full of contradictions.
In this episode of America Uncovered, we break down Mamdani's proposal, why critics say the math doesn't add up, how it compares to existing private-sector programs, and why government-run grocery stores may not solve New York's affordability crisis.
Leave a 🇺🇸 in the comments FOR THE ALGORITHM! Want to see me eat cheap monkey kibble? Support the show! http://americauncovered.tv
NYC Mayor Zoran Mamdani has unveiled a plan to build city-owned, privately managed grocery stores to lower food costs. The critic argues the plan is fiscally irresponsible, contradictory in its requirements, and redundant given existing private-sector solutions and the successful FRESH program.
Zoran Mamdani finally lays out his plan to build state-owned grocery stores in New York
City.
And boy, this is, uh, not gonna work.
Hello, New American Covered, I'm Chris Chappell.
Well, folks, it's finally happening!
Seven months after taking office, New York City Mayor Zoran Mamdani has finally unveiled
the details for his plan to build a network of city-owned grocery stores.
The first two locations are set, one in the Bronx and another in East Harlem.
The Bronx store is projected to be open by the end of 2027, and the Harlem location,
along with other locations in the other boroughs—Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island—are slated for
2029.
Damn.
It really takes the richest city in America 3 years to build less than half a dozen discount
grocery stores.
Keep in mind, the Empire State Building was built in a little over 13 months.
Oh well, baby steps, right?
In any case, New Yorkers will be finally getting some much-needed relief when it comes to buying
food in a city that routinely ranks the most expensive in the country.
Is what I'd be saying if the plan made any sense.
Now before we get into the math, I just need to clear something up.
The second this plan was announced, critics started comparing it to the Soviet Union's
state-owned grocery stores.
You know the image, babushkas waiting for hours in the freezing cold, clutching their
ration cards in the hope of snagging a loaf of rye bread and maybe a doctor's sausage
if they're lucky.
Don't laugh, that's actually what they're called.
As funny or grim as that image may be, that's not really what's happening in New York.
The Soviet Union was a command economy.
The government pretty much owned and operated its entire distribution system, top to bottom.
Now these new Mamdani stores are government-owned, sure, but they're privately managed.
The city put out a Request for Proposals, or RFP, for a private grocery store operator
to actually run the stores day-to-day.
That means handling the staffing, the merchandising, keeping the place clean, etc, etc.
So that's the case, where does the government come in?
And how are these stores supposed to lower the price of food?
Well, first, the city government put aside $70 million for construction.
They pay the contractors to build the store, choose the design, and pick out whatever equipment
the store needs, for example, refrigerators.
On top of not having to pay for construction, the private operators won't have to pay
rent or property taxes.
Those savings are meant to be passed on to the customer.
That's accomplished by the store offering a core basket of goods, which the city defines.
In this case, the core basket includes a selection of produce, fresh meat and seafood, plus 20
or so categories of basic household staples—milk, eggs, flour, those sorts of things—and they're
to be sold at 30% below the current market rate.
But here's where it starts to get messy.
The RFP the city put out to find an operator can't seem to decide on what it actually
wants.
It explicitly says the stores aren't designed to include on-site food preparation facilities,
such as deli or butcher counters, but the core basket they're required to sell includes
deli-prepared items like egg salad, meaning that they'll have to be shipped in from
somewhere else.
And I'll just say it right now, if I ask for an egg salad and you give me something
that's been sitting in the back of a truck all day, I'm throwing hands.
But it doesn't end there.
It also tells operators to carry a limited SKU, which is to say, a small selection of
goods, while simultaneously demanding full grocery departments, plus household goods,
ethnic foods, vegan products, kosher products, and other options.
Okay, so let's just imagine the store's operators figure out a way to stock all these
items at low prices and do it in a way that makes the city happy.
There's still another problem—free riders.
You see, New York City taxpayers are footing the bill for all the construction and all
the tax breaks and subsidies these stores will need.
So ideally, these stores would only be used by New Yorkers, and particularly the poorest
among them who could really use cheaper groceries.
So what if a financially well-off commuter from, say, New Jersey walks in?
What if one of Tony Soprano's goons figures out he can just buy up all the stock and resell
it for a profit?
I mean, what can you do?
Ask for a New York ID?
Well, Mondani's office said there would be no ID requirement to shop at any of these
stores.
And the city's Economic Development Corporation, or EDC, said shoppers wouldn't be means-tested
either.
What that means is you don't need to be poor to shop there.
You could be a billionaire and still pick up your crappy egg salad on the taxpayer's
dime.
The EDC said these grocery stores would be open to all New Yorkers, but with no ID and
no income check, the whole system is left wide open for abuse.
Now these stores will offer a free voluntary membership card program, but that won't require
proof of residency either.
Really, it's just a means to monitor sales.
And so far, there isn't a mechanism to stop, ahem, legitimate businessmen from New Jersey
from cashing in.
But even if everyone goes by Scout's Honor and there's no abuse at all, there's yet
another problem.
I know, I could go on like this all day.
So I think I will.
The cost of keeping these tax and rent-free stores afloat isn't a one-time thing.
It's an ongoing operating subsidy.
And that number could be anyone's guess.
And the timing just couldn't be worse.
Mamdani's budget has risen nearly 10 percent from last year, leaving New York on the verge
of a fiscal crisis.
Albany even had to step in earlier this year and give the city a $1.5 billion bailout to
cover a budget gap that officials are calling the largest shortfall since the Great Recession.
Socialists are bad with money.
I know.
I'm just as shocked as you are.
But you know what really annoys me about this whole thing?
New York already has a program that does exactly what the Mamdani stores claim to do.
It's called FRESH, Food Retail Expansion to Support Health, and it's been running
since 2009.
FRESH gives private grocers tax breaks and zoning benefits to build in underserved neighborhoods.
And since it launched, it's helped open 30 supermarkets across all 5 boroughs, represents
an investment of $177 million in private capital, and created more than 1,400 new jobs.
That's $177 million of private, not taxpayer money, drawn in because the incentive structure
made it possible.
So the city already has a proven 15-year-old model for getting grocery stores into underserved
neighborhoods—one that costs taxpayers a few million a year in foregone tax revenue
instead of tens of millions in direct spending, plus an ongoing subsidy no one can actually
disclose.
So why not just do more of that?
Well, it's because FRESH doesn't get Mamdani what he actually wants.
FRESH stores are privately owned.
Their goal is to turn a profit.
And that only works if the government isn't trying to micromanage every little part of
your business.
And if the goal really is to just get the cheapest groceries possible, the private sector
has already beaten Mamdani to it.
Grocery stores already run on especially thin profit margins, ranging from 1 to 3 percent
after overhead.
And a Consumerist checkbook study comparing prices across the D.C. area found that Aldi's
prices were an astounding 45 percent lower than traditional supermarkets like Giant or
Safeway.
How's that for your 30 percent?
You don't need some massive government program, just open more Aldi's.
That way I can start feasting on sauerkraut and schnitzel instead of on the cheap monkey
kibble I've been eating since YouTube cut off our ad revenue.
By the way, if you'd like to support this show, consider heading over to AmericanCovered.tv
and becoming a member.
If we can get to 3,000 subscribers, I promise I'll eat a heaping handful of this stuff
on stream.
You think I'm joking, but I'm dead serious.
Anyway, unlike Mamdani's stores, private grocers like Aldi and the ones using the FRESH
program pay rent, they pay property taxes, and they still manage to deliver affordable
goods at a razor-thin profit margin.
So here's the real question.
If there's already a working private sector-funded program doing the job, why have the Mamdani
marks at all?
Well, it's because Mamdani made them a core campaign promise.
He has to do it.
If he didn't, it'd be a betrayal of his democratic socialist base.
And the one thing we know about socialists is that economic realities don't matter.
Only the pursuit of the perfect socialist utopia.
And we all know how that ends.
What do you think?
Leave your comment below.
I read as many as I can, but I read every comment on AmericaUncovered.tv, where you'll
get access to thousands of episodes ad-free, plus a community chat, live streams, and,
if enough of you sign up, a tasting review of my favorite brand of primate chow.
Just click the button here or the link below.
Once again, I'm Chris Chappell.
Thank you for watching America Uncovered.