The Failed Megacity of New England
Aug 6, 2026
If you look at the geography of the northeast coast, Portland, Maine should be closer in
size to Boston. It has one of the deepest, most protected natural harbors in the entire world,
and it's physically closer to Europe than any other U.S. city. And in the 1850s,
Portland used this exact geography to pull off the ultimate coup d'etat against its rival Boston.
They realized that Canada's main economic artery, the St. Lawrence River,
froze for nearly half the year. So Portland built a massive railway directly to the heart of
Montreal, Canada, becoming the winter port for all of British Canada. And in doing so,
they were basically printing money. But if that's the case, then why does Portland only have 68,000
people living in it today? Well, to answer that question, we gotta first head across the bay
so we can see Portland from the other side. We have made it to our first stop of the day.
It is bright and early. I still need some coffee. But we have made it to Bug Light Park
here in, oh, Portland. Which is not the primary Portland, but it is still
the main Portland. Or at least it's a main Portland. Get it? Because the state's main
Portland. Yeah, yeah. So we're just about at this little lighthouse thing. I don't have any
information on it. Don't know really if it serves a purpose anymore or if it's just like a nice
little area to be. But it's a nice little landmark for us to come out and, you know, film. Yeah.
The answer to why Portland never exploded in population, which, by the way, is the city right
behind me, really does start with the ground that it's built on. You see, Portland's actually a
peninsula that juts out into Casco Bay. And while that peninsula creates an incredibly deep,
ice-free natural harbor that gave it a huge geographic advantage, it also created a massive
physical constraint. In fact, the historic core of the city, the city that's still on the peninsula
today, is barely three miles long and only about a mile wide. Of course, today the city has expanded
geographically onto the mainland, but the city of Portland itself is still relatively tiny. This
leaves the city proper with only about 68,000 people total. Now, I know what you guys are going
to say. That number is a little bit of a lie. Because if you zoom out to the greater metropolitan
area of Portland, there's about 550,000 people. But that's still relatively minuscule. To put that
number into perspective, you only have to look about 100 miles south to the city of Boston.
That's a city with 650,000 people in the city and 4.9 million in the metro area. And Boston
is the key to this entire story. Because from a purely maritime perspective, Portland actually
has the superior harbor. It's closer to Europe, it's very deep, and it's almost completely protected
by other islands. But Boston had three massive advantages. A multi-decade head start and
settlement, a much better connection to the interior of the continent, and a physical geography that was
quite frankly much easier to manage. But before we head to any of that, we actually want to head
back over to Portland proper. So let's get back into the car because it is actively raining right
and I'm tired of being wet. It is really raining and you can't see it anymore, but somewhere in
this area is a thing called Fort Gorges. Basically it was built in the 1860s, finished up in like 1865,
and it was a military fort. But by the time they finished it, military technology had advanced so
much that it became kind of useless. And with a lack of funding, they just never updated it. So
I think in the 1960s, 100 years later, the city of Portland took it over and now it is
a national historic place. Super cool. We wanted to go out there, but clearly with this weather,
we're not going to make it. All right, quick correction. Jeff is wrong. What what did I do?
We are still in South Portland and actually only like a few minutes away from where we just were.
So just a little behind the scenes stuff. We sort of fill out different parts of like our,
call it our run of show. I don't always know where the next location is. I just assumed.
But bonus, it's not raining anymore. But I do think we hit a dead end.
Oh, and just to illustrate what I was talking about earlier, the islands that are protecting
this bay, you can kind of see them out here, right? So it's like there's this big island,
there's that little island over there. You can sort of see how it's just sort of funnels right
out to the ocean over here. But it really does protect this harbor from, you know, storms and
swells and everything that would be very damaging to ships and ports, which is why ports aren't
usually just sitting out right there on the coast to the open ocean. We love a natural harbor.
After exploring all of northern Maine in our last video, we know that Maine is a really old state
with a whole bunch of history. And while today we are mostly focusing on the 1800s to present day,
there is a lot of history that predates that, that helps set the context to better understand
why Portland never became the big city of New England. Before Portland became Portland,
it was known as Mashagon, which meant great neck in Algonquin. The Eastern Abenaki tribe were the
original peoples that lived in this area before the Europeans began taking over the land in the
1500s. With the injection of European settlers, unfortunately, many of the indigenous people died
due to disease, warfare, or they were just relocated from this land. It's raining, so we
might need to take a quick pause before I pass it off to Jeff to finish out this historical section.
We made it to the car, got a little wet again. I'm very damp. It wasn't supposed to rain today.
Not like this. A few minutes later. Quick update, it is still raining really hard, so I think what
we're going to do is we're going to head back over to Portland proper and wait out the storm a little
bit and then, I don't know, keep recording on that side. But unfortunately, that means we're not going
to see more of the fort that we were over here to see. That's a little too rainy. It's just too
rainy. All right, we're gonna do that. Figuring out why a city like Portland never expanded into
a massive metropolis is like uncovering a hidden piece of history. Speaking of uncovering mysteries,
a huge thank you to June's Journey for sponsoring today's video. June's Journey is an immersive
hidden object game that drops you right into the glamorous 1920s to solve a gripping murder mystery.
You step into the shoes of June Parker, a sharp amateur detective, as she unravels the secrets
behind her sister's murder and uncovers long buried family mysteries. After our busy travels,
I really enjoy coming home and relaxing, but instead of scrolling endlessly on social media,
I like to do something that will entertain me while also challenging me. That's why June's
Journey is so fun. The hidden object scenes actively challenge your observation skills
to reveal clues and drive the story forward. It's like a visual puzzle that keeps your brain
engaged. June's Journey has a lot of features you can try, but what I personally love is that you
also get to travel and explore different parts of the world with June and unlock special stories
in each place she visits. It's similar to what we do in our videos and is the perfect way for
us to feel like we're still exploring the world from the comfort of our own home. June's Journey
is available on iOS and Android smartphones and tablets, as well as on PC. Please download from
the link in the description or by scanning my QR code right here on the screen. Now, let's get back
to Portland. All right, the rain has subsided a little bit. Unfortunately, it also means that we
are back over here in the primary Portland, Portland, Maine, and that means we also had to
leave Fort Preble, so the historical context and backdrop kind of get lost a little bit, but
use your imagination. So after the first permanent European settlement was established here,
the Massachusetts Bay Colony would take it over in 1658, and over the next 100 years or so, there
were consistent battles that would destroy any sort of settlement or village that was established
here. This all came to a head on October 18, 1775, during the American Revolution, when the
quote-unquote burning of Falmouth, the name given to this area by the Massachusetts Bay Colony,
destroyed nearly 75% of the town. After that, the town did rebuild, and instead of keeping that
Falmouth name, they renamed themselves Portland. But this would also mean that Portland and Maine
would still remain under the Massachusetts Colony until 1820, when Maine would become its own state
and Portland would become the capital of the new state. But the long-term impact of being under the
Massachusetts Bay Colony left its mark. For one, it was during this time that Boston was really
starting to grow and expand into a major city, and Portland, then being just a part of Massachusetts,
was kind of just a satellite city that didn't get very many resources and certainly not the same
kind of prominence within the state of Massachusetts. And so it wasn't until Maine became its own state
that Portland even had a chance at becoming a major city. And of course, that's another story which
we're going to get to in a little bit. But first, we are heading straight into the heart of Portland,
technically to the old port of Portland. By the way, as we are winding our way through Portland,
if you're enjoying this video and you want more information about Portland, go over to
TheBite.co, where we have two really fun things for you. One, an article about how Portland,
Oregon, and Portland, Maine compare and contrast. And two, of course, Alexa, from Geography Trivia,
Portland, Oregon, Portland, Maine edition. It's going to be a real fun time. We'll see you guys
there. Just in case anybody was wondering, this is still very much a working wharf. I mean,
there's still definitely lobster fishermen, anglers here doing their lobster things.
And it smells like it. And it smells like it. Yeah.
Obviously, we're here telling you guys a story about Portland, Maine, but there's also
two things on my list that I want to experience while I'm here. Alexa, what do you think those
things are? Okay. One has to be a lobster roll. Ding! It is a lobster roll. Gotta have one. New
England, Maine, lobsters. Come on. The second one? My guess is like going to a Portland brewery.
Exactly. I would love to go to a Portland brewery and specifically to find a New England pale ale,
which is sort of like a specialty here. So those are the two things that we're on the hunt for
as we show you guys all around Portland. I will say my hair is not made for this New
England humidity. It is growing. It's the humidity! But we're not here to talk about my hair. We're
here to talk more about Portland. Portland did something really interesting in the mid-1800s
that at the time seemed like a pretty good idea. You see, Portland's harbor was completely
ice-free during the winter. And given that it was about 200 miles southeast of Montreal,
a major British-Canadian industrial center, it made for the perfect port for most of eastern
Canada. And so Portland kind of had a monopoly on Canadian shipping, with Canada building a
rail extension all the way down to Portland. But there was kind of a problem with that,
and I'm going to pass it to Jeff to explain more. All right. We have made it to the site
where all of those Canadian trains would have come down and unloaded all of their goods to then be
shipped off to the rest of the world. But here's the thing. Canada Railway at the time used something
called broad gauge, which was different from, well, down in Boston where they used standard
gauge. And this means that the tracks that connected to Portland from Canada were physically
wider than the tracks that went down to Boston. Now, I get it. This might seem like a little bit
of logistical minutiae, but at the time it was actually a really big deal. Freight arriving in
Portland from Canada on that Canadian broad gauge, right down here, had to then be unloaded by hand
and then reloaded onto U.S. standard gauge trains just so that they could leave the state of Maine,
which created a huge bottleneck for shipping. That is so silly. But again, this was all known,
and it was a bet that Portland was making in order to corner the Canadian market.
By looking north to Canada and using their infrastructure, they didn't have to compete with
an already booming and growing Boston. And so for a time, everything was actually looking pretty good
for Portland, right up to the point when it all went up in flames. But to get to that, we're gonna
head back to the old port. Unfortunately, there are no more tracks here, which means at some point
they did get ripped out, and this building was probably used for something else. It has since
fallen into disrepair, obviously. But there is another train that runs along the waterfront here,
but if you look closely, the rail is very narrow. One Alexa-sized...
Yeah, actually. I fit perfect in here.
So they are definitely not the original train tracks, and those definitely do not ship freight.
They just move humans around the waterfront. All right, so I got my lobster roll. First bite.
It's okay. Okay. This was very expensive. I paid $42. I did it for you guys. Don't blame me just
because your ideas are bad. Probably one and done for me. I can't afford it anymore. Yeah, this economy?
All around me, you'll see a bunch of beautiful brick buildings, and there is a very good reason
why there are so many in this downtown core area. By 1866, Portland was becoming a booming city.
Industry was growing, and the waterfront was filled with wooden massive warehouses filled
with things like Canadian grain, molasses, and lumber. But beyond industry, Portland was also
becoming a cultural and literary hub with literary artists like Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and John
Neal. With so much to celebrate and so much going on in Portland, they decided to throw a massive
Fourth of July celebration. Now, here's the thing. The summer of 1866 was a dry one. It was hot, and
there were gale force winds blowing straight off the harbor into the town. Despite these conditions,
fireworks were used, and unfortunately, some of that, like, firework stuff? Sparks! There we go.
Sparks landed in a wooden boatyard. That doesn't sound good. A fire ignited, the wind caught it,
and just like that, the city was up in flames. In a single day, the fire tore diagonally across the
city, all the way from Commercial Street through Maple Street. The destruction was devastating.
It wiped out 1,500 buildings, left 10,000 people homeless, and destroyed their commercial center.
I'm talking their brand new city hall, their customs house, their post office, several churches,
and a whole lot of homes were destroyed instantly. Like many other fires that happened during this
time in the United States, there was a surge of resources and support to help with rebuilding.
In the aftermath, Portland updated their city codes, which is why we have brick buildings like this,
and they completely rebuilt their city from scratch. This could have been an opportunity
for Portland to regrow past just the small port town that it was before the fire. But while there
were great strides in rebuilding the city, it wasn't quite enough to launch Portland from
small town to large, populous, booming city that it could have been. Now, this all happened in the
mid-1800s, and we're in 2026. There was a whole lot of time for Portland to become the next big city,
so why didn't it? We'll get to that, because we have to. That's the video.
So here's what I'll say. That's the city hall here for Portland Main, which is much smaller
than our home city of Portland, Oregon, but that city hall, much more grand than our city hall.
Yeah, this is beautiful. Much more beautiful. Ours is a little sad. A little sad, a little dumpy, yeah.
Okay, so as we move into the 20th century, the era of massive railroads and huge wooden ships
carrying things around mostly comes to an end, and the United States shifts its focus to, well,
automobiles and the interstate highway system and, of course, the airplane. Unfortunately for Portland,
this was kind of the final nail in the coffin, at least for its megacity dreams. You see, following
World War II, the U.S. saw this massive population boom, also known as the baby boom, but that growth
wasn't distributed equally. Millions of Americans moved to the Sunbelt, places like Phoenix, Arizona,
Dallas, Texas, and Los Angeles, California. Those places generally had flat, cheap land
that was just absolutely perfect for this new kind of era of city planning called suburban sprawl.
And, you know, these were places that were very, very hot before, but with the magical invention
of air conditioning, suddenly became much more habitable and desirable by people who are faced
with very brutal winters for most of their lives, a place just like Portland, Maine. And so Portland
just couldn't compete with the cheap and easy expansion of places in the Southwest. But Portland
wasn't just losing people to the Sunbelt. It was also actively having its people and resources
siphoned away by its neighbor to the South, the archvillain of today's story, Boston. But before
we tell that story, there's one place that we want to head to that I think will give us a really good
view. So let's head that way. As we walk to our next spot, let's continue on with a story about Boston.
Boston was always dominant here in New England, but the 1900s is when Boston became a demographic
black hole in this region. As the national economy shifted from manufacturing to things like
education, technology, and finance, Boston had all the right cards. It had Harvard, MIT, and a massive
influx of capital. In the mid-20th century, Boston manifested the Route 128 Tech Corridor, effectively
becoming the East Coast Silicon Valley before Silicon Valley even existed. Now in comparison,
in the 1970s, Portland was all boarded up. The waterfront was abandoned, and the population
actually shrunk. Between 1950 and 1990, Portland lost about 20,000 people, or nearly a quarter of
its core population. So Boston had won the war for New England. Portland was never going to become
the economic center. But losing that battle might have been the best thing that ever happened to the
We've made it to the observatory, which means we gotta go all the way up there. It's gonna be a lot
of steps. Oh man. You only get good views if you go up steps, man. As we head up the historic Portland
Observatory, we are reminded of how far Portland has come. Well, almost. We couldn't exactly see
out very far due to the fog. Today, Portland is the economic heart of Maine, and one of the most
beautiful cities in America. And each year, millions of people flock to the city, many from
Boston itself. These are people who are looking for something different and more relaxing than
the major city that they call home. In fact, in many ways, as Boston grew and became a national
and international destination, Portland became the quintessential New England city, holding onto the
unique culture that made New England a distinct region in the first place. Deep ties to fishing
and port culture, tree-lined streets with endless brick buildings, and of course, plenty of New
England breweries and pubs where one can have a delicious New England pale ale. Which, now that I
say it out loud, I could really go for one right about now. So one weird thing that I've noticed,
not a weird thing, but just kind of like a geographic pet peeve of mine, is that on the
primary license plates here in Maine, it says vacation land. Mostly innocuous, but I think
why is my home state, if I was living here, a vacation land for people not from here?
Or maybe living here just feels like a vacation. Yeah, maybe. Fresh pale ale. It's good. It's very
floral. I wasn't expecting that. And I'm not even gonna pretend. I got some wine. This is the real
me. All right, Jeff. We are done here in Portland, Maine, and I think it's been amazing. What do you
think? Very cool. Love Portland, Maine. It's always fun to see the namesake of your home city,
which not every city has, so that was really cool to see. See how they compare, see how they
contrast. There's definitely a very similar vibe, I'll say that. And you know, I think after learning
about how Portland almost became a really big city, I'm glad it didn't. Yeah, it's perfect
just the way it is. All right, next week we are back in the Pacific Northwest, but we're checking
out a new state. We're heading to Idaho. We're gonna be like right in here of Idaho,
because of course I would wear a map shirt. So come back next week for another geographic adventure.

