DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THESE BEST-SELLING CROCHET HOOKS!

Knitt & crochet
23 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video evaluates top-selling Amazon crochet hooks using a profilometer to measure surface roughness (RA) and personal testing. The results reveal a \"profilometer paradox,\" where numerical roughness scores do not always correlate with actual glide, proving that the shape and spacing of surface peaks are more critical to performance than the average roughness value.
Amazon knows me well, maybe even a little too well, and I've been seeing a lot of crochet hooks on their site lately and it
Got me curious about what are the best-selling crochet hooks right now?
I expected to see a lot of the big name brands that we all know and love but I was
So wrong out of the top 20 hooks. I only recognized four and that totally surprised me
So today we're going to test out the top
12 best-selling crochet hooks on Amazon to see if they are worth your money and by the end
I'll tell you which one I think deserves to be in the number one spot
I narrowed down the top 20 crochet hooks down to 12 because there were a couple of duplicates which we will talk about
But I also didn't want to include
Tunisian crochet hooks as well as crochet hooks that are made for braiding hair locks and dreadlocks
I'm not skilled in those areas and I don't think my opinion on them matters at all
But we will be working down from the number one
Best-selling crochet hook on Amazon all the way down the list plus I'll be twisting this guy's arm. Oh
You got more stuff for me to measure into giving us some scientific data about the smoothness of each hook surface
So that we can make the most informed decision. Let's get started
I was actually pretty surprised that this crochet hook set came at number one on the best-selling crochet hooks on Amazon
This is the yarn is crochet hook set and I have reviewed them in the past and to be completely honest
They weren't my favorite, but I'm open to giving them a brand new look the yarn is hooks got an average of
4.7 stars and over
26,000 reviews that's pretty impressive and the total price is
$14.99 it comes with a set of 14 different
Ergonomic crochet hooks and it includes a very pretty zippered pouch, which I think is really nice
One thing I do like about these crochet hooks is that each one of the handles is a different color
Which makes identifying the size so much easier. The handles are my favorite part of this crochet hook
They feel really nice in my hands
And I also love that they made the handle colors really pretty the crochet hook neck is really long and I like that
It has a tapered head, but this is where my love for this crochet hook starts to fade, but I need to jog my memory
So we're going to go ahead and test this out just to make sure
Every time I pick up these hooks, I'm hoping they feel different than the last time I use them
But they feel exactly the same it isn't terrible
but these just aren't as smooth as I want a crochet hook to be my husband got out the
Profilometer and measured the surface roughness the RA or the roughness average is 14, which isn't bad at all
but what you'll notice is that some of the spikes are above the red and that means that the roughness is
Above the surface of the crochet hook and that's what I think I'm feeling. I want to love this crochet hook
I really really do
It's the kind of crochet hook that ticks all the boxes and it makes me feel like on paper
This would be the perfect crochet hook
but when I use it
I feel that drag and it makes you question yourself a little bit when you're like
this is the number one best-selling crochet hook on Amazon and there are so many people who
absolutely love it and I just don't my opinion hasn't changed the next crochet hook set and the one coming in at number two is
A collection of 12 crochet hooks from the store meet your store
There are hook sizes from two millimeter up to eight millimeter and it also comes with a bunch of different notions
This crochet hook set has an average of four point eight stars and over three thousand reviews
They also come with a cute aqua colored waterproof pouch for storage
These hooks are also marketed as good for people with arthritic hands, which is a pretty bold claim currently
They're on sale for nine forty eight, which is twenty seven percent off the retail price of $12.99. So let's try them out
While these hooks look very similar to the Yarnus set we just tried they do feel smoother
I'm not feeling that dragging and catching. I also really like the handles and the tapered head
I'm impressed for such a budget-friendly crochet hook set
Once we looked at the crochet hook under the profilometer
You could see why they felt slightly smoother than the Yarnus hooks
This hook has a roughness average of 11
Which is pretty darn good and you can see that there's not much spiking above the red line
Meaning that there isn't much roughness on the surface
You know testing all these crochet hooks
Reminded me of something when it comes to gift-giving we all want to find something that feels special and meaningful
I am determined to get some of my Christmas shopping done early this year
And that's why I'm doing some of my holiday shopping with uncommon goods
They're all about helping you find unique high-quality gifts from independent artists and small businesses
The kind of things you'd never discover scrolling through the usual big box sites
And while I was browsing their site
I found the perfect gifts for my daughter and my new son-in-law
For my daughter who loves her kitty cats as much as I do. I picked out the tabletop tabbies collection
These are six little stoneware plates that have cat faces and they are so adorable
They're perfect as little snack plates to put your jewelry in
But I have a feeling she's going to spoil her little cats with these and for my son-in-law
Who's a total grill master? I picked out the grill master's cookout caddy
It's this beautifully made wooden caddy that can hold all of his sauces and his utensils
But what I love about uncommon goods is how easy they make it to find gifts that feel really personal
You can browse by recipient interest category or even best seller
There are thousands of thoughtful one-of-a-kind options waiting to be discovered
So whether you're shopping for your secret santa or for your entire family uncommon goods knows exactly what they want
You can discover one-of-a-kind gifts for everyone on your list and you can even get
15% off by clicking my link in the description box or scanning the qr code on the screen
Thank you so much to uncommon goods for sponsoring today's video
Next up is the vote ie or the vote ei crochet hook set
I'm, not exactly sure how you pronounce it
This one comes with 14 different crochet hooks in sizes from two millimeter up to ten millimeter
It also comes with some stitch markers and yarn needles
This crochet hook set has an average of four point seven stars and over thirteen thousand reviews
And I paid six dollars and eighty nine cents, which is thirty one percent off of the retail price of $9.99
At first glance these look like pretty standard aluminum crochet hooks
But my concern is at the smaller sizes the two millimeter aluminum is a softer metal and these are going to bend
Quite easily
So if you're doing a project like amigurumi
I would be worried that those really small sizes are actually going to break and bend I started to feel the roughness and drag
Almost immediately. I felt like the yarn was catching and my movements actually felt jerky
I could also hear the roughness of the hook against the yarn
Once we put that crochet hook under the profilometer it all made sense the roughness average was
23 and you can see those spikes above the red that's double the roughness of the last crochet hook
Oh, there's a lot of rough. Yeah when you compare the other two, that's the roughest by far so far
That's why I was experiencing so much drag and you could actually see while I was crocheting that it looked kind of jerky
And that's because there is roughness on the surface of that crochet hook
I didn't mind the feel of the handle actually and I actually like the length of it
But the roughness is a real problem for me
This next crochet hook is also marketed for people with arthritic hands
This is called the extra long crochet hook from the qm
Nnma store, but i'm just calling it the hot pink hook. This hook has an average of 4.4 stars and over
2,800 reviews I paid $3.99 which is 20% off of the retail price of $4.99
This does look a lot like one of my favorite hooks a clover amour with this ergonomic handle and it also has the size
Embossed down on the bottom. So i'm excited to try this one
This hook is much smoother than the previous aluminum hook
We tested but I am feeling some drag
It's slightly better than the yarnness hook
But not quite as smooth as the me cheer set in the aqua bag. Not a bad hook
Just not great when we put the profilometer
Onto this crochet hook. I was expecting to see much better results. The roughness average was
33 that's the highest of any crochet hook we've tested so far
This is so confusing to me what this proves to me is that roughness average isn't the only factor
Did I feel like this was the smoothest hook i've ever used?
No, I did feel some drag. I did feel a little bit of that roughness, but it was
Significantly better than the previous hook and you can actually look at while i'm crocheting
One feels like it's kind of jerky and i'm having a hard time and the second one
You can actually see that it's quite smooth when i'm crocheting even though i'm feeling a little bit of roughness
So this leads me to believe that surface roughness or the roughness average. It's not everything
It's a piece of the puzzle, but it's not the whole picture
I don't know what my husband's gonna think about that, but it really is interesting
Next up is one of my favorite crochet hooks and to be honest
I was a little surprised that it wasn't higher up on the bestseller list
This is clover on more and it was on the top 20 list three separate times
But I am shocked that it wasn't even in the top five
There's so much to love about this crochet hook and it's the hook that taught me a lot about personal preference
This hook has an average rating of 4.9 stars and over 9 000 reviews
And again, I am so surprised that it's not higher up on the list
Well, I paid nine dollars and 72 cents for the hook and that could be the reason why it's not higher up
But I think they're worth every single penny, but let me test them out and we're gonna look at them under the profilometer
There's literally nothing. I don't love about this crochet hook. I like the rubbery handle
I love the length of the crochet hook neck as well as the tapered head
The metal is smooth and I never feel any type of roughness or drag
We've put clover on more hooks under the profilometer before so this does not surprise me, but the roughness average is
29 there's a lot more valley to that one
So it still has a pretty high ra 29, but if you start looking at the picture
You can see this one's really different. It's a little more plateaus
Big broad valleys versus more of a bed of nails approach on some of the other ones
It's interesting every time we do one of these is you learn something because they're so different
They all look pretty much the same but surface roughness. They're all real different
I don't know why this metal feels so much smoother across the yarn
Than some of the other hooks that have a lower roughness average score
but this is why I recommend trying as many hooks as you can get your hands on because
Just because someone else loves a crochet hook just because a crochet hook has a lower
Roughness average score than another one doesn't mean that you're going to love it more
It really does come down to personal preference and what feels best in your hands
Our next crochet hook looks a lot like our clover amour, but it's not this is the ergonomic crochet hook from
Schwach this crochet hook has an average of 4.7 stars and over 900 reviews
I paid four dollars and 17 cents, which is 11 off the retail price of four dollars and 69 cents
I do like the rubbery handle. It does look a lot like a clover amour crochet hook
I also like that. It's got a longer neck and it looks like it has a tapered head. So let's give it a try
I started noticing the roughness and drag on this crochet hook
Right from the start the sound difference may not seem that different on camera
But it was very obvious in person. It was dragging so much. You could literally hear it. Can you hear that?
I'm gonna pause this and try something
This is the schwach hook and i'm gonna put it over here and I want to see if we can hear that same
Roughness against the yarn with the clover amour because I feel like i'm going crazy
Can you hear the difference?
This was very surprising to me
We put this crochet hook under the profilometer and it had the exact same
roughness average as the clover amour at
29 which kind of blows my mind away and I really hope that you were able to hear the difference between the two
The schwach crochet hook was making a definite sound I could hear it almost
Scraping against the yarn whereas the clover hook was sliding through. Yes
There was a sound but it wasn't like that scraping that rough sound that I was hearing with the schwach hook
That's crazy, so it's literally the same ra
As the last one but look how different that is really different
It's the same average roughness, but the actual texture itself is different
I have been so excited to test these next crochet hooks and their official name is the coupe warm crochet hooks
For grandmother. I kind of love that name
They have an average of 4.4 stars and over 3000 reviews
It comes as a set of nine aluminum crochet hooks with polymer clay handles
I paid $7.99 and that was 20% off the retail price of $9.99
These hooks are so pretty and they come in sizes from two millimeter up to six millimeter
The handle on the hooks does look a little bit short
But the neck of the crochet hook looks quite long and the head looks like it is tapered
So I can't wait to try these I wanted to fall in love with these crochet hooks
They are definitely smoother than the previous hook by a lot
They aren't quite as smooth as the clover on more though, but much better than a couple of the others
We've tested but the short handle and the long neck feel pretty awkward
and that's going to affect where they end up on my list the profilometer test on these hooks was
Incredibly surprising they had a roughness average of 10, which is the lowest that we've seen so far
Something isn't adding up to me. So i'm going to do a little bit of research
I have an idea, but I need to make sure next is another 14 piece set of aluminum crochet hooks
This is from the store
HSYMQ and the set has an average of 4.8 stars and over 3 000 reviews
I paid $6.99 for this set and these look like pretty basic aluminum crochet hooks
In fact, they look very similar to the ones that we already tested
In fact when I look at them side by side, they look exactly the same
The colors and the sizes are matching up perfectly just by looking at and feeling these hooks
I'm, pretty convinced. They're the exact same ones as the previous set just sold by a different store
But let's put them to the test. I was fully prepared not to like these hooks
They look identical to the really awful vodii hook set that we just tested that was incredibly rough
But they couldn't be more different. These are smooth and I didn't feel any catching or drag at all
So we put this crochet hook on the profilometer and holy smokes
It was the worst by far at 36 and this is what's making me feel like i'm losing my mind
This hook was nothing like the other hook that it looked identical to this one felt smooth
This one was gliding through
It looks exactly like the other crochet hook set, but it doesn't feel like it at all
Am I crazy?
Am I losing my mind?
I don't think so and I have a theory that i'm going to talk to my husband about
Let's finish the test and let's look at our next crochet hook
This next crochet hook is making a very bold claim the listing title calls this a super smooth crochet hook
So i'm excited to give it a try
This crochet hook is from the shop yo job and it has an average of 4.7 stars and over
1,200 reviews I paid four dollars and 68 cents and this is an eight millimeter crochet hook and I like that
It's embossed right here on the handle now
I do really like this rubbery texture, but I will say i'm a little concerned because this crochet hook neck is
Quite short. I don't know how this is gonna work
I was impressed with the smoothness of the metal and the hook handle
But what I think is a bit weird is the shortness of the crochet hook neck compared to the other crochet hooks
It's quite short and it makes crocheting with it feel a little awkward
the roughness average of the big blue crochet hook was
25 which is definitely better than the last one we tested
But what was interesting about this one is that it actually lives up to the name. It is incredibly smooth
The problem is that the neck of the crochet hook itself is so short
And I think a lot of people are not going to like that feature
I think this would be a 10 out of 10 crochet hook if it actually had a longer neck
This next hook is another one that I thought was going to be higher up on the bestseller list and that's clover soft touch
This is an incredibly popular crochet hook and it has a very unique handle design
This hook has an average of 4.7 stars and over 9 000 reviews and it retails for just under seven dollars at
6.95 the handle of this crochet hook is what makes it so different
It is very flat and it's made of a harder plastic
It's not like the rubbery handles of some of the other popular crochet hooks
It also has a tapered head with a sharper point and I personally love that in a crochet hook. So let's test it out
I usually steer away from this hook because of the crochet hook handle design
But as i'm using it right now, I can feel how incredibly smooth this hook is
It is gliding through the yarn and I have to admit that I like how this handle feels in my hand
We put the clover soft touch under the profilometer and it definitely blew my husband away
You can see how smooth it is on top though. Actually like it doesn't have that big variation. That's an engineered surface
So that's not by accident
The roughness average for this crochet hook is an 18 and what's interesting about it is that it doesn't have those spikes
Into that surface area that red area on the report the profilometer and I are actually really getting along
And honestly using this just now made me like it even more
I also think this is the kind of crochet hook that will work for not just knife holders, but also pencil holders
This is going much higher on my list
This next crochet hook is actually a kit that comes with 54 different pieces
It has an average of 4.8 stars and over 4 000 reviews. I'm so excited to try this one
I paid eight dollars and fifty four cents for this collection from the shop
I'm zay and that was 20 off the retail price of ten dollars and sixty one cents
It comes in 22 different crochet hook sizes
The larger hooks look like they are aluminum and while the smaller lace hooks look like they're steel
It also comes with some notions some stitch markers scissors and some yarn needles and we're just going to be testing out the
Aluminum crochet hook so I can't wait to try this one
I was not expecting to be impressed with this crochet hook set, but I generally am it is smooth
And I feel no roughness or drag
I also like that
It comes with a set of small steel hooks for those who like to do very intricate work like crochet lace or micro
Amigurumi we put this crochet hook on the profilometer and again, I was pretty surprised
This one had the highest roughness average at 51
But what's crazy is that I felt like that. This was smoother than that
Super rough wait, which one was that one? I wrote it down. Where did I write it down?
I wrote it down the votey wait, which one is it?
Aha
Yes, what I find really interesting is that I felt like this was smoother than this set
This is the votey eye votey set that was really really rough and that one
Had a roughness average. Let me look
Let me look I can't remember off the top of my head
Aha, okay that one had a roughness average of 23
This is more than double the roughness average, but it felt much smoother. I don't know
I'm, just a crocheter. Maybe i'm crazy. Just know something's cooking up here. Something's cooking up here
The hook that came farthest down on the bestseller list was actually one that I was surprised to see at that spot
And that's the prim hook
I thought this was going to be much higher up because it's a very popular crochet hook
It retails for $8.99 and has an average of 4.5 stars and over
1600 reviews this hook is very different than any of the other ones because it is made of plastic
There is no metal on this hook anywhere
What I do like about this hook is that it has that ergonomic shape as well as this rubbery plastic handle
So let's go ahead and test it out in the past
The prim hooks haven't been my favorite but after testing so many crochet hooks
They are definitely much better than so many other hooks. I personally prefer smooth metal hooks
But this is a smooth hook and I really like the shape of the handle and that rubbery texture
I believe this is the only inline hook that we've tested and I love the very sharp point of the crochet hook head
The prim hook had a roughness average of 17. This is where the profilometer and I are actually getting along. We are
Agreeing. I wasn't feeling that drag
I wasn't hearing that sound that a rough crochet hook will make with a yarn and it was just sliding through
So I actually I will admit that I didn't really like the prim crochet hook the last time that I tried it, but I think
Sometimes you gotta go through some frogs to find a prince and I actually feel like this one is moving up on my list
This was very confusing to me
And I actually started digging around I talked to my husband and I just needed to know
Why a crochet hook that has a much higher roughness average
Feels so much smoother than a crochet hook with a much lower roughness average and this is what I learned
So it's interesting that you basically experience the same thing that we've seen with engines
Is that the number doesn't tell you the whole story?
It really is about the shape and that's the thing that the numbers don't show right?
It's an average so it kind of hides what those shapes are the spacing and the size of those peaks
That's what influences the feel that you saw the roughness average only tells part of the story
so it can measure the tiny bumps and dips on the surface of a crochet hook, but not how they're spaced or
Shaped and that is very important a crochet hook can have a higher roughness average
number, but if those bumps and ridges are smoother and finer
It can actually feel smoother as we're crocheting with it
And these are things that we cannot see with our eyes, but we can feel it when we're crocheting so i'm not crazy
Well, maybe i'm still crazy, but at least i'm right about this
So smoothness isn't about the numbers
sometimes those numbers align with how we feel but the
Most important thing about a crochet hook is how it feels when you're actually using it
Here's how I would place these hooks in order in 12th place is the vodii hook set nobody's surprised in
11th place is the ergonomic
schwach hook in 10th place and this makes me really sad
But is the coupe hooks the handle and hook ratio is just kind of weird in ninth place is the big
Blue hook from yo job in eighth place is the yarnest set
My seventh place pick is the hot pink hook in sixth place
Is the imsa 54 piece crochet hook set in the orange case in fifth place is the prim hook
My fourth place pick is the aluminum crochet hook set from hsymq
In third place is the crochet hook set from meet your store in the aqua case
My second place hook is clover amour and my number one pick is clover soft touch
So I want to know what your favorite crochet hook is and what is your favorite feature about it?
Please leave it in the comment section. We would all love to hear from you
But I hope you have a great rest of your week. Stay safe and happy stitching
