Brutally Honest Car Talk | Featuring BMW M5

Apex Drive
1 follower
We discuss where the BMW M brand is heading and how many brands seem to be falling into the endless pit of additive engineering. With prices skyrocketing, car attainability down, and future generations' interest waning, is the M5 a blueprint for success?
#cars #technology #business
00:00 Intro
1:20 What the M5 is Today
3:54 Counterpoints
5:35 Electronics
6:27 What Else Can Be Done?
7:08 Qualitative vs Quantitative Engineering
8:11 The Chris Harris Argument
9:37 Weight
10:37 Euro Regs
12:10 Just Because You Can...
13:20 It Would Be Fine if They Held Their Value
13:35 GenX vs Millennials vs GenZ
16:37 Sympathy For Brands vs Customer Reality
AI Generated·May contain errors
The BMW M5, the G90 slash G99 generation, otherwise known as the 2026. This is our
second time in this generation of M car. What I'm going to say is I know this vehicle is very
controversial. Many of you hate how much it weighs, hate what it looks like, and really what
it represents as a vehicle. And while your opinions may be valid, we're going to take a different
approach in this car. In our first video, which wasn't that well viewed if I'm going to be honest,
we took a very traditional Savage Ace approach. We walked through the engineering. We had a pro
driver give you the at-limit driving impressions. Then Mark and I also drove it on the street.
It's a very comprehensive look at this vehicle, and we lived with that car for two weeks at that
point. So if you are interested in buying one, go watch that video. Now that it's been almost a year
since we did that, I spent even more time in this vehicle. I use it as a long distance GT car.
My opinions have maybe not softened, but have changed. We're going to walk you through some
philosophy behind this car, where we think the industry is going, and of course,
how we feel about it today. Now that this thing's been on the market for over a year at this point.
Jack, I don't have the right haircut for this. Pick me up some broccoli hair.
Look, speed is not the problem with this car very clearly. And this being an M car,
you and I are probably about to get into a little bit of a...
A tussle.
A little Siskel and Ebert here.
Yeah, about the pros and the cons of this car.
This is a larger discussion outside of the BMW universe. I think it's applicable to a lot of
brands and models right now, but clearly this brand specifically, since we're in an M5.
I'll have you start, since you've been chewing on this car a lot more than I have.
I think, look, in our first video and the two weeks we had the sedan and the wagon,
wearing my like, Redditor hat, the journalist hat, the guy who's supposed to love wagons.
There's a lot that I don't like about this car. I want to be clear, because I live here in the
States, I would buy the CT5E Blackwing over this thing every single day. I think because that car
is basically an old car in a new package. That's why I love that vehicle and why I would take that.
If they ever decide to make a wagon version of that thing, it'll be God to me.
Problem is, the rest of the world doesn't have the luxury that we do currently in the States of
basically lax emissions laws. So given what they have to do with these cars now,
I guess maybe have a greater appreciation or accept what this thing is in today's world,
which is a very fast, still V8, big all-wheel drive sedan that can do track stuff. I thought
that anyone would ever do that. Be very, very quick in a straight line and now return, at least
prior to this, fill up on the highway to and from Michigan when we filmed the LS6 in the factory,
25 miles per gallon and still do 30 miles of E-range and have good hybrid integration for
the most part and still have the best automatic gearbox on the market. While I understand why
you don't like this thing and you've never liked any M5 to be fair, I've come to appreciate this
thing more. What are your thoughts on Mr. M5? I don't think it's necessarily true that I didn't
like any M5. I think I came up in the era where you saw the Clivo and stuff, the M5 and the 5
series of that era. I've always had a fond memory of the car and interest in it. I think it's when
you start to drive the new ones and I want to make this also very clear that I've owned three
different BMWs. I've owned not the old ones. This is not some red or sidewaxed. I own the ones that
are hated, the new ones. I've found some great things about this brand as they push the boundaries
of what's acceptable. People want to hear about your BMW. I guess people want to hear about you and your iPhone, dude.
This is a perfect car for you. Yes, continue. I'm not against some of these new cars. In fact, I probably am
in one of the minority that there's a lot of things about the new X5 and the potential new M3
that interests me greatly. I like that it's not like everything else, but where this car specifically
and a lot of these cars like it have gone into the mode heaven of changing every single
electromechanical system. They have to have a mode for everything. It's lost in translation of
what it's trying to be. Is it a luxury barge? Is it a performance car? Is it a track car? Is it a grand
tourer? And the side effect of not having a true identity of what this is even trying to do, they've
thrown the kinship sink at it and it's not really good at anything other than padding a spec sheet.
It's got the screens. It's got connectivity. It's got all-wheel drive. It's got rear-wheel drive.
It's got a hybrid system. It's got carbon ceramics. It's got big wheels and tires. It goes
0-60 in an insane amount of time, but the finer detail is it's not a great luxury car. It doesn't
ride great. It's not the quietest car. It's definitely not the most comfortable. The interior
looks like a giant children's toy with the way everything is shiny plastic everywhere. It's like
it's not focused and it's not doing everything. They don't have an identity here,
but it just there's something wrong with it. And I think it boils down to the fact
that I feel, I said this about a lot of M cars, I don't feel anything. There's no feeling to the
machine anymore. It's just a synthesis, a play on electronics and technology to show that they can
do it and that they've been able to do it. And that is about, that's about it. It's soulless,
100% soulless. And you know, there are other luxury products. You could say the same thing,
but at least they're good at being a luxury product. I think while I don't disagree with
you on the fuel side, right? I think this is just a by-product of modern cars. I don't know what
else they can do. That was a question I posted in the shop. That's still how I feel about this.
And given the modern confines from the engineer's perspective of what they have to do, this is the
only option, right? Like people aren't going to accept, at least I don't think people are going
accept a six-cylinder variant of an M5, right? And if you're stuck with a V8, are you telling me
that someone buying one of these cars will accept a slower, less powerful version of an M5 than the
prior generation? I just don't see that happening. It's a fundamental argument of, you were talking
about the qualitative versus quantitative engineering, right? Engineering tends to be,
especially in the German world, very, very specific to goals and checklist things,
mechanically, electromechanically, blah, blah, blah. You don't engineer around fuel,
you engineer around having to make metrics. Yes, but as somebody who's buying this product,
you are now becoming a by-product of fueling. I feel like I've been manipulated into their
zero feel, this is the only way to do it. It's such a rigid way to design a car that should be
emotional. And why this lacks emotion, in large part, is that philosophy of trying to check all
these boxes versus delivering an experience where you feel something connected to the machine.
This car does everything for you. It's, again, hyper expensive. Nobody's going to want to do
a brake job on this thing if they keep it. I just don't see it as different than any other M5.
I think this car would be much better simplified. It doesn't have to be to this extreme. And I know
there's the Chris Harris argument that we talked about. Well, if you don't feel the weight, what's
the difference? The difference is you can see in our track day stuff that we did, the cars only
fast for two laps. It's fake, right? It's the same argument with EVs. They're so heavy that they run
their tires off, you burn through consumables, you burn through brakes, and it's just a giant barge.
And then you have the complication of all these different systems that don't particularly make it
better. Five mile per gallon difference for me, spending $150,000. Or $135,000. I don't care
about the fuel economy in this segment so much. The plug-in part of it, maybe in Europe it makes
a difference. I don't need 25, 30 miles real world range being plugged in. To me, it's not adding a
whole lot of experience there for the weight that it's adding and the way the car is inconsistent
and its performance as you push it harder. So my counterpoint then is what do you, so in the real
world, right, your options currently if you're a German manufacturer in this space, you do something
like what Audi's doing with the new RS5, which people hate. Well, Ruben is in charge of the,
in Audi group, he's responsible for redoing the technology. And he's already said they're going
back to basics. They're going to strip all that ---- out of there. And that's ballsy coming from
the German side to make that commitment. And I think this brand has doubled down on the tech.
They ain't going back. But at least they didn't do the Mercedes thing. I think about the E53 we
just drove, similar price point. That thing's a huge piece of ----. Well, this is far superior
to that, but they have the same problems. They have an identity crisis of what are they trying
to do? And this car would be much better simplified. It doesn't need to be this tech-laden
and this weighed down literally and figuratively. So you'd be okay if this car, they're not going
to drop the car below 4,000 pounds. That just never happens. We don't need 700 horsepower out
of regular cars. No, sure. This is the argument. But this is an M5. I get that. But these cars,
okay, if you dropped 1,000 pounds of weight out of this, do you need 700 horsepower? It's that
argument. So if you dropped 1,000 pounds of weight, you say you were back at the old M5 weight,
which to me is about, I mean, Lexus couldn't make a car lighter than that. GM can't make a car
lighter than that. I think in this size of car, 4,000 pounds, if you're going to hit modern safety
requirements, modern quietness requirements is about where you're at. Plus or minus, right?
About 4,000 pounds. Yeah. Would you think, from my understanding, there's no way Euro regs would
allow this V8 and its current guys of 500 and whatever, 70 horsepower. It wouldn't make that.
It wouldn't make the emissions. So they made 500 horsepower. Would you be okay with that? Would you
think the customers would accept a V8 that made 170 horsepower? Again, this is an argument between,
I'm not saying the United States knows everything. I'm not saying we know better. I'm not saying this
is not us versus them. No, no, no. But you're in Germany. You're a German engineer. You're not
going to make it for the US. The laws of the laws are only going to get more restrictive.
The gun's to your head. Do you make a big, heavy abomination like this that makes a gajillion
horsepower? Or do you say, **** it, my car is about to be way slower than the last one?
That's the question I have for you. Because if I'm that engineer making that decision,
I'm screwed either way. Either I make a car that is slower than the M3 that currently sells,
that, sure, it's a regular twin-turbo V8, no hybrid bullshit, but it's got no balls,
or I make a heavy abomination. Do you think the consumer base, knowing how
the internet works, journalists are, would be like, all right, **** it, 170 less horsepower.
It does zero to 60 in four seconds versus three or four and a half versus three.
Like, do you think buyers would be okay? I don't think buyers would be okay.
Your argument is sound. I mean, I completely understand it. And I get why-
I agree. I think the car would be more fun if it was 4,000 pounds and a V8 that,
you know, I don't know. Actually, I have no idea if it would be more fun.
My argument to the brands and to the engineers we've talked to, and this goes across the board,
and if those people are watching this, they're going to be tired of hearing it because I beat
a dead horse with it. I say all the time, just because you can doesn't mean you should.
And there's this problem- You're giving me the Jurassic Park argument?
It's the leadership problem of, because you can, that you can spin up another product
doesn't mean it's instantly going to be better. And this is a perfect example of that. They've
done too much here. They continue to add more, the additive engineering that you talk about,
and then you have too many models, too many products, too much complication, a supply chain
you have to support and commit to that to do all of this. And at the end of the day,
is the product better for it? And this is not better for it. They've done what they set out
to do on the engineering side, but it is not a good car to drive. From a qualitative perspective.
From a qualitative perspective, as a buyer that wants something like this, it is not good in its
intended function to do all these different things because it fails on the luxury car part.
It's not, again, all those things I talked about, and it goes well beyond the engineering. It goes
onto resale value, desirability, a product that can stay on the road long-term. These have become
more and more disposable products. And it's not just BMW. It's a lot of the other luxury brands
that are just pushing this boundary of tech and complication and electromechanical systems and
moding and modes and all this other bullshit. It just keeps going on and on. And you wonder why
people are getting turned off by modern cars. And once Gen X goes through, you have millennials
like yourself that are probably going to... And yourself, Marcus, you're a young man.
Yeah, I'm a young man. We're going to... Our generations are going to start running out of
money for bullshit like this. And that leaves you with Gen Z, which is incredibly difficult
to wrap your head around. Are they going to be the ones that are going to have the money? And
are they going to be driving these things? And that's exactly long-term what you're going to
run into as a wall with that generation being like, **** this. Like, nobody is going to want
this ---- because it is just... It's asinine to what they've done to these cars. I don't know, man.
Like, I want to agree with you, but you look at the Gen Z, the broccoli hair meme with the G80.
That's who's buying them. I mean, their dads are buying them.
Dude, they're not buying these cars.
But that's what they...
There's no Gen Z that's spending $135,000 on an M5.
Dad is buying it.
That's my point. Once that money dissipates and you get generationally into the swing of this stuff,
like, there's a huge argument of why a lot of younger people are going back to older cars.
One, it's price. Two, it's the level of complication because they can buy a car
and actually get a part and swap it in. And there's not this ---- in here to deal with.
Going back, sure, that's a philosophical discussion about the industry, which I'm sure...
The M5 was not always this. The M5 was V8 and a manual transmission.
The V10 one didn't work, was disposable. The F10 didn't work.
Still, it was a V10 and rear wheel drive in a manual car and they...
Automatic largely.
And they made, you know, they made an SMG. But again, I'm not... This is not about old
BMW being better. This is... This is the other extreme. You know what I mean?
Like, you talk about the Blackwing, right?
Yeah.
It's a car that is... There's a lot of tech, but when you drive it, you have...
You feel like you're driving it because the tech's not in its way.
The car... This car, the technology, that's all it is.
Yeah.
There's literally nothing else about it. You're not driving the car. You feel nothing driving it.
I'll give you that. I... What I love about... I think the controls part...
I can't believe I'm saying this, of GM and their performance products,
is much better done than it is in the German cars currently.
There's too many modes in the Blackwing, but you can figure out how that ---- works.
This, there's like regen, you deal with what level of gearbox,
speed, how much ESC or stability control intervention there is.
Are you rear wheel drive? Are you all wheel drive?
Which power you have when you have to activate boost mode.
I agree this is too much, but one of the reasons I think the Cadillac is so great
is the fact that the drivetrain is relatively simple because it doesn't have to meet Euro regs.
And again, like, I get it. I get the European side and what they're against
with regulations and what their products have to be for their home market.
This just doesn't work here. I mean, it works here and people are going to buy it,
but it's not good at what it does. Like, this needs to be far different than what it is
to be a special experience, to justify the price tag.
And I would say if I could buy this and it wouldn't
go down 50% in value in three years, I would, I would be pulling for it more.
Okay. At least you're not throwing away money, but all these cars and I've owned BMWs.
I'm living that experience with the last, they are, you can throw them away.
Nobody wants them. Nobody wants them. That's a desirability problem.
The next generation is not going to be okay with throwing away half the value of their car
like this, especially when it's, it's not, it's certainly not worth it for what it is.
Yeah. My last question before we get into the final thoughts,
because I know I've been rambling for 20 minutes is do you think BMW cares?
No, they don't care.
Like, why do you think they don't care? I guess is the question.
Because they're Insular.
All right, Mark.
So because this has been 25 minutes or however long our conversation has been in the car,
we're not going to do a final thoughts, but I would love to see in the comments,
what people think and the reality part of having to make a car today,
because that's my argument kind of for this is I don't see what their other option is.
I agree with you.
So, yeah, I don't know that anybody's going to agree with you,
but I think I agree with you. The fact that this brand really can't do much else other than this
to, to have a car like this, to meet their own regulations and home market requirements,
they have to do this. And as a by-product we get the ---- rolls downhill here.
We get what they have to do.
And it's not a market specific product that could be way better for here and simplified.
