The 8,000-Year-Old Camel Mystery

mysterious nature
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAn extraordinary archaeological site in northern Saudi Arabia features monumental high-relief sculptures of camels and equids. Initially attributed to the Nabataeans, multidisciplinary scientific dating suggests the carvings are far older, likely originating in the Neolithic period between 7,000 and 8,000 years ago, challenging previous understandings of the region's prehistoric art.
Hidden in the deserts of northern Saudi Arabia is one of the most extraordinary discoveries from
the last few years. Life-sized sculptures of camels and equids. Nothing like them has ever
been found before in the region. They were initially dated to the Nabataean period about
2,000 years ago, but through a variety of scientific techniques they realized these
could potentially be older. Much older. Over 7,000 years old. Hi, I'm Dr Hugh Thomas. Let's
dig deeper into the amazing camel site of Saudi Arabia. Hi, if you're new here, my name's Hugh.
I have a PhD in archaeology and for the last 20-something years or so I've been taking part
in archaeological fieldwork all across the world. So in 2016 a man called Hussein Al-Khalifa reported
a site in northern Saudi Arabia in the Al-Jawf region near Saqqaqa. Around these rock faces
were carvings of animals, camels, equids. A number of them in very high relief. Unlike a normal
engraving, high relief is carved so deeply that much of the animal projects out from the rock.
Now a lot of them are quite badly weathered, meaning they almost blend into the natural rock.
But once you get your eye in, there are animals everywhere. It kind of reminds me of one of those
3D eye puzzles that used to be a big hit back when I was a kid, where you stare at them long
enough something appears. Look, a shark! So since 2018 this site has been studied by an international
and it's been published in a number of papers, but it's this paper that I will focus on today.
And just to make it clear, whilst I am a co-director of a number of archaeological projects in Saudi
Arabia and friends with a number of the people who work on this research, I'm not affiliated
with the camel site. I just think it's really cool archaeology. So the site is unlike anything that's
been found in Saudi Arabia. And don't get me wrong, we find a lot of rock art. Some of it is spectacular
carvings of animals like cattle, but others are much simpler. Generally the rock art is scratched
or pecked into the surface, making it very two-dimensional. But at the camel site, as I've
explained, they found these monumental high-relief sculptures, basically more 3D. So obviously it
looks very out of place in Saudi Arabia, but they're not unique when you look at the larger
region of West Asia more generally, because similar carvings have been found at the site of Petra in
Hey, if you're enjoying this video about real archaeology that isn't crappy AI, I encourage you
to subscribe and press the little bell and turn on notifications. Any support you can throw my way
is fantastic. Now Petra is one of the most famous archaeological sites in the world. It was the
capital of the Nabataeans and was flourishing around 2,000 years ago until it was annexed by
the Romans. So because of the similarity between Petra and the camel site, it was thought that
the carvings dated to the Nabataean period. And yes, the Nabataeans were in Saudi. Their second
capital is at a site called Hegra in Al-Ula, known for these famous rock-cut tombs. Fun fact,
the dig house that we used for our project was actually just a couple of minutes walk from here.
But these sculptures weren't found at a Nabataean site like Petra or Hegra. So in order to work out
who made them and when, they would have to date these sculptures. But the problem is that dating
rock art is incredibly difficult. So when we think of archaeology, the most common scientific
technique used to date an archaeological site is radiocarbon or C14 dating. C14 dating works by
measuring the carbon left in once living material. But stone like this doesn't contain carbon that
can be dated. So how do you date rock art? Well the project used a number of different methods
in order to narrow down the date range for when this site was made. One technique they used is a
or OSL. OSL is a technique where archaeologists can date the last time the quartz grains were
exposed to sunlight. Basically when the sediment is exposed to sunlight, the clock kind of resets
to zero. But once those quartz grains are buried by either a structure or a large rock falling on
top of them, they absorb little bits of natural radiation which can then be tested for in order
to determine the last time they saw light. Now obviously these sculptures are on the site of a
but several pieces eroded and fell off trapping some sediment underneath which was dated by OSL.
So three OSL samples returned a date between 4,230 to 2,920 years ago, plus or minus a couple
of centuries. So there are two things that we can understand from these OSL dates. Firstly,
this site is not from the Nabataean period because the rock fell down at about a thousand BCE and
places like Petra are in its heyday about a millennia later. But secondly, the OSL dates
only show when that stone fell, so the rock art has to have been earlier than that event.
So how do they get more evidence? Well, you've got to excavate. Now much of the sediment around
the site had been bulldozed away, but they found one section to drop a test trench underneath one
of the panels. This excavation uncovered animal bones from three different depths which produced
C14 dates between 5,600 and 5,200 BCE, placing human activity at the site firmly in the Neolithic.
They also found things like lithics, like these transverse arrowheads,
that are nicely Neolithic in date. Now this information isn't a smoking gun so to speak,
but it does mean that the date range for these sculptures likely falls between the time period
of the 6 millennium BCE, so between about 6,000 and 5,000 BCE, down to a thousand BCE when some
of these panels had fallen off the rock base. The archaeologists also analyzed the stone carvings
There was no evidence of metal chisels, so this has potentially suggested that the site
is pre-bronze age, that is that it's older than about 5,000 years or so. That being said,
just because metals arrive on a landscape doesn't mean that lithics stop being used,
so we do need to be mindful of that. But the final technique they used is one that is not
commonly known about but is really, really cool, but it does need a little bit of explaining.
If you look at rocks in arid regions you'll often notice they are a variety of different
colors from a honey brown color to much darker. Now that dark patina you can see is a thing called
desert varnish. Desert varnish is a thin dark coating that slowly forms on exposed rocks in
arid environments. It's mostly made of clay along with minerals like manganese and iron
and a sprinkling of organic matter. But here's the thing about desert varnish, it takes a long
time for it to build up on rock faces and when someone carves into the rock the varnish is
scraped away from the surface exposing fresh stone. Over time this new layer of desert varnish begins
to grow, so by measuring how much varnish is present on rock art you can estimate how long
ago the carving was made. So this is a really good example from a different part of Saudi Arabia where
you can see the desert varnish has covered most of the older carvings but the newer carvings are
still much brighter, it doesn't have a lot of the varnish on top. So to measure the accumulation
of desert varnish scientifically you use a thing called portable x-ray fluorescent spectrometry or
PRXF. You take measurements on the rock art, untouched desert varnish and freshly exposed rock
and this allows the researchers to estimate the rate of accumulation of the desert varnish
and thus estimate how old the rock art is. Now this type of dating has a large error range and
that's because the accumulation of desert varnish on a rock base is impacted by a number of different
variables. Things like the weather, wind, the direction of the rock base for example. So the
date ranges provided by this technique often have an uncertainty of about 30 to 40 percent which
is big. So although this technique is not going to be able to date the rock art
really accurately it does at least demonstrate what time period they were made in. So on one panel,
panel one, which is one of the best preserved rocks with desert varnish, they found the panel
was about 8,100 years old with an error either side of 3,200 years. Or to put that more simply
the panel was carved sometime between 11,300 years ago and about 4,900 years ago. Another sample was
between 9,600 years ago and 4,200 years ago. You get the idea. Now individually each one of these
techniques has its limitations but when the archaeologists studying the camel site put them
all together they believe that all of this information and evidence points towards the
camel site being made between 7,000 and 8,000 years ago in the Neolithic period. So we have
camels and equids at this site. Now the equids they've been found at other types of rock art
sites dating to the Neolithic period. This is this beautiful panel of a hunter with his dog pack
hunting a wild ass. Now if you've watched any of my Saudi Arabian archaeology videos before you'll
know that this time period between about 8,000 and 7,000 years ago was a big one in Saudi Arabia.
There were a lot of changes happening and this is where I get to talk about my own project's
research. The project I co-direct in Al Ullah and Kaibar have identified the arrival of domestic
structures at about this time period. These structures called standing stone circles.
Likewise monumental ritual structures mustateel date to this time period as well. We find fun
arrowheads and domesticated animals in both structures all pointing towards a larger
cultural connection with the wider region like the Levant. So although we find lots of wild and
domesticated animals in the domestic and ritual structures of this time period you know the one
thing that we don't find in there? Camel bones. It's quite a big mystery but what sites like the
Camel site demonstrate is that between about 7,000 and 8,000 years ago Saudi Arabia was a
hip and happening place that a lot was happening in. But here's the thing the love of camels in
Saudi Arabia may not be 7,000 to 8,000 years old because this isn't the only site with large-scale
camel rock art. At another site studied by a number of the same researchers as the Camel site
they found more big camels along with other animals. Not high relief like the Camel site
but still really impressive. Now through various techniques they believe that this site dates to
and get this between 12,800 and 11,400 years old. But the question is why so many big camels? Well
as the lead author Maria Gweneen states these large engravings are not just rock art they were
probably statements of presence access and cultural identity. If you'd like to know more
about what the researchers think about both sites I'm going to link in the description
their research articles and a couple of interviews so you can dig deeper into it for
yourself. But I'm really curious write a comment below and tell me what you think is the reason
for people carving these monumental animals into these rock bases. Now as more publications and
research about Saudi Arabian archaeology comes out you know I'm going to be making videos about it
so if you're interested in this kind of archaeology please make sure to click that subscribe button.
I really value any support you can throw my way. Thank you so much for watching. Cheers.
