8 Rare Watches From the Vault: Phillips' Paul Boutros on Hype vs. Value at Auction

Antique Clock
13 followers
1 Video View·Aug 1, 2026
George Mayer is joined by Paul Boutros, Head of Watches for Phillips, about a collection of rare watches pulled from the vault. Using his expertise of both the watch and auction world, Paul breaks down his views on some of the most hyped watchmakers and brands like F.P. Journe, Patek Philippe, Kari Voutilainen, and more. Check out the full interview to see the entire collection!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedGeorge Mayer and Paul Boutros of Phillips discuss the booming independent watch market. They analyze the record-breaking success of brands like F.P. Journe and Kari Voutilainen, the technical appeal of De Bethune and Greubel Forsey, and the enduring prestige of Patek Philippe's neo-vintage era, emphasizing a shift toward wearability and passion-driven collecting.
Hi everyone, I'm George Mayer, and we're here today at the 1916 company headquarters with a
very special guest, Paul Boutros, the head of Americas for Phillips Auction House. Paul,
thanks for coming down. George, thank you so much for having me. Great to see you again.
Likewise. Congratulations on the highest-grossing watch auction in U.S. history in June.
Thank you, sir.
Amazing. And I think the only auction that beat it was the Phillips auction in Geneva the month
prior, correct? Exactly, in May. Yeah, they achieved the highest sale total in history
just a month in advance. Incredible. Congrats on all the success. We've got some really cool
watches here today. Figured we would discuss what happened in the auctions, where we are now,
where you think there may still be some bargains or good values, and where we're heading moving
forward, what trends we're maybe going to see. Yeah. So I think it's indisputable after the last
couple auctions after the season that Jordan is king, correct? Jordan is the new champion,
let's call it, of the field of independence. And we achieved a world record price for any
21st century wristwatch, not for charity, with the subscription resonance number 007,
which achieved $13.9 million, breaking the last record that Jordan Watch achieved in our December
New York auction, the FFC, made for Francis Ford Coppola, which did $10.7 million. So
Jordan is achieving world record prices, and it's amazing to watch. We have a cool one here today.
So I was just showing you. This could be one of the earliest rose gold brass tourbillons ever made.
It was made in 2000. Serial is in the 60s. But third gen, look at that lacquer dial,
the reflection of it. Super silvery sub dial. And then with the very shallow engravings on the case
back. This is just one year after the brand was launched, 1999. So it has a lot of handmade
details. One especially desirable thing about it is the super silvery timekeeping sub dial.
Jordan's objective when he started his brand was to make that sub dial white. And they were
supplied by a subcontractor. In the first few years, they couldn't get them to be white. They
were super silvery, then a little bit less silvery, and a little bit less silvery. And
finally, probably by serial number 1,000, they were white. And he was so happy. And to this day,
these timekeeping sub dials are white. So collectors, when they find super silvery sub
dials, they go crazy. Right. Fully original, hasn't been replaced. And I do believe for a
while they were replacing them. Yes. Now they no longer do the cosmetic reparations or replacements.
Yes. It's pretty fascinating that early on, if you took your early Jordan watch to be serviced
at the factory, Jordan himself was not happy with the color of the dial, wanted to make the watch
look like his original vision. And he would replace the sub dials, sometimes even the main
timekeeping dials to be as flawless or to his vision as possible without alerting the original
owners. So today when a watch comes to us and it's completely original, it's a great thing.
Right. So we were talking about this briefly a short time ago. Where do you see value in the
Jordan line with everything going crazy? Like, what are the best deals or what do you think
hasn't gone as crazy as everything else? Yeah. I think the Sportline, and I'm very happy you
brought this Monopoussoir Rattrapante of the Sport collection within this grouping. I think
this is the absolute best value in Jordan. And they are selling at a fraction really of his more
traditional, you know, precious metal case strap watches. You can't beat them for the price.
The retail prices are quite, you know, reasonable and the secondary market prices relative to
the precious metal strap versions. I think they are a tremendous opportunity for people
trying to get into the brand where an elegant watch, the quartz, you know, time only timepiece.
I think on the secondary market now, if it has a black dial, it's $150,000 plus
for not too much more money. You can get a mechanical, very cool, very wearable,
whether it's precious metal or titanium, high quality Jordan sport watch. That's just a great
value. Right. And the split second chronograph is definitely one of the most difficult complications
to produce. I've heard great watchmakers say maybe the second after a chiming mechanism.
And this particular movement, which was designed off the movement that was produced for only watch
this one now has the date, right? That original one didn't. So the movement's gorgeous,
incredibly complicated and it's very thin. Yep. Very wearable. It's a mono pusher. So it's really
the hardest execution. Oftentimes watchmakers will put a third pusher and they'll put it at
the 10 o'clock position, which is a bit of a shortcut to make it a mono pusher with a single
button to be able to start, stop and reset is very difficult to do. And it just shows you how
good Jordan is as a watchmaker to make it so thin, but also so complex and to be relatively affordable
across this product. Right. And it's funny, I think intrinsic value or inherit value is one of
the least determining factors now for auction value, market value. I say that, you know, an
example, a mother of Pearl CS, you know, simple watch, an amazing watch, an icon, right. And he's
no longer doing mother of Pearl dials, but this watch time power reserve subseconds went for
500,000 all in at your recent auction. Right. And then, you know, a big chunk of gold with a
much more complicated movement goes for around half that. $250,000 to $300,000 on the secondary
market for a solid pink gold bracelet split seconds chronograph versus a time only manually
wound relatively simple, simple timepiece. This is why I think this is the place of opportunity,
the line of opportunity, the sport line. Yep. I'm with you. Where collectors should maybe pay
attention to. Totally agree. Another brand that's really taken off more recently has been Kari
Boutilainen. I know you had several seven figure results. Yes, it's incredible. We had four different
Boutilainens in our June auction and every single one of them broke seven figures. And it was
remarkable to watch. Right. Well, we have a very special one here today. We have what could very
well be the first ever, I think it actually was confirmed, the first ever Vontuit white dial here.
Pretty special piece, huh? Incredible. It is serial number 001 with a white dial, silver
guilloche dial. Fantastic look. And it's Kari's basically first fully in-house time only movement.
And it's a pretty important historical piece with that serial number. I think it's incredible.
And what do you think is the reason why Boutilainens went to a whole nother level
when they were trading for maybe a quarter of what they're going for now within the last year?
Yeah, I think it has to do with the rise of independence in general. I think the
very strong prices of Jorn on the secondary market has lifted all boats, so to speak. And any
watch maker whose name is on the dial and is still making watches and is recognized as being
an innovator with outstanding hand finishing, you're seeing tremendous demand for these types
of watches on the secondary market, especially at auction. Boutilainen ticks all those boxes.
His name is on the dial. He's making and designing these pieces and the finishing
quality is as good as it gets. And so the market is seeking that today. And more and more people
are discovering watches in general, and especially are fascinated by watches whose
makers are still alive today. And it's just driving demand, which drives prices relative
to very limited supply. I think Boutilainen, if I were to guess, has made maybe 500 to a
thousand watches at most over the course of his brand's existence. And so the supply is extremely
thin. So you just said finishing at the highest level. I would certainly put Grubel Forsey in
that category. I would absolutely agree. In fact, I'm going to go on record as saying, I told you
this earlier too, I think Grubel is the brand that could probably take off the most from where it is
right now. It's really starting to pick up. They make some of the nicest watches in the world,
some of the best complications. Their finishing is next level. I would say probably as good as it
gets, can certainly rival anyone. Here we have a limited edition stainless steel, 33 pieces,
Balenciaga Contemporain, sub 40 millimeters, 39 millimeters and change, I believe it is.
Super cool, simple watch. Where I think Grubel is now getting it right is their watches are smaller
and more wearable for more people. And I know you just had one of these in white gold at your
recent auction and it did quite well. Yep. It had a silver dial, also a limited edition of 33 pieces
in white gold, and that did $250,000 against, I think, a $120,000 starting bid. This one in
stainless steel with the blue dial, I would expect a similar result, but I absolutely agree with you.
The finishing quality is truly as good as it gets. The wearability of this piece is just perfect for
so many wrist sizes. And yeah, Grubels are actually, I do agree with you that they're
quite undervalued for the amount of quality you get. And the ones that I would be pursuing are
especially those that have the smaller case sizes, traditional 40 millimeters or slightly less.
This is 39.6 millimeters. It's just a perfect size for so many people. Right. And that's where
they're trending. They just launched the new QM Quality Musée, 298 parts finished to a new standard.
And there's been really strong demand for that watch already. And I know they have some more
iterations coming out in the future that I've been privy to, fortunately, and I'm super optimistic
and excited about the future of Grubel and where they're heading. Yeah, so I was excited to see
the QM launch and very happy to see that it was, you know, a reasonable size. And yeah, I think
it's a brand to watch. Yeah. And again, I think with all these other watches going for such strong
prices, you start to look at a relative basis. Grubel, you know, offers some value. For the
quality, yeah, I think it's tremendous. So another brand that's starting to get pulled up, I think, by
all the independent rise is a brand near and dear to us, Debefoon, right? And I know that
you've had some recent strong auction results with DB. You know, there was the first ever
in-house movement DB sold at your last auction, the DB15 that, you know, brought over 400,000.
Here we have another DB25 case. This is a Hacking Seconds Deadbeat Seconds Tourbillon
Zodiac with the 12 signs of Zodiac signs on the dial. Unbelievable hand-engraved work.
So this being a fixed lugs piece, you know, you have the fixed lugs line with the DB25 and then
the flex lugs with the DB28, and we brought one of those as well. But this is super cool where you
can see on the back, you have the signature Delta bridge and the 2009 patented balance wheel
here on the back, which you can see. But another gorgeous watch. What are your thoughts on DB?
Yeah. So I think Debefoon is a brand that people don't realize how great the watchmaking truly is
in their pieces. Denis Flageolet is a watchmaking genius, I'll say. And if you examine the details,
the finishing quality, the escapements used, it's just as good as it gets. The aesthetic
is different. It's not a classic kind of classically styled timepiece like a Joran.
But if you're someone looking for a watch that's unusual off the beaten track, absolutely a
conversation piece, and you are seeking outstanding quality, Debefoon is a brand to consider.
Love it. And then also brought out a DB28XS. So this 38.7 millimeters titanium flex lugs.
This is a random guilloché dial. So it's called the Starry Seas because the dial emulates
stars reflecting off of water, off of the random guilloché dial. On the back, you have the
2016 patented balance wheel, titanium with white gold balls, and twin barrel, five-day power reserve.
This watch, you know, more sporty. I would say that this is also a little bit more of a classic
design. You, in your last auction, had the zirconium case, aerolite dial, which is pretty
crazy. So proprietary meteorite with random guilloché on top of it. Which was a spectacular
dial to look at. Yep. And that piece did very well. Yeah. Went for well over what the retail
price was. It did very well. And it is a brand I highly recommend to collectors. If you just
look at the movements, they're unlike anything out there. You know, the structure of
the bridges is for stability. It's a triangle and truss, basically, which is one of the strongest
for robustness and stability and shock resistance that a watchmaker could design.
And they really push the state of the art of watchmaking. You mentioned these proprietary
balance wheels. They're built for timekeeping precision, which is something you have to respect
for a brand to be doing. Right. And both Francois-Paul Jorin and Denis Filagile
made watches that they wanted to be worn. And, you know, Jorin always makes super thin watches.
I always say that I think they're the ultimate package of beauty, technology, craftsmanship,
and wearability. I agree. And I think that there are a lot of amazing watches out there that are
just too top heavy. They don't sit well on the wrist. The balance and proportions aren't correct.
Correct. Yeah. Right. And, you know, DB now is really focusing on making watches that are
ultra wearable. You can wear them during activity, sport. They hug the wrist well, able to withstand
impact and acceleration. So it's cool seeing more and more people really enjoying wearing the watch.
Yeah. And these articulating lugs of the DB28 series, it's awesome. They conform to the wrist.
That thinness and, you know, relative to the diameter, it's so well done.
So as there's been all this Indy rage, as I would call it, which is well deserved,
I have to say to people, and, you know, they've had some strong results too during the Indy rage,
but Patek Philippe was king, is king, will always be king, probably.
Patek Philippe, Rolex, the blue chip brands of our industry, and Patek Philippe remains a king.
Yes. I totally agree.
And you've had some really strong results there. The 5004 piece unique that did really well. I
think you had a unique 5970 rose gold black dial.
Yes. One of probably five.
One of five. Okay.
Wasn't unique.
That did very well. Yeah. This is the era of Philippe Stern. The last of the Philippe Stern
sort of designed timepieces, the 5970.
Yellow gold rarest.
This one that we have here. Yeah. It's the rarest of the four metals that they produced
in series. Yellow gold, rose gold, white gold, and platinum. This one made for one year only
in yellow gold. I think the 5970 is one of the greatest watches of the 21st century. I think it
was introduced in 2004, replacing the 3970, which was produced for about 18 years. The 3970 is
seeing tremendous interest. There's a really strong following for neo-vintage 1980s, 1990s
timepieces. The 3970 is seeing tremendous demand as are 3940s, the perpetual calendar, simple
perpetual calendar versus the perpetual calendar chronograph. The 5970 was produced only until
2010. So 2004 to 2010, so six year production. Across four metals.
Across four metals.
That weren't always made at the same time, right?
Correct. Correct. So there's little overlap and only the rose gold and the white gold were
produced simultaneously. So there's less out there. And today, the prices relative to what
we're seeing in the 3970s, I think this is a great place for collectors to focus, where the value
is great for money.
Yeah. I mean, again, if we're doing a comparison, the fact that a perpetual calendar chronograph,
Lamagna-based movement, gorgeous, iconic watch, one of the most iconic Patek Philippes ever,
is trading for roughly half the price of a Mother of Pearl CS.
Right.
Again, it makes me question the market values and think that we might see some changes moving
forward.
Yeah. And there's some details that I like to point out to people when I talk to them about
3970s and 5970s that really aren't done today in the modern versions of this. The balance wheel
has eight masses. Now they use four masses. It's a free sprung balance, just like today's
version, the 5270. The minute hand and the chronograph hand are curved. Today, they're
flat. It has a Geneva seal and it has several interior angles on the movement, which you
don't see so much of today. So the finishing quality really is exceptional. It's like a
part of a different era of Patek Philippe that I would love to see come back.
Do you think that the neo-vintage resurgence or increase in interest, I should say, will
cross over to more brands? I know we've seen some of it in Audemars Piguet, Vacheron, Daniel
Roth, pre-95 Daniel Roth, maybe even starting to trickle over a little bit into 90s Breguet
before Swatch Group purchased the brand.
Yes. Yep. I do see people nostalgic for the watches they aspired to own when they were
young. Maybe they saw it on their parents. Maybe they saw it on their parents' friends'
wrists in the 1990s and early 2000s, even back into the 1980s. And we're seeing
significant demand for this era. I do feel that there are other brands like Breguet with the
to take a look. The watches are gorgeous. They're a little bit smaller, which fit most
wrist sizes. They ooze class when you see them on people's wrists. 1990s Cartier crashes,
they're doing really strongly at auction because it's a unique size. There were some great
watches being made in the post-quartz crisis era. Even Gerald Genta was making the Mickey
Mouse timepieces. Many fun things to discover from the 80s, 1990s into the early 2000s that
it's a fun place to focus as a collector. Yeah, for sure. You said the word nostalgic,
and I think nostalgia and the social aspect behind watches are two of the main drivers now.
I think that people look back to these older watches that remind them of certain people,
certain events. And now more than ever, people love getting together and sharing in the passion
with others. A hundred percent, I think. We've seen it here at the 1916 company. I know Philips
seems to be doing more events. We do a lot of community building events. We love to spread
the word about the greatness of watches. We know sometimes it's difficult to learn about all the
nuances, different brands, different parts of the watch. And we're here to try to spread that
knowledge. And these societies and communities that are spreading around the world, we're so
happy to see it. Do you think that watch buyers today, auction buyers, are more knowledgeable
than ever? Yes, without a doubt. Knowledge is out there. Back in the 1980s, 1990s, even into
the early 2000s, there was very few places where you could find information. Now with so many watch
catalogs being published, with social media, great content provided by Tim Masso, your colleague,
that's easily accessed. I think knowledge is power. And empowered people are less hesitant
and more willing to go out and make these significant purchases because they're able
to find the information readily accessible. And you're seeing more young blood come into
the game too, right? Yes. From my perspective, watches have become mainstream. We used to be
the rare people who were interested in watches and trying to convince our friends to get into them.
People didn't want to hear about it. But I think with the rise of social media, with so many
celebrities discovering the greatness of watches and being so visible to the public, it's spread.
And now it's amazing to see how many people around the world have discovered this collecting
genre that we love so much. And it's really great to see. Yeah. No, it's certainly become an asset
class. That's for sure. Whereas I was always hesitant to go there and I still am. I mean,
look, I think you should be buying watches out of love and passion first and foremost. But the
have gotten so crazy that you do need to treat them as part of your portfolio when we're talking
about- Your values are high. Yeah. We do not recommend to purchase watches as investments.
Buy watches because you love them. Some of them may go up in value. Some of them may keep their
same value. Some of them may go down in value. But if you're buying watches that you love,
if they happen to go down in value, at least you have something you love.
They will last an eternity as long as you take care of them and treat them as such.
Tangible. Wonderful things to own that keep a significant portion of their value, if anything.
Right. Okay. So give us a little prediction on where you think things are going to close. I
know it's loaded. It's hard to say. You don't have a crystal ball, but do you expect
Indies continue to rise? Do you think it trickles over to more independents? Do you think
the independent rage consolidates? Do you think the neo-vintage craze continues? What else do you
think hasn't barely been discovered yet? This is a good question. And as you said,
you said it right. Nobody has a crystal ball. What we are seeing is just more and more people coming
into watches. In any one of our auctions, every single one, we have a significant portion being
sold to brand new bidders to fill it. That's great. And I'm sure you're seeing it on the
retail side. Many new clients keep coming in week after week. And this is wonderful.
What we're seeing, of course, lately is the rise of the independents,
the continued strength of brands like Patek Philippe, Rolex, Audemars Piguet, Cartier,
Vacheron Constantin. Those established brands continue to do well and will continue to do well.
Independent collecting is quite young. Remember, Joran launched in 1999. By the time there was a
lot of watches to collect across brands, Joran, De Bethune, Voutilainen, it took years for there
to be enough watches to collect. Today, we're at a point where maybe there's 20,000 mechanical
Jorans ever made, 1,000 Voutilainens at most. Other brands like De Bethune, you know better.
5,000.
5,000 overall. Now there's a significant number to collect. They're funner to collect because you
can acquire them. We're at the beginning. This is not a trend. This is a development,
a development in the field of watch collecting. And I think it's here to stay. People enjoy the
process of interacting directly with the living watchmaker. People love the uniqueness of their
designs. I think so long as these independent brands continue to make great product, which they
are, they continue to push the state of the art of watchmaking, and they continue to treat clients
well and customers well, offering a great watch at a fair price, it's going to continue to grow.
And they're here to stay, in my humble opinion.
Love it. Awesome. Well, already looking forward to next auction season. Thanks so much for coming
here today, Bob. Appreciate you.
Thank you, George. Thank you for this wonderful spread and always a pleasure to talk to you.
Likewise.
Hi, I'm Tim of the 1916 Company, announcing our all-new 1916 Company app. Check out our
all-new community features, including wrist time, where you can log the watch you wear,
how often you wear your watches, and see a graphical representation of how you use your
collection. But wait, there's more, because this wrist time feature allows you to post in real
time to our live feed of user wrist shots. Our community functions also include professionally
moderated discussions, all sorts of views, debate, insights into what people want to say about the
watches of our times. And all your favorite features are coming back, including media,
editorial from Jack Forster, video from yours truly. You can continue to build your online
collection and your wish list, plus all the commercial features are back.
Buy, trade, and sell through the app. Browse our global inventory of pre-owned new watches.
A wrist shot can begin the process of a trade or a purchase.
Find the 1916 Company app on the Apple App Store and Google.
