Aged Margaux Bordeaux vs $199 Brunello di Montalcino: The Brutal Truth After Two Full Bottles

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
1 Video View·Aug 6, 2026
Aged Margaux Bordeaux vs $199 Brunello di Montalcino — a certified sommelier drinks BOTH full bottles in a brutal wine fight, and only one survives.
In this Bordeaux wine review and Brunello di Montalcino wine review, I put a 2010 Château des Eyrins Margaux (16 years in bottle, from the legendary 2010
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA sommelier conducts a \"drink-along\" comparison between a 2010 Chateau Irines Margaux (Bordeaux) and a 2019 Salvioni La Cibola Brunello di Montalcino (Tuscany). The session focuses on building a \"mental database\" of flavors and evaluates the wines not just on quality, but on their evolution and emotional impact throughout the entire bottle.
I want you to do something unusual before we start tonight.
Stop what you're doing, wherever you are, and pour yourself not one, but two glasses
of wine.
They don't have to be expensive.
They don't have to be what I'm drinking tonight.
It just has to be in your hand when we begin.
And most importantly, it should be two glasses of something completely different.
Because tonight's video is different.
Tonight you're not just watching a brutal wine fight, you're participating in one.
In my left hand, a 2010 Chateau Irines Margot from Bordeaux, France.
Fifteen years old, already evolved, already showing you what time does to a great wine.
In my right hand, a 2019 Salvione La Cibola Bunello da Montalcino from Tuscany in Italy.
One of Italy's most respected artisan producers, seven years old, still figuring itself out,
still becoming what it's going to be.
Two worthy competitors, one crown.
And here's what no one ever tells you about drinking these two wines side by side.
Experiencing one teaches your brain to taste the other at a higher level.
Each has flavors and aromas the other doesn't.
Drinking one teaches you to pick out flavors, aromas, and mouthfeel you would otherwise
miss in the other.
So pour your wine.
Let's have a nod to Monty Python and pour two glasses of something completely different.
Get comfortable, settle in, and let's do this together.
Look, this is no mere snort, taste, and spit-spat.
This is a knock-down, drag-out, rock-and-roll, brutal wine fighting the streets.
And just like Highlander, there can only be one.
There are no ties.
First we taste, then we fight, until the end.
Before we start tasting, I want to tell you the story behind both of these wines.
And I promise this isn't going to be one of those moldy old history lessons that bores
you to tears and makes you want to skip ahead.
So let's start in Bordeaux.
This is a 2010 Chateau Irines Margaux.
Before you ask, no, it's not a first growth.
It's not Chateau Margaux with a capital M and a $1,000 price tag.
Chateau Irines is a smaller estate in the Margaux Appellation.
And that's actually the point, because what happened in Bordeaux in 2010 was extraordinary,
regardless of whether you were a first growth or not.
The 2010 vintage is what some critics call the vintage of the century for Bordeaux.
Yeah, they're always saying that.
But for once, I actually agree with them.
A long, hot, dry summer, perfect ripeness across every estate on the left bank.
The Cabernet Sauvignon grapes hit a level of concentration and tannin structure that
only happens once every few decades.
And then this bottle sat in the cellar for 15 years, 15 years of slow evolution.
The harsh young tannins, the closed primary fruit, the raw oak, all of it integrating,
softening, transforming.
What came out of that cellar is not what went in.
And we're about to experience what 15 years of patience actually tastes like.
Now let's go to Tuscany.
This is a 2019 Salvioni Lassebriolo Brunello di Montalcino.
And if you know anything about Brunello, you know this name is something pretty special.
Salvioni is what the wine world calls an artisan producer, a tiny family estate.
About five hectares of vines, maybe 12,000 bottles a year.
And I got one, baby, and I'm going to drink it.
No corporate ownership, no committees, no marketing department.
Just a Salvioni family doing what they've done for decades, making one of the most traditional,
uncompromising expressions of Sangiovese anywhere on the planet.
The devil's grape that makes heavenly wine.
The 2019 vintage in Montalcino was excellent.
Warm summers, cool nights at elevation, a late harvest that concentrated the fruit beautifully
without sacrificing the acid and structure that makes great Brunello what it is.
This wine aged in large, Salvonian oak casks, the traditional method, which means no new
oak vanilla or smoke signatures.
Everything in the glass comes from the fruit and the land.
At seven years old, this Brunello is officially released.
DOCG minimum aging is five years.
But is it ready to take on a 2010 Bordeaux?
That's the anticipation tonight.
One wine that has arrived, one wine that is arriving.
Each makes the other better.
Iron sharpens iron.
Let me show you what I mean.
I want to take 60 seconds to explain how tonight works, because this isn't a standard ridiculous
snort taste and spit review format.
This is what I'm calling a drink wine to video.
That name means exactly what it sounds like.
This is a wine review designed to be experienced while you are actually drinking wine.
What a concept.
Not watched afterward, not playing in the background while you cook, while you drink.
So if you have a glass in your hand right now, perfect.
If you don't, pause the video and pour two, two different ones.
I'll wait a bit.
Okay, here's what we're going to do.
As I move through the five steps to a magical wine experience with these two bottles, sight,
nose, palate, tying it all together, then the full whole bottle review, our favorite
part, I'm going to stop at certain points and ask you to taste your wine, whatever it
might be, through what I've just described.
And here's what we're going to do when you do that.
Every serious wine you experience builds what I call your mental database.
It's a library of aromas, textures, flavors, structures, sensations, and most importantly,
emotional experiences that your brain stores as reference points.
The first time you genuinely experience a great Brunello di Montalcino, and I sure remember
what I did, you're adding an entry, high-tone red fruit, that gorgeous sour cherry, iron-laced
minerality, dry chocolatey ties, fine Italian leather, even licorice.
From that point forward, for every red wine you drink, your brain has a new axis of comparison.
The critics have spent decades making you feel like that database lives in them and
not in you, like you need their ridiculous snort tastes and spit scores to tell you
what you're tasting.
You don't experience wine by snorting, tasting, and spitting.
Their mental databases are woefully incomplete.
What we're doing tonight is the opposite.
We're building your database together with your own glass in real time as these two wines
are brutally fighting it out to the end.
By the end of this video, you'll be tasting your wine at a higher level than you were
when you pushed play.
I promise you that.
Let's go!
Step one of a magical wine experience, let's start with sight.
I know you're thinking, John, I can see that one wine is red.
Hey, both of them are red.
What does that color tell me that matters?
More than you'd expect, and more importantly for tonight, the color of these two wines
is one of the most immediate, viable expressions of everything that makes them different.
So I've got some white paper here.
I'm going to get out my wow-stained sight sheet, and we are going to have a look at
both of these wines.
We are going to start with the Bordeaux first, then we're going to do the Brunello, and then
we're going to look at them both together.
This is the 2010 Bordeaux.
Let's look at it over our white paper.
Oh, that's a nice, dark, garnet ruby, well, more to a ruby concentration.
So that tells me definitely this was a warm vintage.
This is not a thin Bordeaux.
I can look at the edges and see there's a gradient.
It just looks like a gorgeous sunset to me, a deepening sunset.
I'd say we have about three rings of orange, so that's going to give us about 16 years
of age.
I can look at that.
You know, and see, I'd probably guess 20 just by looking at the rings.
But the point is, is that the oxidation, which is where the orange color comes from, that
tells you an approximate age of the wine.
So this is just a gorgeous looking wine.
I can roll it around the glass a bit, and I can get some staining on the sides, but
it's not like a very thick coating.
I mean, this looks like both a concentrated and elegant wine at the same time.
So let's have a look at the Brunello di Montalcino.
I just love sight, because you can tell so much from sight.
It's definitely a lighter wine.
You still get some gorgeous orange around there, although the gradient's not as much.
The rings are much, much thicker than the Bordeaux, but they have some similarities.
I mean, I could look at each one and tell which one is which, but there's a lot more
orange in this Brunello than I would expect from seven years of age.
It's just a gorgeous looking wine.
So you can see it in the glass here.
So let's have a look at these side by side and see what we get here.
Oh yeah, you can certainly tell that the Bordeaux is much more concentrated, much deeper than
the Brunello di Montalcino.
But this Brunello, if I was just looking at Brunello, this has some concentration in it.
I could tell that this was a nice warm vintage.
That's in some Brunellos that are water thin.
This one's not.
But interestingly, I would guess that it's older than it actually is just by looking
at the orange around it.
So let's have a dose of these and see what we get here.
All right, take a look at the wine in your glass right now.
Tilt it toward the light source.
Can you see it?
What color is the edge when it's thin?
Is it still purple, meaning a younger wine?
Is it moving toward orange like these two I just showed you with a little age on it?
Just tell me what you get in the comments.
I want to know what everyone's drinking tonight and how old it is, so tell me what your edge
looks like.
Okay, you just looked at your wine in a way most people never do, like we just looked
at the wines that I'm fighting out tonight.
That's a new entry in your mental database.
Now let's compare these two wines side by side and you'll see what I mean by learning
contrast.
Step two, the nose, or as the critics say, the bouquet, or as a snort-tasting spit rear
would say in his tuxedo while standing over a spit bucket.
There's no spit buckets here, as you can see, aromas of rose garden love, campfire coffee
on a cold night, a twist of donkey saddle, soggy compost from the backyard, and all kinds
of other weird things you can't possibly smell in a wine.
Come on, man.
The nose isn't magic.
It's just pattern recognition.
Look, your olfactory system compares what it detects to every scent your brain has stored
since the day you were born.
Blackcurrant, tobacco, whetstone, dried roses, those are all smells you've encountered in
your life.
The wine just assembles them into a particular combination and asks your brain to decode
it.
The bigger your scent library, the more you catch.
Your sense of smell remains fixed, but what grows is the processing power behind it, which
is why as I describe what I'm finding in these wines tonight, I want you to pull up your
own memories of these smells as I go through them.
Don't just hear the words.
Think of the actual smell.
That's what makes the connections stick.
So enough talking.
Let's do some nose, and we're not going to snort.
We're going to do this the right way, and we're starting with a 2010 Chateau Irons Margot.
Oh, gosh.
Immediately what I get, it's just I get a nice, soft, calming feeling.
I know it's going to be a good wine when my first response to a nose is emotional.
Now, what do I get?
I get blackberry.
I get blackcurrant.
So fruit's coming out here.
I certainly get some baking spices and vanilla from oak.
I don't get an aged wine smell, though, so let's have one more sip and see what these
tertiary flavors are.
Yeah, I get a little bit of a warm climate.
The fruit might be definitely ripe, maybe even overripe.
It was a great vintage, so I can smell the character of the wine.
There's a little bit of earth going behind it, a little bit of perhaps minerality.
I do like minerality.
It comes across as almost kind of a wet stone, if you ever had rain on concrete.
But this is just a gorgeous wine here.
But the one thing that I love is, and I know it's going to be a good wine, and this is
a point in this wine's favor in this wine fight, is when my first reaction is emotional,
not just aromas and flavors, I know it's going to be a good wine.
Let's do the Brunello di Montalcino.
Wow, that's an interesting one.
I always expect beautiful sour cherry on a Brunello, and certainly this is here.
But what I did get immediately, it was almost like a savory, almost meaty leather.
I was like, wow, that's really interesting.
It caught me by surprise and threw me for a loop.
Sometimes you'll have preconceived notions of what you should smell, and then the wine
says, oh, maybe I got something different for you.
So let's see what else is going on in here.
There's that sour cherry.
There's that licorice.
Now you can see the flavors are starting to rotate a little bit.
There's a little bit of leather coming out there, definitely some earth, maybe a little
bit of minerality in there as well.
But this is a very, very complex wine.
But I got to tell you, that sour cherry is certainly there, but that meatiness, oh, that
caught me off guard.
Boy, we got these two swinging at each other tonight.
All right, that's your turn here.
Take a slow sniff of your wines.
Start about an inch above the rim and breathe in slowly.
No snorting.
Tell me, is the fruit you're detecting, is it red or dark?
Getting any meatiness?
Is it light?
It's a tart, cherry, deeper, cassis.
What are you getting?
Is there any earthiness?
I get it in both wines.
Any flower note?
Even faint, not too much flowers, maybe a little bit of violet in the Bordeaux, but
that's about it.
Now, let's notice these two wines side by side.
I want you to do it with your two wines as well, because this is something that very
few people do, yet it's where you learn the most.
What we want to do is see if we detect any scents in either that we missed before.
So, you know what's a little bit interesting?
You usually don't get them in a Bordeaux.
I get a tiny little bit of meatiness in there, and that's not just a suggestion.
That's my brain looking for something that wasn't there.
I'm going to take one more sniff of this Brunello, because there was something in there I couldn't
quite describe.
Oh, it's like a stoniness, a rockiness to it.
So there's definitely minerality in this.
There's some in this, I would say, more like a rockiness to it than like a strict minerality.
But yeah, this is kind of triggering that and back and forth.
Maybe you get some hallucinations doing this, but I don't think so.
So what we're doing is we're using two reference points, Margaux and the Brunello, to triangulate
where this wine lives, and that's exactly how your mineral database is supposed to work.
So let me know if you pick up any new aromas you missed when you nose them individually.
Hey, quick pause.
If you're finding this useful, hit subscribe.
I'm a certified sommelier, and I put out entertaining wine education every week.
Brutal truths about wine, deep dives like this one, what I call the whole bottle review
experience, which is how wine is supposed to be evaluated.
And if you know what hypes are and how to use them, hey, throw a few my way.
Let's get this video in front of other wine lovers.
Look, we can nose these wines all day, especially that meatiness and sour cherry on the brunette.
Oh, I like that.
But we didn't come here to sniff wine.
We didn't come here to look at wine.
We came here to drink wine.
So let's drink and go to step three, the palate.
And this is where the whole bottle review methodology, which I invented, diverges completely
from every other wine evaluation framework you've ever encountered.
Because there's a brutal truth about the single sip evaluation.
You guys know this.
The first sip of any great wine is incomplete information, hopelessly incomplete.
Wine doesn't perform on demand.
It doesn't sit in a trade show glass under fluorescent lights and give you its best.
Great wine opens up slowly.
It changes in your mouth.
It changes in your glass.
It changes across the hours you spend working through a full bottle.
The traditional critic who snort, tastes, and spits is evaluating the introduction.
They're reviewing the handshake, not the long conversation.
We're going to have the full conversation in this wine fight.
So what I'm going to give you right now, after I taste these wines, is my initial sip and
swallow score.
It's my first impression read.
And then we're going to come back later with the whole bottle review when these wines have
had time to show us exactly who they are.
And what usually happens is you see how far off the initial sip and swallow score is from
the whole bottle experience.
So let me quickly explain this whole bottle methodology.
We use what us sommeliers call theory to choose a wine that has a high probability to deliver
what I call a magical wine experience.
The floor for me is 96 points, but this is not a linear scale.
Hey, I suffered through a degree in electrical engineering from UT Austin, graduating in
1994.
And one thing I remember was a logarithmic scale.
Sounds like geek speak, and it is, but it's very useful.
Most snort, taste, and spitters use a linear scale.
Each point weighted the same as the last, but in a log scale, each point is worth 10
times more than the previous one.
So 96 is just an entry point.
What we're looking for here is movement.
If I taste a wine, give it an initial 97 sip and swallow score, and it finishes there,
it's a dud.
If I give it an initial 96 score and it goes to 97, that's pretty good.
97.5, great.
98 and higher, a two point or more jump.
That's a magical wine experience, something you get two or three times a year, no matter
how good your theory is.
Enough talking.
Let's taste it and award the initial sip and swallow score.
And we're going to start with the 2020 Chateau Irenes Margot.
Oh gosh, again, that's, that gets, it leads with emotion.
It's a calming, relaxing, wonderful Bordeaux.
I'm actually getting a little iron coming out on this on the finish, which is kind of
neat.
Definitely a lot of plum going on in there.
Definitely some fresh tobacco still going on there.
Definitely some earth, a lot of fruit in here.
So we can go blackberry, cassis, black plum, the usual type stuff.
But to me, what we have here is a wonderful, warm vintage, cool night Bordeaux that has
a lot of promise.
And so my initial sip and swallow score for the Bordeaux, I'm going to give that a 97.
Usually I come in at 96, 96.5.
That's a really nice first sip.
So I'm going to go with a 97 for the Chateau Irenes Margot.
And by the way, like a proper Margot, oh, the nose and the palate just work well together.
All right, let's, next up the Brunello di Montalcino.
Let's have a taste of this one and see what we get.
Wow.
A little more tannic on what you would expect, a lot of great red fruits in there.
The similarities I get are the earthiness from both.
At first I was like, wait a second, is this a continuation of this one?
And then it went much more toward a Brunello di Montalcino, but oh, we get some wonderful
licorice, a little bit of that savory, not quite as much on the nose, but oh, we're getting
this wonderful licorice come through, which is definitely not in the Bordeaux.
So this one right here, oh gosh, I'm going to go with a 96.5.
The tannins were a little bit, I'm not going to say harsh, but a little bit scratchy, maybe.
We'll see what happens as I go through this bottle.
So this one, 15 years old, you're going to expect the first sip to be what you want it
to be.
This one's going to need a little time as you go through the bottle, 97, 96.5 for the
Brunello di Montalcino, but it's not about the initial sip and swallow score.
It's about the whole bottle review.
So now what we're going to do is we're going to taste both together, one right after the
other to see if any aromas, flavors, or sensations appeared that we didn't get when we tasted
individually.
Then we'll do step four, tying it all together, my Nostradamus wine prediction of where I
think these two wines may go based on two sniffs and two tastes.
That's pretty ridiculous, huh?
But hey, that's how all the snort tastes and spitters operate, but they ain't man enough
to stick around, drink the whole bottle, and see if the wine proves them wrong.
I am.
Let's taste, bang, bang, one, two.
Oh, both together, all about the fruit niche, baby.
We got some wonderful blackberry there, and that blackberry, oh, that just brings out
that beautiful sour cherry.
Oh, yeah, tasting one or the other, one fruit triggers the other fruit, second one, completely
different sips than the first one together.
They're just fantastic.
So I want to check in with you right quick.
Take a slow sip of your wine.
Don't rush it.
Hold it on your palate for five full seconds before you swallow.
What's the texture?
Is it silky and smooth, closer to the Margaux, or does it have some grip and structure, closer
to the Brunello di Montalcino?
Neither is better.
They're just different languages, and now you got both in your vocabulary, at least
I do.
Now, do it like I did.
Taste both one right after the other, back again, see if you notice any new flavors or
textures like I did.
Leave it in the comments, because when you write it down, that locks it into your mental
database.
All right, step four, tying it all together.
This is a step that separates the whole bottle review from a tasting note, because it's not
enough to describe what each wine is doing separately.
The real education, the real expansion of your mental database happens when you understand
why these two wines are different at a structural level.
It comes down to two things, the grape variety and the philosophy of time.
The 2010 Margaux is built on 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, supported by 27% Merlot and 3%
Petit Bordeaux.
Thick skin, high tannin, deep color.
Cabernet ages by transformation.
The tannin softens, much softer in this wine.
The primary fruit evolves in the secondary and tertiary complexity, and what the grape
was at harvest becomes something completely different over a decade.
At 15 years, this Margaux is less about the black currant it started with, and more about
the tobacco and leather it has become.
However, the fruit in this one is holding up really, really, really well.
Very impressive.
The transformation, and this is transformed from release, is the wine.
The 2019 Brunel is built on Sangiovese, thinner skin, naturally lighter in color.
Higher in acid, structurally different tannins.
Sangiovese doesn't age by transformation, it ages by deepening.
The red fruit stays red.
Tart, cherry, and pomegranate.
Yeah, I'd say we get a little pomegranate in there.
For decades.
The minerality builds.
Definitely some of that minerality in there, but it took me tasting the Bordeaux to kind
of bring it out a little bit more.
Oh, that fine Italian leather that definitely comes out.
I get a little leather in both of them.
French leather, Italian leather.
I don't know if there's French leather, but I know there's Italian leather.
That savory quality, which we get some, yeah, almost meaty.
Savory, almost meaty, and the finish becomes longer and more complex with every year.
That's what I love about Brunel.
This is a wine that at seven years has caught between its primary and secondary phases.
You can taste what it was and what it's becoming simultaneously, and that's actually a window
that collectors pay to experience.
I pay, and I'm looking forward to it.
So what does your palate actually learn tonight from experiencing these side by side?
Your brain is now storing, my brain is now storing two completely different tasting maps.
Mine is now reinforcing and storing these.
Map one, dark fruit, cedar, tobacco, well-integrated tannin.
It's an evolved Bordeaux.
Map two, red fruit, iron, definitely got some iron on that.
Dried herbs, savory, meaty, dry, chalky tannin, traditional Sangiovese from Montalcino.
The next time you encounter a wine that reminds you of either of these maps, even personally,
these maps activate from the wines you're drinking.
Your recognition is faster.
Your description is richer.
Your enjoyment is deeper.
Your experience is more vivid.
And here's the thing the traditional wine establishment will never tell you because
their entire business model depends on you not hearing it.
You don't need expensive wines to build this database.
You just need to drink two vastly different wines and think about the differences and
similarities.
The way we're doing it right now, hey, the Coravinia is your friend for this.
I'm not drinking both bottles tonight as much as I want to.
I'm going to do one tonight and one next week.
I need to be able to give you an honest whole bottle review of both in this wine fight.
Look, the ridiculous snort, taste, and spit critics have convinced generations of wine
drinkers that valuation is a skill reserved for professionals and they can do it in 30
seconds.
My ass.
That you need a certification, not my certification, a credential, a $100 a year wine subscription
to have a valid opinion about what's in your glass.
It's nonsense and you as well know as I do, it's self-serving nonsense.
Think about how patently ridiculous it is and you can evaluate an entire bottle where
each sip is different than the last by snorting and tasting a single sip of a wine.
You won't take another sip up.
What you need is exactly this, two contrasting wines, a framework to evaluate them, and the
willingness to just pay attention to what's going on in your brain and an understanding
that the wine experience that creates new emotions, that brings up old memories, that
takes you on an emotional journey only comes from drinking the whole box.
Hey, since you watched this far, I have a gift for you.
My Magical Wines Guide, a list of wines that have been magical for me and others, constantly
updated.
All you have to do to claim your copy is go to wholebottlereviews.com forward slash email.
The link is in the description and in a pinned comment.
Back to the show.
Before we go to my Nostradamus wine predictions, take another sip of your wine.
Not to analyze it, just to drink it, to appreciate it, and notice whether anything has shifted
in your experience of it since the beginning of this video.
If something has, if a note has clarified or come out, a texture has registered it differently,
that's not coincidence.
That's your mental database running and processing in real time.
Hey, let me know what you're getting in the comments.
Before I open and drink the whole bottle of this gorgeous Brunella, I'm going to do something
I genuinely love about the whole bottle review process.
I'm going to make my Nostradamus wine predictions.
Not vague, not hedged, not this wine might improve with the air.
We'll see.
Specific predictions, a real stake in the ground.
And then we go back and see if I got it right.
The prediction business is a tricky one, as you will see.
Sometimes I nail it, more often the wines nail me.
All right, my Nostradamus wine prediction for the 2020 Chateau Irenes Margot.
Oh, we got a 97 coming in.
I think that this can get up as high as a 98.
I mean, it's just an absolutely gorgeous, such a fantastic vintage.
So much going on in there.
So if we start out at a higher elevation and then we move up a point from a 97 entry point
to a 98, that's going to be a magical wine experience.
I think this one could get up to this far.
Oh, the Nostradamus wine prediction for the Brunello de Montalcino.
This one's a little bit trickier.
I love Brunellos, but you know what?
There's so much going on in this one.
This is such a small artisanal producer that meatiness really just led right out of the
gate.
Although I started with a 96.5, I'm thinking this one could reach 98 too.
Both of these could deliver a true magical wine experience.
And I get 97s and 97.5s, but for wines to make it to 98 or 99, that's really rare.
So I've got high hopes for both of these wines just based on what they showed me.
But as they say, that's why we play the game.
All right.
That's those predictions said.
We're going to come back to them.
And while you're sitting there with that second glass, and I hope you're pouring your second
glass of wine right now, take a moment to notice.
Has anything else shifted since your first sip?
Because most of the wines do change with air.
Even simple wines open up.
Even wines you've had a hundred times show you something new, if you're paying this kind
of attention.
That noticing is your menthol database at work.
So stay tuned for my whole bottle review of both the Brunello di Montalcino and the Bordeaux,
plus the winner of this wine fight.
My whole bottle review score coming up right now.
I have returned, fully recovered from my wine hangover, and ready to give you my final whole
bottle review of both the 2010 Chateau d'Irens from Margaux in Bordeaux, France, Thomas Jefferson's
favorite wine region, and the Salvione 2019 Brunello di Montalcino from Tuscany in Italy.
And oh, what a great wine fight this was.
We definitely have a clear winner in this one.
Although both, of course, were magnificent.
So we're going to get right into it.
As you can see, both bottles have been fully consumed and are ready for review.
And I was very happy to consume them.
So let's get right into it.
We are going to go to Margaux and start with the 2010 Chateau d'Irens.
I gave that a 97 initial sip and swallow score.
And as I got into it, the goodness only continued.
So what I really liked about this one, and as you can see, as always, I have taken some
notes here.
What I really liked about this one was it had a very, very slow evolution.
So we already had 16 years in the bottle.
So I didn't expect an enormous amount of evolution from this wine because it had already evolved
to the point where the start of it is going to be like the midpoint for, say, a six or
seven-year-old bottle.
And so the first glass was really quite like the first sip.
It was dry.
It had that wonderful Bordeaux dryness to it.
It had some great fruit, blackberry, black plum, like you would expect.
The tannins were very well integrated.
Smooth mouthfeel.
And, you know, of course, you can name the Bordeaux tasting notes.
It's like a point by now, graphite, cedar, cigar box, a little bit of earth in there.
And it was just a great, wonderful, classic, smooth Bordeaux.
And it stayed that way pretty much through glass one.
As we got into glass two, it was a very, very slow evolution, almost, I would say, glacial
type.
But the one thing that I did notice that I liked was the fruit slowly started to come
out.
In the beginning, everything was pretty much in harmony and did not get out of harmony
because it was a nice warm vintage.
The fruit really kind of rose to the top and everything supported it.
So we got some nice graphite supporting it.
Definitely got some pretty good earth in this one.
Wasn't as aromatic as most Margots, but still had quite a nice aroma.
The oak was there, certainly not overpowering in any way, shape, or form.
And it was just a gorgeous expression of Margot.
But as I said, the wine was already pretty much evolved to where it was.
And one of the things that I did like as I got into glass two, I just kind of got this
nice, peaceful, mellow, easy feeling that I'm in a really happy place and I'm drinking
a great Bordeaux from Margot.
Now, the thing about glass three and actually four and glass five was the evolution really
stopped after glass two.
I didn't really expect it to go further.
This is not a first growth.
It's not even a classified growth.
It's a great value Bordeaux.
But it really, after the end of glass two, it really kind of hit its stride and it stayed
there.
We got the great fruit.
I would say a tiny little bit of evolution.
No more emotional components to it.
I just felt great because I was drinking a Bordeaux.
And pretty much what was in glass two was in glass three, glass four, glass five.
A little bit of lengthening on the fruit and heightening, but not too much.
It kind of started where it was and it finished pretty close to where it was.
I actually didn't have an issue with that at all.
So I'm going to go ahead and grade this wine a 97.
I didn't get enough evolution there to really move it.
Certainly not going to downgrade this one.
It was absolutely fantastic value, but slow evolution, not too much emotion in it.
And this wasn't, like I said, a first growth.
So because there really wasn't that much emotion in it and there wasn't that much evolution,
we're going to go with a 97 on this one.
So let us go to the Savioni Brunello di Montalcino, which I graded 96.5 to start with.
Oh, what a bottle this was.
Because the one thing that I really liked about this from the very beginning was it
literally had a meatiness to it.
Not quite cured meats.
It was almost like smoked meats or something.
It didn't predominate the wine.
It was behind the fruit, but it was a really unique characteristic.
And I'm going to give you a little foreshadowing.
We got significant evolution in this wine.
So it started out, it was tannic.
Definitely a little bit rough, which is why I graded it at 96.5 to start with.
It was a little bit rough.
My suspicion was it would soften as we went through the bottle.
And I was right.
It was meaty.
But we had that wonderful sour cherry.
We had an earthiness.
There was almost a flavor that I call sunset to it.
It's a little bit hard to describe, but it looks like a sunset in the glass.
And that begins to what you come across in the nose.
It comes across in the palate.
That kind of radiates throughout the whole wine.
It's a really unique thing to describe.
Of course, we've got some earth in there, a little bit of leather, a little bit of
licorice.
But for me, this wine wasn't so much about the flavors and aromas.
It was how it made me feel.
Immediately as I started drinking this, I felt alive.
There was a vibrance to this wine that began to grow as I went through the bottle.
And so as we got into glass two, what was really interesting, all the flavors really
kind of started out disparate.
When I got into glass two, what was neat was how they began to rank themselves.
And so it was like a layer.
It was like a stratification.
Of course, sour cherry was on top.
Then we had that meatiness underneath.
Then we had leather.
Then we had earth.
Then we had licorice.
And so it was literally like if you were looking at a geographic diagram of sediment, you would
see the sour cherry up here.
Then you get the meatiness.
Then you get leather.
Then you get earth.
Then you get licorice.
And what was really neat is I got into glass two, it layered out like that.
But then each of those layers began to kind of lengthen and heighten.
And so you got more of them.
It was just a remarkable experience as I went through the bottle.
But as great as that was, as we started getting into the end of glass three and glass four,
was I really started to focus on how vibrant this wine felt, how alive, how exuberant it
made me feel.
And there was an acceleration to that feeling.
And so that by the time that I got to the end of glass four, I'd put all the wonderful
flavors and aromas to the background.
And I was just focused on that wonderful feeling.
Like I thought that tannins had resolved and integrated very well.
And quite frankly, any structure, any non-fruit indicators, any oak influence, any of that
stuff.
By the time I got to the end of glass four, I wasn't thinking about that.
I was just focusing on this wonderful, alive wine that was telling me the story of Tuscany,
of where it came from.
And that accelerated and intensified as we got to the end of glass five.
And so the whole thing was just a wonderful, beautiful, rapid evolution that had an emotional
component to it as we went all the way to glass five.
This was just an absolutely gorgeous wine.
One of the best Brunellas I've ever drank.
Definitely going to drink some more of these.
I'd love to drink the 2016.
I'd love to drink an aged one of those.
Salvione, small producer.
But oh my God, was this fantastic.
So I am going to go ahead and award the final whole bottle score of 98 to the 2019 Salvione
Brunello di Montalcino.
A full, well-deserved point and a half increase from where we started at 96.5.
This was a magical wine experience for me.
And so for in this wine fight, the Brunello di Montalcino wins handily.
Although quite frankly, I was the one who really won because I got to drink both of
these bottles.
Now what's better than one whole bottle of your wine fight?
Another one.
Stay tuned for my latest video coming up right now.
