Canon Cameras Are Unlike Everyone Else

Photo Camera Landscape Expert
201 followers
#PhotoCamera, #LandscapePhotography, #PhotographyExpert, #NatureShots, #ScenicViews, #OutdoorPhotography, #CameraGear, #LandscapeExpert, #TravelPhotography, #WideAngleShots, #PhotographySkills, #NaturalBeauty, #CameraTips, #PhotographyMastery, #LandscapeLovers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTwo hosts critique community-submitted photographs, focusing on the technical execution of motion blur and long exposures. The discussion explores the intersection of traditional photography and AI, covering AI's role in conceptualization and retouching, while analyzing specific images of animals, urban scenes, and landscapes to evaluate composition and authenticity.
Hey, guys, welcome to the next Critique the Community.
Today, we're going to be critiquing images with motion blur.
And if you would like to be a part of the next critique, it starts right now.
You can head over to fstoppers.com slash contest.
The next genre is we're going to be doing A.I.
augmented or supplemented photos, so they need to have an element
of real photography in them.
But you've somehow enhanced them or built upon them with A.I.
maybe to edit or expand the canvas.
I won't say too much, but you've been doing a lot of this, haven't you?
Yeah, I mean, it's getting so good now that I'm really just using A.I.
to just generate full images.
I'm doing lots of stuff with my hot sauce business, Olivium.
Just I've taken really good looking, highly edited pictures of my sauce
and box and everything, and I'm just uploading that.
And then I'm just telling it like, hey, put this in this different environment.
And a year or two ago, I had to do this manually.
I would generate these backgrounds with A.I.
I would take the pictures of my product and then I'd put them in there.
And now I'm getting the best results with ChatGPT.
It just does amazing job.
Like I'm about to put a box for sale online that has 12 boxes inside.
And so I just said, hey, just make up Amazon listing photo with 12 of these.
And it's coming up with ideas of things that I'd never really thought about.
Like, should it be in a box and you can kind of see them all?
Should they be piled on top of each other?
Should they be stacked?
And so it really just helps you come up with ideas, too.
Even if even if for some reason nobody would think,
but even if for some reason you were like, I hate A.I.
and like, I'll never use A.I. and I'm going to take the photos myself.
You could still use it to come up with the idea.
Yeah. And then you could shoot it.
Because a lot of times it's awful about being a photographer
is you're really paid to be the creative director, right?
But when A.I.
throws out an option that you didn't think of, that's better
than what you would have done, even if you go and shoot it for real.
Yeah. You're still like, man, this concept.
Well, and then the problem, the problem is, is like,
not only is the concept better than what I came up with,
but then the finished image, I'm like, it already looks perfect.
Why? Why would I spend all day photographing this?
When I can just like fix the logo and it's perfect.
I don't need like the logo.
That was always a problem.
The text, little text on stuff, you know, a few years ago
is people's fingers and stuff.
All that's gone now. It's all perfect now.
And it's free. It's free.
Like maybe I paid 20 bucks a month for the chat GPT one.
But like if you don't pay for it, I think it's free for you.
But those poor little towns in Indiana that have those data centers
humming away, they have no water and they're just worse off.
So yeah. Anyway, so the next genre, A.I.
Augmented, we want to see photos that you've used A.I.
and photography together in some way.
And we want to hear the story.
So make sure you write not too much because we're not going to read it,
but write, you know, the basic premise of how you use the two together.
Let's get into this critique.
All right. So we're starting off with
an image where I'm not even sure I know what's going on here.
This looks like she getting run over.
Is she doing back handsprings, you know, side by side?
Or is she somehow got her leg in the stirrup
and is like hanging off this horse?
I mean, I see your hand now.
It kind of feels like she is.
I think he's about to pick something up off the ground.
I don't know about that.
I think she does.
I would think she doesn't want to touch the ground.
That could be disastrous.
But it feels like she's like
doing like a BMX move on the horse.
Yeah, but I mean, it looks like she's about to grab something.
It's funny.
I recently went to a rodeo
in Mars Hill, North Carolina.
I don't want to speak ill of these people.
This is where you went to college in the area.
I was like an hour or two away.
But is there that much variation?
Oh, my God.
The people at this thing were crazy.
And then the stuff I'm trying to even remember
all the stuff that I saw going on, like a lot of it's a blur now.
But the thing that I remember the most, they had these little kids
like I don't know how old they were, six, seven.
And they would put them on sheep.
And I'm trying to remember if they were on the back of the sheep
hugging the neck or if they were under the sheep
holding on like this. Yeah.
And they would just let these sheep go
and they would be running 100 miles an hour in this pig pen.
And these kids would just be holding on.
And like, I don't even know what the goal was.
Sounds kind of awesome, though.
I don't know. It was the craziest thing I've ever seen.
It's easy to judge, but I could also see that being really fun as a kid.
It was like a dream or a nightmare.
No, no, no.
But the kids would let go and everybody would cheer
for these little kids on these sheep.
And I'm like, how is this real life?
How is this a real thing?
I can't believe I'm here right now.
It was wild. It was wild.
And this already, like the fact that she's wearing an outfit
and the horse is wearing an outfit.
This is a whole other level of production than the one I went to.
Yeah, I was just sat like a mud pit on the side of the highway.
Yeah. Some of these rodeos, you know, I know we've gone to the bullfights
in Spain and then I've gone to some like chicken like cockfighting in Mexico.
They used to have a lot of it here in Puerto Rico.
But it's banned now, right?
I think it's banned, but there's still right by the airport.
There's still a huge cockfighting arena just right there.
All right. Let's rate this image.
Three, two, one. I'm going three stars.
I think it's a solid image.
It's certainly interesting.
Is it too much motion blur or have we gotten too picky
about things being too sharp?
Like in the 80s and 90s, this would be 100% acceptable.
The other weird thing that I just noticed about this,
the motion blur has definitive lines to it.
What do you attribute that to?
Do you think that is somehow like this was taken with a Canon T2i?
I don't think the camera sensor should have anything weird.
Do you think what we're seeing is the refresh rate of the light?
So like the light is flickering at 60 hertz.
Are you saying these lines up here in the top, like above her?
Yeah. And on the horse's hooves, you can see these lines.
It almost looks like a cloning thing.
Yeah, but I kind of like it.
You would think that if it's a constant light,
it would just be like a light streak like you'd see with a car.
Right. But instead, you're capturing the pulse of the.
I think it's like cheap outdoor.
I don't know. Fluorescence, the right term.
But, you know, like cheap lights on light poles that are flickering
and the human eye probably can't see it, but the camera.
But shouldn't that be consistently?
I mean, it is kind of happening throughout the entire scene.
But then if you look at this over here,
there's some lines that are very straight that don't have the blur.
Maybe that just has to do with distance.
No, that's the motion of the camera.
The camera is panning with the horse.
But what is this building right here?
This building shouldn't all those lines be moved to.
But they're sort of straight.
But they're they're not moving.
The vertical lines are showing up, but the horizontal lines are not
because the camera is being moved horizontally.
I don't know. There's something weird with the brightness.
You'd think all the vertical lines would be like repeated
in the exact same brightness.
Like, look at the hooves, like one of the back legs,
is it brighter than the other?
It's kind of all exactly the same exposure and also above the horse,
like every one of these like diagonal lines,
they're all basically the exact same exposure.
But when you go over to the far right, it just feels like whatever
that structure is, it's almost like it's been flashed.
Yes, it does.
And then it's got the repetitive.
It does feel like that.
Any detail?
No, they don't really tell us how this flash and second curtain.
So there is some flash.
Oh, so maybe that explains.
Good eye. Good eye, Patrick.
Well, the flash on a Rebel T2i is usually the pop up flash.
Maybe. But it was also taken on a Rebel T2i
with a 70 to 200 millimeter F2.8 lens.
So this was taken with like a $400 camera
with a $3,000 lens on it, which is a little strange.
It's all in the glass.
I guess so. All right, let's move on.
This is super interesting.
I really like this.
But of course, I assume that this is fake.
Now, now I'm second guessing.
I just when I first saw this, I was like, all right, the motion blur has been added.
How can the stick be sharp?
Well, the whole bird is sharp, except the wings and like maybe the legs.
It doesn't make sense.
I feel like the bird is not moving fast enough for the shutter
to introduce motion blur.
But the wings are it's like the hummingbirds aren't all hummingbird photos.
The wings are blurry, but the birds keep sharp.
But the hummingbird is a little bit faster moving than this bird, I would think.
So let's read what he says here.
I am blown away here.
But the way that Mark Moll has suggested he shot this.
This is real.
And he is saying that he shot this with a slow pan
at one fortieth of a second.
This is on what, like a 50 millimeter?
Are you joking?
Last last episode, I said something like, oh, this looks like a shot at one
30 millimeters was like a tiger.
And you guys were all like, are you insane?
That's a 400. Yeah.
He doesn't say this is more than 50.
He doesn't say what could be 50 with like a 10 crop factor.
But wow, I just I've never seen.
And look, OK, here's a question.
What is that blurry thing under the beak?
Well, that's his wing.
Not not to the left and behind his head, directly under his yellow beak.
What is that? This this?
Yeah, that's just part of it.
The bird, it's like it flapped up and then it came down.
I would assume.
But it looks like the end of the there is a weird
there is a weird line going right under the red.
Yeah, but I feel like that's just something like weird
that happens with digital sensors.
Don't you sometimes get a weird line and people say it's a ghost or spirit or
it just it just looks like that last wing is way bigger than the right wing.
But maybe that's just the perspective.
I think it's yeah, I think it's a perspective.
But yeah, it's just it's just wacky to me to see the feet be blurry
and the face of this bird and more important.
OK, I do see a little bit of blur on the tips of the branch that he's holding.
But what do you think this bird's doing?
Like, is he building a nest?
I would guess that would make the most sense.
I was wondering if there's like insects on the stick
that he's taken back to eat or like, why is he transporting a nest?
Yeah, wild, wild image and then very beautiful
color shift in the background, you know?
Oh, I was going to say the color of the birds.
Like, it's just not a boring looking bird.
Yeah, it almost looks like is it Ripley from Metroid?
Something like that.
One of those alien birds.
Pterodactyl ish.
Don't remember that.
Let's rate it.
All right. Three, two, one, four stars.
I mean, I don't disagree with you necessarily.
It's just kind of pretty.
It's just better than the last shot, though, right?
And you get the last three.
But see, the problem is like the three is a big bell curve,
you know, where a lot of stuff can fall on a three.
And as you get over to the fours and fives, like fewer images
kind of fall into it. But next up.
All right. I've only looked at the thumbnails from this critique so far.
But this without question was my favorite thumbnail.
And look at all the sensor dust that he left on there.
So does that mean that this was shot?
I would immediately think seeing sensor dust
that this is shot at a really small aperture, because at f4, even 5.6,
you're probably not going to get it would make sense
because a lot of times you would stop down your lens
so that you could lengthen your shutter and a bright scene.
So it only kind of seems natural that it's a small aperture
with a long exposure, right?
But it gives it such an old timey feel like this almost looks like,
you know, pre like at the beginning of photography,
like the pre digital camera, right? Pre film.
I mean, it's not pre film, but it's, you know, pre modern film.
So this photographer wrote the most annoying description.
It's just everything to do with horses and their relationship to the rider
and the most ridiculous flowery language ever.
And nothing about actually taking the photo, the camera,
the camera, setting the lens, anything.
Could it be the script that he threw into AI?
This is what he wrote.
And then I'm submitting this to a photography contest.
They love bullshit. Please write something for me.
That's what it seems like.
Oh, I don't mean write the write up from AI.
I mean, like he actually wrote this and threw it into the image creator.
And this is what it made.
I mean, again, when people start saying things like
I don't like AI images, I'm like,
what I think you mean is you don't like ultra polished
AI images because AI could make any AI could make a lot of them now.
The first thing it asks is like, what style do you want?
And it could be like old film or it could be modern or clean or,
you know, Scorsese.
Like you could have all these like different directors points of view.
I don't think AI typically would make sensor dust like this
unless you specifically wouldn't think so.
And then the other weird thing that's going on in the background,
you see these cubes like above the horse's head
and above the writer's head at the top.
There are these weird cube shapes.
Those are just windows, some kind of window where like
it's been panned and it's caused the windowsill to.
OK, I don't know. That looks weird to me.
But I absolutely love this image.
This image is like incredible.
And I'm trying to decide right now, do I like the sensor dust?
Do I like the weird cube shapes in the background?
Or would I remove those?
What do you think?
Really, there's only two that bother me.
It's the one right above the horse's head,
and then it's the one straight up above the writer's head.
Those are like, for some reason, the most geometric.
The other ones are all a little more abstract.
Yeah, the only ones I notice.
The sensor dust is one of those things where I think it bothers me as a photographer.
But I think the average person doesn't even see this at all.
Like they don't care.
One speck of sensor dust on one of my images.
I'm like, ah, my camera's ruined.
I can't. So that's the thing.
I think if it had one speck or two specks, I would be like, you got to clone that out.
But when there's so much, it almost just makes it feel like really intentional.
It's like if you had like fake scratches on an image or something.
Yeah, look like the negative was cut up.
Yeah, I feel like it's a better than if you have one ran.
It's like that with flyaways.
You have like one strand across the face.
You're like, clean it up.
OK, but if you have a bunch, it kind of feels like it was intentional.
Are you ready to rate this?
Yeah. All right.
One, two, three.
I still don't know what portfolio.
I thought about doing five on this.
Yeah, I just think this is such a wild, beautiful, artistic looking image.
I don't really know what to say about it.
It's just like there's something magical about this.
And I I like weird crops on it, too.
Maybe that's a little tight for me.
But like, is he wearing a tie like that?
It's pretty cool.
I think one thing that makes this image really interesting is that his wardrobe
feels like prehistoric because, but you know what I mean?
Like, it feels like he's in the Middle East or something.
It feels like he's wearing.
Well, it is in Upper Egypt.
Oh, there you go.
Like, it just feels like he's not in modern clothing.
And that kind of makes the image feel a little more timeless.
But then I'm like, is he wearing a tie or is that just like an opening in his shirt?
Let's move on.
So at the end of this, we probably should still rate our three favorite images
from the whole critique just to give people like that badge of honor.
Oh, because we are giving away.
Because everyone, and we didn't say this at the beginning, but for this contest,
every single person is going to win a free tutorial.
Oh, my goodness. Made the episode.
But that still means that we could have our top three favorites.
Sure. So sure.
But you've already won.
If you've been featured, you can send me a private message.
Lee Morris on fstoppers.com.
Let me know which tutorial you would like.
Now, I know in the comments of these contests for the last like year or so,
people always want more street photography.
And so I thought this one stood out.
Yeah. And I don't know if this is like a statue here.
Almost looks like it's out of like a Disney movie or something.
But I'm going to guess that the buildings back there,
this is some European city or something.
I don't know. I'm pretty sure this is Puerto Rico.
This is Sector 66.
I love this.
Super interesting.
Little bit of weird haloing going on on that dome in the back,
which makes me think it was a lot darker and they brightened it up a little bit
much, which I'm fine with you brightening it up.
But it seems like there's a little glowy halo around it,
which I don't like very much.
I would think that that's more to bring the detail in the sky
because that dome should be brighter because it sits higher than.
OK, so then what I think they've done is they just added a very thick vignette
to the top, which might feel it feels a little bit too heavy handed to me.
Maybe the other thing that I don't know that I like is that weird red
thing right behind the biker, like the hot dog stand.
Yeah, it is like I feel like I would like this so much more
if that wasn't in there at all.
And you could argue that's a huge part of this whole image.
But and not like the photographer can take it down.
But with AI, you could remove it with a single click.
Have you used the erase feature on the iPhone photo app?
Yeah, I just recently discovered that.
Like, how can I be a professional photographer and not know that exists?
And I'm like, this is freaking incredible.
Just retouching is right there.
Yeah. In case you guys haven't used it before, you literally pull up an image,
hit the erase button and the iPhone will highlight everything in the image
that it thinks you may not want in there.
And then you just touch what you want to go away.
You're thinking of the same thing, right?
OK, I just showed my mom this and she's like, no way.
My mom used to email me stuff.
I'd have to Photoshop and then send it back to her.
I'm like, now is it good with I get emailed a lot of like
children's pictures, school pictures,
because they always have the proofing on it.
And my sister's like, can you just remove them?
It used to be in Photoshop or certain applications.
It would not want to remove watermarks.
But I feel like everything's released now.
Anything's on the table.
It's the Wild Wild West.
Let's rate this image.
Three, two, one.
I'm going for I think I love it.
I'm between a two and a three.
You're being an asshole today.
Any details on the.
I just I just feel like how this was shot.
Oh, oh, Dresden.
We've we've been to Dresden.
Nothing about the camera.
I think Dresden was this the time that Igor tried to like climb a stop sign
and fell on his ass or something.
Maybe, maybe you guys wouldn't know that story.
But there was the trip that we met a Lila Cardi.
Like we did this huge trip around Europe.
And Dresden was I think is Dresden.
Also, it's like one of those cities in Germany right on the border
where I think it was like our Airbnb guy was telling us like
100 percent of the city was destroyed or something crazy like in World War Two.
He said they already built it back to look like this.
Everything you see is like a recreate.
I could be wrong. I could be.
I mean, these buildings here look kind of modern.
It literally says in the description, Dresden was destroyed
during World War Two and rebuilt in long stages.
There you go.
Anyway, I love the image.
My first thought is get rid of that red cart thing.
And then my second image.
My second thought is, do I want to get rid of the van
and that trailer on the left side?
I kind of like the van and the trailer.
They they have that super dark.
And part of me wonders if the photographer
removed the saturation from both of those things, because like
who sells a dark gray van like that with no color whatsoever?
And then I've seen one of those in our neighborhood before.
That's a little creepy.
You're like, who is riding that van around?
Yeah, but, you know, it seems kind of the same with that trailer.
Like there seems to be logos on it.
Who would make a trailer with a black and white logo?
But anyway, that red cart just kind of ruins it for me a little bit.
I still give it four stars. I love this image.
And you see what I have on my table right here.
Yeah, you talked about.
No, not that I talked about this last month.
You still haven't installed this after all that?
I this is supposed to be a long story.
I know. I know.
I'll keep that off camera because it's a touchy subject.
It's not a touchy subject.
I just I started and then I realized I needed another power cable over here.
And I just OK.
Well, you have something else much more value.
Canon. Yeah.
I don't feel like I have held a Canon camera in 10 years.
I've always wanted Canon because we were Nikon shooters.
And then we kind of moved over to Sony.
And we've also been Panasonic shooters.
But Canon is the largest camera company in the world.
It's so crazy.
So I I went to Acadia National Park and I thought I'm going to just review
a camera on something new I haven't tried in a while.
So I don't even know what I don't even know what Canon camera I have.
The video will come out.
So I get the camera, I get the lens, I put it on, I charge it up.
And I'm just like, all right, I'm just going to figure it out
when I get to Acadia.
So it's just the type of thing.
Like, I'm not going out trying to take pictures.
Is that on main?
Yeah, I'm going out with family
and I just have the camera on me and it's available.
And as always, you know, there's like, oh, it's a pretty view, but it's not.
Yeah, I might as well just take it on my phone or whatever.
But I took a few with the Canon camera.
And oh, my gosh, just every one of the main settings
that you would use is reversed on the Canon camera.
So like the big one is the zoom on the lens, right?
So like I'm used to turning to the right to zoom in on Nikon,
Sony, Panasonic.
They're all one way.
Maybe even Fuji is like all that way.
And then Canon is the opposite.
That's annoying, but I can get used to it.
Then shutter speed, aperture, ISO, all reversed.
I was there for a week using this camera.
I never got used to it.
Not one time did I get used to the settings of these things.
Which makes you it begs the question, would you prefer to know
how to use 90% of the other cameras you just mentioned?
Or to be proficient with only the Canon
and in every other camera you pick up, you're like, oh, yeah,
you can pick up most any other camera.
It just feels normal because they all work one way.
Yeah, kind of strange.
I just did not know that their buttons were all reversed like that.
And then I was expecting Canon's menu was going to be like super friendly.
And like, you know, it's huge and like confusing,
like Sony's was the first time I used it.
And so I expected to kind of fall in love with Canon.
I there was a small chance that the first camera I ever got was going to be Canon
and like my whole life would be different now had I got that rather than my Nikon.
I haven't put a ton of time into this camera.
I just kind of used it for fun as we were hiking around.
But I have not gotten over that hurdle yet of like
becoming comfortable with using it yet, which is a shock to me.
And so I feel like I can't finish this review until I put more time in
and like really give it a fair shot, because right now, every time I used it
was just frustration every single time.
Yeah. I don't know if that's an interesting story.
I probably shouldn't have told you that.
But it makes me wonder like those, you know, commercial photographers,
people like Monty Isom, who don't really even own cameras
and they just rent whatever the client wants.
Yeah. You know, if they find the same frustrations of like having to use
a Hasselblad and then go to a Canon, then I got to shoot a Nikon.
Like when I switch cameras, it kind of like drives me crazy.
And one saving grace with AI is I don't even look through the menu anymore.
I'm just like, where is the setting to turn off the eye focus, whatever it is?
And it'll just tell me where to go.
But, you know, three years ago, before we had that feature,
you're having to go through the whole menu.
And I felt like Sony's menu was incredibly complicated
because I just Nikon's menu was so bubbly and clean.
And I just used it for so long that I knew it's something flash related.
It's going to be under the purple setting, you know, where Sony I'm like, man,
I can't find out how to turn on Wi-Fi.
Like it should be in this one setting and it's not.
So I don't know.
I feel like I like owning one camera system
and knowing exactly how it works in and out.
But in the last like five.
But as the owners of fstoppers.com, maybe we should be able to use other cameras.
Right. Yeah.
But not as proficiently as the one that we actually use
professionally day in and day out. I don't know.
All right. Moving on.
So this image, it's like it seems like the most simple, boring thing ever.
But the composition and the color scheme
all come together to make this, I feel like a more solid image
than it probably should be.
I love this.
How real are these colors?
This this isn't real, right?
You think it's just overly saturated?
I'm wondering if it's just completely fake.
Like it's all gray and they made it blue and orange.
It just looks way too good to be true.
I don't think the average photographer has the creative.
Oh, they're not even capable of doing it, huh?
Well, if this was all gray, how many people are going to spend time
colorizing it and adding color in this beautiful way like this?
It feels more serendipitous.
Like you stumbled upon this.
Wow, this is crazy.
It's like, you know, is it Sweden that has all the crazy
tunnels with the entryway into the subway systems?
You know, like they have intentionally built that
and then therefore they become these famous places that people like to photograph.
I think this is the same situation where this is intentionally painted this way,
not for photography, but for the sake of art and aesthetic.
And it just opens up a really good opportunity to take a photo like this.
Look at the middle of the train at the very bottom
where it connects to the tile floor.
What is going on in that bottom portion and why?
Why are there lines on the bottom right and bottom left that are black and orange?
And then what is going on in the middle there?
I'm trying to think of how the train could look in real life
that would make it look like that with a long exposure.
So the orange makes sense in the sense that perhaps behind them
is an orange wall, too, and it is reflecting
the color of the train.
I didn't think about that.
Then I would say maybe was there somebody standing in front of them?
They had to clone out or there's some reason that they had to try to.
Well, OK, so that's that's my question.
It feels like that.
It feels like something fake is happening on the bottom middle of this train.
And now but but look, if you look above,
there's also black lines on the right and left up.
And there's a dead spot in the middle of blue at the top of the train, too.
And then there's like that orange stripe on the left top side of the train.
But then there's like a hint of it on the right top side of the train.
I don't know. I don't know.
I just feel like this looks incredible.
Everything about the train and the back wall and the wires
and everything looks so good.
And then you I would think like it's almost CGI.
It doesn't even look real.
And then when I look at the very bottom of the tile floor,
that looks boring and real.
Yeah, it seems like it's a cloning issue or something
with the exact same blue color of the train has passed through the scene
during the exposure.
I don't know if there could be like a caboose or something.
That's not the right word, but like something that extended out
that like swept past while the exposure was taken.
But then why didn't it affect the other side?
Yeah, I don't I don't know.
And I assume he doesn't explain Norbert doesn't he wrote a lot of bullcrap,
too, like vibrant planes of color.
The train sweeps through the frame like a turquoise veil.
Guys, don't write stuff like that.
I don't care about this long exposure.
Make speed visible.
OK, let's rate it.
Three, two, one.
This is my highest rated image so far.
I love it. I do love it.
I wish the description was a little bit more descriptive
and a little less flowery, but I still love this image.
Like little squiggly wire up there.
I know it looks so good.
Like is that how they installed that?
I don't know. Everything about this image is great.
This one in the weird, blurry guy on the horse are incredible.
So hold on. There is like your funny business.
If you scroll down to this tile, the tiles are all a certain size.
But there's this weird like kind of like cloning line or something going through.
Well, it goes through the whole thing.
I don't mean that looks like a broken line.
Like, I don't know.
I feel like something in the very, very foreground of the tile
has been cloned out, which I want to see the original raw photo.
Something's been done to this.
But whatever you did, I still love it.
What if there was just some huge, like homeless man with a shopping cart there
and he just completely cloned out a massive part?
Well, then you can upload the same image to our next critique.
The AI enhanced photo.
Speaking of AI is a story that might have happened a month or two ago.
I don't know if I told this,
but I got a phone call that I was convinced was AI
because somebody said that this is a good story.
They were I get this phone call and I miss it.
So it's a like unlisted number.
And so I didn't answer and it left a voicemail.
And it's this lady in the phone.
The voicemail starts off with like, hey, is this on?
Am I being recorded?
Hey, Patrick, this is so and so and so and so.
And I'm here with Neil Patrick Harris.
And we're trying to get in touch with you.
And I'm like, obviously, this is AI, right?
The whole thing started off really weird.
Like who starts a phone call with like, you think this thing's on?
Is it starting? No, but I doesn't really do that either.
But go ahead.
I feel like every video you make, it adds a soundtrack to it.
And it's always like you've seen videos like the world is burning
and the audio soundtrack is like, oh, my gosh, look out.
It's falling. You see these videos here?
Yes, they make really bad scripts. Yes.
Anyway, so in the voicemail, she did happen to say something
like Neil has messaged you on Instagram and you didn't answer.
So I was like, well, that could be verifiable.
So I log into the F Stoppers Instagram account and deep into like
the spam folders, which this is such a shame that this happens.
There is Neil Patrick Harris with like six million followers.
And he has messaged us, me specifically about setting up a photo booth for him.
Because you did a photo booth at your wedding.
And then you made a video about how I made the most complex photo booth
you could imagine that needed somebody there to just manage it
because it would constantly do all this.
Anyway, it turned into this crazy thing
where like I eventually got on a phone call with him.
I'm Neil. What's up, dude?
First of all, your content is amazing.
And watching that whole video inspired me to
do my own photo booth.
I got to talk to him.
I get to hear about this whole setup that he's trying to do in his house.
And, you know, I won't spill all the details
because I don't know how much he wants people to know about it.
But the interesting idea was that you never know who's watching your videos.
When you make a video and you get 100000 views, you just think it's like
photography nerds, but it very well could be
somebody that you like grew up watching on TV.
And then who would have ever think that they would reach,
have somebody reach out on their behalf to get consulting?
So I guess now I can add that I have been a, you know,
photography consultant to Neil Patrick Harris.
Yes. And if for no other reason, I got to have a FaceTime
phone call with him. Yeah. Which was pretty crazy.
So there's this podcast that I love called The Necessary Conversation.
And it's it's a son and daughter
who are like in their forties or fifties and then their parents
and the son and daughter are ultra liberal.
And the parents are like super Republican.
Right. Yeah. Like the dad is insane.
He's he's basically like anybody other than Americans.
Like we should kill him.
Like we should just bomb him. You know, it's crazy.
Maybe even some Americans. Oh, yeah, you're right.
50 percent Democrats.
If you're from a blue state, we should get rid.
You should leave the union. Yeah.
So I listen to this podcast all the time.
It's just wild to hear what he says.
I want a white Adolf Hitler month.
In your mind, Black History Month
is equivalent to white Adolf Hitler month. Yeah.
You understand Adolf Hitler is widely regarded as one of the most
monstrous human beings to have ever existed.
Yeah. Ushered in the slaughter of millions of people.
And then I'm watching this other interview with
Hunter Biden, Joe Biden's son.
Yeah. And Hunter Biden brings up this podcast.
You know, there's this incredible show.
I really want to meet them one day.
You've probably I don't know if you listen to it's
called The Necessary Conversation.
And Hunter Biden brings up this podcast and he's like,
you guys got to watch this podcast.
It's this family and they're like constantly arguing about politics.
And the mother and father will bring up what my dad and me,
you know, like 10 percent for the big guy or whatever.
And he talks about he's like,
here's where the 10 percent for the big guy line came from.
I didn't write that.
Somebody else wrote that.
And like when I was the consultant for this, I was blah blah blah.
And then he'll be like,
let's look at what Trump and his sons are doing right now.
Yeah. And if you're mad about me being a consultant for this other company
for a few million dollars, let's see what and he starts going through it all.
Then I watched The Necessary Conversation podcast
and they play that clip for the parents on that show.
And I'm like, this is so crazy.
I'm watching like two worlds collide here on YouTube.
It was really interesting.
That's my whole story.
Yeah. The big story that I feel like this last week is besides Taylor Swift
getting married has been, you know, no idea.
There's been Trump has made like over a billion dollars on his like crypto coin.
Yeah. And how like it was designed in a way to where even if you bought in early
it like it was kind of like the Robin Hood where they would just shut it down
and you couldn't sell when you were like, yeah.
And so like you were guaranteed to lose money.
And then here Trump has made over a billion like my parents
and many people out there.
My dad probably watches this show.
So like, hey, dad, you'll probably appreciate the story.
They would just say things like, how did the Clintons
and how did the Obamas make so much money in office?
Well, Trump has now made more money than anyone in office
in like six months or something.
Well, I mean, I remember when he was running for office two years ago,
there was a chance that he would be bankrupt
because he had like three different lawsuits that were each two or three
hundred million dollars.
And they were trying to calculate how much money does Trump have?
If he has to pay these lawsuits, he literally could have zero dollars.
And now he's a billionaire just two months, two years after that situation.
So, so, but it's fine because nobody owning the libs.
Nobody really cares.
Like everyone's just like, whatever. Yeah.
All right. Here we are in.
I would say Alaska, but I don't think there's trains like this.
Alaska, Canadian, Iraqis.
Oh, we're still in North America. Wow. OK.
10 second long exposure.
Nikon Z8 five stop ND filter.
Is this what the the wall looks like in Canada?
Did we build a northern wall?
They're building a wall now to keep us out.
So this is a long exposure, right?
It's got seconds.
I mean, if it's not, then this doesn't qualify for our contest.
But I feel like the problem I have with this
is it just doesn't look like a train anymore.
It looks.
But isn't that's what what makes it interesting?
If this just looked like a train, would it be an interesting photograph?
I mean, maybe you would say that it just looks like every other train photo.
There was another one in this critique that I didn't in this contest
that I didn't pick, where it was a more drone aerial shot facing down.
And the train was more.
It reminded me of Alaska.
We went to a place where you tried to do a photograph.
There's a beautiful scene with a bridge and a little train coming by.
I think the train even came through the scene. Yeah.
But it might just look like every other landscape shot
where this one is a little different.
But it's just something about it feels so
there's such a man made element in this
that is exotic enough that doesn't feel like a train.
It feels like a serpent or a wall or I don't know what it is.
But I agree. Yeah, it kind of makes me feel a little uneasy.
It's like this is what the A.I.
did after it took over Canada and the humans weren't in control anymore.
Yeah, I kind of get that. All right, let's rate it.
Three, two, one.
But I kind of like it.
I was in between the three to four. I almost gave it four.
I like it. It's interesting.
It's different than your average train shot.
The color of the train super unique.
You know, if it was just a gray.
Do you feel like the clouds above are a little too ominous, a little too dark?
Do you feel like if they were airy, a little brighter, it might
sit a little bit better?
Do you like the clouds and you feel like I was thinking something
feels a little heavy handed with those clouds.
I don't know. It's all right.
Moving on. Wow.
What do you what in the world are we shooting through?
I would say this is like pine trees or something.
But like, how do you get it that perfect?
And if you're having to, you know, pan the camera,
what's the chance that the car is sitting right in the one spot that.
You have visibility.
Well, not to take away from this photographer,
but I'm sure you're locking your
your focus, you know, you're pre-focusing on that spot
and then you're just in auto, not auto, but continuous shot.
And as it goes through the tree, right?
Well, it's got to be more like the.
Sure. Right.
Depending on how much tree there is and how far away. Yes.
But I'm not going to get the streaking without like
make up a number, a tenth of a second, you know, something.
He says he shot at a fifth of a second, a fifth of a man.
I've been pretty close on a lot of stuff.
So a fifth of a second means you're going to get.
What's the math there? Five shots per second.
But this car is only going to be there.
Like you're really only getting one shot, right?
Yeah. But but how many, you know, there's 20 cars in there
and maybe they come through every two minutes. I don't know.
But then even then, you're still panning, hoping that you catch
the car in that opening.
Yeah. So I just the failure rate of what I'm trying to say
is the failure rate seems like it would be incredibly high.
He says lots of people attempt this shot and it is a challenge
with very low keeper rate.
But when nailed, it's real cool.
I agree. I think it's well done.
Ready? Yeah. Three, two, one.
I'm giving it three like in a professional portfolio
of other really high quality racing shots.
I'm giving this a four.
You know, I feel like you're kind of showing
that you can think outside the box on its own.
I'm not blown away.
But in a series like you like to say, I feel like it's even more strong.
And I kind of like that better.
Yeah, I'm trying to think if I if I like it vertical or I keep thinking
this could be used in like an editorial format where
the bubblegum race or something and CNN would write an article about it
and like what would be the lead image?
It's probably going to be horizontal for a blog, not vertical.
So if you zoomed in, like, could you make it even more abstract
where it's just all about the car and it sits a little bit larger in the screen?
The nice advantage is the way it's shot.
You can do both.
All right. Next up, we got some pictures of trees here.
I'm trying to figure out what makes this long exposure, because
this looks very painterly.
But nothing in the image is screaming out long exposure.
I assume whatever is orange is some weird
fireflies or
plants that are moving in the breeze.
There's something going on with the orange that must make this long exposure
because unless there could be like a vertical movement,
but I'm not exactly understanding what is moving
in the scene or how the camera is moving.
Do you can you make sense of this?
No, I can't.
It almost just feels like it's an effect that's been added.
Yeah. And of course, a photographer, he wrote a bunch of B.S.
like if anything more than a whisper would disturb it.
But he didn't explain what he did to get the shot.
And I don't fully understand.
When I first saw it, I thought, OK, he he did a long exposure
and he panned up or down.
He says he took it at one third of a second.
But you're right.
The effect on the bottom.
I'm not sure what all those splotches are.
And some of them seem kind of sharp, like it feels like there's a right,
you can make the impressionistic.
It's leaving something on the sensor
that makes it feel like it's sharper than it should be.
But he says the sunrise was backlighting the canopy
during a peaceful moment.
You see those vertical lines.
They come all the way down through the shot.
Yeah, that seems like where the movement is.
But you think it's with a pan head?
And it's like, I would think.
All right, well, let's rate it, you know, you like it.
I do. Three, two, one, three.
I like it. I don't know that I love the color.
Maybe it's OK.
There's just there's elements of green in the tree trunks
that I'm like, I just want it pulled over to magenta just a little bit.
Yeah, but I don't know.
Maybe that's my only complaint.
I do like it, though.
It does definitely have a vibe like orange could.
I don't know.
Orange gives a very certain feel that I don't know
that I want to see it all the time in a big room.
But it could be nice.
Next up, totally know how I feel about this.
I didn't like it as a thumbnail.
And now I like it a lot more.
What do you think of the umbrella in the foreground?
I think I think I like it.
Well, oh, oh, at the bottom. Yeah.
I did not even recognize what that was.
I was looking at the green umbrella.
I wonder if I don't know if it was like a dark red.
If you colored it, huh?
Made it just it almost just feels like, you know, you get those
like disposable cameras
and somebody's put their finger over the lens by accident.
Yeah. You always see like a finger on the bottom.
It feels like that.
It feels like it's kind of an unintentional mistake.
And I kind of want to see more of the crosswalk
or I want that umbrella to have a tone that just doesn't feel black.
And it's like, oh, it kind of gives some it adds something to the image.
But I don't know.
I feel like it's like 30 percent too large or ill placed.
I don't know something about that.
That's where my mind goes immediately.
And then we have like a blurry walk symbol or something, but.
Well, and the buildings in the back are blurry.
So is this like is this taking off and you've panned with?
That's what it seems like to me is you have a long exposure
and you are following this bus tram thing.
I don't know.
I find this very interesting and beautiful.
I I like it a lot, probably more than I should.
And now I'm trying to decide, do I like the umbrella on the bottom?
For some reason, when I first saw it, I just thought it was a shadow
or dark ground or something, but I don't know.
I don't know what to think.
It's it reminds me to sound bad.
It reminds me of like the art that you find at like Marshall's or something.
How dare you?
Like where, you know, the like artsy girl puts this in her college apartment,
you know, and you feel like it's.
I mean, I feel like that is the ultimate compliment.
It's like this art is so good.
It could be.
It could come in picture frames that people put up in their home
around the world.
Ikea sells this. Yeah, I would.
I would give anything.
They probably don't pay.
Give my left testicle.
Yeah, but they they probably don't pay you a licensing fee.
They probably just buy it outright for a hundred bucks online.
But if they did give you a licensing fee and you were like, yeah,
I've sold a million of this print, that would be incredible.
But it's it's interesting enough to where it's not.
You know, a lot of these images are so over the top that you're like,
do you want this massive pink, orange image with all the trees
or do you want something a little more subdued?
It almost feels like you could have taken this
and your eye wanders around and looks at all the different elements, you know,
but it would also be really nice in black and white.
Well, if I'd like it, I don't know.
I think I think I like the muted colors, the green and the red and the yellow.
I think do we rate this?
No. Three, two, one.
I'm going a little hard on three.
I'm going between three and four. I like it.
Moving on. Final image.
And I believe I don't know if I pulled the highest rated image
from this critique or not from the community,
but I think this is the highest rated image that we are featuring.
OK, I like it.
It feels a little underexposed to me.
Two thirds of a stop, maybe. I don't know.
He says he used constant and flash
and he positioned the flash at the face to get a sharper face
and then the hot light down below to get a longer exposure
at one half of a second.
I feel like technically pretty interesting.
And then, you know, that background,
I assume that's some sort of like painted seamless backdrop.
It really fits with the motion of the dress and everything.
It kind of feels like a painting. Yeah.
My critique of it.
I mean, my my eye keeps going to her dark shadow on the shoulder
and on her arm and her hand.
That's and I just want to like throw this into separate
frequency separation and just like paint some fleshy color on her.
I agree. It looks like she got punched.
Yeah. And like maybe there's a little bit of that going on in her face, too.
Or like I just want to brighten, like dodge just the face a little bit.
Or I don't know if it's like you're good with lighting,
breaking down lighting a little bit better.
It looks like the light's kind of coming down and casting a shadow in the ear.
But something about it feels like the light's too low or too flat.
Or it just I don't know.
I feel like her face is.
I want it to be even brighter.
And I know he said that he put the strobe light on the face, but
I just that shoulder just feels like it almost you said a bruise.
But it also feels like you accidentally have ever been in Photoshop.
You accidentally like burn something by accident. Yeah.
And then you don't notice it till later.
And you're like, why is there like a circular thing?
And yeah, well, it's just happening to me yesterday.
You know, I'm trying to paint on a mask and I'm like, why does it look like that?
And then I realize like, oh, I'm not clicked on the mask.
I clicked on the layer.
So it's like painting black on the layer. Yeah.
So I don't know.
I feel like I would I'd want to adjust the shoulder a little bit.
Maybe even that bottom elbow.
I love the movement.
I think it's really cool.
Her expression's a little flat.
Maybe. Maybe.
I don't know what the expression should be.
It's not supposed to be like overly joyful or something, but
let's rate it.
All right. Three, two, one.
I'm going three. I went three as well.
I don't community like this more than I did.
I included it, but I don't feel like it was my favorite image.
All right, guys, we have deliberated and it doesn't matter
because all of you are getting a free tutorial from F Stoppers dot com slash store.
But in case you're interested, we could not come to a clear winner.
Number one, we were arguing about the horse picture by Shams Saber
Grodwan, the photographer, or this orange and blue one
that something fishy is going on with this image by Norbert Rost.
Probably said that wrong. I'm sorry.
We both liked them about equally.
I went with the subway.
I think you went with the horse.
But I feel like we both felt like they were one and two.
Yeah, we like those a lot.
And then third one, we came to a consensus.
It's probably this one with the the sub subway, but the buses.
Whatever. Yeah. By Jacob Holdsworth.
So congratulations, guys.
All of these images from today were awesome.
But these three were our particular favorite.
If you would like to be a part of the next critique, it starts right now.
It's free to join.
You can win free prizes, maybe F Stoppers tutorials, maybe something else.
So check it out at F Stoppers dot com slash contest right now.
It's totally free. What do you have to lose?
A.I. augmented. A.I. augmented. That's right.
So we don't want to see just images and we want good descriptions.
Don't give me flower flowery bull crap written by A.I.
Just write how you took it and what you did.
I don't need to hear for this one, too.
We need to know what algorithm or program you use to manipulate it.
Did you use something like Evoto to do skin retouching?
Or did you use, you know, generative fill in Photoshop?
Or did you throw it into Gemini or some other program?
And, you know, what specifically was augmented?
So. All right, guys, we will see you next month.
