Can I get around a pre-existing condition limitation in a disability policy?

Disability Insurance
6 followers
Jul 29, 2026
Disability insurance attorneys Rachel Alters and Gregory Dell discuss the situation where a disability claimant with a pre-existing condition may be be able to get around the pre-existing condition limitation in a disability insurance policy. It is a common occurrence for a disability insurance company to deny claims based on a pre-existing condition.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAttorneys Greg Dell and Rachel Alters discuss the \"pre-existing condition limitation\" in long-term disability insurance. They explain how insurance companies use these clauses to deny claims filed shortly after a policy begins and provide strategic advice on timing claims to ensure coverage.
Hi, I'm attorney Greg Dell here with attorney Rachel Alters. And Rachel, you just came
across a case that was decided yesterday in the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, which
reminded you of this issue that affects many people applying for benefits, which is the
pre-existing condition limitation. So let's talk a little bit about what that is. And then,
since we help so many people with the application process,
ways that people could possibly get around that pre-existing condition limitation,
if it's something that comes up. So what is the pre-existing condition limitation?
A pre-existing condition limitation is usually contained in most group policies in their long
term disability plan. And it's really a way of the insurance companies to avoid paying claims
when you make a claim prior to one year of the plan being enforced. So it's really important.
Oftentimes, I get calls from claimants, potentials who want to make a claim or who have already made
a claim, and they've only been employed at their job for less than a year, or sometimes they're
employed for several years, but the employer had just offered the long term disability plan.
And when that happens, there's usually a clause which states if the plan has not been enforced
for at least 12 months, then the pre-existing condition comes into play and they look at a
three-month look back period for the three months before the plan was enforced to see exactly what
you treated for, what doctors were prescribing for you. And if anything during that three months
was related to the disability you're claiming, they will deny coverage. So it's really, really
important to make sure you know when that plan became enforced and to wait at least 12 months
to file a claim if you can, in order to avoid that pre-existing condition from kicking in.
Some have three months and some have 12 months, so it just depends. But it's not an
unfair, I don't think it's an unfair provision in the policy, because if you employ somebody and
they're 55 years old and they already have a bad back and an employer hires them
and they work for three months and then they say, my back's hurting me, it's kind of
to avoid fraud. You really should be working. It's not unreasonable to say, hey, you got to be
working for 12 months and then this coverage will kick in for something that you already had.
Otherwise, I don't think a lot of these companies would write these policies. So a recent case,
the issues that come up where we see litigation is, yeah, I might have had something going on,
you know, beforehand, but what my actual disability is was not caused by what you're
saying it was. And that's where we see a lot of litigation on the pre-existing. So what was it
about this particular case you just read that came out two days ago that that was significant to you?
This was a case where a truck driver filed a lawsuit against Lena, which is also known as
Cigna. He was working for the company for around a little under a year and he developed a macular
degeneration issue where his retina detached and he went blind. Now, obviously in this case,
a truck driver cannot drive if he cannot see. So he probably couldn't avoid filing the claim
at this point. But he did argue, he appealed the denial and he argued that the condition that Lena
was claiming that caused his retinal detachment, which caused the blindness, was not the reason
why he went blind. It was a different condition and they and Lena hired two different experts to
argue that the condition was in fact related. They denied coverage. The plaintiff appealed.
The court agreed with Lena saying that in their opinion they believed that Lena was correct
and that he did have a pre-existing condition and therefore he had no coverage. So unfortunately,
he cannot see. He's a truck driver. He can no longer work and he's not covered by his disability
policy. And this is an unfortunate situation that happens to a lot of claimants. And in this case,
he probably couldn't have avoided filing the claim because he had this serious condition.
But in some cases, the claim can be filed at a later date if it's a chronic back condition or
something that maybe you can hold out a little bit longer to file so that the pre-existing
condition doesn't come into play. But again, it just depends on the situation. Right. Because,
I mean, there's like 140 million working people in the United States. I think it's fair to say
that probably about half of them have some kind of office or sedentary type job. Correct. So,
this guy was a truck driver. In this case, obviously blind. There's no way he's working.
But many of the claims we deal with are orthopedic type limitations, some cognitive limitations,
rheumatoid type conditions, fibromyalgia, lupus, Lyme disease, different things where people have
been struggling for a certain period of time. And they may call us and be like, look, I've had
this condition, I'm treating. And then we get into their policy and be like, first thing we say is
how long we had the policy. Right. And often they'll be like, well, I had it for six months
or seven months. Immediately, we're going to tell you, look, you've got to have that policy for at
least 12 months, maybe even 15 months because that three months look back you're talking about.
Otherwise, they're just going to deny you for pre-existing conditions. So,
there are scenarios, take the classic example of someone who has a back problem and they're
like, look, I'm working, but it's so uncomfortable. And really, and they're nine months and they got
to get another three months. Basically, we're going to tell that claimant, you got to stick
it out. Yep. And if you do, then you're going to have coverage. If you don't, then they're just
going to deny you for the pre-existing. So, you can have people get confused. You can have a
pre-existing condition. Most people who are, you know, over 55 have some kind of pre-existing neck
back or some injury to their shoulder, whether it was 20 years ago or a knee surgery or whatever it
may be, and it rears its head again. Right. You know, so, but you have to have basically had,
you know, what is it in the pre-existing? No treatment during that 12-month period or...
And no medications being prescribed for that particular issue. And even if they see that
you had one medication prescribed that could have been for something else, but it also treats that
condition, they can deny you on that basis too. Now, there are certainly exceptions. You know,
the person who has a back problem and then, and again, this could still be litigate. What if they
get in a bad car accident and they go, now it's my back. Right. Well, they still may argue you had
that back problem beforehand and now the accident, you know, but so they're going to look, do a
serious look back on your medical records. Now, we talked about this in the group context for that
12 months, but we're also always see this on people who have private disability policies.
And when you bought your policy, they're going to look back at what you put in that initial
application for when you bought in that. I've had that go back 25 years. So if you fail to
disclose a pre-existing condition, it's a little bit different pre-existing condition issue, but
something very serious that could also be a basis for denial because you didn't disclose to the
carrier a condition you had. So if you're dealing with anything pre-existing and you're considering
filing claim or you filed it already, you have to be aware of what your prior medical condition is.
The last time you saw a doctor, it's okay if your back was hurting you, but you didn't go to the
doctor. But once you got it documented, it's on paper and it's going to be found and it has to
be dealt with. So what I encourage you to do, if you have any concern whatsoever about a pre-existing
condition or even there's other issues that come up as well, call Rachel, call any of our disability
attorneys for a free initial consultation. What we're going to do is review your disability policy
for free, let you know what we think are any potential concerns that may come up with your
claim, and we'll let you know immediately whether or not we can help you or not. We offer this
service anywhere in the country and we look forward to the opportunity to speak with you.
