PRO-4X vs. TRD Pro! | 2025 Nissan Frontier vs 2025 Toyota Tacoma

Van & Truck Lab
86 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the 2025 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro and the 2025 Nissan Frontier Pro-4X. The Tacoma is portrayed as a high-tech, aggressive powerhouse with superior off-road capability and luxury, while the Frontier is presented as a nimble, cost-effective alternative that focuses on off-road fundamentals and overall value.
Work and play, they coexist.
If you're buying one of these two trucks,
the Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro, the Nissan Frontier Pro 4X,
the most factory-capable off-road trucks that you can buy.
Among the midsize segment, they're among the most fun,
the most powerful, and have a ton of technology.
Let's go on the road and off
and find out which one is right for you.
For decades, the Tacoma and the Frontier
have been the top-selling pickup trucks
in the midsize segment in the United States.
The Frontier has been new since 2022,
the Tacoma since 2024, and now it's the Tacoma
that's taking power and size
in a completely different direction.
You can look classic, but not appear too basic.
That is the styling essence behind the Frontier Pro 4X,
which for 2025 has new disc-styled wheels and a new grille
that's a bit more chiseled,
and there's three cutouts on the top portion.
The strips of LEDs still remain,
and the black strips that connect now the fog lamps
to the top portions of those headlights,
that's new for 2025.
Very subtle changes, but this truck looks good,
and it still looks compact.
It's classified as a midsize.
It's sitting 9.8 inches above the ground.
Large, but not too large.
You'll definitely notice it, though.
That's the loud part.
Afterburn orange is a brand new paint for 2025.
And the Frontier has kept looking really good
in this generation and will to come.
In the back, there's a new black strip on the tailgate.
That's on the Pro X and Pro 4X models.
Basically, everything that you already liked about it,
it's still here.
The Tacoma is a mini monster truck.
The TRD Pro just towers above every other truck
that's out there.
It's so much wider, so much longer,
and everything on this truck,
from the exposed red shocks, the cross members,
the big, thick skid plates,
it's all on display in a way that other trucks,
even other off-road trucks, do not do.
You get a big light bar in the front, red tow hooks.
That's a new feature for 2025.
Out back, the TRD Pro has high-lift jack points
directly on the frame.
You can spot them just as you can see the ARB steel bumper.
This truck means business more than any other trim,
maybe a Ranger Raptor,
but this Toyota truly is kitted out
like it's an F-150 Raptor.
So much more equipment than you'll ever see before
in other Toyotas, and a whole lot more aggressive,
including a power-folding and power-rising rear tailgate.
Both of these trucks are high off the ground,
but the Toyota, 11 1⁄2 inches, that's insane.
The Nissan is still really tall at 9.8 inches,
but for approach, breakover, and departure,
the Toyota wins by a long shot.
Just look at those numbers.
It's also just bigger overall.
The wheelbase, six inches longer.
Total length, three inches.
Three inches wider, and a couple inches taller.
The Tacoma used to be the size of the Frontier.
Not anymore.
These are smaller trucks, but they've got huge power.
Look at the torque on the Tacoma, over 460 pound-feet,
all from a little four-cylinder engine
that's turbocharged and electrified.
But don't sleep on the Frontier.
It's got a large displacement, naturally aspirated V6
that's making nearly as much horsepower as the Tacoma.
There's a nine-speed automatic transmission on the Frontier
and eight-speed on the Toyota, but for fuel efficiency,
because of the hybrid system on the Tacoma,
it's way up in the city, highway, and combined.
Both of these trucks, as the off-road trims,
have locking rear diffs, locking center axles,
low-range transfer cases.
Fuel efficiency isn't the name of the game,
but towing actually is,
and the big number goes to the Frontier,
both in max and across all the trims,
and on this trim, the Pro-4X,
hundreds of pounds more than the Tacoma.
For 2025, the Frontier steering wheel does this.
That's standard.
Also, two-way power lumbar is standard
on SV trims above for the driver's seat.
The most welcome change inside the Frontier
is the new 12.3-inch touchscreen,
with Frontier embossed right on the dash.
It carries the same orange accents
you'll find throughout the interior,
including on the seats, which are thin but very supportive
and have a really fun design,
including this nice carbon twill
on the outer parts of the seat backs.
But the rest of the interior is truly basic.
The window switches, the steering wheel, the knobs,
all the parts definitely feel from yesteryear.
The Tacoma is the sports car of midsize pickup trucks.
These seats alone could be in a BMW,
and the entire cabin just feels racy all over.
The Toyota just feels more modern.
The switch gear, these knurled toggle switches,
the shifter, the steering wheel, and the displays.
It doesn't matter the technology behind them,
but the cabin itself just feels better and more high-end.
And for what you're paying, well, it had better be.
The Frontier has a usable and pretty roomy backseat
for a smaller truck.
Fold this up, there's a fender sub under here.
Fold this down, and there's a lot of light.
A lot of trucks are much smaller.
In the Tacoma, the backseat is for the front seats.
There's no room to actually sit back here,
but this is where all the hardware goes.
The struts in this seat
are actually based off aircraft landing gear.
There's a combination of oil and air,
and you can adjust them with valves here,
and fill them up with pressure valves right up here.
Really, really impressive stuff,
and off-road, it delivers a truly comfortable ride
that helps smooth out both of these seats,
and you can easily adjust them on the fly whenever you want.
Can you sit back here?
Of course not.
This bed is pretty shallow.
You can still fit a lot.
The spray-in bed liner is optional.
The payload on this one, 1,220 pounds.
That's among the lowest,
because this is the Pro 4X,
but it goes up to 1,480 on other trims.
What you're paying for in the Tacoma is all the hardware.
There's a sport exhaust here,
and on either side of the tailgate,
a button that powers down and powers up the power tailgate.
Not something that you typically find
on trucks in this caliber.
This bed is also a whole lot deeper than the Frontiers.
There's a 2,400-watt power outlet,
because remember, this is a hybrid,
and the payload is also up significantly.
Over 1,400 pounds on this TRD Pro,
and over 1,700 pounds on specific trims
of other Tacoma models.
So everything I like about the Tacoma,
I can get inside this Frontier.
I can just drive quicker over these same bumps,
because there's way more suspension travel,
more clearance, and there's just more power,
so you can just kind of really eat away at the terrain.
In the Frontier, fine, you slow down a little bit.
Maybe you get bumped around slightly more,
but all the capability is right here,
and I like that it's narrower.
I always mention that when I drive off-road,
because I'm not in the middle of a desert.
I'm not in a sand dune.
I'm on trails in New England,
and a lot of places, when you're going in places like that,
width is not your friend at all.
You want nimbleness.
Braking is also easy to modulate,
and there's no driving modes.
Not gonna find that in the Frontier, not even in 2025.
It's got four-low, a rear locker,
and your right foot, and your two hands.
It's still got great approach and departure angles,
no matter what.
So you gotta ask yourself,
do I really need to be sitting a foot off the ground
rather than, say, 10 inches?
That's up to you.
I like the fact that I can drive this Nissan
without all of the electronic aids,
and still feel very comfortable in control.
I paid a whole lot less money.
And then when I get on the road,
I do sacrifice some noise,
certainly not as powerful,
but it's hitting all of those elements.
I like that Nissan keeps it basic.
They keep it simple.
You stick to the off-road fundamentals.
And at the end of the day,
the Frontier is gonna go
everywhere the Tacoma can,
except if the road is very steep,
or there's one particular articulation
that I can't get over,
because there's no disconnecting sway bars on here.
Again, no fancy equipment,
but for 90% of what you're doing in a truck,
I'd say the Frontier hits all those marks.
Nissan makes do with a big, naturally aspirated V6.
And by making do, they're doing just fine.
With this nine-speed automatic transmission,
pretty quick to react.
And while it does not have the turbo
or the electric assist of that Tacoma,
the Frontier feels lighter, because it is.
Hundreds of pounds lighter.
That's what happens when you don't need to have a truck
that's a foot off the ground
with tires that could crush a small car.
The Frontier is very, very capable as it is.
It's kind of tough to think of that now
when trucks just keep getting bigger.
The Frontier is keeping its size intact,
because this Frontier wasn't really that much different
than the previous Frontier,
which lasted well over a decade in terms of dimensions.
Driving position.
This feels like an older truck.
My knee is much higher,
because the sill here on the window is lower.
I'm still sitting pretty high,
even though I'm at the lowest position.
In the Tacoma, I feel more like I'm in a sports car
that's been lifted.
In the Frontier, it's more like,
hey, I'm in a regular truck.
Two very different sensations.
This Pro-4X, surprisingly, again, quiet, noise,
harshness, not an issue.
It's incredible.
Both of these trucks, all-terrain tires,
not the street versions.
They're really meant to be pushed off-road on trails,
but I'm impressed.
Straight-line stability is also good.
I prefer the Tacoma's steering a little bit more.
This one, I just kind of have to wrestle with slightly.
There's less steering assist, especially at low speeds.
That makes it a little tougher.
I'm not perturbed at all driving on the highway
in this Frontier, but compared to the Tacoma,
there's definitely more wind noise coming through the cabin.
It's not terrible,
but the isolation and the quietness of that truck
is actually just probably the most impressive thing.
You really have to grab the Frontier's steering
with two hands to pull out at low speeds.
That's what makes it feel a lot older.
I'm just so used to these days
having a ton of power assist.
This one, even just the off-center reaction,
it's more delayed, requires more deliberate actions,
but it has that kind of nice,
even just way more mechanical direct feel than the Tacoma.
And on the smaller roads, this is the easier truck to drive.
It's the Nissan.
I don't have a giant domed hood.
I can see the corners very easily.
I can see the back.
I don't really feel like the size is getting in the way.
This isn't any bigger than any sort of crossover
that's on the road right now.
And the compact and midsize segment feel very comfortable.
So if you're driving on a day-to-day basis,
I would say the Frontier is the better package.
It's slimmer.
It's easier to work with.
And frankly, without the added bulk,
Frontier, in many ways,
feels more like a car-based crossover
in terms of how it handles turns.
The steering makes it feel older.
The ride is a bit choppier.
And the brake pedal, a little soft on initial travel,
but I'm actually pretty impressed
with how the Frontier keeps itself together.
It is a modern truck.
The Tacoma just essentially just launches over anything.
What I'm driving across is not just
some little shallow puddle.
It just feels that way because the Tacoma is so big.
It's almost just crushing the landscape
in the way that the Frontier kind of drives through it.
The Tacoma is just driving and smashing over it.
There's additional driving modes with multi-terrain select.
Of course, there's a locking diff.
Really, it's all the suspension travel.
They're big, really.
It's just remote reservoirs in the back,
completely, completely confident.
And really, it doesn't make much of a difference
what you're driving over.
And this seat, well, the seat is really described itself.
It is a sport seat,
and it does do a good job of keeping you placed,
I gotta say.
The great thing about both these trucks
is that the cameras stay on, front, side.
Sometimes the parking sensors don't go off,
but I'm also not in a specific off-road mode.
It's definitely a quieter, effortless experience
that you find off-road,
just the same as you would drive this Tacoma on-road.
So for dynamics, I gotta say,
it's way more impressive than the last generation,
and it does impress me more than that Frontier.
In terms of power and performance,
this Tacoma definitely feels a full generation
ahead of the Frontier.
Now it weighs more.
This is a turbo hybrid.
There's a battery.
It's not a plug-in hybrid,
so it's not nearly as heavy as it could be,
but it's hundreds of pounds more.
This Tacoma is larger by far than the previous generation.
But even so, with all this power and torque,
and the sound from a little four-cylinder engine,
it's quite impressive.
On the road, the Tacoma is also more comfortable,
not just because of these seats, but the suspension.
Despite all the geometry of that suspension,
the positive camber of these front tires,
it's actually very agreeable.
It's quiet, much quieter than I ever would have expected
for a truck that's over 11 inches off the ground.
It's towering over that Frontier, and that's the Pro-4X.
So it's a really good balance of comfort,
really almost a luxury feel in this truck
in terms of isolation,
despite all the tires and everything on here.
The way the transmission shifts
and all that turbocharged torque,
you don't even need the other driving modes.
Previous versions of the TRD Pro
were never this comfortable or as quiet.
So Toyota's done a lot,
but you also pay a whole lot more for it.
Nice benefit of this being a hybrid
is that you can roll silently at low speeds,
and then it kicks into gear like that, very fast.
Unlike other Toyota hybrids,
this one is strictly meant for performance.
The efficiency is better than that Frontier
by actually a lot,
but just don't expect true fuel efficiency.
But for an off-road truck, it's actually a lot better,
and it takes regular gas.
On center field with this steering wheel,
it's very chunky, first of all,
and there's some play,
all to be expected on the TRD Pro,
but it absolutely feels tighter than before.
I do feel, though,
that despite how well this behaves on pavement,
I still can't get over the width.
The cabin doesn't feel any bigger than that Frontier,
but the amount of truck
that's basically swallowing this lane,
I'd rather be in the Frontier.
It's lighter, it's more approachable.
This truck, you really just don't wanna get
into too many narrow spaces
because it's really approaching just behind the wheel
like a full-sizer.
Once you get used to the size,
again, there's significant body lean
when you're really pitching it into a corner, so don't.
The Frontier, I think, handles a little bit better
just because it's not as high off the ground,
so you lose some of that composure with this newer TRD Pro,
but overall, it's pretty well-behaved
considering how extreme it is.
The way this TRD Pro drives reminds me of a Raptor.
The speed, the body lean, all the power,
braking actually does feel good.
It's a hybrid system on this iForce Max,
but there's a lot of pedal pressure.
It's not soft, and that's what you want
in a performance truck.
Instead of the old-style television that was here before,
there's now a 12.3-inch touchscreen,
but there's no way to use most of the screen,
or at least that side of it,
unless you're using stereo,
or you go in here and wanna customize the menus,
and you can put the weather or a clock.
That's all well and good.
However, what really needs to be here
is Nissan's newer system,
like you'll find in the 2025 Armada, completely redesigned.
This is the old one, but now wireless Android Auto is here.
That wasn't there before.
So was Apple CarPlay.
But really, this is an old system.
It's fine.
The cameras are good.
That, I'll give it.
And off-road, these will operate at higher speeds.
Other than that, though,
the system really does need a redo.
It's a shame because this is a brand-new truck
and doesn't have Nissan's latest equipment.
The Tacoma has a 14-inch touchscreen
with excellent legibility.
Just look how big that is.
Everywhere you go on here, it's just easier to read.
There's not really much you can see here.
Wireless Apple CarPlay is there, the maps.
It's just the things you can't see.
For example, all of these camera views.
There's so many of them, way more than the Frontier.
You can zoom in, 3D, bed cams, trailer cams.
You can see your off-road information all the time.
And remember, there's also a disconnecting sway bar.
The seats are cooled.
There's adaptive cruise control with lane centering.
Really, there's so many more features on the Tacoma.
And even though it's more expensive,
well, there's more features here.
The 2025 Nissan Frontier starts around $32,000.
There's five trims.
And this one, the Pro 4X,
with the convenience and premium packages, about $50,000.
The 2025 Toyota Tacoma starts at $32,000,
but there are 11 trims
because there's also the iForce Max, the hybrid option.
As tested, the TRD Pro, 65 grand.
The Frontier wins by a few feet.
Objectively, it does basically everything
that the Tacoma does for a lot less money.
Value is all part of the equation,
from the previous generation and to now.
It's delivering the off-road performance,
a lot of the on-road refinement,
and while it's more basic inside,
especially with the technology,
I really like the Frontier
and how it packages it all together.
However, if you have more money,
you're getting a whole lot more truck.
On the Tacoma, it's the power,
the sheer horsepower and torque
that you're not gonna get in the Frontier.
And all of the off-road equipment,
from the way the tires, the suspension, the shocks,
it is such an extreme vehicle
in a way the Tacoma never was.
So you're spending a lot more money,
but you get a lot more truck.
So what do you think?
Which truck are you gonna take home?
And which one would you choose to pay for?
Well, go to CarGurus.com, browse our listings,
and subscribe to our YouTube channel.
See you next time.
