Reacting To 25 "BLOCKBUSTER" MLB Trades

Shelfy
1 follower
60 Video Views·Aug 4, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
It's trade deadline day, so we have turned the trade sliders all the way up in MLB The Show.
Let's jump into a franchise and see some of the best trades that MLB The Show has to offer.
We're ranking these trades by three tiers.
We have S-tier, which are the really good trades that I think work both ways.
We have our C-tier trades, which are just the mid trades that, meh.
And then we have our Alec Baum trades, which are terrible.
Trade number one, Adrian Moreon, along with the now-retired Hugh Darvish,
going to the Rangers for Cameron Cully and Dave Valilo?
I actually want correction on that.
I've never heard of this guy, but that's a pretty cool name.
We're putting this in the Alec Baum category.
No ranked prospects and a guy that's retired?
Oh! An eight-player mega deal!
Trevor Rodgers is going to the Cubs, along with Zach Eflin, Dean Kramer, and Keegan Aiken
for Justin Steele, Jackson Wiggins, Jamison Tyone, and Kevin Alcantar.
Now, I'm gonna put this in C-category right out of the gate because it would absolutely never happen,
but I gotta give some credit for the Electric Factory.
Eight players and six of them are major leaguers?
I don't think this has ever happened in MLB history.
Our oldest Chapman, I guess the Red Sox never turned it around in this sim.
He's going to the Chicago Cubs.
I'll say this isn't the first time the Cubs went all-in by adding our oldest Chapman.
The New York Mets making pretty much a Freddy Peralta 2.0-type deal here.
They're gonna give up Jonah Tong and Christian Scott for Michael King, Miguel Andujar, and Alex Verdugo.
I'm giving this one a C.
Just passed the trade deadline in year one. Let's get into the offseason.
The Astros landed Tetsuya Amai in the offseason, but now they're trading him along with Josh Hader.
How do you not break those two up for more value?
Franklin Wales and Rick Rice.
I will say, though, according to the MLB The Show ranks, these are not one, but two top 20 prospects.
These guys aren't just in the top 100.
This is two top 20s, and they're both 18 years old.
So this actually feels like an incredible deal both ways,
although I'm one to split up talent like this if you're gonna trade both.
Two top 20s is a crazy return.
I'm gonna give this one an S.
This is our first really good one, I think.
Padres trade for Roberto Valencia.
They give up Jeremiah Estrada and Tristan McKenzie, who's now bouncing around the league.
Jeremiah Estrada added to the Mets' bullpen.
We'll say that last one's mid.
The Mason Miller blockbuster goes down in the offseason.
Mason Miller, Randy Vasquez, Matt Waldron, and Brian Hoeing.
At one point, I was a huge fan of Waldrip,
but I don't think this is nearly a good enough return for Mason Miller,
especially if we're adding in a bunch of depth pieces.
I'm giving this one an Alec Bohm stamp of approval.
Just not enough.
Steven Kwan's gonna go north of the border for top 100 prospect JoJo Parker and Adam Macko.
All right, this is a good trade.
If the Blue Jays feel like they really need a right-now outfielder, I like this deal.
We're giving this one an S trade.
Solid, simple, good player for good prospect.
That's baseball.
And Morejon, the Rangers lock in their guy.
Had to add that one to the mix.
28-year-old Adrian Morejon signs a five-year deal with Texas.
Brandon Sprout on the move again.
Goes from the Mets to the Brewers.
Now he goes from the Brewers to the Orioles in exchange for Kyle Braddish.
The Orioles extended Braddish this year in real life,
but he's still on ARB in this sim.
So the Brewers get him.
For Brandon Sprout and Luis Lara, I'm gonna give this trade a C.
This is mid.
Sprout had some really good value at one point though,
but obviously this wouldn't happen in real life.
Braddish signed an extension.
But that's not all for the Orioles.
They also sent Adley Rutschman and Yanir Cano to Texas.
So coming back to Baltimore is gonna be Sebastian Walcott,
the number 12 ranked prospect in baseball, along with Pablo Guerrero.
I am giving this trade an S.
This is a great deal.
The Orioles probably in the running to move Adley Rutschman at some point
since they're now committed to Sam Pasalo.
They kind of have the flexibility there.
He's a good player.
Big name value.
Hasn't had the best couple of years here,
but Adley Rutschman, a really good player,
goes to Texas for a top 100, top 15 prospect in Sebastian Walcott.
Scoob Dogg goes to Toronto.
Seven years, 275.
Feels like an underpay.
Holy Brady Singer, three years, 90 million.
What?
Freddy Peralta's gonna go to the Yankees.
Eight years, 309.
Freddy Peralta just got more money than Tarek Skubal in a year one offseason.
It is the first offseason.
They're the same age they are in real life.
Freddy Peralta just got more money than Scoobs.
Year two, let's see what they have in store for us.
Some guys are in new places.
Dick Lodolo going to the—
Look at the Marlins buying in.
29-year-old Lodolo.
I've been big on this guy for a few years now.
I still think— He's getting up there in age.
I still think this guy could break out and be one of the best pitchers in baseball
if he puts it all together.
His stuff is insane.
Blake Mitchell used to be a very high-ranked prospect.
He's ranked 56 now.
He's the return for the 29-year-old Lodolo with one year left on his deal.
This is a pretty good trade.
Hey, this is an S trade.
I like seeing small- to mid-market teams coming together to improve their rosters.
Nick Pavetta is going to the Mets.
Are you kidding me?
A.J. Ewing, the number 68-ranked prospect, going to the Padres.
Nick Pavetta going to have to return to the Annalise, where he once was a Phillies player
during those dog seasons before Bryce Harper joined the club.
I'm going to give this one a C mid-tier.
Langeleers is on the move.
Don't do that to me.
The Athletics.
I guess it's an Athletics type of move.
They can't keep everyone.
Shea Langeleers is going to Boston, and that feels like—
You know what? He looks very good in that uniform.
I'm going to remember this if he ever actually goes to the Red Sox.
Tyson Witherspoon is the number 89-ranked prospect.
Jefferson Rojas, 69 overall, C potential, shortstop.
And Tsu-Che Chang, the 25-year-old—25?
25 with C potential?
This is not enough.
This is not even remotely close to enough.
We're actually going to put this in Alec Boehm territory,
one of the best hitting catchers in baseball with an extra year of control.
Wow, Tamar Johnson on the move.
I remember when he was drafted and compared to Robinson Cano.
Not even ranked anymore.
Cade Smith, 93 overall, one of the best closures in baseball with three years of control,
might I add.
This is an Alec Boehm-tier trade.
I don't even have to think about it.
Vinny Pasquantino's going down to Houston along with Lucas Erceg,
might I add, and Keegan Aitken,
who was recently brought in in that Orioles trade earlier in the video.
The return for Vinny Pasquantino is going to be Rick Rice, Sean Gauthier, and Zach Cole.
Gauthier's the 61-ranked prospect.
Rice is the 19th-ranked prospect.
So again, if you're going to put two talented pieces in one deal and send them together,
getting two top-ranked players, including one top 20, is a pretty good return.
We had an 18-year-old as the higher-ranked prospect.
That is huge, and as a corner outfielder, ranked that high at 18,
you got to assume he hits absolute moonshots.
Justin Steele is now on the move.
He once went to the Orioles in that Keegan Aitken deal.
Now he's going to Houston for Frank Gildahaus.
God, I can't even speak right now.
Frank Gildahaus is a 53 overall, B potential, 18-year-old catcher.
He is a 34-ranked prospect at 18, though.
Justin Steele had the Tommy John a couple years ago, 31 one-year left on his deal.
I'm going to put this at C.
This could work both ways if the Astros are any good.
All right, going in the offseason number two, season number three.
Gabby Moreno for Tommy White.
Oh, man, Tommy White was fun in college.
This is an entirely different Tommy White, by the way, but I like that name.
This is a—I'll say C.
This feels like an Alec Boehm deal.
A 23-year-old B potential pitcher for an 87-year-old catcher that's still in ARB.
I don't like this one for the D-backs.
Oh, Joe Onderon leaves the Phillies three years, 46 million with the Royals.
If we don't match that in real life, I'm flipping tables.
Mackenzie Gore going to Atlanta, four years, 125, 31 mils per year.
And, of course, part of the money will be donated to the Atlanta Braves Foundation.
Nikola Tolo, after getting dealt, must have locked in.
2.69 ERA, and he's getting a monster $218 million contract.
All I had to do was say it, and my boy locked in.
Oh, Brady Singer, who's on that three-year, $30 million contract
after just one season with the Rockies,
gets traded for the number 13-ranked prospect, Jorge Bautista.
I gotta say, this is an S-tier trade.
The Rockies spent money and flipped it for a top-20 prospect.
Smart baseball, guys.
This is incredible.
Seiya Suzuki signs a three-year, $78 million deal with the Phillies.
I actually think that's a very realistic possibility
when he hits the end of his contract.
We got Pablo Lopez, 101 to the raise,
and Griffin Jacks got 51 million from the Astros.
William Contreras locks himself in with the Brewers.
Five years, 103.
That feels like a discount, brother.
Ew! Oh, my gosh.
Bryson Stott signs with the Braves.
Six years, 128 million buckaroos.
And I'll be honest.
I think this is more likely than people realize.
Stott can play anywhere on the field, high-level defense,
and he grew up a massive Chipper Jones fan.
That's his favorite player of all time.
Most people don't know that
because Brandon Marsh gets all the attention
as the Braves fan on the Phillies.
Bryson Stott's a Chipper guy.
Logan Gilbert gets a $250 million deal from the Mets.
He was the number-one-ranked free agent in this pool.
Going into year number three.
Let's see what they got for us here.
They're starting to spice up a little bit here.
That offseason was crazy.
Riley Green's going to the Athletics.
Wow! So they sold Shea Langeleers
and then traded for a 27-year-old
that's going to demand a lot of money in the offseason.
And they gave up the 27th-ranked prospect in baseball
to get that guy who's only got one year left on his deal
before he gets to make a contract.
This feels like an Alec Boehm deal
because you know the A's aren't going to pay Riley Green.
We'll see what happens later in this video,
but I'm going to hold them on that.
You've got to pay him or this is a ridiculous trade.
Oh, wait a second.
Are they all in?
Are the Athletics all in?
They traded for Jaron Duran,
who's still an 89 overall with B potential in this game,
for the number 51-ranked Jamie Arnold,
a pitcher that a lot of people are high on right now.
Okay, listen, in the context that the A's are going for it,
I'm going to give this one a C
and I will rechange the score of the last one to a C.
However, if they don't win and they don't pay these guys,
it's a Boehm deal.
Like, it's June.
We're still a month away from the deadline.
How are the Athletics going all in?
I am confused.
Brandon Woodruff goes to the Diamondbacks,
along with Tristan Costas and Tanner Hawk.
Going back to the Boston Red Sox will be number 43-ranked
Jorge Coronado, Mitch Bratt, and Tommy Troy.
Again, this is another one of those situations
where a team like the Diamondbacks
that typically doesn't spend a ton of money,
they're bringing in Brandon Woodruff
with years left on his deal at big money.
I can't fault a team like the Diamondbacks
for trying to go after it.
This is one of those teams I'd love to see
put their foot to the pedal a little bit more
when they have good teams.
Andrew Abbott's getting down to the Athletics.
Oh, yeah, they're like way, way,
but what do you mean you traded Lawrence Butler, though?
Okay, maybe the Athletics lineup is better now
than it was two years ago at the start of this sim,
but they give up Lawrence Butler to bring in Andrew Abbott,
so that really does help the rotation a lot.
I'm going to have to look at their depth chart
to really make a decision on this particular trade,
but it feels like if you're all in,
Lawrence Butler's a guy you want to keep,
especially with five years of control at 27.
It's a solid player.
I don't think I can grade this one.
Shane Bieber's going to the Rangers.
Didn't the Diamondbacks just add pitching?
Now they're selling pitching?
I am so confused.
Alec Baum territory.
There's three years of control left.
He's an 87 still.
They didn't give up anything.
I don't know what's going on in Arizona.
I'm moving on from that one.
Off season number three before year four.
Let's do it.
Kyle Stowers going to the Astros.
The Astros and the Marlins
have been very involved in this video.
Casey Mize, who I guess was a Marlin,
and Gavin Sheets also going to Houston.
Russell Stewart, the 27th ranked prospect,
is a B potential starting pitcher at 20 years old.
He's the big piece on the other end.
Stowers is in ARB.
Casey Mize has three years of eligibility,
so I do think this is a big win for the Astros.
I got to put it in C tier.
Not seeing enough in return for the Marlins on this one.
Francisco Alvarez is on the move
for number 46 ranked Richard Hirsch.
Wow. Well, I guess if Alvarez in the game
has developed up to an 85 overall,
still has B potential,
so he'll maintain those 80 plus overalls for a while.
This is an S tier trade.
In real life, I would say this is a thumbs down
because Francisco Alvarez still has a lot of work
to do on his game,
but Richard Hirsch is the 46 ranked prospect at 18 years old.
A pitcher at 18 years old
and the top for a really good power hitting catcher.
That's a good deal.
Is that Jose Ramirez with the Yankees?
And he's not even the top feature.
Why is he not in the top slot of this deal?
Tanner Bybee and Jose Ramirez go to New York
for Carlos Lagrange, Robert Wilson, and Ryan Walker.
The best player going back is a 33-year-old reliever.
Oh, now Byron Buxton wants to leave Minnesota, huh?
The Phillies could have used you for the last three years.
He doesn't want to get dealt,
but now, now he'll go to Milwaukee.
Shane Boz is returning to Pittsburgh where it all began
along with Colton Couser and Spencer Arrighetti
for Manuel Rios, who's the 29th ranked prospect,
Nick York, former top ranked prospect,
Joey Bart, former top ranked prospect,
and Wilbur Dotel.
We'll put this one in C.
It's okay.
It's a good deal,
but this isn't blowing anyone's socks off
when you get the notification.
Ronald Acuna Jr. at 31 signs a 10-year deal.
My guy has one knee and no hips,
and he signs a 10-year deal at 31.
He's still a 99 overall.
How is he the number five ranked free agent,
though, is my question.
What an offseason.
Gunnar Anderson, the number one ranked free agent
this offseason, 27-year-old, 98 overall,
gets a 319 mil for the Toronto Blue Jays,
finally replacing Beau Bichette.
George Kirby, six years, 202 million,
does end up staying with Seattle.
There's a lot of rumors that he could get moved
right now in real life.
Grant Taylor, the Diamond Dynasty glitch,
is going to the Atlanta Braves for Kareem Column,
who's a 19-year-old, I guess, auto-generated player.
I don't know.
Jordan Alvarez gonna go get himself
some more citizenship this time in Canada,
nine years, $330 million.
Hunter Goodman going to the Astros.
The Astros have got to be the most active team
in these trades.
87 overall, 29-year-old Hunter Goodman
off another 27 home or season.
He also stole eight bags, apparently.
Getting traded for the number 18 prospect,
Franklin Wales, to the Colorado Rockies.
I feel like the Rockies have acquired
like four or five top 100 prospects in this video,
and they're still selling.
What was that Brady Singer contract all about?
That's an S-tier trade.
Adley Rutschman is on the move once again,
along with Ryan Helsley.
So a 31- and 34-year-old, 88 and 85 overall,
are getting traded for Bryce Matthews and Jack Caglione?
26-year-old Jack Caglione still only a 78 overall,
batted 213 last season.
He was on the Reds, now he's on the Athletics.
What happened to Jack Caglione and the Sims?
I'm giving this one an Alec Baume,
because Caglione just being there confuses me.
Josh Hader.
Josh Hader's got to be the most traded player
in the history of MLB The Show at this point.
He's going to the Chicago White Sox
in exchange for former top prospect, Drew Romo.
And that's it for the last trade deadline.
We're going to do one more offseason, see what they got.
Here we go, one more offseason of fun
before our current core players get too old.
Ranger Suarez is 34,
and he's getting traded to the Chicago Cubs
with just one year left on that deal
for no top-ranked prospects.
Alex Call really being the feature player.
I'm going to give this one a C-tier.
Just, we're getting into that point
where I don't even know some of these prospect names.
Eli De La Cruz, $425 million, signed through age 40.
He's a 99 overall.
Oh, well, would you look at that?
The Philz lost Yoan Duran last offseason,
but they add Mason Miller this offseason.
Just 19 mil per year.
A mostly quiet offseason here in the offseason of 2030
as we get into the final spring training.
That is it.
Nothing, that offseason was boring.
Seems like as the years go on,
the action gets less and less crazy in the offseason,
but those deadline deals are crazy, man.
Another wild trade video here on Franchise.
If you guys enjoyed, hit the like button down below.
Subscribe if you are new.
It's like a common thing here on the trade deadline now,
and we throw some up throughout the year as well,
but if you're new, go check out the offline playlist.
If you're not in the Diamond Dynasty,
I totally respect that.
I have all kinds of offline content
and a lot more coming, so subscribe down below.
Enjoy your day and let me know
what you thought of the trade deadline,
the real life one in the comment section down below.
Louisa Rice got sent to the Phillies
in the middle of this recording.
