FIN 68 M and M Proposition 2

Coin Crunch
8 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explains Modigliani-Miller (M&M) Proposition 2, demonstrating how a company's capital structure (the mix of debt and equity) affects the cost of equity and the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) in both tax-free and tax-inclusive environments.
The M&M Proposition 2, we'll do one version without any tax.
That's easier.
We'll do a slightly harder version with tax, but let's get down to business.
Flyer Company has zero debt and can borrow at 4%.
The company's weighted average cost of capital is 8%.
Scenario one, assuming no taxes, answer the required below.
So required A, what's the cost of equity?
Okay, well, if the company has zero debt and the weighted average cost of capital is 8%,
the cost of equity is 8%.
But let's prove it with a little bit of math.
So there's our assuming no taxes M&M Proposition 2 formula that we introduced in previous videos
and showed you how to derive this in previous videos as well.
I wonder if anybody sat through that explanation.
It was pretty long.
But I would expect you're either in a test situation going to be given this on a formula sheet
or being allowed to prepare a formula sheet or being expected to memorize this.
I would not expect anybody to be deriving this formula from the weighted average cost of capital formula.
Anyway, let's get down to business.
We're given the formula here.
Okay, so our cost of equity is the cost of capital, 8%, plus 8% minus 4%,
8 minus 4 is 4, times debt divided by equity.
Well, here we go. Debt is zero.
Equity is 100%, so zero divided by 100 is 100.
So 8 minus 4 is 4.
Four times zero is zero.
Our cost of equity here is 8%, right?
8 plus zero is 8.
So in Scenario 1, the cost of equity is indeed 8%.
Okay, let's continue.
So what we're going to do, what's the cost of equity? 8%.
Let's do B.
B says, if the company changes its capital structure to be 25% debt,
what's the cost of equity here?
Okay, so Scenario Part B.
So there's A, here's B.
Our cost of equity here is the 8%, plus 8 minus 4.
I'm just going to put 4 here. 8 minus 4 is 4.
Times, and what was the borrowing here? 25% debt.
So the debt to equity ratio is, if it's 25% debt, it's 75% equity.
And there we have it.
So we've just got to do the math.
Actually, 25 divided by 75.33333 times 4, 1.33333.
So 1.33333 is on the right, 8 is on the left.
It's 9.33333%.
Let's look at C.
C says, now we're going to 75% debt.
What's the cost of equity?
I haven't forgotten.
We're also asked to calculate the weighted average cost of capital
at these various debt levels.
So we'll do that momentarily.
Our cost of equity here, though, is 8% plus 4%.
Times, now what's the ratio?
It's flipped.
Now it's 75 debt, 25 equity.
And so the math here is 75 divided by 25.
3 times 4 is 12.
12 plus 8 is 20%.
Okay.
So our cost of equity is rising.
As our debt levels are rising, that should hit your intuition as right.
Because, of course, more debt means more risk.
More risk means the shareholders are going to require more returns.
So cost of equity will, of course, rise.
Now let's look at the weighted average cost of capital.
Because, again, this is our cost of equity, 8.
So, again, this is our E, right?
Our cost of equity.
But we want to know what is the weighted average cost of capital.
And let's do some math.
In scenario part A, if we have 8% is our equity, and equity is 100% of the portfolio,
then it doesn't really matter that we can borrow at 4%.
And that's 0% of our portfolio, just 8 times 100 plus 4 times 0.
It's 8%.
That's our weighted average cost of capital.
In the second scenario, 9.33, 333% times.
In the second scenario, it was 75% debt.
Or no, sorry, 25% debt, 75% equity.
So 9.333, it's 75% equity and 4 times 25% debt.
Let's do the math here.
0.9333333333 times 7.
Oh, I screwed that up.
Actually, let's do it this way.
9.333333333 times 0.75.
We get 7, right?
6.999999, 7.
4 times 25%, that's 1.
7 plus 1 is 8.
And what we find here is the weighted average cost of capital is the same, no matter what.
And we'll do it for the last one just to prove that out.
Our cost of equity is 20%.
And in the third scenario, we have 25% equity.
Our debt remains 4%, but in this scenario we have 75% debt.
20 times 25% is 5, 4 times 75% is 3, 5 plus 3,
counting on my fingers, 8.
So our weighted average cost of capital is 8.
Our firm value is the same here, no matter what, right?
The weighted average cost of capital sort of drives firm value
and certainly a key number for any firm,
and our firm value is the same no matter what,
regardless of the debt to equity ratio.
Now what we're going to see is once we incorporate tax,
companies that take on debt end up being more valuable,
and the reason is their weighted average cost of capital goes down,
and the reason for that is debt causes interest,
and interest is tax deductible,
and so the tax deductibility of interest
causes the WAC to go down and firm value to go up.
Let's go ahead and solve this in Scenario 2.
So Scenario 2, exact same thing,
but this time we assume a tax rate.
So that brings us to a new formula here,
and the formula is pretty familiar.
It's pretty similar to the previous one,
just a couple of minor, well, significant, but minor tweaks.
Rather than RA here, you can see it says RU.
That is the cost of capital or cost of equity
of an unlevered version of our company.
In other words, a company with zero debt.
What's the cost of equity or the cost of capital?
Same difference.
When there is zero debt, and in this case it's 8% is RU,
and then 1 minus the tax,
and so the tax rate is 20%,
1 minus the tax rate is going to be 80%.
1 minus 0.2 is 0.8.
So we'll plug in 80% here.
Let's just plug in our numbers.
So what is the company's cost of equity
at a time when we have zero debt?
Let's run the numbers here.
So our unlevered cost of capital is 8 plus 8 minus 4.
So 8 minus 4, cost of debt is 4.
8 is RU.
4 is RD.
8 minus 4 is 4.
I'm just going to put 4 here,
times the debt-to-equity ratio.
Well, if we have zero debt,
our debt-to-equity is 0 over 100 times 80.
So what will end up happening
is the things I'm writing in brackets here
just multiply out to zero
because we're multiplying everything by a zero.
So our cost of equity at a time
when we have zero debt
is going to be the same
as our weighted average cost of capital.
That should make intuitive sense, right?
If you have no debt,
your cost of equity is your cost of capital.
Let's move on to Part B.
So that was Part A.
Part B, you know, gets more interesting.
Our cost of equity remains this.
Unlevered is 8% plus 4
is RU minus RD is 4 times.
Now, what's the ratio?
25% debt, 75% equity.
So 25 75ths times 80%,
1 minus the tax rate.
So again, let's take the middle stuff.
I always do the ratio first.
I don't know why you don't have to.
Of course, 0.33333 times 4 is 1.33333
times 0.8, 1.07.
So 8% plus 1.07 is 9.07%.
Okay, let's move on to C.
C says, same calculation,
just flip the debt and equity.
Now we're 75% debt, 25% equity.
So same type of math.
8 plus 4 times 75 25ths times 80%.
Let's run the numbers here.
75 divided by 25 is of course 3.
3 times 4 is 12.
12 times 0.8 is 9.6.
9.6 plus 8.
Our cost of equity here is 17.6%.
Okay, so we've done our cost of equity.
And while they were different from the ones up here,
right, 8, 9, and 20,
and this is 8, 9, and 17,
like slightly lower 9, 9.07 versus 9.33.
So it's slightly less our cost of equity
as we climb the ladder here.
But still the same story is told, right?
You end up in a situation where you borrow more,
while equity costs more because risk is higher.
So there's a premium placed on that
and shareholders will want a higher return
given that they're taking on higher risk.
Okay, so that's sort of the story there.
But weighted average cost of capital
tells a more interesting story.
So let's figure out our weighted average cost of capital.
So in scenario A, it's pretty simple.
8% and we have 100% equity in scenario one.
We had zero debt.
Again, I keep circling the same thing.
And our cost of debt or our debt cost is 4%.
But remember, we want to know the after tax.
Now we got a tax rate to deal with.
So we actually do 4% times 1 minus the tax rate,
which is 80%.
1 minus T, 1 minus 20% is 80%.
So I'm actually going to use 4% times 80%,
4 times 0.8.
I'm just going to put it in 3.2
as our sort of after tax cost of debt
and then times the proportion of debt,
which in scenario one is 0%.
So I went through all that work for a zero
at the end of the day.
But I'll use 3.2 as our after tax cost of debt
times the proportion of debt.
So 8 times 100 plus 3.2 times zero is 8.
Our weighted average cost of capital
in the first default scenario is 8.
Let's look at the part B scenario.
The part B scenario, our cost of equity is 9.07%.
Our ratio here is 25 debt, 75 equity.
So times 75% or proportion of debt
plus our after tax debt times the proportion of debt.
So 3.2 times 70.
What is it?
The 25%.
Jeepers, creepers.
Easy for me to say.
Okay, so let's run the numbers.
9.07.
My goodness.
9.07 times 0.75.
6.8 plus 0.032.
No, let's do 3.2 times 0.25.
0.8.
6.8 plus 0.8 is 7.6%.
So we're seeing a little difference here, right?
Up above, it was 8% every time
for our weighted average cost of capital.
Here, because we're taking tax rates into consideration
and because we now have some debt,
well, guess what happens?
Our weighted average cost of capital
falls from 8 to 7.6%.
All right, let's do the last one.
We'll see the weighted average cost of capital
will fall further still.
So our cost of equity went way up, 17.6%.
Wow.
But we only have 25 equity and 75 debt this time.
The cost of debt remains just as cheap as ever.
3.2% times 75% in this scenario.
So let's run the numbers here.
17.6 times 0.25.
4.4 plus, well, it's the same.
3.2 times 0.75 is still 0.
Oh no, what am I talking about?
Let's do the math.
3.2 times 0.75 is not the same.
It's 2.4.
So 4.4 plus 2.4 is 6.8%.
Okay, so what is this telling us?
What does this even mean?
If our weighted average cost of capital is going down,
the value of our firm is going up, right?
We're able to take on more projects.
It's better for the firm.
And just having a lower weighted average cost of capital
implies a higher firm value.
So the implication of this is clear.
Firms should just take on as much debt as humanly possible.
But wait a second.
I'm an accountant.
I'm a frugal guy by my nature.
I think debt is on a personal level.
Why would I recommend this?
And the answer here is, well, that's what the math will tell you to do.
And finance is math and money.
And so if you're just going a pure math game,
the math game says, my goodness, our weighted average cost of capital goes down.
The value of our firm goes up.
Let's take on more debt.
And finance books will tell you this as well.
It's kind of a fool's game.
If you take it to its logical end, and the reason is,
if you take it to its logical end, you will go bankrupt.
The risk of bankruptcy becomes more and more significant
the more debt you take on.
And I always think of this like a role-playing video game.
If you're a video gamer like me, you might have played a role-playing game,
and you might have even decided, I want to be a magic user,
a wizard in this role-playing game.
And so here's what happens to wizard characters
that do the logical thing and take it to its logical end.
Because I'm a numbers guy, and I go, all right, my wizard just leveled up.
Let's see, I can add to his or her strength.
I can add to their dexterity.
I can add to their magic power.
And I will always add to their magic power every time I level up.
More magic power, more magic power, more magic power, more magic power.
And what inevitably happens to my characters is,
I just start killing all the bad guys because I'm so powerful.
My magic spells are spectacularly strong.
And then I come up with a bad guy who can withstand one of my spells.
And they go up to me and they go, tink.
And they kill me in like one shot because I have zero hit points.
I've invested everything in magic power, nothing in hit points.
And they go, tink, and I'm dead.
That's what happens to companies that take this to its logical end.
They go, we're going to lever up to the extreme degree.
We're going to take on more and more and more debt,
as much debt as humanly possible.
And then one little problem, tink, and they're bankrupt.
So lenders know this.
They're not going to lend to the logical degree.
And investors and even owners of the company know this.
But it's very tempting to look at this formula and say,
I should borrow to the hilt because it maximizes firm value
and I should be trying to maximize firm value.
Bankruptcy is the thing that sort of prevents this from being
the greatest infinite money strategy you've ever heard of.
All right, I hope this video was helpful.
I hope, you know, you don't take too much risk as you're headed
towards your midterm or final exams.
And I hope you'll hit one of those buttons for me.
Thanks for watching.
Have a great day.
See you in the next video.
Bye bye.
