The Pearl Price Challenge: $50 vs $500 vs $5,000

Secret Life of Pearls
4 followers
2 Video Views·Aug 4, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedExperts analyze eight pearl strands in a \"Pearl Price Challenge,\" evaluating value based on luster, shape, and origin. The video educates viewers on the distinctions between saltwater and freshwater pearls, the impact of the nucleus on size, and how rarity and culturing processes determine market pricing, ranging from affordable everyday wear to high-end collector's items.
On this desk, we have a $5,000 strand of pearls
and another one that costs less than $50.
Can you tell which is which?
We'll show you how.
Hi, and welcome to another episode
of our YouTube Versus series.
Today, we're taking the Pearl Price Challenge.
We're gonna check out loads of different pearls
and see what makes each of them unique and valuable.
So we have eight necklaces here, eight pearl strands.
This one immediately jumps out to me
from my limited pearl knowledge.
I see incredible luster.
They almost all look like they are spherical.
I immediately think this reminds me
of an Akoya strand, perhaps?
This is going to be on the more expensive side.
Definitely.
Pearls are graded by their luster,
which is their beautiful shine,
their orient, which sort of determines their color,
surface quality, their size, and their shape.
That luster is so, so attractive.
Akoya pearls are the world's
first commercially cultured pearls.
Which is good because it opened up the world
of other types of pearls for us
because finding a natural pearl is next to impossible now.
These are saltwater pearls.
Normally with a saltwater pearl,
it's one bead per oyster, meaning one pearl per oyster.
The process is very meticulously done.
They take a bit of what is like ground shell
to create the bead.
It's sort of injected into the oyster
where it considers it an irritant
so it develops nacre to coat it.
And that is what the pearl is.
Most Akoyas take 10 to 18 months to be harvested.
You can imagine how much time and effort it takes
just to get a strand of all the same size,
same orient, and put them together so that they all match.
These are cultured in the more northern waters of Japan
and that's supposed to enhance the luster,
the colder the water.
And many consider these to have the brightest luster
of all cultured pearls.
They certainly are incredible.
The Akoya tend to grow in a smaller oyster.
So these are actually kind of large for an Akoya strand.
That also adds to my argument
that this goes in the more expensive end of our alignment.
Yes, absolutely.
I think we're saying the least expensive here
and the most expensive down there.
So I think she goes over here.
Yeah, I agree.
For sure.
I'm going to pick this
because this is so cool looking to me.
I love the organic shapes here.
These are what we call Baroque pearls.
They're funky little shapes
and they give you a funky little necklace
that I absolutely love
because it has all these sort of bumps and dents
and bulges and things.
It reflects that luster in so many different directions.
I'm thinking these are Kashi pearls.
They're not officially pearls.
Really?
What happens is when they're culturing pearl,
another irritant can get inside of the oyster
alongside of the bead.
It's growing more nacre around this irritant.
This could be a little bit of sand,
anything that could cause it.
So you could open that oyster two years from now
and find both a cultured pearl and a Kashi.
They're sort of a freak of nature kind of accident
and they're a happy accident because they're so pretty.
These are almost all nacre.
The color of the pearl is almost always determined
by the color of the oyster, the lip.
You can get different colors.
So even though these are all still in the same family,
you can see the differences between some of them.
This has a little bit more of a silver orient
and these definitely got some pink in them
and a little bit of green even.
Every single strand that you're gonna get of a Kashi,
it's not gonna look uniform.
Each one, like a snowflake or a fingerprint
is gonna be unique to you.
If you don't want the same uniform strand
that everybody has, I would go with something like this.
This one, I'm a little stumped on, price point wise.
No, I do know that they tend to bleach the Kashi
just to lighten them up a little bit.
I would guess this is sort of somewhere in the middle
or middle to inexpensive.
That's what my guess would be.
So I'm gonna put it like here.
Yes.
All right, I see yellows.
I see beautiful white.
I see a little bit of surclay in here.
This feels expensive.
This feels like it may have a South Sea quality.
This is South Sea pearls, untreated.
Whoa, for those who didn't hear what our producer said,
this is white and gold and silver
South Sea pearls, untreated.
I feel a little bit nervous around a strand like this.
I know, but I want it.
It's so breathtaking.
It's almost like when you see somebody wearing
like a huge carat weight in a diamond.
It has that equivalency because this is something
that can be so expensive, so rare.
South Sea pearls are actually one of the largest
cultured pearls.
They can grow to be anywhere from the size
that we're looking at right now,
which is roughly an eight millimeter,
nine millimeter size, all the way to something
as huge as a 20 millimeter size.
That's what I like to call like the jawbreaker size pearls.
That's because of the size of the oyster
that they're cultured in.
Those oysters can actually grow up to a foot wide.
I need a lot of lemon juice for that one.
A lot of lemon juice for that.
The oyster is called the pintada maxima,
and it will have either a gold lip or a silver lip shell,
and so that's how the color is determined in the pearl.
And the gold pearls are highly valued,
and you can see why.
I mean, just look at them.
I mean, they're just luscious.
These pearls are known for their exceptionally thick nacre,
which is what contributes to their very soft glow.
The largest ones in this variety can take
as much as four years to grow.
You typically find them in this type of shape,
which is a cercle, where you see these sort of rings
going around each one of these beautiful pearls.
To find a South Sea in a true, completely round pearl
is very, very rare.
We have the Akoyas here.
We have the beautiful Keshis.
My instinct is to put this in between,
but I feel like it's more expensive than the Akoya.
I know, I feel like it goes on the other side of our Akoya.
Yeah, that's what I'm thinking.
Could be wrong, but we'll find out.
I wanna pick these.
These are a beautiful size, about 10 millimeters.
Very uniform round, very uniform color.
I'm suspecting that these are from our Genesis.
Yes, that is what I was thinking as well.
This is sort of a revolutionary process.
Freshwater pearl normally grows with a tissue nucleus.
This is a freshwater pearl,
but it's done with a bead nucleus.
It allows us to get these larger sizes.
So it's almost like we took the process of culturing
that we do with a South Sea pearl,
or something that is a saltwater pearl,
and we've done it with freshwater.
Exactly.
We actually cut open a Genesis pearl,
so you could see the bead nucleus.
It's kind of the same color, almost.
Wow, yeah.
You really get the sense of how big that is,
but how it helps it grow to these larger sizes.
And you can see the layers.
Exactly.
And you can see how they kind of crisscross
over each other too,
and that's what's reflecting the light.
That's actually, the material is called aragonite.
That's so cool.
And this is an exclusive line to JTV,
something that can replicate that gorgeous look
of a Cozumiga pearl, but it's so much less expensive.
And these are dyed.
So, you know, helped by man a little bit,
but they are a pearl.
I'm thinking this is going to be
on the more affordable side.
I do too.
Just first instinct.
So I think maybe on the other side of the keshi.
Yeah.
I think you're right.
We'll bring this beauty in.
Ugh.
I know.
That exact response is elicited
when you see a strand like this.
Immediately, I'm thinking Tahitian.
Tahitian.
You don't have to know much about pearls
to know that this is one of the most valuable
forms of a pearl.
Tahitians are famous for the dark color pearls.
These are like 12 to 15 millimeter.
They're fantastic.
There's something so sexy about a Tahitian pearl.
It feels mysterious and beautiful.
These come from the Pinctada Margaritafera,
and that's a black-lipped oyster.
Now, the culturing process is kind of complicated.
So it starts the way you would normally think.
There's a bead nucleus inserted into the oyster.
But then, after a year, they look and say,
okay, these are the best oysters in the group.
These grew the best pearls.
So they take those top like 5% of those pearls
and then put in a larger bead.
Okay.
They're basically sort of stretching their ability
to grow a larger pearl.
So each year, they keep giving them
a little bit bigger bead nucleus
until they can get to this size.
Wow.
So it's a year-by-year process
just to develop those oysters.
And you're down to like 1% of the oysters you started with
as far as being able to get this size for us.
That's incredible.
So these are completely untreated.
Let that sink in for a second.
That's pretty crazy.
They contain a lot of thin, translucent layers
that interact with the light
and give you that sort of iridescent, orient,
and beautiful color play when you look at a pearl.
It does exist in other white pearls,
but because of the dark backdrops that you have,
you can actually see them.
And the polish is so beautiful.
And the luster's so beautiful.
People often describe it as sort of metallic
or mirror-like.
Yeah, that is why people are reaching for this
as the aspirational strand.
I think I know where this goes in our lineup.
Yeah, I think I do too.
All the way to the end.
All the way at the end.
I'm picking this next.
Wow.
Now look at that.
This looks perfect.
It is perfect.
Or maybe we should say pearl-fect.
Pearl-fection.
Our beautiful pearl-fection line,
which is actually a pearl-simulant line.
I love this because this really gives you the ability
to wear something so expensive-looking.
I think these are beautiful,
and I would challenge anybody on the street
to tell me if it is or isn't a pearl.
I think it's because of the process.
This is actually made with a mother-of-pearl nucleus.
We use a specific blend of materials
to create the overlay that is simulating
that giant, whopper-sized South Sea pearl.
This really looks like the classic South Sea pearl,
treated as if it were a South Sea,
knotted in between each one.
They have a nice weight to them too.
And the clasp, the attention to detail here,
it's treated, just like Sharon says,
like your genuine South Sea pearl.
I'm thinking this is more affordable
just because it is from Pearl-fection,
and that's sort of the theme.
I think, yeah, right now,
between the Genesis and the Catchy.
Yeah, I'm good with that.
I'm thinking we're gonna do this pink beauty.
I've been waiting for this one.
Yeah, we have been eyeing this the entire time.
Beautiful color here.
I mean, this is exactly that posh pink color
that seems like it is signaling
it's from one specific place.
It does.
This looks like Casamiga to me.
That's what I'm thinking.
So they're known for their different delicate colors.
You can get lavenders, pinks, champagnes.
I was actually in a prep room with Mark Brown
the first time we brought in Casamiga pearls.
My eye went right to this ring that he had.
This is so beautiful.
He goes, that's Casamiga.
We just started selling this.
And I'm like, I want this so much.
It's just the most beautiful color.
This is also uniquely uniform.
I mean, look at all of the spherical pearls.
These come from a lake in Japan called Lake Kasamogara.
And these are actually a freshwater pearl.
But they are bead-nucleated.
You are only going to get one per oyster.
There's something about the temperature of the water,
the location that just gives them
this unique, absolute beauty to their color,
to their orient that can only be achieved
in Lake Kasamogara.
There were several families
who had different pearl farms on the lake
and that were harvesting this specific type of pearl.
As of 2026, there's only one pearl farmer
that is currently farming Casamiga pearls.
There's only one farm now.
That's crazy to think about.
The production is not there.
And so what little there is,
JTV is getting their hands on it.
Yeah, which is very impressive.
So these have been bleached.
So it typically lightens their color just a little bit.
Where are you thinking?
Because I'm a little bit stumped here.
I'm feeling like they go right in here before the Akoya.
Right before the Akoya?
Okay.
I'm agreeing with the expert.
All right, last one.
She's beautiful.
She's a classic.
But not round.
No.
These are, again, the Circlay
with those ridges around them.
Is this a freshwater cultured pearl?
I feel like it is a freshwater.
Yeah.
Most cultured pearls today that are available
are freshwater pearls.
So these are the ones I was talking about
where you can get several per oyster or mollusk.
This makes it a very affordable,
very attainable pearl look.
This is still a classic, beautiful organic gem.
Absolutely.
They're almost solid nacre in there
because it's a tissue in there in the beginning.
So it's all that natural material in the first place.
So oddly enough, there may be a large bead
in other pearls where it's a thinner layer of nacre.
You're getting more nacre with these,
but they're more affordable.
I know.
That's a little funny to think about.
Kind of backwards.
Yeah, it's kind of backwards.
So these are eight millimeters.
It takes two to four years to get to this size.
But again, these are a little bit more abundant.
So where do we put these in our lineup?
I'm thinking closer towards the front.
I think so too.
Wanna say the first?
Yeah.
I think so.
So if we line them all up.
All right, on my side, we've got the freshwater.
We think this is the most affordable.
Then we have our Genesis Pearl.
Yes.
Which is still a freshwater pearl,
but it's bead-nucleated.
Then we have our Pearlfection,
which is a pearl stimulant,
but it does start with a mother-of-pearl nucleus.
Yes.
And then we have our Keshi,
which is sort of the happy accident
that happens in an oyster.
Yes.
And one of my favorites.
Then we have our classic Cozumica Pearls.
Then we have our Saltwater Akoya Pearls.
And then we have our Golden South Seas
that also have white and silver South Seas featured.
And then the piece de resistance,
the beautiful whopper-sized Tahitian Pearls.
Do you guys think we got it right?
Pause the video right now and let us know in the comments.
I feel pretty good about this.
I think I do too.
Oh no, really?
So it turns out we got a few of these wrong.
It turns out that the Akoya strand
is actually more expensive
than this particular South Sea strand.
Okay, okay.
This is surprising.
Wow.
This is actually still not as expensive as the Cozumica.
So we're gonna swap these around.
So what we're theorizing here
is the reason why this isn't as expensive as the Cozumica
is because these are not perfectly spherical pearls.
These actually have a cercle.
Now for your biggest mistake.
Oh my gosh, what?
You have vastly underestimated the value of our gemstone.
Oh!
Wow, okay.
So I'm just going to swap these two and see if I...
Nope.
Our producer says no, so let's shift on down
and move our Genesis Pearl into this position.
Boy, did we have it wrong.
That is the correct position.
Okay.
Oh, wow.
I hate that we undervalued this Genesis strand.
What's funny about this is this one is actually dyed
to give you the look of a Cozumica,
but the way that it's cultured is very similar
to the Cozumica Pearl.
They have grown in similar environments.
They come from freshwater lakes,
but this is actually roughly half the price of this one.
They're all beautiful.
There's a pearl for everyone here.
So if you're just looking for your classic white strand,
but you can't afford the Akoya,
you've got the freshwater.
There is absolutely nothing wrong
with having beautiful freshwater pearls around your neck.
Obviously, we have your red carpet looks,
your expensive collector's items,
maybe the pearl that you pass down
from generations in your family.
And then you have the strands that you can wear every day
that you feel comfortable bringing on vacation.
If you've got one of those personalities
where you're just like,
I want something totally different,
these just are just bursting with personality.
The Baroque nature of these,
to anyone's guess what shape it'll be,
they all have a wow factor to them.
Yes, absolutely.
We wanted to show you a bunch of different strands today.
We actually don't have a strand of these,
but we wanted to share with you the Mabe Pearl.
I love these, and I think they're just a cool story.
So these actually grow on the inside of the shell.
It's also called a blister pearl.
Pearl farmer will cut that
and basically fill it with a resin
and then give it a back,
which is probably a mother of pearl backing.
And so it has these flat backs,
so it's really easy to set into jewelry.
So these are South Sea Mabe Pearls,
which means these are coming from those big oysters
we were talking about before.
And they're gonna have that luster
that the South Sea Pearls have.
With like a fraction of the price.
These are super affordable.
They're just over $100, which I would not have guessed.
I mean, I'm genuinely looking at these and thinking,
do I get married wearing these earrings?
I'm gonna get married.
Please shop the links attached to this video
so that you can shop all of the items
that we shared with you today,
plus many more pearl options.
We had a few surprises in here,
so I wanna know what surprised you the most.
Let us know in the comments,
and then like, subscribe, and ring that bell
so you don't miss any future episodes.
We'll see you next time.
