The Best $40 Bordeaux? Chasse Spleen vs Meyney

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
Jul 27, 2026
If you had US$40 to spend on a bottle of Left Bank Bordeaux, would you choose Château Chasse-Spleen or Château Meyney?
Neither estate appears in the famous 1855 Bordeaux Classification, yet both have consistently outperformed many classified growths for decades.
AI Generated·May contain errors
If you had just 40 US dollars to spend on a bottle of left-bank Bordeaux,
would you choose to buy Chateau Chaspin or Chateau Ménet?
Neither appears in the famous 1855 classification.
Yet, after more than 30 years of collecting Bordeaux,
they are still two of the wines I buy most often.
Not because they are inexpensive.
Because, year after year, they deliver the kind of quality
that often rivals classified brews costing two or three times as much.
When I first started building my cellar,
I dreamed of owning the great Creuse Classés.
Over time, though, I relied that some of Bordeaux's smartest buys
sit just outside that famous classification.
Chaspin and Ménet became two of those discoveries.
They have remained fixtures in my cellar ever since.
And if I were rebuilding my collection today,
I would happily buy both again.
The remarkable thing is that recent vintages still sell for around 30 to 40 US dollars.
In this video, I will compare two bottles from my cellar,
explain how differently they taste, which fruit they suit best,
and ultimately, which one I would recommend,
depending on the kind of Bordeaux you enjoy.
And one final thought before we begin.
While you are still discovering their preferences,
buy three or six bottles rather than a full case of 12.
The cellar should evolve alongside your taste.
Although both are famous for over-delivering,
these wines couldn't be more different.
If you enjoy elegance, perfume, or silty texture,
you will probably prefer Chaspin.
If you enjoy darker fruit, greater structure,
and wines that reward patience, Ménet may be the better choice.
The reason lies largely in where they are grown.
Château Chaspin comes from Moulisse-en-Médoc,
one of the Médoc's smaller inland appellations,
where gravel and clay soils tend to produce refined, expressive wines.
Château Ménet sits farther north in Saint-Esteve,
overlooking the Géhone estuary.
Here, gravel, clay, and sand produce wines with more structure,
concentration, and longevity.
The grape blends reinforce those differences.
Chaspin is typically around 40-50% Cabernet Sauvignon,
40-50% Merlot, with a little Petit Verdot.
The generous Merlot contribution gives the wine much of its charm
and early approachability.
Ménet usually contains 40-55% Cabernet Sauvignon,
around 40% Merlot, and 5-10% Petit Verdot.
That extra Cabernet Sauvignon, and especially the Petit Verdot,
gives Ménet its firmer structure and distinctive spicy character.
So, even before opening the bottles,
you already know they're aiming for two very different styles.
Château Chaspin
If your idea of Great Bordeaux is elegance rather than sheer power,
Chaspin is incredibly difficult to beat at this price.
The estate was created in 1822,
following the division of the larger Château d'Anpougeot.
Its modern era began in 1976,
when Jacques Merlot purchased the property
and placed his daughter, Bernadette Villard, in charge.
Today, the 130-hectare estate is run by Bernadette's daughter,
Céline, and her husband, Jean-Pierre Foubet.
The nose combines dark berries, vanilla, cedar,
smoke, and delicate floral notes.
On the palate, you will find Morello cherry,
blackberry, plum, tangerine, and pastry flavors
layered with herbs and graphite.
Bright acidity, fine tannins,
and a long saline finish keep everything beautifully fresh.
What I love most is the balance.
The wine feels polished, elegant,
and remarkably pure without ever becoming thin.
It avoids the rustic edges and excessive richness
that can sometimes appear elsewhere in the Médoc
and instead focuses on precision and freshness.
Considering the price,
it regularly outperforms classified Ross
that cost considerably more.
The 2020 and 2022 vintages are around 40 US dollars,
while the 2024 and 2025 are around 30 dollars.
Château Ménet
If Chasplin is elegance, Ménet is quiet power.
Its history stretches back to the 13th century
when Cistercian monks first cultivated the estate,
expanded during the 16th century,
and confiscated during the French Revolution.
It eventually passed to Désiré Cornier,
owner of Gros-La-Rose and Talbot in 1919.
Since 2004, the estate has belonged to Cadillac École Grand Cru.
Its 51-hectare vineyard forms one continuous block
beside Château Moreau, gently sloping towards the Gironde.
The nose offers red berries, leather, pencil shavings,
earth, and bright flowers.
The palate combines raspberry, blackcurrant, damson,
game, and baking spices with subtle mineral notes.
Bright acidity, fine tannins,
and a long savory finish bring everything together.
Compared with Chasplin,
Ménet feels broader, denser, and more structured.
The generous proportion of Petit Verdot
adds an attractive spicy lift
while the freshness prevents the wine from ever feeling heavy.
Over the past decade,
Ménet has quietly established itself
alongside many excellent fifth-growths.
The 2020 and 2022 vintages are around US$40
while the 2024 is around US$25
and the 2025 around US$30.
The verdict
This is one of those comparisons
where there isn't a wrong answer.
They are simply built for different occasions.
Choose Chasplin if you enjoy fragrance,
elegant Bordeaux with silky tannins,
and effortless charm.
It's affordable, relatively young,
ages beautifully,
and consistently delivers far more than its price suggests.
Around the table,
I naturally reach for Chasplin
when the meal is on the lighter side.
Roast chicken,
duck,
veal,
pork,
mushroom dishes,
or even a cheese board.
Its freshness and finesse complement rather than overpower the food.
Choose Ménet if you prefer darker fruit,
more structure,
and a classic Saint-Esteve personality.
It's richer,
more savory,
and rewards longer sellering,
yet remains surprisingly enjoyable even young.
When richer dishes are on the menu,
Ménet is usually my choice.
Roast lamb,
steak,
slow-cooked beef,
venison,
or hearty winter stews
all benefit from its extra depth,
firmness,
structure,
and savory character.
If I were reburning my seller,
I honestly wouldn't choose between them.
I would buy both.
For around 30 to 40 US dollars,
they remain two of Bordeaux's greatest bargains.
If you had to choose just one,
would you reach for the elegance of Chaspline
or the power of Ménet?
I would love to hear which side you are on.
And if there is another Bordeaux comparison
you would like to see next,
let me know in the comment section below.
You will find more of my seller insights
and tasting notes on Instagram.
Massive thanks for watching today,
and I will see you in the next one.
