2025 Nissan Frontier vs Toyota Tacoma / Battle of Principles

Van & Truck Lab
86 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the Toyota Tacoma and Nissan Frontier, contrasting Toyota's modern, feature-rich, and premium approach with Nissan's traditional, value-driven strategy. While the Tacoma leads in technology, interior design, and market popularity, the Frontier excels in towing capacity, ride comfort, and overall affordability.
The latest Toyota Tacoma has angered a vocal group of truck enthusiasts.
These folks are yearning for a lower price and less complexity.
Kind of like what you get with the Nissan Frontier.
So, does more simple equal more better? Let's find out.
And if you would like to see more fun, detailed car content,
consider subscribing and hitting the notification bell.
Thank you. And thank you to the kind people over at Royal South Toyota in Bloomington,
Indiana for letting me test drive the Tacoma for today's truck brawl.
If you're in the market, check them out.
I've driven a wide variety of new Tacomas, along with
the most expensive and least expensive Frontier you can buy.
The difference in philosophy is stark.
Obviously, the Frontier is going to appeal even more to the traditional truck person.
You can now get the long bed in any trim.
For 2025, the standard towing capacity is over 7,000 pounds,
and there's a basic V6 under the hood.
The starting MSRP of the Tacoma is roughly the same as what you're going to get with the Frontier,
but its powertrain has been detuned unless you spend more money.
And that's a common theme with the Toyota.
A lot of the features are hidden behind paywalls
that slowly climb this thing past $55,000, like the truck that's behind it.
Get that Toyo trash out of here, brother.
Maybe this can justify that price tag.
And maybe someday my wife will come back.
Why would I pay more for a turbocharged four-cylinder truck
when I could get something that tows more and costs less?
Fair, but we'll need to drive them first.
Then we'll talk.
Let's have the Nissan set the bar.
The Frontier now packs a very unique engine for this segment.
It is a 3.8 liter V6, naturally aspirated, making 310 horsepower.
It definitely likes to rev.
Your redline is actually 7,000 RPM.
The VQ engine series has been out for a long time.
This 9-speed automatic, though, is fairly fresh to the Nissan lineup.
It's actually a Mercedes design.
And after some initial hiccups, I do think that they have the software down pretty well here.
It kicks down in gear exactly the way that I want.
Shifts are usually pretty smooth.
When I ask more from the truck, it doesn't really ever feel out of the zone,
like I used to find with the old Tacoma.
The downside here compared to its turbocharged competitors is that
it doesn't have as much of that mid-range power,
so the engine speed will need to be a little bit higher if you really want to accelerate.
Though they've also tuned this to be jumpy, especially from a stop.
You really do not need to give it much throttle for this thing to take off.
While an 8-second sprint to 60 isn't impressive, the truck does feel peppy,
and it sounds much better than the more torquey Tacoma.
This also packs a 7,100-pound tow rating, and the highway fuel economy beat my expectations.
Overall, I think this engine-transmission combo is one of the best parts about the Frontier.
People who really want to test the limits of where a vehicle should go
might opt for the Pro-4X trim, which gives you traditional off-road equipment.
All of these things are going to have underbody protection up front,
but that package is going to get a different suspension tune,
along with a rear-locking differential.
When it comes to how this handles on-road, the Nissan also feels very traditional.
We'll start off with the steering, which is kind of a double-edged sword.
So it is actually hydraulic, something you rarely see these days,
and that's probably because this generation of truck is really just a thorough refresh
on the previous truck, which came out in 2005.
Where electric power steering can change how much weight it has
based on your speed or drive mode, this can't.
So when you're cruising, you know, driving around a back road,
I think this is weighted nicely.
It feels substantial, but still pretty easy to change direction.
But any remotely tight maneuvers will require three-pointers like a fourth-quarter comeback.
By the numbers, this is no worse than the Tacoma,
yet I think it is perceived as worse because of how heavy the wheel is at low speed.
It does require a serious amount of effort during parking maneuvers.
You can probably get used to it, but it is a chore.
Still, it doesn't feel too clumsy.
You have great visibility from this low belt line, making it feel somewhat approachable.
And the ride quality, considering the class of vehicle we're talking about, isn't half bad.
It does have that truck-like jitteriness, but it's kind of soft.
I mean, I hit larger potholes in this thing without it really crashing into the cabin,
and it's not like this has coil-sprung suspension.
It does at least have rear disc brakes.
The design here is basic, but the execution is good.
It's also fairly quiet up at highway speeds,
though don't expect much in terms of modern mannies.
You have adaptive cruise control and a lane departure warning system,
but no lane centering or steering intervention system whatsoever,
something that I think actually appeals to a lot of the Frontier fans.
This is the most expensive Frontier that you're going to find, and it still doesn't touch $50,000.
What does that mean for the interior?
Well, one, it has a very interesting blend of attributes.
Starting things off, I like that the seats here are soft,
and that most trims will have lumbar adjustment, though thigh support is lacking for tall drivers.
What I see people appreciating about the Nissan Cabin the most is how straightforward it is.
This cluster is well laid out.
The new widescreen infotainment on the SV has wireless carplay, and it's responsive.
Even the more basic screen you'll find on the S is snappy.
And the controls here are as simple as they come.
Now, the adequate build quality and cheap materials
may be excusable in a truck like this.
After all, we do want this to be easy to clean, but there's no denying that this does feel old.
The layout, the door handles, the lack of an auto up-down for the passenger windows,
and the lack of power mirrors on the base trim make this feel like it was from a different era.
The Frontier will show its nicer side as you step up the trim lead.
The optional fender audio system is punchy and crisp.
You can get heated seats and a heated steering wheel,
but compared to a new Taco Supreme, the Nissan is down on some toppings.
Surprisingly, this does have a 360 view camera as an option,
but it looks like the camera feed is coming from a dusty BlackBerry.
And because Nissan didn't want to format it to the new screen,
it looks even more like beta software.
Now, sitting behind myself at 6'3", I can fit,
and I have a good amount of knee room for this kind of truck.
However, it's going to be far from comfortable for most taller adults.
At least every Frontier will get a rear window that slides open.
That's actually an added extra for the Tacoma,
and you do have a little bit of storage underneath the rear seats as well.
Both trucks can have 6' beds, but the Frontier can have it in a wider variety of specs.
I appreciate the available bed rail systems you'll find in either truck,
but the Nissan's feels more beefy.
And the small cab Frontier will still give you rear seats that you can use if you're desperate,
something that the Toyota doesn't think is needed.
What I like about the Toyota is that you have a composite bed as standard,
along with some more storage compartments.
Dimensionally, they're pretty similar,
especially here because I have 6' beds equipped on both.
And the payload capacities are similar too.
If you are spending big money, you do get a power rear tailgate,
something that you might think is unnecessary,
but it is really nice whenever you have hands that are full,
and you can just bump it up with your knee.
The problem is, if you want just a damped tailgate,
sometimes you gotta spend $45,000 in order to get it.
They really nickel and dime you for these options.
Now, image is probably more important than it should be when we're talking trucks.
This has led to some very angry, bold designs.
But I do like both of these.
Personally, I lean toward the less busy Frontier.
But let me know what you guys think.
Some of the extra money for the Toyota goes toward a modern interior
that still has common sense.
The seats are supportive.
The storage is plentiful and smart.
The back seat is, well, pretty unremarkable.
The tech is simple but fresh looking.
Wireless CarPlay is standard.
There aren't a bunch of glossy plastics.
And Toyota plays around with the textures too.
There's a lot more character to this design than what you'll find with the Nissan.
While some panel fitment is unimpressive, and I don't think this feels expensive,
it doesn't feel like a disposable tool either.
And if you want it basic, the SR or SR5 give you that for a much more reasonable sum.
It's only when you begin to ask for things like power seats,
or a sunroof, or leather, when you reach the lunacy.
If you have the cash to spend, at least you are rewarded with a nicer cabin than the Nissan,
along with things like ventilated seats, a power rear window,
a much, much better 360 view camera,
and a few other details that the Frontier doesn't get caught up on.
You can choose whether those things will be worth it.
However, you are going to have forced induction.
It's going to have 2.4 liters to work with,
and thankfully, Toyota's had pretty good luck with
turbocharged 4-cylinders when it comes to reliability.
The brand says they've given this the cooling capabilities of a V8
and a commercial-grade turbocharger.
It marks a pretty big step up in usable performance over the previous V6.
Between 3,000 and 5,000 RPM, you have plenty of power to pass.
Flat out, I've gotten this to 60 in the mid-7 second range,
just a smidge ahead of what I found with the Frontier in similar conditions.
While I don't think the 8-speed automatic is as refined
as the 9-speed that you're going to get with the Nissan,
it does make pretty good decisions regarding which gear it needs to be in.
This also enables slightly better fuel economy than what you'll get with the Frontier,
though unfortunately, it will tow less.
Substantially less if you go with the base model,
which does not get the extra transmission cooling and results in a 3,500 pound max.
I wish Toyota didn't nerf the base like that,
but for contractors or people who really just care more about
payload capacity and efficiency, that is a good option still.
With 278 ponies, yeah, this was just the right engine for the job.
It doesn't make the best sounds,
especially if you go with a cheaper spec that doesn't get engine insulation.
This is a very noisy motor then, but yeah, that is,
it does feel a little bit more spry than the Frontier, unless you're foot to the floor.
And adding even more to the options, you can get a hybrid system in here,
which will make this noticeably more responsive,
a little bit quicker, and a little bit more efficient in the city,
but otherwise, it's not going to transform the driving experience or your running costs.
Plus, with that powertrain, the price becomes even harder to bear.
What matters more to me personally is that you can
get a six-speed manual transmission with the Tacoma.
It is a very rare option to find, and it's also not the greatest gearbox that's ever existed,
you know, rubbery long throws.
The last third gen that I drove with that gearbox had awkward gearing as well,
but it's just kind of fun. It's another point of engagement for the driver,
and if you're a car enthusiast who needs a daily driver or a truck to pull,
you know, another car or something, I think you'll like it.
For most other people, yeah, you're probably going to be happier with that automatic.
Oh man.
The ride quality here is unfortunately not as good as the Frontier,
at least here with the firmer shocks of the TRD Sport.
You're going to feel the road quite a bit. It reminds you that it's a truck.
I think the coil spring suspension is going to help out a little bit with control,
and it does make it smoother than the base Toyota Tacoma.
But really, after driving that Frontier and then this,
I think that the TRD Sport here does feel a little bit more poised,
but it is at times harsh in comparison,
and visibility out the front isn't quite as good either.
I think the belt line is definitely higher,
and the big fake hood scoop of the TRD Sport isn't helpful.
Still, I could see a lot of people preferring how the Tacoma drives,
especially in the SR5 or TRD Off-Road grades,
as those would be a little bit more forgiving than this,
and the steering just all around is easier.
Up at higher speeds, it does feel a little bit more precise.
It's also going to be lighter, especially there at low speeds.
Plus, if you're going off-road, that 360 camera is going to be a lot more reliable,
and Toyota is going to give you more tech to get you unstuck as well.
The TRD Off-Road, like the Pro 4X, is going to get a rear-locking differential.
It is also going to get crawl control,
which can break any spinning wheel, including the ones up front,
to help get you out of tricky situations.
Along the front sway bar disconnect to improve articulation,
and if you want to go absolutely crazy,
you can get the TRD Pro or the Trail Hunter,
which make further improvements to the suspension, even changing out the seats.
You're going to find much more configurability with the Tacoma.
As you would expect with this kind of sales volume.
According to the sound meter, this is a smidge quieter than the Frontier.
To my ears, I think there's a little bit less wing noise and a little bit more road noise.
You're also going to find all of the driver aids that you could want,
including a pretty decent lane centering system
that does help reduce fatigue on long drives.
But what about the long haul?
Well, this generation of Tacoma has caught a lot of attention
for switching to a turbocharged engine.
So far, this hasn't been the source of any issues.
However, the 8-speed automatic did have quite a few failures early on.
Reports of that have largely slowed down here in 2025.
We also saw a few reports of manual transmissions not going into even gears.
Recently, we had a rear brake line recall.
And for the people who are really off-roading these things,
the suspension top hat is a known weak point,
though thankfully you can buy reinforcements for pretty cheap.
The latest Frontier has had less severe,
but more common complaints according to the NHTSA and Consumer Reports.
Most notable problems come from the ABS brake module,
faulty cruise control, quality control issues, and infotainment bugs.
There was also a recalled parking pawl that allowed some trucks to roll away.
Owner reviews are generally positive for both of these,
which tells me that most aren't running into serious concerns.
However, given the sheer numbers of Tacomas sold,
it seems like these are racking up complaints
over on NHTSA and Consumer Reports at a slower rate.
In other words, the tried and true V6 is reassuring,
but we do not have the data to prove whether or not the new Tacoma
is more or less reliable than the Frontier or the previous Taco for that matter.
We'll make a more thorough report in five years.
The Nissan Frontier is the truck that the internet seems to constantly ask for,
and the Tacoma is the truck that the market wants.
Now, that's not me saying that the new Frontier should be more like the Tacoma.
It's the true last stand in value-driven internal combustion pickups,
and I hope it stays that way even if it does receive meaningful updates.
But there's no getting around that the Tacoma in the first quarter of this year
has outsold what the Frontier did in all of 2024.
The most important criteria for evaluation is finding out
what was the goal and how well was that executed.
The premise behind the new Tacoma is not to cater to the ultra-traditional truck dude.
Toyota wanted to build a more well-rounded vehicle.
It still needs to be rugged and ready to haul,
but they put more effort into improving the handling over the third gen.
It also has a fresh, comfortable, and practical interior along with any feature you could want
if you're willing to burn more racks than a bad barbecue pit master.
It caters to lifestyle buyers first, but it doesn't forget tradesmen.
The latest Frontier clearly did not have the taco development budget.
Instead of wooing people with the latest features, design, and handling,
they stuck to the truck basics.
Keep it simple, keep it capable, and keep it affordable-ish.
It will never take on the Tacoma for sales with this approach.
However, I find the Nissan charming,
and for the person who has more work to do than desires to fulfill, it's my recommendation.
Thanks for watching, and thank you to my channel members for helping me improve my content.
For more videos, consider joining.
I'll catch you in the next one.
