60% of Americans polled think billionaires like Elon Musk are good for the economy, but the economic data reveals something very different. "These people become a black hole for the economy," says economist Gary Stevenson.
WIRED spoke with Gary as well as Princeton economist Atif Mian to debunk some commonly held beliefs about this nation's ultra rich.
Director: Lisandro Perez-Rey Director of Photography: Cole Evelev Editor: Chris Davies Experts: Atif Mian and Gary Stevenson
Line Producer: Joseph Buscemi Associate Producer: Samantha Vélez Production Manager: Eric Martinez Production Coordinator: Fernando Davila
Post Production Supervisor: Alexa Deutsch Post Production Coordinator: Ian Bryant Supervising Editor: Doug Larsen Assistant Editor: Justin Symonds
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video challenges the myth that billionaires drive economic growth. Through economic data, it argues that the ultra-rich act as \"black holes\" for wealth, hoarding capital rather than reinvesting it in productive ways. The content highlights how extreme inequality stifles competition, reduces overall economic productivity, and impoverishes the middle class.
Recently, the CEO of Patagonia got widespread media attention for donating his company to charity,
while Jeff Bezos announced that he'll give away most of his fortune, close to $120 billion.
We have this idea that rich people are wealth creators, you know, because they invest the money.
60% of Americans polled think billionaires like Elon Musk are good for the economy,
but the economic data reveals something very different.
These people become a black hole for wealth,
and they start to suck the wealth out of the economy.
Where is all this wealth actually going?
Wired spoke to a former trader and an economist from Princeton
to debunk the top myths about the ultra-rich.
I'm not a moralist here, I'm an economist.
My job is to look at the economy.
We currently exist in a situation where the super-rich
are getting massively richer very, very quickly.
But didn't that massive wealth often start off humbly?
Didn't Microsoft and Amazon start out in a garage?
Aren't billionaires self-made?
To become a billionaire, you need to make a million dollars every single day for three years.
There are some self-made billionaires, but if you look at the statistics,
increasingly more and more of them inherited their money.
That's certainly the case for the Waltons, the Mars and the Trump dynasties.
In fact, according to Forbes,
most of the ultra-rich grew up in wealthy families or in the upper middle or middle class.
It is becoming more important how wealthy your parents are if you want to be successful.
And you're seeing this all over the world because you are competing
with the very rich for the ownership of assets.
And these guys have a passive income of billions of dollars every year.
How are you earning $50,000 a year ever going to compete with that?
The share of income going to the top 1% of households,
that share has almost doubled since the early 80s.
But although the world's richest are earning twice as much money as before,
it doesn't mean they're investing twice as much.
When you go and look at the data,
real investment has actually gone down since inequality has started to rise up.
According to research done by Professor Mian and his colleagues,
real investment by the ultra-rich is down by 2-3% over the past few decades.
So even though billionaires have been earning a lot more compared to everyone else,
they haven't been reinvesting that cash.
In fact, the top 1% saves an average of 50 cents
for every dollar of disposable income they receive.
And that's not good for the economy.
So if an important part of the economy is not consuming,
that money is not going into investment,
that will ultimately lead to a shrinking or a smaller economy than before.
When rich people invest, they don't necessarily have to create new resources.
They don't need to necessarily just build new factories.
They can use that money to buy the existing houses.
They can use that money to drive you and your government into debt.
And that doesn't lead to investment.
What it does lead to is the impoverishment of the middle class.
But how can you say that when high-profile billionaires
are behind some of the largest employers in the country?
Don't billionaires create new jobs?
That is, when they aren't laying off workers like Amazon, Twitter and Facebook just did.
The billionaires, they own the corporations, they own the land.
So of course they get to control who works or not.
The very rich, while they are saving a lot,
those savings are not going into new business creation.
That saving is not creating new jobs.
There has been this slowdown in business creation,
a slowdown in sort of more competition in the economy.
That slowdown in competition from smaller businesses
doesn't necessarily mean that larger companies like Walmart or Amazon
will increase their workforces as they become more dominant.
Increasingly, a big part of the thing they own is technology.
And increasingly, because of automation, they don't even need that many workers.
They don't need human workers because they're replacing them with robots.
By some estimates, automation is on track to eliminate
close to 20 million jobs worldwide in manufacturing by 2030.
But aren't billionaires like Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates,
George Soros and Michael Bloomberg making up for it
by giving away tons of wealth through charity?
Whatever they give, they report on their tax returns.
So based on all of that data, we know that even after they give for philanthropy,
they are saving a lot more.
We should obviously acknowledge anyone who gives money for philanthropic reasons,
but it's not large enough to actually negate
the negative effects of extreme inequality.
I think it's also worth looking seriously into actually how they give to charity.
And I think in many cases, these guys give to charities which they own.
In the case of Patagonia, the $3 billion company was transferred
to a specially designed trust overseen by the Chouinard family.
Moves like this could be seen as a tactic to perpetuate wealth and avoid taxes.
Often, only a small percentage of certain charities' operating budget
is actually given directly away.
Philanthropy charity is fantastic.
Well done if you do it.
It is not going to prevent this economy from going off the edge of the cliff.
The only thing that can do that is serious reformation of the tax system.
But some billionaires like Elon Musk famously complain that the government
already takes too much in taxes.
It's actually not true that the very rich pay a lot as a fraction of their income in taxes.
It is remarkable how flat a tax system the U.S. has.
And so by and large, people are paying roughly similar cents on the dollar of income,
whether you are in the middle class, the upper middle class, or the billionaire.
We have a tax system that is very, very good at taxing working people.
But rich people, because their income comes in a variety of different ways,
capital gains, inheritance, and those are forms of income
in which it's very easy to legally avoid tax.
So although high earners in the top income bracket may pay up to 37% in taxes,
billionaires like Warren Buffett, whose income is from the stock market,
use loopholes to wind up paying very low tax rates.
But at the moment, for the very richest, it's effectively a 0% rate of tax.
I think Elon Musk paid zero tax for a couple of years in a row,
and he's the richest man in the world.
Very, very wealthy people, like the Duke of Westminster in my country,
they get billions in income of their lifetime and pay nothing.
So what's the solution to widening income inequality? A so-called wealth tax?
Wealth tax on very high levels of wealth, that would actually be a good thing in this economy,
because that will take away some of that excess in savings
and channel that back into the economy through spending.
In the 50s, 60s, and 70s, top rates of tax, estate taxes, and income taxes were massively higher.
And that was a period where the economy was growing,
where ordinary families could buy houses,
you know, where standard of living was good for ordinary people.
In fact, during the post-World War II era up until the 80s,
there was actually a decline in income inequality.
The gap between the haves and have-nots was narrower.
According to Professor Mian, total factor productivity,
which measures production output efficiency, was higher too.
The economy's growth was more equitable and more robust.
So we now live in times where growth has been more unequal,
the taxation has been less progressive,
and this fundamental measure of growth, which is total factor productivity,
has actually slowed down as well.
If you put money in the hands of ordinary people, ordinary families,
they will spend it, that will drive the economy.
If you put all of the money in the hands of the very rich,
then there will be no spending,
and they will use that money to buy the rest of the assets,
which will make the middle class poorer still.
So given that data, why does the misperception
that tackling income inequality will damage economic growth persist?
You need to understand that these people, they have political influence,
you know, and in many cases they own, you know,
their own newspapers and they own their own news channels.
So they're going to try to convince you that it is good.
There's an unbelievable power imbalance,
and they are using that power to get more of the existing resources
and more of the existing power.
So if we don't take action,
that power imbalance is only going to get worse over time.