The Truth About Black Pearls | Tahitian Pearl History, Identification & Value ft. Matt Harris

Secret Life of Pearls
4 followers
1 Video View·Jul 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedExpert Matt Harris discusses the history, valuation, and characteristics of Tahitian pearls. The video distinguishes between natural and cultured pearls, explains the factors that determine market value, and warns buyers about the differences between naturally dark saltwater pearls and dyed freshwater alternatives.
Round, beautiful, aubergine, you know, peacock color,
teijin pearls, nobody can say no to those. Beauty in these darn things is just what does it. I
don't care if you're a male or a female. Naturally black pearls have captivated the
attention of men and women in the last few years. Discussing the history and value of
black pearls with us today is Matt Harris of Matt Harris Designs. This video is ideal for
the pearl shopper and seller alike, so stick around to learn everything you need to know
Tahitian mollusks were a big deal back as far as the 1800s. As a matter of fact,
the big industry for Tahiti, most of their income came from people harvesting oysters.
They weren't looking for pearls though, they were looking for buttons. Keep in mind,
at the time plastics weren't developed yet. There was no such thing as a plastic button,
so the button industry was like a huge deal. All right, so step ahead though to cultured pearls.
When did they start in Tahiti? For all my pearl nerds out there,
it's important that I make the distinction between natural and cultured pearls. In the pearl world,
natural means that the pearl was found, stumbled upon, located really in a wild mollusk,
cozy in its saltwater or freshwater home. Cultured pearls are still real pearls from real mollusks,
but as a result of human intervention, usually at a pearl farm. This is how the vast majority of
pearls on the market today are formed. Within both the natural and cultured categories,
we distinguish pearls based on whether they are from a saltwater or freshwater source.
Tahitian pearls are grown in the South Pacific Ocean, so they are saltwater pearls.
The first Tahitian pearl farm was created in 1960, but the pearls reportedly weren't that
great. They weren't round. And the first round pearls that came out of Tahiti were in 1970.
And once that happened, of course, everybody started farming pearls in Tahiti. And they're
popping up all over the place. And a few other things that happened that really pushed it.
In 1976, GIA officially called Tahitian pearls a natural colored gem, so that quite helped.
The value factors of pearls come down to luster. Obviously, the more luster, the better. And you
really want the luster to look reflective and iridescent. Color. The darker and more intense
the color, the better. Surface. Ideally free of blemishes. Size. When all other value factors
are equal, the value of a pearl is determined by its size and shape, with round being the
most desirable. Here is some Tahitian pearls. Here are some Tahitian pearls that are perfectly round.
They're almost blemish free. They've got anywhere from kind of a light silver to a light gray to a
dark gray. These have got good luster. If you were to take the same strand, but say in the same
size and the same luster, but let's say these were a dark gray with purple and pink, you know,
overtones with some orient, then they'd be amazingly more expensive. Although these aren't
going to be inexpensive. Here's the thing about the value and what you should be paying for pearls.
There's like a hidden gem, so to speak. And that is that beauty is in the eye of the beholder,
right? So I particularly think that anybody as a designer can put together the perfect strand
of pearls and a clasp, right? But what I love to design is pieces that use Baroque pearls. Pearls
that have such personality. They're funky shaped. Circlay pearls have circles kind of around them.
I like putting funky stuff together. It's important to note that there is a significant
difference in value between naturally black Tahitian pearls and dyed black pearls. It's
pretty easy to spot the difference if you've seen it before, but it's still important that
the seller disclosed the color treatment when selling dyed pearls. Some pearls are dyed. When
you buy black pearls, you could be buying dyed black pearls. Often those are freshwater pearls
that have been dyed, or you could be buying Tahitian pearls. Here are some dyed pearls
that are cranberry color. Great for Thanksgiving, by the way. These sell great, but there's no way
these are coming out of nature. Now this is a great example of strands of black pearls,
or Tahitian pearls. Same difference, but you see how some of them are kind of a light gray. Some
of them are darker. These are natural colored pearls from French Polynesia called Tahitian
pearls or black pearls. I have, I brought to you because I knew you'd ask me that question,
some dyed Chinese freshwater pearls. Hard to tell on a video, but if you look at these enough
in person, it's really easy to notice the difference, and there are ways to tell pearls
are dyed or not. But if you're buying, say, from a reputable person, just ask, you know,
is this a freshwater pearl that's dyed? Is it a Tahitian pearl that's a natural color? And you
should get the answer. So inexpensive freshwater pearls probably started out as some sort of cream
color that were dyed blackish versus natural Tahitian pearls that are all shades of gray
So dyed pearls are by no means bad unless they're being unscrupulously sold as having
natural color. Regarding Tahitian pearls, the pearls that are coming straight out of Tahiti
have completely natural color free of treatment. However, some Tahitian pearls that have gone
through Japan or China may be color treated to mimic rare colors such as chocolate or pistachio.
Are all naturally black pearls Tahitian? Naturally black pearls tend to be called
Tahitian pearls on the market, even though naturally black pearls that come from the
come from not only French Polynesia, but Fiji as well. We call those Fijian pearls,
but they're sometimes sold as Tahitian pearls. And some black pearls come from the
farmed in the Sea of Cortez in Mexico. Are all Tahitian pearls black? No,
there are white pearls that come out of Tahiti. And really, technically, as you can see,
Tahitian pearls aren't really black. This is a strand of black nephrite jade from Mason Kaye.
This is a gemstone that's actually the color black. In the case of Tahitian pearls,
they have a dark body color due to their opaque pearl nacre. But the overtones tend to be purple,
blue, green, and everything in between. I think the depth of color and overall allure of Tahitian
pearls makes them very appealing, whether as a fine and valuable 18 inch strand for ladies,
or an inexpensive men's single pearl on black cord. These are great sellers. When I sell
Tahitians to men, this is often a starting pearl because this looks great. A single Tahitian,
this one's drilled right through the middle on a steel chain. I either wear them on steel or
leather. You can get those for, gosh, anywhere from $300, $400 up to a few thousand dollars.
I love seeing men wear pearls, but I especially love seeing men wear Tahitian pearls. What do
you think of men wearing pearls? Be sure to let Matt and I know in the comments.
And I'm a big fan of this. And this is where I might butt heads with a few people watching this
video. Men and pearls are a thing. And men are wearing white strands, Machine Gun Kelly white
strands, Harry Styles. You see Tahitian pearls on Steven Tyler, yeah, on Pierce Brosnan. Tahitian
pearls on men I think is super cool. I wear one every day. Matt sells more than just Tahitian
pearls. In fact, I'm wearing a strand of Pink Freshwaters from Matt along with my Black Nephrite
Jade beads from Mason K. And this bracelet from Matt features a single freshwater pearl on a
stretchy bangle. You'll definitely want to check out Matt's YouTube channel, which I'm going to
link to in the description, which is dedicated to educating the public about pearls. Tahitians
tend to be much more expensive than freshwater pearls. In the pearl world, there is freshwater
and there's saltwater. Freshwater pearls being grown in lakes and streams and saltwater being
grown in saltwater. So in the saltwater world, you generally break it down into South Seas
pearls, Akoya pearls, and Tahitian pearls. In the Tahitian world, saltwater pearls are generally,
whether any three of those, more expensive than freshwater. A lot of men and a lot of famous men
that are wearing pearls, I've noticed, have started with freshwater pearls and not Tahitian
pearls. In the world of Tahitian pearls, generally the less expensive pearls that you might spend
five, eight, nine hundred dollars a strand on would probably be something smaller, Baroque,
meaning not round, and maybe multicolored. Under a thousand bucks, you could get a strand of those.
This is what I always say about pearls, but it's also what I always say about other gemstones.
This is what I say about art, about anything. I mean, you name it in life,
the prettier it is, the more expensive it is. I want to remind everyone watching this that it
is always important to shop with a seller that you trust. If you work in the industry or even
if you just want to be a more informed pearl buyer, I strongly encourage you to take CPAA's
Pearls as One course, which you can take for free if you use the discount code JOT at checkout.
Check out the link in my description. I caution people, even though I have a website and I'm
selling pearls online, I caution people against buying pearls online, at least from a source that
you're not familiar with, that you don't trust, that you can't kind of verify a reputation through
someplace else, because sadly enough, there's a lot of people that misrepresent their pearls online
in terms of what it is, whether it's dyed or not, for example, what origin it came from,
all that sort of stuff. And it's also really hard to see online things like overtones and whatnot.
I mean, it's very hard to photograph pearls. We do it all day long and it's tough.
