800,000 college students are paying full tuition — to earn LESS than a high school grad. Not a typo. The government just cut off federal loans for degree programs that don't pay off. Dr. Phil names the schools cashing the check anyway — USC, Juilliard, NYU, Reed — and breaks down why $260,000 can buy you a $40K salary. Before your kid signs that loan, listen to this.
Thank you to our sponsors: Don’t wait! If you’re on Medicare or will be soon, reach out to Chapter: Call: (352)-845-0659 or go to https://askchapter.org to learn about your Medicare options and get help finding ways to save money.
Struggling w Poor Sleep? RELAXIUM® Sleep is backed by a 90-day guarantee, so you’ve got nothing to lose. Enjoy restful and refreshing sleep with drug-free, non-habit forming RELAXIUM® Sleep. Get your risk-free bottle now. Go to https://TryRelaxium.com or call 800-952-7770.
Experience a side of Dr. Phil McGraw you may have been missing as he provides critical information on some of the most important issues we face today. McGraw delves into the minds of the most exciting and accomplished people. From celebrities to ordinary people in extraordinary circumstances, to the world’s leading experts, every guest and topic is provocative, informative, and relevant. http://drphilpodcast.com
Dr. Phil McGraw, one of the most well-known and trusted mental health professionals in the world, is the host of daytime TV’s top-rated program, Dr. Phil. This trailblazing and award-winning platform continues to provide the most comprehensive forum on mental health issues in the history of television. Dr. McGraw’s unique ability to take complicated and technical information and make it accessible and understandable to the general public has distinguished him both among viewers and within his profession.
The speaker critiques the current higher education system, labeling many degree programs as financial scams that leave students with unsustainable debt. He supports new federal regulations that restrict loans for programs with poor returns on investment and encourages students to consider high-paying blue-collar trades as a more viable path to financial stability.
A whole lot of these college programs are just a damn scam.
Kids got buried in debt without the upside of a respectable salary.
I'm not anti-college. I got more degrees in a thermometer.
But do you know what you make as a plumber?
Well, it's the dog days of summer, but college is already in the air.
Kids are thinking about it. They're going to be heading off.
A whole new phase of their life, right?
And that means millions.
We're talking millions of incoming freshmen about to step foot on campus for the first time.
They're thinking, okay, I'm an adult now. I'm getting ready.
I'm going to go out and set the world right.
Exciting times, but that ain't the real story, is it?
The sad truth is that one in 25 college students is being ripped off.
Now, that's not a random number.
More than 800,000 students are sitting in college programs right now
that will leave them earning less money than the average high school graduate,
even four years after they finish.
So think about this.
They spend four years in college.
Then they go out into the work world for four years and look at what they're making,
and it's less than if they had never spent that four years in college.
They're making less money than if they had gone to work as a high school graduate
and got on with their lives.
So after spending all of that money on college,
these students are worse off than they would have skipped it altogether.
You got to let that sink in for a minute.
What does that mean?
That means that a whole lot of these college programs are just a damn scam.
A scam.
Universities charging for worthless classes that will earn you less than a high school diploma.
And what's more, they know that.
Do you not think they know that?
Do you not think when they have these students lined up
and signing up for a bunch of these degree programs,
they very well know this will never pay out?
And they're going to get loans.
They're going to spend money.
They're going to do all of this work, and it will never pay out.
Now, that's why I am so happy that part of the president's big, beautiful bill,
whether you like the bill or not, don't care, not interested in that,
let's just talk about this specific aspect,
is putting an end to this nonsense.
The new rule as of July 1 of this year,
students can no longer take out federal loans for degree programs
that fail to deliver a return on their investment.
You got to think about that too.
We're talking about a student that may say,
oh, well, oh, I can't go to college.
I can't get a loan.
That's good news.
You've probably seen me talking with ex-students with student loans,
some of them with $100,000 debt.
Now, Holly, you're an attorney, right?
Yep.
You racked up $120,000.
And you say you don't think it was worth it.
I personally do not think it's worth it.
And if they had been turned down at the time,
they would have thought, oh man, this is terrible.
I can't go to college.
I'm stuck.
But here they are 10 years after graduating with $100,000 debt load,
and they just feel like there's no way out ever.
Why?
Because they got scammed by a university.
Now, if you want to go to college for a career that earns you less than a high school diploma,
first off, they need to tell you that.
A college counselor needs to sit down with you and say,
you need to understand you're going to spend a lot of money here,
and it is not going to pay off for you.
And if you want to go into debt to do this and not have the money to pay it back,
make that decision with clear eyes open.
When you get through, you're going to have a debt load
that you won't be able to pay off in 10 years or 20 years.
But they don't do that.
Why?
Because they want your money.
That's why.
And if you want to do that, and you're willing to pay for it,
then knock yourself out.
But don't expect the government to help you,
and the government shouldn't cripple you with it either.
For years, the government underwrote loans for teenagers
without ever asking if the product worked.
They didn't care.
Schools raised tuition.
Taxpayers footed the bill.
Kids got buried in debt without the upside of a respectable salary.
Let me give you some examples.
Music grads from the University of Southern California, USC, $34,124.
Juilliard School of Music.
Juilliard, greatest music school ever, $32,842 average salary.
The new school, $32,930.
All earned less than a typical high school graduate.
Four years after graduation.
So maybe they didn't get a great salary when they started out,
but four years after working in the field,
they're still making less than a high school graduate.
Cooper Union Fine Arts, $24,920.
Four years out.
Bard College Liberal Arts, $34,571.
And Fine Studio Arts, $34,667.
Also less than someone with a high school degree.
Now, with the new rule, if you decide to enroll in these programs,
you can do it, but you're going to pay for it on your own.
And some people will.
They'll say, look, I'm not in it for the money.
Dr. Phil, you've said a million times there are all different kinds of currency, right?
There are different kinds of currency.
And there are different kinds of currency.
There's emotional currency, social currency, achievement currency, spiritual currency.
There's all different kinds of currency.
I want more than just that.
Great.
And if you can afford that, you should do it.
If somebody says, I want to go to some kind of literature program and write the great
American novel, fine.
If you can afford that, do it.
If you can pay for it on your own, knock yourself out.
Let's do some math.
The all-in average cost for a private college is $65,000 a year.
That's tuition, room, board, and books.
Multiply that by four years, and you're looking at $260,000.
But then you graduate with a degree that four years into your career lands you a salary
of $40,000.
Does that make sense?
You can't live on that in this day and time.
How are you going to service a debt of $260,000?
That's over a quarter of a million dollars.
It doesn't make sense.
It never made sense.
And the government should not help you pay for a losing proposition.
Think about it if it wasn't college.
Let's just say you went into the Small Business Administration, or you went into your local
bank and said, okay, I need a loan, and here's my business plan.
I'm going to spend four years preparing.
I'm not going to make any money in this four years, so you're going to have to fund me
with this loan.
But when I get through with that four years, I'm going to go open up a small business,
and it's not going to pay me enough to live or pay back the loan.
So that's my business plan.
Will you make me the loan?
We'll be right back.
Here's what nobody warns you about Medicare.
It isn't one decision.
It's a hundred decisions stacked on top of each other.
Most people make these decisions mostly alone and hoping for the best.
I've said it for years.
Hope is not a strategy.
That's why I want you to know about Chapter.
You don't have to untangle Medicare alone.
In one simple call, a Chapter advisor, a real human, learns about your situation, your doctors,
your prescriptions, your budget, and compares every plan in the country to find the best
fit for you.
They break down your options in plain English.
Your best Medicare strategy isn't hoping.
It's free help from Chapter.
Stop hoping.
Click the link below.
Are you one of 70 million Americans struggling with poor sleep?
Lying awake at night?
Mind racing?
Unable to shut it off?
Dr. Phil here.
I've spent decades talking to people at their breaking point, and I hear the same thing
over and over.
They're not sleeping.
And when you don't sleep, your brain goes into survival mode.
You can't focus.
Problems feel bigger than they are.
That's why I did my research, and Relaxium Sleep is the only sleep aid I take and recommend.
Relaxium Sleep helps me fall asleep, stay asleep, and wake up refreshed.
And once you experience the amazing health benefits, like more energy, better mood, and
clearer thinking, you'll see just how much better life can be.
Relaxium Sleep is backed by a 90-day guarantee, so you've got nothing to lose.
Get your risk-free bottle now.
Go to TryRelaxium.com or call 800-952-7770.
That's TryRelaxium.com or call 800-952-7770.
Here's my business plan.
I'm going to spend four years preparing.
I'm not going to make any money in this four years, so you're going to have to fund me
with this loan.
But when I get through with that four years, I'm going to go open up a small business,
and it's not going to pay me enough to live or pay back the loan.
So that's my business plan.
Will you make me the loan?
They would laugh you out of the bank.
They would laugh you out of the building.
They wouldn't do it.
But yet, if you're a student, it's just automatic.
Now, to be fair, most degrees are worth it.
Engineering and computer science majors typically start $75,000, $80,000 range, roughly double
the majors that I just talked about.
And some of these questionable majors catch up by mid-career.
By the time they're 35 to 45, they do catch up.
For example, biology starts near $45,000, but they reach mid-80s.
So low starting salary isn't always worthless.
You do catch up.
But you spent all of those years servicing that huge debt, sacrificing, doing without.
Now, that's why the new rule targets programs, not majors.
The lowest of the commonly tracked majors, foreign language, $40,000 median.
General social sciences, $41,000 median.
And here's how the new rule works.
Undergrad programs must prove their graduates earn more than a typical high school graduate
four years after finishing.
And if you fail two out of the three consecutive years, you're cut off of federal loans.
As I said earlier, the Department of Education data suggests over 800,000 students
currently attend a program that is likely to fail.
The Department of Education will begin calculating graduate earnings in early 2027.
The first programs could lose aid eligibility in the 28-29 award year.
I think that's a little too late.
But that's the deal.
And I don't think it goes far enough.
As long as their grads, four years out, make even a few dollars more than a high school
graduate, they can keep getting federal loans.
That's crazy.
The Berklee School of Music dance degree grads earn $35,702 four years after graduating.
The high school benchmark is $34,808.
So it passes the test by $894.
So about $17 a week at a school that costs nearly $80,000 all in.
Reed College psychology grads earn $36,430 four years after graduating,
clearing the high school grad benchmark by just $1,622.
So even though one of the most expensive colleges in America at nearly $74,000 a year in tuition,
that's over $300,000.
And they're going to be paying for that with so little money?
NYU dance grads earn $38,571, beating high school diploma by $37,063 four years after
graduating.
Who knows what they make until then?
The total cost there, $95,000 a year.
Every one of these programs keeps full access to federal loan money.
Now look, I'm not anti-college.
I'm a college graduate.
I got more degrees than a thermometer.
It's paid off for me.
America needs to lead the world in higher education.
I've encouraged my kids to go to college, and they did.
College has always been part of the American dream.
There was a time when a college degree was the ultimate achievement.
It was a huge deal to be the first person in a family to graduate college.
It wasn't just your accomplishment.
It felt like your entire family had crossed the finish line together.
Graduation caps tossed into the air.
Your diploma hung in the living room.
Parents would proudly drive around with the back window stickers where their kids go to school.
Many still do, but let's look at some alternatives here.
We're talking about a quarter of a million dollars for some of these schools.
Now in-state tuition, it could be less.
If you go to a state school and you can get in, which is really tough,
it's still going to be, we're talking six figures.
Do you know what you make as a plumber?
A plumber can earn anywhere between $75,000 and $100,000 a year.
An electrician, $75,000 to $100,000 a year.
You may start out at $62,000, but that's 50% more than some of these college graduate programs.
Same thing for a carpenter.
What's it cost?
If you become an apprentice, it can cost you nothing,
and you're earning money while you're learning to get licensed.
If you go to a program, a school, it can cost $10,000, $12,000,
and you're still earning money while you're going,
and you don't come out with a huge student loan debt.
So all these people that are turning their nose up at blue-collar trade jobs,
they're going to be so much more affluent than you are,
so much faster than you are, so much longer than you are,
and maybe making double your salary.
Have you really thought about that?
You can get into a trade, and if you're entrepreneurial, you say,
hey, I'm entrepreneurial, then get 10 plumbers working for you.
Get a master electrician's license and have an electrical services company.
Become a carpenter and own a lumber yard.
You can be as entrepreneurial as you want in whatever field you want,
but don't foreclose that and go put yourself in debt with no way to earn your way out.
The real story, a college degree is still a massive accomplishment.
It can be a doorway to success, but colleges have gotten out of control.
Every school in the top 30 now charges over $72,000 a year.
It's up 4.5% on average from last year.
They keep going up.
The top five by tuition?
Oh my gosh.
Colgate, 76 grand.
Williams, 76.
Vassar, 76.
Wesleyan, 75.
Colby, 75.
USC, a home of one of the flagged failing music programs, is number seven.
Add room, board, and fees, the total cost of attendance is 100 grand a year.
Here's the thing.
Only about 38% of undergraduates pay full sticker price because
generous aid can cut real costs dramatically.
Vanderbilt can drop from 95 to 35.
That's why the government has finally put its foot down.
It will happily help students pay for college,
provided the college is giving them a real education,
which is worth more than a high school diploma.
It's not all or nothing.
A community college costs six times less than a private four-year degree.
Like I said, trade schools lead to lucrative blue-collar jobs.
Military has done an amazing job paying for college in return for service.
College degrees should be a launching pad,
not a quarter-million-dollar lesson in what not to buy.
So before your child signs on that loan line, do the math.
Help them sit down and think it through.
I know they gotta study some, but get a job.
Because for the first time, the government is finally doing the math.
But the accountability you have is for you and your family and your child.
And when somebody steps up and says,
It's hard to say no at the time.
It's so easy to take somebody else's money,
but you find out really fast it's yours and those payments come due.
And then you hear all this talk about,
well, are we going to forgive student loans?
There's no forgiving student loans.
Somebody's got to pay that somehow, some way.
Somebody's got to pay it.
And let me give you a clue who that somebody is.
Want to take a guess?
Yeah, raise your hand.
That somebody is you and me.
Somebody's got to pay that, and it's us.
And when I hear politicians say,
Hey, we're going to forgive these loans.
It's not going to impact taxes whatsoever.
It's already paid for.
My administration is working to provide up to $10,000 in student debt relief.
The authority is already there in law for the president and his team,
the administration, the secretary of education,
to cancel out this student loan debt.
Do you all believe that this student loan program is fully paid for?
But we do believe it will be fully paid for
because of the work that this president has done with the economy.
Well, unless somebody stamped stupid on your forehead and mine,
we know you just don't make money out of thin air.
It's got to come from somewhere,
and the government makes money from taxes,
and we are the ones that pay them.
So when it comes time to go to college,
ask your child for real.
Can you make a living with this degree?
And if they say, Well, it's not about that.
I just want to help people.
I want to have an impact.
I want to contribute something.
That's fine.
But somebody has to pay for that largest.
Somebody has to pay for your willingness to want to do that.
And if you're willing to be the one to do it, that's fine.
But taxpayers aren't going to be willing to do that.
The government's not going to be willing to do it.
Just do the math, ask the hard questions, and make an informed decision.
And every college should be required to tell a student,
Here's the likelihood that this is going to pay out,
and here's the likelihood you're going to be strapped with debt
that will drown you for years and years to come.
Tell the truth. Be transparent.
That should be the real story.