France vs. Byzantines (Online Battle #71)

Historical Identity
26 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 6, 2026
Taking you through a battle blow-by-blow and explaining tactics. In this fight I feint left, hook right, and land a massive charge up the center. Hope this helps illuminate certain effective strategies you can employ yourself!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedOakley demonstrates a strategic victory as France against the Byzantine Empire in Medieval 2. By prioritizing positioning and local superiority over raw unit numbers, he overcomes a disadvantage in cavalry and skirmishers. The victory is achieved through a combination of layered defenses, \"meat shield\" tactics, and a decisive flank collapse.
Hey what's up guys, it's Oakley and we're back playing Medieval 2.
I can't tell you how much I love this game, just the time period, the way the units stack
up, the way cavalry is all but too crucial, and just the synergy you need to have with
all your units, I'm really really digging it.
So hopefully I can see you guys online, I've already had the pleasure of playing with a
couple of you online.
So I'm going to be playing as France, let's go ahead and put this on maybe, might as well
put it on pause.
Anyways going over the army, so in the front I've put mounted sergeants followed up by
peasant crossbowmen.
The thinking behind this is I like having really cheap cavalry guys and they'd make
a good screen for your own missile units because they can, basically if you have a missile
on missile fight, these guys can kind of dart around the sides, force your opponent back,
all the while you have these guys taking potshots at the enemy.
If he decides to charge with cavalry, you can intercept with these cheap mounted sergeants,
keep getting shots off and that'll buy you time to allow your own cavalry to react.
So this is a good way to guard your own peasants, maybe even better than having spearmen, although
don't have spearmen too far.
So I have two sergeant spearmen positioned around the flanks, in the center I have religious
fanatics.
These guys are cool units, pretty high attack, I'm not sure what weapon they're using but
very high attack, pretty good morale but really low armor so they're kind of like meat shields
but very good on the charge, almost like the fox units that you have in Rome 2 and they
kind of function like Nodachi in Shogun 2 where they have nice attack stats but not
very good at sustained melee.
And then behind them I have three of these armored sergeants so I brought actually a
lot of heavy spearmen because I knew my opponent was using Byzantine Empire which is notorious
for cataphract so we'll go over that shortly, actually let's put it on play.
And then in the back I have two dismounted feudal knights so two swordsmen and then three
on this right flank so I'm tending to think I'm going to edge a bit more on this side
with my swordsmen and in the back I'm keeping my cavalry at a distance.
Let's go ahead and look at my opponent and then I'll tell you how my train of thought
usually goes in these battles.
So in the front he has four of these archers, in the back he has a combination of Byzantine
spearmen and a Varangian guard and behind those three more Byzantine spearmen and then
he's sending his cataphract away, these are basically, the Byzantine Empire is obviously
the sort of the, how do we put this, I guess the successor of the Roman Empire when it
split east-west, these guys adopted the more eastern approach to cavalry, you started seeing
a lot more use of the heavy cataphract type units, becoming very standard in the Byzantine
army so these guys are very formidable, high attack, charge, armor, everything, they can
really deal death to your infantry, especially your cav.
So he has an advantage in cavalry, he also has an advantage in skirmishing potential,
look what he's doing right here, he's going to bolster his cavalry ranks with spearmen
on both flanks so he knows that this is going to allow him to gain the upper hand and then
over here he has his own scouting cavalry units, instead of using sort of my light cav
unit that I had positioned in the front, he's going to be using a light cav unit that is
actually a missile unit.
So let's go ahead and pause this so I can explain to you my thinking on this.
So I know he has, as I put it, a cavalry advantage and a skirmisher advantage, so when it comes
to cavalry advantages, the best way to counter cavalry is try and get him to waste his charge,
so that's where these light cavalry come into hand, I can charge into his guys, rob him
of his charge, and then strike from the back with my other cavalry, and then also having
some spearmen, so that's what I'm doing on this flank, pushing forward with two spearmen
and one crossbowman, and then some cavalry backed up by these dismounted feudal knights.
The crossbowmen are positioned in this group to take some potshots at his men, even though
he has a skirmisher advantage, they're all concentrated in the center, so I'm going to
go ahead and strike where he doesn't have any archer units, so that's going to be sort
of giving myself skirmishing advantage by positioning my troops where I can have that
advantage.
So just because your opponent has it on paper, it's really all about where you deploy them,
so to counter his cavalry and spearmen, I'm going to put my own cavalry, spearmen, and
archers, so because I have a better mix, I can take on that wing, and on the left, I
see he has a pretty good balance of cataphractoid, skirmisher cav, and then spearmen, so to counteract
that I'm going to have feudal knights, but I'm not going to be deciding to attack, what
I'm going to do instead is just position these guys on the defensive, hold on we're getting
a little bit of some problems with this, okay, it's a little stuttery after the last patch
of Medieval 2, but my thinking is I'm going to try and push out my cav here, and when
you don't have a cavalry advantage, keep in mind you don't actually have to charge,
force your opponent to come in, and by doing so you can force him, usually through the
use of some skirmishers, so for instance my crossbowman here, getting some shots off against
his skirmisher cav, and my sergeant spearmen, who are just here for cannon fodder, are going
to soak up the fire, and just by being able to take out his skirmishers, I'm then going
to be able to put some pressure on his own cataphractoid, I'm also using my cavalry here
to try and bait his other cav to move in, I'm preemptively sending forward my skirmishers
over on this flank, I anticipate a response from his cataphractoid, there we go, he's
coming in, but I have skirmishers in the vicinity, just to ward those guys off, meanwhile, these
guys are going to get some shots off right at his cataphractoid, so at all points in
time I'm going to try and do as much damage to those guys as possible, I also moved in
more of these feudal knights to guard these peasant crossbowmen, I knew the spearmen had
to be over here to guard my cav, this weakened these guys, so I have to support them in some
manner. Now, my opponent is getting away from his core, I know that's going to be his vulnerability,
his army functions best when it's working together, cavalry superiority holding down
the flanks, skirmishers basically just taking a toll on my guys, what he should be doing
is moving this big line forward, forcing my guys to either deal with the death dealt from
his skirmishers or fall back, if I fall back, then he can just keep pushing me into a corner
and pushing forward slowly with his cavalry wing, I can't really engage this, just because
if he had the support of his archers, he could do lots of damage to my cav and also send
forward some of these additional spear guys and whatnot, so what he should be moving is
with all his guys together, from my point of view, I know that he's not, and so I have
to exploit that, the way I'm going to do that is sort of force an engagement on this flank,
I move my crossbowmen up pretty close, I got some early volleys off, you can see I killed
a decent amount of his cataphract, these crossbowmen have really good armor penetration, he's going
to decide to counter charge my guys, but again, because I'm using these light cav, that's
fine, he can waste an entire charge from cataphract toy into these light cav, they'll hold up
for a while, they won't win, but they'll hold his guys up, meanwhile he's splitting apart
his spearmen, they're going to try and hold this up and he's going to try and swing around
with his cataphract toy on this side, but I have my own spearmen and I have more reinforcement
units, I anticipated this assault, so I sent more reinforcements on this side, so look
at how I'm sending my guys, sergeant spearmen to even up this fight, then more armored sergeants
to intercept these byzantine spearmen, and then also some dismounted feudal knights who
I'm going to be sending into the fight to eliminate these guys, so he's really getting
too separated and I'm using sort of integral use of all my forces to counteract his moves
here. Now, as I said, I'm going to counter this appropriately with first my sergeant
spearmen who are going to be moving out, they're going to intercept his cataphract toy, he'll
get some initial damage off, but spearmen in the long run will be able to take out his
guys, and then armored sergeants moving in to finish off the kill, that is because they
can defeat spearmen and also cavalry at close range, and over here I feel like I can take
this on pretty well. Now take a look at what's happening next, my opponent realizes that
there's engagements on both sides and I can just pour in the support, so he's going to
decide to move up, on this flank he's going to be doing the same thing as well, because
I've been able to take out just clumps of his guys at a distance with crossbowmen, he's
going to decide to do something about that, so he's pushing forward, but this is where
I've massed all of my cavalry, so again, it's all about positioning and having local superiority.
In the center, take a look at what I do, because he's on the move, his archers aren't positioned
to fire, that's exactly when you want to charge, so I realize both his wings are tied up, that
wing is about to be engaged, so I charge forward with all my guys, take a look at how I position
my men as well, in the front, the first guys who, if my opponent decides to get shots off,
the first guys who are going to take the fire are going to be these religious fanatics,
very lightly cheap armed, cheap guys, who, they'll be my meat shields, they'll soak up
all the fire, and if they get through, that's good, you know they have high attack, so they
do a pretty good amount of damage to the front ranks, then I'm sending in a huge cluster
of these dismounted feudal knights, all together in a compact, almost right hook, a fist of
like steel and mail and just heavy armor, pouring into this right flank, that's where
I'm going to try and collapse it, and I'm going to leave all of his left flank pretty
much unengaged, until I can win this battle, so that's again using local superiority, breaking
through with superiority on this flank, and then reinforcing with a heavy right hook,
landing it on that edge, and then behind my fanatics who anticipate losing, I don't want
him to be able to just, you know, flow through that gap and attack either of my flanks, that's
why I have some armored sergeants to plug that gap, over on the left, he's grown weary
of my crossbowmen taking the action to him, so he's going to charge forward with his spearmen
to try and hold me back, that's not a good move on his part, he should be keeping them
together with his cav, mostly because if those guys aren't engaged with my spearmen,
that's fine, they kind of cancel each other out, I can quickly land a strike with these
feudal knights, take out his spearmen, and then three of my cavalry can easily take out
two of his cav, so we'll see just how that turns out, what I decide to do is, look at
this, send actually, I know he's, let's explain this thinking, so I know he's targeting my
spearmen, so what I decide to do is redirect them over to this cavalry fight, charge in
with my feudal knight here, and then send in, so spearmen and feudal knights will take
out his cataphracts, and instead of sending all my cavalry here, what I decide to do is
just double envelop this spearmen unit, because he's targeted here, he's not going to be ready
for this charge, and because I get this double assault from my cavalry, it's going to quickly
break these guys, so without maybe one or two losses here or there, I'm able to break
an entire spearmen unit, and just because of the efficacy of that move, now my cavalry
are free to not only kill that unit, but now sweep around and finish off his cav, who are
otherwise engaged with spearmen and feudal knights, so that's probably a more efficient
way than keeping my spearmen here, that engagement wouldn't have lasted a while, and my cavalry
would have been tied up for too long, this is a much better way to clean up this fight,
and it frees up way more of my troops, I even have my general's bodyguard, who can go and
chase off his cav, these guys as I said are going to pour in and just take out his units
one at a time, this last unit is sort of left to fend on its own, if I were him, I would
try and pull him back, or at least draw away as many guys from the fight as possible, you
can see because his troops were still in the move, basically his archers are only just
now getting their shots off, he got a couple volleys concentrated on these forces, but
that's fine, they're still going to pour through, his ranging guard, these really high guys
were really wanting to tear into heavy infantry, they're going to be tearing into some light
infantry, so it's going to be sort of like a hot knife through butter, but it's going
to be wasting all its power on these meat fodder units, over here his dismounted byzantine
lancers won't hold up to these specific feudal knights who now have really numbers on their
side, so I'll be able to crash through this wing, combine that with the fact that I deployed
enough reserves here to really clean up this flank, and that's going to allow me to not
only win this fight just because superiority, but also swing around and help with the envelopment,
also keep in mind, look at this, look at the movement I'm doing with my troops, I realize
I didn't have to engage all of them, just enough to hold, this other dismounted knight
is going to wait back here for the time being to see if there's any breakthroughs, the other
one is looping around and he's going to help with the engagement around the flank, so cavalry
are helping to, or they're going to soon help to take these guys out, byzantine spearmen
here who would have held up my cavalry are going to be engaged with my swordsmen so that's
ideal for me, in the center, look at this, he's quickly going to chop through my men,
but we're doing a decent amount of damage, this is exactly what he's doing which is good,
which is sending these generals bardyguard around the flank, and he's going to try and
hammer and anvil his way, break free of what I've done here which is holding up his center,
and try and relieve those forces, however because of the advantage I was able to get
on this wing, I chased him off with just one feudal knight and one sergeant spearman
against his cataphractoid, and the rest of my cavalry are returning to the fight, and
you'll see what I do, I engage some of these byzantine spearmen, try and hammer and anvil
them, let me just fix this frame rate a little bit, so let's go fast forward, slow, fast
forward, pause, sorry it's freaking out a little bit, I'm getting some really low frame
rate, but anyways let's go ahead and analyze this while we can, but here where he would
have had his cavalry charging into the back, look at this, my cavalry who came back to
save the day essentially stopped him from doing so, what would have been a continuous
hammer and anvil up the rear of this already really wavering front, I was able to intercept
them with my cav and prevent that from happening, over on this flank I took my dismounted feudal
knights and just kept swinging them around the flank, and it's causing an all out collapse
on all fronts, so I think this strategy that I employed worked pretty well, my opponent
had the advantage in the skirmisher department and cavalry department, but he squandered
it, I was able to use local superiority to my advantage, so I hope this tactic helps
you out, now if you're wondering how my opponent could have fought better or how you could
probably beat someone who's trying to employ the style that I am, what I would say is if
and just use that as a wedge that he drives forward, he had a good line of spearmen in
the front, so he should have just kept pressing the advantage, engaging with me with his skirmishers,
and kept his cavalry by his side, he should have just kept them kind of stationary, this
cataphractor would have been huge bodyguards for the flanks of his army, they should have
swatted away any attempts at my cavalry from charging around the sides, and then by having
this long line of spearmen in the front, as well as these heavy Varangian guard, he
could have chopped through any of my forces coming through the center, as well as the
fact that if he deployed his archers in a staggered position, maybe two out in front
of his lines, and then two behind his lines, he could have kept a continuous wall of fire
on my guys, peppered my cavalry, peppered my crossbowmen, really negated all my armor
and specifically targeted my troops, he should have held out, and on the flanks he should
have attacked my own French nobility, who tried to go around the flanks with his cataphractor,
supported with skirmishers, and I think he would have cracked my center, and then on
the flanks he would have fought it to a standstill, cataphractor probably would have won in the
end, and then he could have done what I'm doing right here, which is land some nice
hammer and anvils on my cluster of troops that would have been in the center, but what
happened is he decided to attack piecemeal, and I took that to my advantage, and really
ended up, as you can see here, wrecking his men, and these cavalry charges into the back
of infantry are what's going to win you the day, and not cavalry against cavalry, it's
cavalry striking the rear of infantry that's really going to do the most damage, so you
want to kind of position yourself the whole battle to be able to land those types of strikes,
and then there we go, I finally take out the enemy general, and soon my opponent is going
to start to, you know, I think he realized he's dead, but he's going to keep up the fight
for a little bit before admitting defeat, crossbowmen are also a very good investment,
they have good armor penetration, and as you saw, let's try and take a look at some
of these clumps, I think these guys were targeted by my crossbowmen, so I can take out these
heavy heavy cavalry from a distance, and that's really how you want to use your crossbowmen,
make sure you use them on specific targets, high value targets, and really force your
opponent to either, you know, take this fire, or retreat, so that's where my opponent should
have probably countered my crossbowmen, with a couple of his excessive archer units, who
had really good range, but anyways, that's going to be it for the battle, I hope you
guys enjoyed, I hope you get a sense of the thinking that goes on on my part, how you
could employ it, or if someone's using my strategy, how you could try and counter it.
Anyways, that's going to be it for this battle, hope to see you guys next time, thanks so
much.
