Unmasking The Michigan Relics Enigma | Parable

What Was The Life
13 followers
Aug 5, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe Michigan relics are a controversial collection of clay, slate, and copper artifacts found in Michigan between 1890 and 1920. While some proponents argue they prove ancient Mediterranean or Coptic presence in North America through linguistic and astronomical evidence, scientific analysis and investigative reports overwhelmingly identify them as an elaborate 19th-century hoax.
In a public museum in the center of the United States,
there exists a collection of archaeological relics
so unexpected that they challenge the imagination.
These artifacts tell of an ancient people
that existed in North America before Columbus.
The language symbols on the artifacts
come from the Mediterranean, Egyptian hieroglyphics,
Greek letters, and cuneiform writing.
The artifacts were all discovered
in the state of Michigan, at the center of the Great Lakes
region.
Thousands of artifacts, discovered in 17 counties
over a span of more than 25 years.
Artifacts that have survived under a cloud of uncertainty.
Are they the artifacts of a hoax,
or are they the artifacts of history?
Either way, they've come to be known as the Michigan relics.
When they were first discovered, interest in the Michigan relics
was intense.
But they would fall into obscurity,
becoming all but forgotten, to be rediscovered, reexamined,
and put on display 100 years after their first appearance.
They have been labeled as frauds by scientists and investigators
several times since their discovery.
Yet, these artifacts continue to inspire
independent researchers who are certain that the artifacts
contain important historical facts.
Facts that have profound religious and cultural
implications.
The artifacts are kept here, in the Michigan Historical Museum.
When they arrived at the museum in 2003,
John Halsey was the Michigan state archaeologist.
The task fell to Dr. Halsey to protect and preserve
these artifacts that are a part of the largest
archaeological controversy in American history.
The Michigan relics were a series
of objects that were found in various parts of North Central
and Southeastern Michigan, starting in 1890
and running up to about 1920.
The first ones that we're aware of
were discovered by a man named James Scottford, who
discovered a clay cup while digging fence posts up
near Wyman in Montcalm County.
Scottford went about the community
showing these things off and getting
the people really excited about these artifacts
that he had discovered out there.
So a number of people in the local community
went out with Scottford, dug into small mound-like rises.
Probably not really true burial mounds,
but they started finding things.
Finding copper things, finding slate objects.
And so this led some of the city fathers
to say, hey, there may be some money to be made in this.
And under the tutelage of Scottford,
they went out and did a whole lot more digging
and found a whole lot more stuff.
Their goal in doing this was to sell these things
to the Smithsonian Institution.
But before they did this, somebody
said, maybe we ought to have somebody
who knows something about artifacts look at these.
And they got a professor from Lake Forest College in Illinois
to come up and look at them.
And he looked at them, but not for very long,
before he said, these are fakes.
And they're not just fakes, they're bad fakes.
Guys, you got really nothing here.
And they dissolved the archaeological trust,
and it probably should have died right then.
It was not the end of the story, however,
as Scottford would continue to show up with artifacts
for the next 30 years.
He eventually moved to Detroit, and suddenly he
started finding artifacts in the Detroit area.
But now, the artifacts they were finding
had begun to turn more to slate and copper.
By 1906, Scottford was listed in the Detroit city directory
as a painter of signs.
In that same directory was the listing
for a Daniel E. Soper, who listed
his profession as investments.
Soper would become a dominant player in the story
of the Michigan relics.
Soper was a flamboyant personality
with a dubious past.
Soper was a former Michigan Secretary of State
who had been forced out of office because
of some questionable activities.
He had taken up the cause of the relics.
And eventually, Soper became the promotional guy for it,
sort of a low-grade P.T. Barnum.
He was really promoting these things.
On many of the Michigan artifacts
were images of what looked like biblical scenes,
indicating a Judeo-Christian people had, at one time,
inhabited Michigan, and then disappeared.
Soper showed the artifacts to the highly-regarded pastor
of Holy Trinity Church in Detroit, the Reverend James
Savage.
Father Savage, he really believed these things
were legitimate antiquities.
And his stated position was, I'd rather collect these things
and have them seen, eventually, as a fraud
than lose something that was really legitimate.
Father Savage wondered if the artifacts
were connected to the lost tribes of Israel.
Seeing the biblical images and the mysterious writings,
Father Savage became committed to preserving
the artifacts that promised an astounding historical tale.
He would purchase all the artifacts that came to him.
James Scottford and Daniel Soper were
the source of those artifacts.
These artifacts, depicting biblical scenes,
also drew the attention of members of the Church
of Latter-day Saints.
Well, Mormons have this belief that, in addition
to the Bible, that there are other scriptures.
And the other scriptures, known as the Book of Mormon,
basically talks about a group of people that left Jerusalem
and ended up in the New World somewhere.
And so whenever some archaeological find comes along
that talks about large civilizations with roads
and buildings and cities in the New World,
they get excited about it.
The Michigan relics have three main groupings.
Some are made of clay.
Some are made of slate, carved slate.
And some are made from copper.
For the Mormons, to find copper plates with inscriptions
was reminiscent of the original text of the Book of Mormon,
which was not on copper plates but on gold plates.
So when Mormons heard about plates with inscriptions,
oh, they were quite excited because here's verification
of what they had been thinking about and talking
about ever since the 1830s.
While the discovery of the relics
would generate excitement, they also produced frustration.
The artifacts promised the great potential
of filling in some biblical mysteries,
and yet no one could read the artifacts.
What made the Michigan relics distinctive was, first of all,
almost all of them had a very distinctive mark,
a series of actually scratches, which eventually
became known as the mystic symbol.
We don't know what it was supposed to be.
If you look at it quickly, it has something like the IHS,
the Christian IHS.
What distinguishes them, moreover,
is the size of some of the objects,
and particularly the slate objects.
They're large, they're heavy, and they, in many cases,
also have what has been called writing.
Lots of symbols, but it is not in any
of the known Indo-European languages.
Interpreting the languages on the tablets
would prove to be the most enigmatic aspect
of the Michigan relics.
One interested Mormon of the day was the Bishop Rudolph
Etzenhauser.
He was a member of a break-off group from the Mormon church,
and he was a bishop.
Etzenhauser was very enthusiastic
about the discovery of the relics in Michigan.
He even joined Soper on a dig.
Etzenhauser commissioned a pamphlet
of photographs of artifacts, hoping
the writing on the relics would come
to the attention of someone who could interpret them.
The pamphlet contained good quality photos
and some information about the dates and site
locations for the discovery of the artifacts.
There is also a portrait of a studious Daniel Soper
examining an artifact.
Etzenhauser's credit to Soper would prove ironic.
To Daniel E. Soper belongs the credit
of having been, for several years,
the moving spirit in the investigation
of these prehistoric relics of Michigan.
How did they go about finding these things?
Well, they would sometimes come into a new town,
and they would contact the local sheriff, chief of police,
maybe a local minister, postmaster,
and would say, we've got these very interesting
prehistoric relics, and we think we're
going to find some more in your area,
based on our long experience with finding these.
Would you be interested in going out with us?
You seem like an educated man, like to see what you think.
So they'd get together a team of respectable people,
and they would go to the appointed spot.
They'd say, OK, well, let's dig.
And Scottford would say, OK, well, gentlemen,
you go rest in the shade for a minute, and I'll start digging.
And so he would dig, and then he'd go thump, thump.
Oh, come here, I think I found something.
He would say to them, here, you excavate.
And then they would uncover these artifacts.
And of course, he believed that this thing was real.
He'd found it.
He'd lift it out of the ground with his own hands.
There was no way that it could be a fake.
And then Soper and Scottford would say,
well, we're really having a lot of trouble
with the archaeologists.
They say these things are fake.
Would you mind signing an affidavit to the effect
that you found this thing and that, in your opinion,
it's not a fake?
And he said, sure, I'd be glad to.
So in that way, the legitimate authority
of the postmaster, the minister, whoever it was,
would be transferred to the bogus artifact.
And this was their standard MO for most of the time
they were involved with the creation of these things.
While gaining local and national notoriety,
Soper and Scottford also drew the attention
of a newspaper reporter in Detroit, William A.
Benskoder.
Benskoder suspected that Soper and Scottford were not
what they claimed to be.
And he took it upon himself to investigate
what they were up to.
Benskoder's reporting revealed that Scottford
had enlisted the help of his sons, Percy and Charles
Scottford, as well as his son-in-law, William Scobie,
in the production of the artifacts.
The sons bragged about their father and their work
to Mary Granny Robeson, who lived in the same boarding
house as the brothers.
Granny Robeson told Benskoder that she occupied a room
next to the brothers, and that hammering went on day and night
in what the Scottford brothers told her was Detroit's
ancient relic factory.
Benskoder got himself very much involved in researching this
and talked to all of these people,
would confront them on the street in their homes at night.
One particularly memorable instance was when Benskoder
confronted Scobie at home one night, and Scobie threatened
him when Benskoder was asking too many pointed questions,
as if we weren't in the city, I'd punch you in the nose.
And then, and this is not a direct quote,
and what are you doing interfering
with private enterprise anyway?
That's as close as we ever come to one of the principal
participants in this admitting that this thing
is actually an industrial exercise.
Later on, Scottford's daughter, in a formal deposition,
states that she saw her father make these things,
and that there were other people involved with it,
but that she wanted it kept secret until after her mother
had died, so her mother lived on for many years.
The availability or the existence of this deposition
wasn't known until well into the 20th century.
At the turn of the 20th century,
the science of archeology was still in its infancy,
but there were several professors of science
that were angered by what they saw
as a blatant perpetration of fraud
being foisted upon the American public.
Together, these distinguished academics
formed a committee to expose the Michigan relics.
In 1911, they published their findings
in a scholarly journal of the day,
the American Antiquarian,
thoroughly denouncing the validity of the relics.
In addition, on July 28th, 1911,
in a front page Detroit News article,
Professor Frederick Starr,
Dean of the Department of Anthropology
and American Archeology at the University of Chicago,
very publicly declared the prehistoric relics were fakes.
Soper was undeterred by the academics,
and with the help of Scotford,
he continued to discover relics until 1920.
In all, it is claimed that from 1890 to 1920,
as many as 3,000 to 9,000 relics
were found in 17 counties in Michigan.
Soper retired to Chattanooga, Tennessee,
where he began referring to himself as Colonel Soper
and continued his celebrity with appearances
at social events where he regaled prominent individuals
with reports on the ancient artifacts
he had discovered in Michigan.
Soper died in 1922,
leaving a large collection of artifacts.
Father Savage died in 1927,
also leaving a large collection of the Michigan relics.
Father Savage's collection ended up in storage
at Notre Dame University in South Bend, Indiana,
where they would sit for 30 years, mostly forgotten.
It was in the late 1950s
when the artifacts in storage at Notre Dame
came to the attention of a Mormon church leader
in Salt Lake City, Milton Hunter.
Hunter asked to examine some of the artifacts
and the university obliged his request,
eventually sending him the entire collection.
Hunter also purchased what remained of Soper's collection.
Combined, the artifacts came to be known
as the Soper Savage Collection.
Hunter studied the artifacts until his death in 1975
and willed the entire collection to Brigham Young University
where it was stored but unexamined for another 20 years.
At the heart of the controversy about the Michigan relics
is the question, how did these artifacts get here
and who made them?
At the turn of the 20th century,
it was commonly held by archeologists
that the oceans had acted as barriers
to isolate the Americas from the rest of the world
and that the only cultures in North America
before Columbus were Native American
and yet these artifacts are clearly not Native American.
The idea of the oceans as barriers
is known as the isolationist theory.
Counter to the isolationist theory
is the idea that humans have traveled
and spread their cultural influences in every direction,
especially where there were waterways.
This is known as the diffusionist theory.
Diffusionists think the massive deposit of pure copper
in the upper peninsula of Michigan
was a destination point for ancient people
from the Mediterranean.
Diffusionists maintain that 2,000 years ago,
access to Northern Michigan by ancient mariners
would have been possible because water levels were higher
and there were several different water routes
to the Great Lakes region.
Artifacts discovered in North America
that are not of Native American origin
are held up as strong evidence
for the diffusionist point of view.
Discovery of artifacts that could not be explained
by the isolationist view have often been labeled as frauds
by professional archeologists
or just left ignored and unexplained.
During the 1950s,
while the Soper and Savage collections were in storage,
Henriette Mertz, a researcher who subscribed
to the diffusionist theory,
began working with a different collection
of Michigan relics.
Mertz would research the Michigan artifacts
for over 25 years.
Her conclusions?
The relics were artifacts of an early Christian sect,
probably Copts, that they used Greek as their main language
and were in Michigan around the third
and fourth century Common Era.
Mertz authored what would become, for some,
the definitive book on the subject.
Her book, The Mystic Symbol,
would renew interest in the Michigan relics.
Ancient American Magazine is a forum
for diffusionist ideas.
Wayne May is the publisher of the magazine
and he points to his own collection
of North American artifacts as evidence
that supports the diffusionist model.
Wayne thinks that among the frauds
of the Soper-Savage collection,
there are some authentic artifacts,
artifacts that shed light
on North America's pre-Columbian history.
The material that comes to us in Ancient America,
I mean, we're very, very open,
not just scientific information,
but we listen to the oral history of the Native Americans.
That's very key.
And we also look at the artifacts that are found.
And even though they're outside the paradigm,
we just have to say, well, my gosh, here it is.
And for example, Native Americans do not use oil lamps,
but yet this comes out of West Virginia.
I bought this out of a private collection at an auction.
And the fellow that had this auction,
I mean, that had this artifact,
he's well-known, all of his artifacts are all authenticated,
yet within that pile of typically Native American
recognized and accepted material,
you'll find this, an oil lamp made out of clay.
Now, I could take this little lamp here
and go to a museum in the Mediterranean,
you know, Rome, Greece, Egypt,
and put this in a museum and no big deal.
Wouldn't mean a thing,
because they've got thousands of them.
But yet here we have one from North America.
So it's like, well, how to get here?
The Indians will tell you, again,
we didn't use stuff like this, we didn't make it,
but yet here it is.
And this is just one example.
There's a lot of things like this that pop up.
You know, I'm not an archeologist, I'm not a geologist,
I'm not an epigrapher, I'm a publisher.
And I'm just showing the American people
what's really out here in the history of North America.
And we've got a lot of unanswered questions
and stuff like this shows up all the time.
Since their discovery,
experts have quickly dismissed the artifacts
because the symbols appeared
to be a mishmash of ancient languages
that were randomly placed on the tablets.
And yet some researchers continue to ask,
what language is on the artifacts and what is the message?
There's a guy by the name of Glade Bergen
who did his thesis
of all things on the languages of the Michigan tablet.
This is the Michigan tablet.
These are the actual characters.
Now we keep hearing how they're goofy characters,
they make no sense, you know, they're this and they're that,
but yet we find the very same characters
right here in Central and South America.
We find them on the Kinderhook plate in Illinois.
So the hoaxers that did this,
they came over to Southern Illinois
and did this one too.
And this is Egyptian characters.
Again, another match.
Here's a Semitic, here's Biblos,
and then here's a Crete and a Mediterranean and Cyprus.
For the guy who would hoax this material,
he would have had to have knowledge
of all these ancient languages to hoax the material.
See, that's my point.
It is so big, it is so grand
that something out of there has to be genuine.
And I think we need to look really carefully
because this could be the largest,
biggest archeological tragedy in North America
because of the quantity of material
that has come out of Michigan.
Glade Bergen's doctoral thesis from 1972 is interesting
because it demonstrates a high statistical correlation
between the symbols used
on several different artifact sources.
His was an effort to unlock the languages on the artifacts,
but no one to date has been able to use his work
as a Rosetta Stone for the Michigan relics.
What's neat about Henriette,
she, during World War II,
she worked for, how would you say it, cryptography.
She was a, well, she understood languages.
She looked for fake things and real things
and tried to decipher and break codes
and all that kind of stuff.
She was a smart lady, very well-educated.
A friend of hers, a judge in Chicago,
approached her before she began this project
and introduced her to all of this mystic symbol business
and asked her if she would look into it
because he had several artifacts
and he just wanted to know if it was real
or if she thought it was bogus.
And when she started out, she was very skeptical.
When you read this book,
you'll understand there's no doubt in Henriette's mind
that these things are absolutely authentic.
I got permission to pursue the book, which I did,
and I have republished it.
We have not changed any of Henriette's work at all,
but we've added an addendum in the back of the,
not all, but several of the articles
that we have published in the Ancient American Magazine,
which helps kind of bring things up to speed for our day.
One of the authors for the additional material
was an avocational researcher, David Allen Deal.
Deal's work is probably the most rigorous look
at the language and symbolism
on the Michigan relics to date.
David Deal is an accomplished graphic artist.
He is also a self-taught scholar of Paleo-Hebrew.
His efforts to learn and master the reading
of early Hebrew scriptures
led him to many interesting research projects
and resulted in the writing and publishing of several books.
His writings put him deep in the Diffusionist camp.
Working with the artifacts researched by Henriette Mertz,
David has produced three significant insights
about the relics.
He has deciphered a language,
identified the theology,
and established a date for their creation.
Anybody can clearly see that they're religious,
they're biblical in context,
and they are what some people have said,
yeah, they're scenes from the Bible.
Okay.
Given that, it'd be easy for anybody to see the flood
and see the rebus with four rows of 10 squares
that stands for 40,
and then you see the symbol for a day.
Oh, a circle.
Oh, 40 days.
Oh, it rained 40 days.
So some of it is very easily read and understood.
David Deal's work revealed a startling new interpretation
of the mystic symbol.
Instead of being the IHS of Christian significance,
it reads in Hebrew as YHW,
which is the Hebrew spelling for the name of God, Yahweh.
This alphabet right here was completely deciphered by me
after realizing that wherever I encountered it,
they were using a Hebrew phrase or word,
and they put it in Paleo-Hebrew,
but Paleo-Hebrew disguised by the fact
that it was done with a cuneiform nail.
Any language can be written in cuneiform, even Chinese.
When I saw the designs of the letters,
to me it was very instantly clear
that they were Paleo-Hebrew inscribed
with a cuneiform nail
and made to look something like cuneiform.
It's a total invention,
but it's yet based on the shapes of the letters
that were already recognized as ancient Hebrew.
Ancient Hebrew is over here.
Here's the Aleph, the Beth, the Gimel, the Daleth.
These are all standard Paleo-Hebrew.
This comparison chart is very interesting
because it allows someone who has no real expertise
in these alphabets to be able to look at them and compare,
and then look at the tablets
and work out the sound of the letter anyway.
You can do that even if you don't have a vocabulary.
And you get a Hebrew dictionary and look it up
and see what the word means.
David Diehl demonstrated the use of Hebrew
on a clay tablet that was used for much of his research.
And here's where I got letter number one, two, three.
That's a Y-H-W.
And here I've got letter number four, five, and six.
How do I do that?
Well, the first letter I recognized
was this one that looks kind of like a W.
It's got three strokes going up.
That letter is a classic Babylonian shin,
which is an S, S-H.
This letter, that's the keth, the other H, the hard H.
And my designer's eye tells me
that that's an M, done with cuneiform.
You know how you take an M up, down, up, and down?
Yeah, the M, the S, the shin, and the keth,
which is broken.
But if you look at it very closely,
you'll see the relationship of these two strokes.
This one is brought up just like this one right here.
There's a keth right there
with a left-hand stroke pulled up.
And then in that case, the word is M-S-H, Messiah, Mashiach.
The theology of the Copts was a central deity named Yahu,
a good son of the right hand named Yahu,
Sabaoth, the good son,
and an evil son of the left hand,
brother to the other one, called Samael.
Samael, to them, was the devil.
Here's the theology, basic theology.
Creator deity with two brother sons, one good, one bad.
In 1895, a French translation of the Epistus Sophia,
which is this Coptic-Egyptian theological document,
came into print, and not wide printing, wide distribution,
but some distribution, in France and in Europe,
three years after Scottford was accused
of creating the first of these artifacts.
So you have to make your mind up yourself.
Was Scottford able to convey this theology
at a time when it was unknown in the world,
and it was not a standard Christian theology?
How could he have put that in there?
The answer to the question is, clearly, he could not.
I see a consistent theology and letter forms
that never existed before in anyone's world
invented by these people.
And why would they invent these new alphabets?
Very clear reason why.
There was a thing in the beginning of the fourth century
called the Arian Dispute, and the Arian Dispute
was basically Bishop Arius of Alexandria
disagreed with Emperor Constantine's approach
on the Trinity, and the emperor wanted there
to be a Trinity, which he succeeded in achieving,
and Bishop Arius was the subject of the Nicene Council
in Turkey in 325 A.D. when it was determined
that the nature of the messiah was the same as the father.
They were the same nature, whereas Bishop Arius
held that they were of different natures,
different substance.
The son was a created being, created by the father
as an angel first, totally different than Constantine's
idea of a Trinity, ever-present, co-equal,
Trinity godhead, which is what he conceived.
So Bishop Arius and his followers were in a lot of trouble
in the eastern Mediterranean, southern Mediterranean,
around the beginning of the fourth century
to the middle of the quarter, first quarter
of the fourth century, but they were ensconced in Egypt,
and they were ripped out at the time of the Arian Dispute.
Another intriguing observation made by David Diehl
came from the book of photographs published
by Rudolf Etzenhauser, containing this image
of a slate tablet found near Roland Township
in Michigan's Isabella County.
When I saw the photograph in Etzenhauser's book,
I saw this eclipse, I analyzed it, I said it's a calendar,
I could see the date that the event occurred
because there was an event horizon,
there was a picture of a face with his nose
pointing at the edge of the circular calendar
where it occurred, it was at the end of the fifth month.
The fifth month is not May, by the way,
the fifth month is July if you use spring reckoning
for the new year, which is what the Hebrews did.
So this means it's the end of July.
So somewhere near the end of July, this event occurred,
and you could see the partially developed eclipse,
you could see the crescent moon shape,
there is a meteorite flying in front of it,
and then there's another total eclipse next to it,
and then there's three little figures looking at it.
So I went to my friend who had the Voyager program for Max,
I asked him if he'd run the conjunctions
for the period of 325 AD to 425 AD,
I estimated 100 years period,
and I based it on the Nicene Council
when the events occurred that transpired
that actually caused the Copts to be forced
to leave the Mediterranean.
Or die.
Etzenhauser happily put,
it was in Roland Township, Isabella County.
I was able to give him the exact grid coordinates
where the artifact was found
within an eighth of a mile maybe or something.
The reason it's important is in a total solar eclipse,
it's not the whole world that turns dark,
it's only about 20 mile strip, 20 mile circle
of primary umbra shadow.
The penumbra goes out a long ways
in some cases hundreds and hundreds of miles,
but in this case the solid full blacked out eclipse
only covers about 20 to 30 miles
depending upon the position of the moon.
And so my friend popped up about 10 dates
for solar eclipses during that period of time.
Only one of them went through Michigan,
and one of them went directly over
these coordinates of Roland Township.
He called me back, he says,
how does July 27th, 352 AD?
I said, bingo, it's right on the mark.
And then there was the question of the meteor.
A meteor during a total eclipse would be visible,
but it's a rare thing.
Wouldn't have been very visible at this point,
but it would definitely have been visible at this point,
so I don't think that that's a real problem.
I think what they're saying is while the eclipse occurred,
meteors were going by.
Particularly one, apparently large one, meteorite.
Went back and found that on the 27th of July,
precisely the date of the eclipse,
it's one of the two days of the maximum intensity
of the Delta Aquarid meteor shower,
which occurs every year on the 27th and 28th of July.
That, to me, confirmed that my,
estimation of the meaning of this artifact was correct.
I'd predicted that it was going to be a solar eclipse.
Found roughly where the artifact was found,
somewhere near it.
And it turns out it was precisely under the path
of the center of the eclipse.
So I think that's a confirming piece of information
that some forger wouldn't have really bothered
to go through the effort and trouble, even if he knew it,
to create all of this data, this beautiful detail.
I think that that just confirms to me that this is real,
and these people were really there at that time.
And it puts them right there at the time
of the Copts' exile from the Mediterranean.
So the detractors are gonna have to deal
with this stuff somehow, some way.
They can't just say nay.
With the increased attention inspired by Mertz's book,
BYU began getting requests to examine the relics.
It also brought forth accusations of concealment
of the relics by the church and the academic community.
To address the controversy and to assess the collection,
the editor from the university's publication,
the BYU Studies, contacted Dr. Richard Stamps,
a Michigan archaeologist.
I had heard references to the Soper Savage collection.
Didn't know much about it.
Maybe had seen a photograph of some of the tablets.
And when the editor of the BYU Studies came and said,
hey, we're looking for an archaeologist from Michigan
to analyze this collection.
We got this big collection.
I, yeah, sure, I'm excited about this.
And I was excited because I was able to take in
20 years of experience of looking at Michigan artifacts
to go and see how do these match up?
Where do they fit?
How does it fit into the big picture?
I go in with certain questions.
What are these artifacts?
What is their function?
Where are they from?
Where do they fit in Michigan's prehistory?
We have a pretty good record of artifacts,
lifestyles here in the state of Michigan.
There are the Paleo-Indians,
been here since the glaciers retreated.
Then we have a shift when the climate changed,
the vegetation, the animal life changed.
The archaic period comes in.
There are intensive hunters and gatherers.
So I was excited to take this new collection of artifacts
and kind of pass them through the filter.
Dr. Stamps reviewed the entire collection
and published a report of his findings in the BYU studies.
The title on my article is called Tools Leave Marks
because I was looking at these pieces
and I was starting to find marks
from tools that didn't quite exist.
Finding pieces of clay with an imprint
on the back of the clay
where the clay had been put on a wooden table
and the table was made of wood
that had been cut with a saw.
And you could see the imprint of the saw marks
from the wooden table on the clay.
Or to find copper artifacts
that had been filed with a file.
And you could see the file markings.
Or you could see the chisel marks
where artifacts had been cut with a cold chisel.
Tools leave marks.
And so I was looking at the artifacts,
finding these kinds of marks,
finding tools that were basically non-functional.
You make a knife, but if it doesn't have a sharp edge,
you know, what is the purpose of it?
Or if you make a clay vessel that won't hold water,
what's the function of it?
How did they fit into the larger context
of Michigan prehistory?
They did not fit.
There were no paralleling finds
that had been excavated in the last hundred years.
So they didn't match up.
And that's when I started to look a little more critically
and try and find some of these things
that didn't make sense.
Well, things like the slate.
Now, these slate pieces are made of beautiful slate.
They're cut and they're polished smooth.
They have right angles.
Some of them have holes drilled through them.
So I'm saying, well, how did you polish the slate?
This smooth, this big.
How did you do that?
And we looked around.
I ended up going to the Slate Museum
on the Vermont, New York border,
taking samples from the Michigan Relic Collection
and saying, how do you make something this smooth?
And the guy walks me over to the piece of machinery
and says, you put it through this machine.
He said, when you cut them, you use this kind of a saw.
And he walks me over and shows me the saw
and shows me the cut marks on the modern pieces,
which match the cut marks on the Michigan relics.
And then I take some of the samples
and I say to them, where do you think this slate came from?
And the one fellow says, oh, that came
from the such and such mine.
He recognized the consistency,
the color of the slate itself.
So then I say to myself, well, now hold on.
How is this stuff getting from New York, Vermont
to Michigan?
I did some research.
And slate was a very popular material,
raw material for making things like window sills,
some door sills, but also making things like sinks.
And one of the pieces that I'd seen
in the Michigan Relics, it just boggled my mind.
I couldn't figure this thing out
because flat across the top, comes down at a right angle
and goes up at an angle and down at an angle.
It's a strange piece.
And it had certain holes drilled in it.
And the holes became part of the decoration.
They were either starbursts or borderlines or something.
So here's this piece of slate.
And I'm looking at this saying, what's going on here?
And then I'm walking around the museum
and what do I find but a sample of a sink.
In the old days, they used to make sinks out of slate.
And these were the two end boards
were the same shape as this Michigan Relic
that had had this carving put on it.
Where did they get the slate from?
Somebody was coming along construction site
where they were putting in window sills,
door sills, sinks, found the old stuff,
took it off to their workshop
and then changed it from a 19th century
construction material reject,
put a decoration on it and turned it into a Michigan Relic.
I also looked at some things on copper artifacts
and I went to a metallurgist and I said,
look at this metal and tell me what you think about it.
And they did a couple of things
like measured it with their calipers
and they came up with the average thickness
and something like three sixteenths of an inch, okay.
This was a standard, you wanna buy some raw copper,
you go down to the store and it comes in this size,
this size and this size.
And there's one of the sizes that's available
when you're buying copper.
Also, we looked at some of the fine lines.
The metallurgist, when he was looking at this,
he said, boy, whoever created this had a sharp tool.
I said, what do you mean?
He was able to measure the very, very thin line
that was scribed on the copper tablet.
And he says, you have to have a sharp steel tool to do that.
And also at a molecular level,
we got the metallurgist to look at it.
They could see the conformity
and they said, this has been smelted.
So some people would say, well, come on Stamps,
maybe the Native Americans were smelting copper.
And it's a great thought, it's a great idea.
Show me some evidence of a heavy copper smelter
of all the archeological sites in the state of Michigan.
And nobody's found a smelter that dates to the time period,
this prehistoric period.
So the copper didn't line up, the clay didn't line up,
the slate didn't line up.
So I came to the conclusion that these were made
by someone other than early pre-contact folks.
I think Scottford was making them,
Soper was helping bury them
and getting customers to come and dig them.
And Father Savage was the unfortunate fellow
who was kind of duped into believing that they were real
and he amassed this large collection.
So what was the purpose?
I think Scottford was making money at it.
If the artifacts could speak for themselves,
what would they tell us?
Would they reveal an engineered lie or a hidden truth?
Did Scottford and Soper discover
genuine historical artifacts,
preserving them until the writing could be read
and their authenticity proven?
Or is anyone that looks for meaning in the artifacts
just another victim of Scottford and Soper's hoax?
How will we get to the truth?
Does a technology exist today
that did not exist at the turn of the 20th century
that could prove the authenticity of the Michigan relics?
Thermoluminescence is basically a dating technique
that can be used on some ceramics.
It's a technique
and it's one that we need to pursue in the future.
The University of Southern California, Long Beach
has a well-regarded archeology program
and a thermoluminescence testing facility.
Under the guidance of Dr. Carl Lippo,
a clay tablet that David Diehl had deciphered
was recorded with a 3D laser
and a fragment of the tablet
was submitted for thermoluminescence testing.
The test report from Dr. Lippo was thorough,
within a 10-year window of possible error.
The report indicated
that the tablet was manufactured in the late 1890s.
It would seem that with a luminescence test
and with Dr. Stamp's examination of the artifacts,
that the story of the Michigan relics would be closed.
But there are some lingering doubts
that keep the controversy alive.
The clay tablet examined by David Diehl and Henriette Mertz
was not a part of the Soper Ore Savage collection
and might be an individual example of fraud.
Pieces from the Mertz-Diehl collection
were claimed to have come from an earlier discovery,
some say as early as 1870 or even 1850,
well before Scotford,
and yet there is no evidence for that claim.
The Mertz-Diehl collection can be traced
back to a collection from a curiosity museum
in Springport, Indiana, run by Professor Edwin Wirth.
Wirth moved his museum from Detroit to Springport in 1906.
Newspaper reports from 1900
indicate that Wirth had recently put his curiosities
on public display in downtown Detroit
at the Wonderland Pavilion.
Where did Wirth get his relics?
Did he buy them from Scotford?
They were both in Detroit at the same time.
Again, no records have been discovered
to answer these questions.
In the Etzenhauser pamphlet,
there are two intriguing documents.
This is the book, by the way, let me just hold this up,
that was published by Rudolf Etzenhauser, 1910 or 1911,
concerning his take on the Michigan artifacts.
And it has many, many pictures
that we've already seen before,
but what it has that nobody else has is this.
One of the claims that's been made
is that Scotford from 1890s and Soper and Savage,
which they were, all involved
on the discovery of the Michigan tablets.
However, prior to that, we've got many players
on the Michigan scene pulling up artifacts
as early as 1856.
Here we have two signed affidavits
with the people's names, they can all be verified.
And all of these people who signed here,
we have no Mr. Soper, no Father Savage,
and no Scotford brothers here at all.
So here we have two affidavits, absolutely clean,
have nothing to do with Soper, Savage, or the Scotfords.
And these are different people
and pictures of the artifacts that they found.
We do not know today where these artifacts are.
And then just one more comment,
the Monhegan stone we talked about earlier
at the mouth of the St. Lawrence River.
This doesn't show the whole stone,
it just shows what's inscribed on the stone.
And this is what you would see
if you go there today to see it.
And of course, here we have the mystic symbol
and other cuneiform writings and markings.
Down here is the mystic symbol with two messages,
going at different messages going across
to the travelers coming in that way.
That's the Monhegan stone.
This is what's carved on the Monhegan stone
at the mouth of the St. Lawrence.
And I believe these people, these Michigan folks,
this is exactly the highway they came in on.
The rivers and the waterways of North America
were their highways.
In addition, Wayne May had this interesting story.
And if I may, it's only three paragraphs.
Can I read that to you?
Okay, now I want you, this is what it says.
Yod-Heh-Vah article, Dear Mr. May.
In the article, Christ in America, volume four, issue 26,
Wayne May wrote of a claim that the Ojibwa name
for Henry Mertz's mystic symbol is Yod-Heh-Vah.
Mr. May adds that the Yod-Heh-Vah is remarkably similar
to the biblical Jehovah.
It's not only similar, he goes on to say,
it's identical to 75% of the biblical name.
The name that we angelicize as Jehovah
is actually the Hebrew tetragrammaton,
which can be stated in our alphabet as Y-H-V-H.
But whose Hebrew letters are called Yod-Heh-Vah.
So, Mr. May's informant, in fact,
gave him the Hebrew names of the first three letters
in the name of God.
Presumably, the additional syllable spoken once a year
is a final Hey, to complete the tetragrammaton.
The Yod-Heh-Vah is a Hebrew tetragrammaton.
Those are cuneiform writing.
And what's it doing in North America?
And then, there is David Deal's work with the language.
It appears that Deal broke the code
to reading the cuneiform writing.
Does it reveal a real language?
Or does it reveal the genius behind the forgeries?
Where could Scottford or Soper have gotten the language?
Did they invent it?
Or did they copy it from a real artifact?
If you think that Scottford had a style sheet
to make these objects, I would say yes and no.
I say that by virtue of the fact
that when you look at these artifacts,
you see the care that was taken to create them,
as opposed to Scottford's banging and bashing
with his chisel and his clippers
on standard, commercial-grade copper plates,
eighth of an inch thick.
It's pretty clear that they're fraudulent,
but not the ones that much care had been taken with.
Scottford polluted this mass of artifacts.
But I think that there was enough of the artifacts
around in Scottford's time for him to draw off
the known ones at the time.
As a style sheet.
Did he make all of those artifacts over,
spread all over Michigan over a many, many year period?
No.
And why are there no artifacts being found now?
Well, a lot of people I know of that have collections
are afraid to come forward with collections
because they think they'll be treated as fools.
So many of them will probably never surface
for that reason.
I think the Michigan tablets, to me,
also are extremely important because of the quantity.
Now, if you had maybe 50, maybe even 100,
I could say, well, yeah, that can be faked.
But 10,000?
3,000?
I have a hard time with that, especially when we know,
and the professionals even admit that we have evidence
they come out of at least 17 counties.
I've got evidence for 27 counties
throughout the state of Michigan.
One or two may be fake, but are they all fake?
You say 1,000.
I mean, how long does it take you to make 1,000?
Come on, he was doing this for, what, 25 years?
To make 3,000 is a number that sticks in my mind.
But hey, you can crank those out in a hurry.
The clay pieces don't take that long to make.
Now, to scribe the ones on copper,
that's gonna take a little more time.
Again, put it in a 25-year time frame.
And how many a month do you have to make?
It's not that many.
Nobody ever fessed up.
Without having any of the perpetrators admit it,
there is this lingering doubt.
A lot of people take that as evidence
that it really wasn't a fraud.
So people expect that there's some kind of resolution,
and the lack of a resolution leaves a doubt in their mind.
Some have said, well, yes, there are fakes,
but there may be a few that are real.
I touched and held and looked at every single piece
that was in the Salt Lake Museum that came here.
And if there was a real one, I sure couldn't find it.
And maybe there's some in another little museum someplace.
Maybe Henrietta Mertz had something that I didn't see.
Okay, all I can say is every single piece that I looked at,
I couldn't find one that was right, that looked right.
It just wasn't there.
So maybe it's there.
Hey, that's science.
The door is always open.
The fact is that the Soper, Savage,
and Mertz Steel collections
contain manufactured artifacts,
enough artifacts to make the Michigan Relics
possibly the largest archeological fraud
in North American history.
And yet questions remain.
Was there ever anything of ancient historical value
to be discovered in the Michigan Relics?
Is there a possibility that an ancient Coptic group
was actually in Michigan, but a group so small
that they left only a tiny trace of their presence
and that the trace has been lost in the piles of fakes
created by Scottford and Soper?
Or as the whole story best summed up by Francis Kelsey,
the Michigan archeologist who wrote in 1911,
it may be presumed that men will be ready to believe
what they wish to believe,
and that no hoax will be too preposterous
to be without a following.
Whatever aspect of the story you focus on,
it must be agreed that the tale of the Michigan Relics
is filled with the works of some very creative
and industrious individuals.
Perhaps what is most remarkable about this story
is the persistence of the desire
for the artifacts to be real.
The fact that the Michigan Relics
still stir the imagination 100 years
after being labeled as frauds
speaks to the power of the story they present.
The sheer numbers of items created
and the compelling story they invoke is by itself
a testament to the genius and the creativity
behind their creation.
The story on the artifacts and the story about them
may be most valuable for an unintended reason.
They may remain as a timeless example
of the need for careful discernment
when it comes to telling the difference
between what could be the truth and what is the truth.
