The Forum with Becky Quick | A Podcast by The Economic Club of New York On this episode of The Forum, hosted by CNBC’s Becky Quick, Reed Hastings, Founder and Chair of Netflix, joins David Westin, Anchor of Bloomberg Wall Street Week, for a wide-ranging conversation on artificial intelligence, economic growth, and the technological shifts shaping the future.
Drawing on his early academic work in artificial intelligence and decades of leadership across technology and media, Hastings shares insights on how AI could drive productivity gains, influence global competitiveness, and reshape entire industries. He discusses the importance of maintaining U.S. leadership in AI innovation, the potential impact of emerging technologies on jobs and GDP growth, and what responsible development may look like as AI capabilities continue to accelerate.
New episodes of The Forum with Becky Quick drop monthly. Subscribe for exclusive conversations with global policymakers, business leaders, and change agents shaping the world economy.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker analyzes the evolution of AI, comparing its potential for super-intelligence to a species-level shift. The discussion covers the tension between rapid competitive development and the necessity of AI alignment, the economic paradox of productivity versus job displacement, and the geopolitical urgency of maintaining leadership to ensure global stability and human flourishing.
I'm Becky Quick of CNBC and your host of the forum. I'll be guiding you through exclusive
conversations among some of the world's global leaders. Conversations previously held behind
club doors, but today we invite you in. The Economic Club of New York serves as the premier
forum for non-partisan discussion dedicated to connecting the world's brightest minds with
preeminent public and private sector leaders. A non-profit, 501c3, the club is a 115-year-old
platform for the conversations that help shape the future of our world. The Economic Club of
New York, brightest minds, critical conversations, catalyst for innovation. A master's in computer
science from Stanford in 1988 in artificial intelligence. I was a new partner at a law
firm called Wilmer Cutler and Pickering in Washington during international trade. What
did you see in artificial intelligence at the time? It's an honor to be with you all. I wish
I had been a behavioral economist. That was my only real big regret in life. And so what did I
see in AI, which is sort of related, what's the nature of intelligence? I think I saw a dream
of understanding ourselves and our society a little better. And that was sort of the primary
motivator. I will say that the AI that I studied was the equivalent of the sun goes around the
earth field. So we had a fundamental theory in the 1980s that was completely false and didn't work,
but we didn't know it at the time. So me and many other people then fled to all kinds of
other fields. And it's exciting now to see a new set of techniques really be transformative.
So looking back on AI as you saw it then and whatever you saw then, comparing it to now,
I hear a range of things being said as extreme as this is as big an invention as the industrial
revolution. Some people say it's the discovery of fire. Are we overestimating or underestimating
the effect generative AI will have on us? Well, let's think back 30, 40,000 years ago when we're
a bunch of Neanderthals and we're in the entrance to our cave. And you know, we've been the dominant
human species for a couple of hundred thousand years. And the two of us look down and we see
homo sapiens. We're like, look at those guys. They're so skinny. They're hairless, but they're
pitiful. But those guys were really intelligent. And ultimately those homo sapiens dominated the
earth and killed off us Neanderthals. So I would say intelligence per species has been
highly selected for and that homo sapiens intelligence has allowed us to become the
dominant species on earth because we use our intelligence to make tools and do other things.
So I think it's a lot different than say mechanizing muscle power. So if you think
of bulldozers and how did that transform society, it did a lot, but it did it over a hundred years.
And although muscles are important, they're not the core human attribute, thus the dislocation
of the Neanderthals, which were much stronger than humans. So if AI develops to actually be
super intelligence, then it will be a lot more profound, I think, than anything else. And that
we will have actually real species threats because the AI will keep getting smarter and smarter and
smarter without limit. And natural selection works quite slowly in terms of making humans
more intelligent. So then we have to sort of say, okay, how fast and how, you know,
will the computers really think? Obviously, when we all use AI as consumers, we can find,
you know, it's pretty miraculous in some cases, but in other cases, it's not very effective.
But, you know, we're understanding more and more of the techniques. And again,
one theory is it'll be like Moore's law and just AI will get better and better and better and better.
The other theory is it's sort of like the war on cancer, where cancer developed over a very long
time. It has lots of different etiologies, and we keep coming up with a solution for one cancer,
but not another. And our overall progress in society against cancer has been, you know,
pretty steady, but flat and definitely not exponential. And so, you know, it may be that
as AI gets better, it hits various walls, and that we've got some time to deal with it. Or it may be
that it stays on this exponential. So we're just going to have to watch, but I think we need to be
prepared for it to be on the exponential, in which case we're going to have a lot of societal stress
over the next 20 years. So your analogy is very helpful, but a little disturbing, because I don't
see many Neanderthals around anymore, right? We have a lot of homo sapiens. In your analogy,
what can we do to make sure that we survive that, that this thing we're creating doesn't become so
smart and perhaps not even have our best interest at heart? Well, it's a big challenge. It's hard
to slow down, because unlike chemical weapons, like we're kind of in a war with the West and
Russia, and yet no one's using chemical weapons and no one's using nuclear weapons. So even in
this incredible state of war, we're able to put some limits on what happens. The problem with AI
is it's very continuous. You know, your thermostat is an AI thermostat. So there's no good way for
even the major powers to agree not to use AI, because it's so integrated through everything
else that we do. So there's no real practical scenario to take a break as human society,
even if we can get the politics to work on that. So instead, we're in the situation where we in
America better well damn win the race. And so everyone acknowledges that. And so all the
companies are going full out, both for their own, you know, competitive reasons. And so,
you know, it is a race hopefully to the top of what can AI do for us. And there will be
amazing positive scenarios, you know, all kinds of medical cures, all kinds of productivity.
I certainly six years ago, AI was very good at image analysis. That was one of the kind
of workloads that it first got good at. And in particular, in radiology, it got significantly
better than the typical radiologist pretty quickly and has been better than the typical
radiologist for at least five years. And so I would say, you know, weddings and with friends
who are radiologists, what's good to your kids are not going in the business, because radiology
is going to be the first profession that's wrecked by AI. Good for humanity, but not good for
radiologists. Well, what happened is, as radiology got better because of AI's analysis that helped
radiologists, the price of scans went down. And the number of scans turned out to be hugely
elastic. Now you walk in, you've got a cough, boom, you get a scan. Okay. And so what's happened
now is there's about 34,000 radiologists in the US, which is a shortage. We now have a labor
shortage of radiologists, okay, by about 5,000. So it's incredible story of, of course, elasticity
of demand to improve lives, i.e. more scans. And so we may well see with AI that it makes
Wall Street analysts more productive, it makes software engineers more productive,
and that in fact, the elasticity grows and that we grow the economy. And when people ask,
you know, we're spending collectively as an industry, a half a trillion dollars on AI data
center, how is that ever going to get paid back? Well, you know, add one or two points to GDP
growth and it gets paid back fast. So I don't want to like guarantee that it's always going to
be like radiology. I do think software engineering is particularly fascinating because all the major
AI companies are working on it. And so it is the white collar canary in the coal mine. And if
software engineering jobs go down a lot over the next five years, then that's probably going to
happen to law and architecture and many other things. If in fact, because of the increased
productivity, people are building a lot more software, sort of the radiology example, then I
think in many professions, we will see a big expansion and we can be more confident of the
high productivity. None of that really answers the long term question that you asked, which is how
are we not the Neanderthals? So I think reasonable chance, high productivity rather than mass
unemployment. OK, but then ultimately, what if they're smarter and smarter and smarter than us?
We're going to have to find ways, and I don't know what they are, to both continue to insist
on alignment. And that's where you train the AIs to care about human beings. So they are aligned
with our values. OK, but if somebody doesn't train, somebody programs their AI to try to take
over the world, we're going to have to enlist the other AIs on our defense to protect us. OK, so,
you know, there's a number of scenarios out there. And probably for 10, 20 years,
we're not going to know how serious the threat is, but we will have tools. Biological species,
we have been selected for dominance to try to grow our species. So AI is not naturally trying
to expand, not naturally. It can be programmed for that, but it can be also programmed to keep
humans on top. So it's not as scary as a super powerful human, which we all kind of intuit,
a super powerful human would be hard to hold back from taking over the world. It's not as
dire as that. In so far as we do make progress on trying to reshape generative AI in a more
positive direction, does that come from outside the industry or inside the industry? Does that
come from government regulation and agreement, or does it have to come from inside? Because
as I talk to many people in the business, they're much more focused on the race you talk about
than they are on the safety part. They don't want to get slowed down in that. I mean,
you're on the board of Anthropic, which I know is trying to make a move in the other direction,
but can we do it from the outside or does the industry itself somehow have to internalize the
risk? Well, I think lots of the industry is working on it. So there's different sides of
safety. So there's when you're treating AI like a counselor and it, you know, helps you tie a noose,
that's not a good thing. And so those cases across the industry are getting, you know,
more and more watched for and eliminated. So there's inevitable safety bumps as any technology
grows. So then there's more macro safety, like none of the major AIs can be used to design
chemical weapons or biological weapons. But those defenses in the AIs, you know, aren't perfect.
And we have to constantly invest in them to prevent people from using this super powerful
technology plus some CRISPR to do some really bad things. So there's active work across the
whole industry, you know, on those scenarios. Because from a commercial standpoint,
nobody wants their AI brand to be the brand that develops some bad virus. So there is an
incentive there to protect against the negative cases. But the sort of big long-term case is that
the AIs get so smart that then we have to do things to make sure that they're aligned with
human values, that they are programmed so that success is humans flourishing.
Give us your view about where we are likely to see the biggest effect. You mentioned biomedicine,
mentioned computer software programs. Let's talk, turn to the news with the deal between Disney and
open AI and the entertainment space that you know well. I mean, you manage transition from
my perspective, at least from more traditional TV, cable, broadcast through to streaming.
What does the transition look like from streaming through to AI?
Would you like to be a part of the conversations at the Economic Club of New York?
Learn more about membership, the New York City and National Fellows Programs,
and other opportunities for engagement in the club at www.econclubny.org.
So just as an example, we can look at video creation storytelling and sort of say,
let's look at what AI is going to do and the mechanics of generating video. And frankly,
whether that's a news channel trying to illustrate a concept or entertainers trying to do amazing
special effects, we're going to have higher quality special effects. And that will shift
to be AI generated instead of manually generated with sort of overseas visual effects companies.
So there is a shift there. But the core thing of storytelling is very hard. How do you do
long form character development, creating tension, resolving tension? That's not a case that the AI
does well today. Eventually, 10-20 years, the AI may win the Booker Prize. Okay, and then if it
does, it's going to be able to do a movie script also. But for now, the AI is really helping on
sort of industrial aspects of what we do like an amazing visual effects shot. And so it's,
important and we want to stay on the front as Disney does, but it's not doing the core thing,
which is which story is going to captivate human attention. I'm not sure this says much about my
job, about whether I keep my job in the AI world, because there's a lot of things that are done on
television with news and other things that frankly are not creating the next Lion King.
Well, I think interpreting the world in your case is a broad general wisdom. And so I think you'll
have a relatively long standing role in your success. Given my age, I'm good. Given your age,
you're good. But it is a very big change. Again, people want to compare it to the Industrial
Revolution. That happened over 200 years. This is going to happen over 10 or 20. And it might be
that what's caused political polarization in the last decade or two is rate of change. So think
about, since NAFTA, sort of the rise of globalization, the redefining of marriage
equality, immigration, all kinds of change in society. And one view is enough of our fellow
Americans, it's just too much. And it radicalizes them and they're willing to vote for things they
wouldn't normally vote for. And if that's fundamentally what's going on in US society,
as well as Brexit and a couple other places, then we're in for a pretty big storm because
the rate of change is not going to slow down. The rate of change in society, partially or maybe
largely driven by AI is going to be large. And so that may be that, you know how everyone today
is nostalgic for Reagan. There may be a day when we're nostalgic for Trump, that our polarization
has really continued to increase because the rate of change has continued to increase.
So that's why I think it's so important that leaders like all of you are thinking about
how do we build bonds? How do we have people, Americans care about each other so that we can
keep the society coherent and caring despite the rapid amounts of change generated by technology.
I want to come back to something you referred to, which is to explore a bit more. And that is,
how are we going to pay for it? There is so much money going into data centers and investment
right now. And to some extent, I think it's been supporting the markets because there's
been so much investment. How do you get a return on that investment without laying off an awful
lot of people? With GDP growth. So you can either automate away the jobs. That's one theory. And
the other is that people will produce more. I'm sure it'll be a mix, but efficiency often
generates more growth. I mean, we did the radiology example. So it's sort of that at
larger scale. So the way we pay for it is more GDP growth. You can do GDP growth with fewer people.
And so what happens to the people who are out of work or have to take much more menial jobs than
they had before because it's the knowledge workers? Well, I think it's a great question.
Compare it to globalization. Probably this is a room full of globalists who believe in the
benefits of trade. And yet, despite that that really did deliver in terms of the overall
economy, there was enough dislocation and enough of the countries that our politics has been
shifted. So I think there probably will be things like that because of AI. But at least it's not,
again, it's not a mass layoff scenario, most likely. It's much more likely that there's a
growth response and that we also see significant GDP growth increased beyond what we typically
see because of the productivity of AI. What I hear from you is AI has enormous potential,
a lot of it for good, some of it for decidedly not good. It's very complicated. It's coming
very, very fast. Where will the leadership in directing AI come from? Are there people who
understand this, who get it, who have the right values, who can help us go in the right direction,
particularly given how fast it's coming? I would say that's an emerging area. I mean,
I think this was likely to be a big political issue in the next couple cycles because many
Americans will be concerned about the world changing too fast and too much. And I think
it's up to our politicians to sort of understand that and channel it in some productive way.
There's leaders in the industry like Geoffrey Hinton that spends full time now on these,
how do we keep humans at the center of the system? So there definitely are emerging leaders in that
way. But again, it's a new area like nuclear energy or other DNA for a long time was very
controversial. Timing is everything. And it comes, the developments you talk about come at a time
when there's a decided rise in populism in the United States as well as in much of the Western
world. Right now, the early things I'm hearing, at least about political, from the people is
it increases our energy costs and it reduces our jobs. We're against it. And some politicians are
showing signs now of trading on that and saying we should be against actually data centers. We
should be against them. How do you put together the rise of populism with the likely effects of
generative AI? Well, you know, the heart of democracy is we're going to live in this country
together and we're going to have different views. And so you want a system that's not civil war
to work out those views. And I think a lot of people will have those concerns. There'll be
those effects. We have to take them thoughtfully and seriously. And arguably during the era of
globalization, there was sort of lip service to retraining, but we didn't really understand or
take seriously the devastation of a lot of communities. So I think, you know, the elites
in this room, as an example, do a better job at that, which is, you know, where is AI really
providing benefits to people's health care, to their day-to-day lives? And if we can do that,
then there's more toleration of the dislocation, which is, as you said, cost of electricity,
data centers, those things. Are we over-investing? It's unlikely, but, you know, it's definitely
possible. But again, you know, the telecom boom in 2000, I mean, you know, it's a slight
over-investment. If you look in the telecom one, everyone got so excited about the internet that
they forward invested and were disappointed for a while, but ultimately the internet really
did deliver. But if you look at the mobile phone, it never had a bubble. It came out and just grew
and grew and grew in impact. So you can get both things that live up to the hype and things where
the hype gets bigger than the actual technology in the short term. And, you know, the market's a
good way to work that out on AI. Does it matter who gets there first? I mean, is this like beta
and VHS, where the one that gets there first gets to really set the standard? Well, if you're
talking countries, it matters a lot. So US versus China, take that. Correct. If you're talking
companies, you know, I care a lot because I'm on the board of Anthropic, but from a society
standpoint, it probably just matters that the technology is developed and deployed in great
ways. But it does matter in the US versus China. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, if another country
doesn't have to be China, that's ahead of us. There are significant scenarios referred to in
a class of the singularity where the AI gets so good that it writes the next day and that AI is
much better. And then that writes the next day. And so, you know, being first by even just a year
gives you an enormous advantage. So that's the exponential. But again, that's a theory
that's not yet proven. But even its slight possibility means we better darn get there
first. And I think we're on a good path. Well, that's my question. If that were your one goal
in the United States, what are the policies that get you there? What are the things we need to do
or avoid doing to make sure we're as competitive as possible? I think we're doing a pretty good
job on that. I mean, there's you would push the edge on light regulation, make it easy to build
data centers. I think the government's done open field running. So I can't think I don't I don't
think we need like a government investment program or something like that. So there's a
lot of progress and we are ahead of our competitors as far as we can tell. And again, we don't want
to make it zero sum because you would like just like we did in globalization. We would like to
bring the rest of the world along with us so that we've got a stable and we have less likely chance
of war. You've been listening to the Forum by the Economic Club of New York, a nonprofit 501C3
dedicated to connecting the world's brightest minds for critical nonpartisan conversations.
Be sure to subscribe now to be alerted to future new episodes. Would you like to be a part of the
conversation at the Economic Club of New York? Learn more about membership, the New York City
and National Fellows programs and other opportunities for engagement in the club
at www.econclubny.org. I'm your host, Becky Quick. Thanks for listening.