The BEST Beef Stew That Never Changed... CHEAP, HEARTY, and RICH

English Cuisine
7 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video celebrates the timeless art of making traditional beef stew, emphasizing how patience and simple, affordable ingredients can create a rich, comforting meal. It advocates for a return to slow-cooking methods over modern processed alternatives, highlighting the emotional and nutritional value of a homemade dish that transforms tough cuts of meat into a hearty feast.
There are dishes that come and go, that are the fashion for a while and then forgotten,
but beef stew is not one of them. Beef stew is one of those dishes that has never changed,
not really, not in hundreds of years, for it was good and simple and right from the start,
and there was never any need to change it. A cheap, tough cut of beef, cut small, browned,
and then simmered long and slow with humble root vegetables until the meat is fall-apart tender
and the whole pot is rich and thick and savory. That is beef stew, and folks were making it just
so hundreds of years ago, and they are making it just so today, and it will be made just so
hundreds of years from now, for there is no improving on it. It is one of the great,
honest suppers of the world. I have seen the old recipes for it from long ago,
and it is a wonderful thing to see how little it has changed. The words are old-fashioned,
and here and there a fine house dressed it up with some fancy touch, but underneath,
it is the very same stew your grandmother made and that you can make tonight, the same cheap beef
and the same browning and the same long, patient simmer. That is a rare and beautiful thing in this
hurried world, a dish so right that it has come down through all the years unchanged,
needing nothing, asking only a cheap cut of meat and a little time. So today, I am going to show
you how to make a proper old beef stew, cheap and hearty and rich, the way it has always been made,
and along the way I will tell you a bit about how the old fine houses used to dress it up,
which is a curious thing to know, though we will keep our own bowl plain and honest,
for the plain version is the best of it. Let me show you, step by step. Beef stew is bound up in
my memory with the deep of winter, for it was cold-weather food in the house I grew up in,
the sort of thing that simmered on the back of the stove through a gray afternoon when the wind was
hard against the windows and there was outdoor work to come back in from. There is nothing like
coming in from the cold, your hands aching with it and your face raw to a house full of the smell
of a stew that has been simmering for hours, and a hot bowl of it thick with tender beef and soft
vegetables put into your cold hands. It warms you from the inside out in a way little else does,
and it warms you cheap, which mattered in a big family through a long winter.
My mother could make a little beef go a long way in a stew, stretching a cheap cut with plenty of
vegetables and a good thick gravy to fill a whole table of hungry children, and no one ever felt
they were eating poor, for a good stew feels like plenty even when the meat in it is little.
That is the quiet magic of it, that it turns a little cheap meat and some humble roots into a
pot of warmth and plenty that carries a family through the cold. Before I go further, I want to
say one quick thing. The old methods my family uses, there is more of it than fits in any one
video. I gathered the whole of it into a book at EliasYoder.com. The book is the long version.
If you want it, it is there. I will not mention it again.
We begin with the beef, and here is the beauty of a stew, that it wants the cheap cut, the tough
cut, the very meat that is no good for a quick cooking. A good chuck or a stewing beef, cut from
the hard-working parts of the animal, cheap and tough and full of flavor, is exactly what you
want, for the long, slow simmer of a stew is what turns that toughness tender. So do not buy a deer
cut for this. Buy the cheap one, the stew meat, and know that the low price is no mark against it,
only a gift. You take that beef and you cut it into small pieces, bite-sized chunks, cutting
away any bone, for smaller pieces cook tender faster and give you a good bit of meat in every
spoonful. Now the first step, and it is the one that gives a stew its deep rich flavor and its
color, is to brown the meat. You season your beef chunks with salt and then, and here is an old touch,
you dredge them in flour, tossing them so each piece is dusted all over with flour. That flour
does two good things. It helps the meat brown up beautifully and later it will thicken the stew
into that rich, thick gravy we want, for a good stew is thick, not thin and watery. Then you heat a heavy
pot, a dutch oven is perfect, with a good bit of butter melted in the bottom, and you brown those
floured beef chunks in the hot butter, in batches so as not to crowd them, turning them until they
are deep brown on all sides. Do not rush this, for that browning is the foundation of all the flavor
to come. Brown them well, and let those good browned bits build up in the bottom of the pot,
for that is pure flavor. And hear me on the browning in batches, for it matters more than
folks think. If you crowd all your meat into the pot at once, it heaps up and steams in its own
juices and goes gray instead of browning, and you lose that deep flavor. Give each batch room to sit
against the hot bottom of the pot and truly brown, and do them in two or three batches if you must,
setting the browned meat aside as you go. It takes a little longer, but the difference between a stew
of gray steamed meat and one of deep browned meat is the difference between a thin flat stew
and a rich deep one. And those dark browned bits that stick to the bottom of the pot are not to be
scraped away and lost, for when you pour in your liquid later, they will loosen and dissolve into
the stew and give it a depth of flavor you cannot get any other way. So brown well, brown in batches,
and treasure those browned bits. Now, once the meat is browned, we build the stew around it.
And here is where I will tell you of the old ways, for I have seen a recipe for this very stew
from a fine old cookbook of long ago, and it is a curious and lovely thing. In a well-to-do house
of the old days, they would take this same plain browned beef and dress it up grand for their fine
table. They would add a whole onion stuck all over with cloves, and a piece of lemon peel for a
bright note, and a bundle of sweet herbs tied together, and pour in a pint of small beer to stew
it, and then at the end they would enrich it with mushrooms and boiled artichoke bottoms cut in
quarters, and even garnish the top with the hard-cooked yolks of eggs. All of that to turn a
humble stew into a dish grand enough for a rich man's table. Now, some of those old touches are
genuinely fine and worth keeping, and some are just fancy show, and I will keep the good honest
ones and leave the show. The clove-studded onion I will keep, for it is a lovely old trick, and I
will tell you why in a moment. The bundle of herbs I will keep, for it flavors beautifully. But the
artichoke bottoms, and the lemon peel, and the hard egg yolks garnishing the top, those were the
fine house flourishes, and our bowl will be the plainer, heartier, honest one, which to my mind
is the better eating anyway. So let me show you the good old touches we keep. That clove-studded
onion is a clever old thing. You take a whole peeled onion, and you stick whole cloves into it,
pressing them into the flesh so they stud it all over. Then that whole onion goes into the stew,
and as it simmers, the cloves lend their warm spice to the whole pot, and the onion softens
and flavors it. And here is the cleverness. At the end, you simply lift out that whole onion,
with all its cloves still stuck in it, so the clove flavor is all through the stew, but you have
not got loose cloves to bite down on in your bowl. That is the kind of sensible old wisdom
the old kitchens were full of. A way to get the flavor of a spice without the nuisance of it in
the eating. So stud your onion with cloves, and nestle it down into the pot. And the bundle of
sweet herbs, which is another fine old way. You take your herbs, a bit of thyme, some parsley,
a little sage, whatever good savory herbs you have, and you tie them together into a little bundle,
or wrap them in a bit of cloth, and you tuck that bundle down into the stew. As it simmers,
the herbs give all their flavor to the pot, and at the end, you lift the whole bundle out, spent,
and again you have the flavor with none of the loose bits. A clove onion and an herb bundle,
two old tricks, both worth keeping. Now the vegetables, the humble root vegetables that are
the heart of a stew alongside the beef. Carrots, scraped and cut into rounds or chunks, and I like
to cut mine a touch thinner so they go good and soft and sweet in the stew. A bit of celery,
chopped, for its savor and a little texture. And potatoes, cut into good chunks, which make the
stew a full and filling meal and thicken it further as they soften. Here, choose a potato
that holds together well enough not to wholly dissolve, a waxier kind, though a starchier one
is not wrong either, for as it breaks down, it thickens the stew, which some folks like.
You add these to the pot with the browned beef. And onions, of course, beyond the clove-studded
one, a good chopped onion or two for the body they give. These are the classic roots of a stew,
but do not feel bound by them, for a stew is a forgiving and generous thing that welcomes
whatever the cellar holds, a turnip, a parsnip, some peas stirred in near the end, whatever your
garden gave and your cellar kept through the winter. That is how the old kitchens cooked,
not from a strict list, but from what they had. And a stew is the very dish for that kind of thrifty,
use-what-you-have cooking. Now the liquid. The old fine recipe called for a pint of small beer,
but we have no need of that, and I make mine with good broth, for it makes a richer,
honest-er stew and needs nothing from a bottle. That golden bone broth I showed you making is
glorious here, and gives the stew a deep, savory body no water could. So you pour in your broth,
and as you do, stir and scrape the bottom of the pot to loosen all those good browned bits into
the liquid, and top it up with water if need be, until the liquid comes up near to the top of your
meat and vegetables, covering them well. A good bit of salt and pepper, some whole peppercorns in the
old way if you like, and a bay leaf if you have one. And then the whole point of a stew, the long,
slow simmer. You bring it up to a gentle bubble, then turn it right down low, cover it, and let it
simmer, slow and patient, for a good long while, an hour and a half or two hours or more, until the
beef is fall-apart tender, and the vegetables are soft, and the whole thing is cooked down into a
rich, thick, savory stew. This is the same low and slow patience I am always preaching, for it is the
truth of nearly all good, cheap cooking, that time turns the tough and the cheap into the tender and
the fine. You cannot hurry it. You let it bubble away low and slow, stirring now and again, filling
the house with its good smell, and the flour you dredged the meat in early will have thickened the
liquid into a proper, rich gravy as it cooked. If it is too thin for your liking at the end, you can let it
simmer uncovered a while to thicken, or stir in a little flour mixed smooth with water. You want it
thick, a stew you can near stand a spoon in, not a thin soup. When the beef is meltingly tender, and the
stew is thick and rich, you lift out your clove onion and your herb bundle, spent and done, and you
taste it and adjust the salt, and it is ready. And there it is, a great pot of rich, thick, hearty beef stew.
Tender beef and soft, sweet vegetables in a deep, savory gravy, made from the cheapest cut of beef
there is. The very same stew folks have warmed themselves with for hundreds of years, and will
for hundreds more. You serve it in bowls, good and hot, with a piece of bread to sop the gravy, and it is
one of the most satisfying suppers there is, a whole meal in a bowl. And here is one of the finest
things about a stew, that it is even better the next day, and the day after. A stew that has sat
overnight in the cold box, its flavors settling and deepening and marrying together, is richer and
better than it was fresh from the pot. So this is a wonderful thing to make a big batch of, and eat
across several days, or to make a day ahead for company. It warms up beautifully, gentle in a pot,
and asks only a little water if it has thickened too much in the keeping. It freezes well too,
so a big pot made on a cold day can put several suppers by against the busy days to come.
This is the old thrifty wisdom again, that a stew is not just one supper, but the beginning of several,
one afternoon's simmering feeding the family through a good stretch of days, and getting better
as it goes. There are few dishes so generous that give more the longer they keep. Now I want to be
plain about who profits from you believing that a good hearty supper is hard, or dear, or a thing to
be bought in a can or a frozen tray. There is a whole aisle of canned stew and frozen dinners,
sold on the notion that a real stew is too much trouble, and those canned things are thin, sad,
over-salted shadows of the real thing, with a few gray bits of meat and a thin broth, sold at a
price that would buy you far more and far better if you made it yourself. And meanwhile, the real
stew asks only a cheap cut of beef and some humble vegetables, and a couple of hours of mostly
leaving it alone. Nobody schemed to convince folks that they could not simmer a pot of stew.
It is worse than that. It is just a system nobody has to coordinate, a slow drift where the canned
and the frozen got dressed up as the easy, sensible choice, until folks forgot that the cheapest,
oldest, most warming supper there is was always within the reach of their own pot and a little
patience. The stew never changed because it was never wrong, cheap and hearty and rich from the
start. The people who built this country with their hands warmed themselves on it through hard
winters and lean times, and we are only just starting to remember how good and how cheap a
real bowl of it can be. Now tell me something down in the comments. What went into your family's beef
stew, and did anyone add some old touch to it, some particular thing handed down that made it theirs?
Every family's stew is a little different, and I would dearly love to hear about yours. Tell me.
Next time I am going to show you something to spread on that bread you sop your stew with,
for I am going to show you how to churn your own butter at home—sweet, golden, fresh butter made
the old way from nothing but cream and a jar and a little patience, far finer than any you can buy.
Once you have tasted your own fresh churned butter on a piece of warm bread beside a bowl of hot stew,
you will never look at the store kind the same way again. Next time, the making of butter. Until then,
take good care of the ones at your table, and keep a kitchen that knows the oldest,
cheapest supper there is, simmered slow with a little patience,
is one of the richest and most warming things you can set before the ones you love.
