Lebanese President Joseph Aoun met US President Donald Trump in Washington this week with a historic proposal: end the war between Lebanon and Israel, force an Israeli withdrawal from the south, and disarm Iran’s proxy group Hezbollah. Could it work?
On today’s bonus episode of Iran: the Latest, Venetia Rainey speaks to Lama Amine, arts director at local charity Seenaryo, about the reality for civilians caught up in the conflict in Lebanon, how people are worried the latest escalation in Iran will spillover, and why Hezbollah would just be replaced by a similar group if it was disarmed.
Plus, first-person accounts of what it’s like to live under the shadow of war. Excerpts from pieces written for Seenaryo by Syrian refugee Eman Fisal Almodhi, read by Irish actor Jessie Buckley, and a WhatsApp conversation between Lebanese women displaced in south Lebanon, read by British-Lebanese-Palestinian actor Sirine Saba.
AI Generated·May contain errors
I'm Venetia Rainey and this is Iran The Latest.
This week Lebanese President Joseph Aoun met with Donald Trump in Washington.
Aoun declared that his country would permanently end hostilities with Israel
and asked for help to disarm Iranian proxy group Hezbollah.
It was a big moment.
Israel and Lebanon don't have official diplomatic relations.
They've been at war ever since Israel was founded in 1948.
So Aoun is trying to do something momentous.
His plan involves a gradual approach.
First address the Israeli occupation
which reaches six miles into Lebanese territory in the south.
Then the Lebanese army will assume full control over security
i.e. taking over from Hezbollah.
And then thirdly reconstruction and economic recovery led by the state
rather than Hezbollah or Iranian money.
It's a bold plan but can it work?
And does it reflect the reality on the ground?
Israel currently occupies more than 200 square miles of southern Lebanon
and has raised entire Shiite villages to the ground
along with associated infrastructure.
Hezbollah is against the plan and has vowed to fight Israel
for as long as they remain in the country.
It's also still being armed to the teeth for the fight.
Meanwhile hundreds of thousands of people have been displaced in Lebanon
and many are still forbidden from returning to their homes
if they even still have homes to return to.
So what's it like being in Lebanon and being stuck in the middle of all of this?
To discuss everything earlier this week I spoke to Lama Amin.
She's Director of Arts at Scenario Charity
which works with displaced and vulnerable people across Lebanon and the Middle East.
She also headed up a wonderful writing project
that captures the experience of being in the middle of a war, of being bombed.
It was performed in London recently and it caught my eye
because we discuss war every day on this podcast
but it's hard to capture what it's actually like being on the ground
for ordinary people like you or me.
So do watch or listen to the end to hear some excerpts of those
being read out by actors including Jesse Buckley.
They're rather brilliant.
First here's my conversation with Lama.
Lama welcome to Iran The Latest.
We've had some big developments in terms of the Lebanon war this week.
Lebanese President Joseph Haoun was in Washington to meet with President Donald Trump
and the pilot zone scheme, this US-backed plan to see Israel withdraw from parts of the south
and the Lebanese army move in in its place has taken its first baby step.
Just one village in the south at the time of recording
but no residents allowed to return yet
and there were some warning shots fired by the Israeli army
when the Lebanese army I believe neared an adjacent village
that wasn't part of the agreement.
We've also heard from Israel's Defence Minister Israel Katz.
He's repeatedly said that they won't withdraw from any territory
taken in Lebanon, Gaza or Syria
and Trump when he was asked about all of this
he didn't offer a withdrawal timeline for the Israelis.
He just said they're in the process of redeploying to other sections.
So I guess I just want to ask how hopeful are you
that this deal will lead to the Israeli withdrawal from southern Lebanon?
For us as Lebanese kind of we're not believing on it
because we've been through wars since I was young
like I grew up and this war never ends between Lebanon and Israel
and I don't think Israel is gonna decide to leave
and not wants to take any land from Lebanon
so I don't think that deal would work.
So we still like it says 60 days of making this like for the deal to be happen
but I don't have any like feelings towards it
because kind of we are a bit worried about what is happening now in Iran
and if the war might affect what is happening in Iran
also in Lebanon.
So to be honest no idea.
Okay so you feel very pessimistic and you feel like that pessimism
is that widely shared by Lebanese
and it's been made worse by the increased fighting
that we've seen between Iran and America in recent weeks.
Yeah I feel like now people even in Lebanon
that kind of they don't talk about it
because kind of it's not gonna happen.
So why so people are trying to live daily basis life
because even the things in Lebanon is really hard and it's heavy.
Everything's you feel how people are feeling heavy
feeling really uncertain they don't know what's gonna happen
so that's why kind of let's enjoy that moment that time
being with the loved ones the people that we family we love
and then the struggle is still there
and we don't know what's gonna happen.
So it's not in our hands kind of as Lebanese people to make that deal.
It's bigger than us and kind of we are watching waiting.
Tell me a bit more about daily life in Lebanon at the moment.
You work with displaced people every day.
We know there are hundreds of thousands of people
that have been displaced by this fighting.
I think some have started to return to the south but not all of them.
Tell me about them.
Yeah like after this announcement about this deal
some people went back to their villages in the south
but lots of people lost their houses lost their people.
So kind of people visit their places but they can't stay there.
So they return to Beirut and some of them are still staying in shelters.
There's no places for them to go.
So this is the daily struggle like for them to find food to find a job.
Even lots of people lost their jobs lost their businesses.
So kind of it's become harder and harder and even there is nothing
is the government can also help with.
There is lots of people like who is like civil like kind of community
are coming together and support and help but the resources are really low
and no one can like the war started in March and kind of people are feeling useless
or like they can't continue what they can do.
But for me like working for Scenario what we can do from our side
is open up a space a safe space for people like to come and reflect
or like to write about what is happening.
So this is kind of what we can do from our side.
The cost living in Lebanon become really expensive.
Have you been down to South Lebanon?
No like it's hard for us to go because we don't know it's to go like and it's unsafe.
But because I am from Beirut so I live in Beirut so I don't have like a town
or like I used to go to the south.
I used to like the summer I used to go with my friends to enjoy the summer there
and spend the time there by the beaches and stuff but or like visiting friends.
But nowadays it's really hard like to take this risk to go to the south.
But lots of people who are friends of mine who can't stay in Beirut
they need to see their land.
They need to see their houses.
They need so so yeah it's sad that like since 2024 I couldn't go to the south.
But in the work what Scenario does some of the people who went and we did some projects
even during the war like this year we were doing a project in the south
and it was really hard for us to go physically to visit our group of women or a group of children.
But we kept in contact with these people because also some of them especially in Sur
people don't want to leave.
And some of the people who are even not only Lebanese they are Syrian
so or Palestinian who are living in a camp in the south.
And it's hard for them to continue to like leave because where they have to go.
Like there is a clash between that in Lebanon the society between Syrian Lebanese and Palestinian.
So even during the war some of the people are not welcoming to be in a shelter.
So yeah there is layers and layers of how the life in Lebanon is hard.
And becoming more harder for other people.
So kind of the project that we were doing it with the women we kept doing it over Zoom
over Google like to continue to have this conversation and give them a space for them
to at least breathe to like take them to zone out from what is happening around them.
But even during the Zoom meeting imagine us talking and suddenly some people really need
to run out because the bombing is happening near their houses.
So we're living even for me I live in two realities in Lebanon because I'm living in
Beirut.
Nowadays in Beirut is calmer.
But when I speak with participants from the south they're living a different reality.
They are like in uncertainty if they are going to live or they're going to stay.
And the powerful things that they always bring to the table that they always say
Alhamdulillah everything is going to come.
They have this hope even in a harder harder situations.
And it's this like people call Lebanese people or the people who lives in Lebanon resilience.
But it's beyond this word to be honest I feel that.
Yeah it almost becomes a sort of cliche doesn't it the Lebanese phoenix always rising from
the ashes ever resilient.
But how much can the Lebanese people bear with all these successive rounds of conflicts
and also things like the Beirut port explosion COVID that knocks the country back again and
again.
And thank you for reminding us of that very important context.
Lebanon hosts a lot of refugees a lot of Syrian refugees that came over during the Syrian
civil war.
A lot of Palestinian refugees that date back to the 60s 70s 80s and live in refugee camps
and have never been naturalized as Lebanese citizens.
What kind of things are people telling you when you speak to these participants in projects
in the south.
Children women what kind of experiences are they sharing with you about what these last
few months have been like for them.
Yeah recently we did a project called creative writing.
And this project we asked participants to to come together to reflect on what is happening.
And I thought it's going to be like having around maybe 15 to 20 people maybe.
But in two days when I sent the link to the participants we had around 130 participants.
And I felt like this is not like just people want to come and participate.
No it was like a need for them to express to say what is happening to like let their
voices to be heard.
So I was and this project happened with around 96 participants in all over Lebanon.
And I had the opportunity to work with the migrant workers in Mecca.
One of the participants came to me and she said that how is important for her to just
sit even during the war.
She's looking after her kids but at least have like for one hour or like two hours to
sit by herself.
Even her kids are surrounded her.
For her to express to like go back to her feelings to to to say something that kind
of she's hiding it in inside her.
Or Najah who was living in the car who scenarios participants since 2017.
Najah was telling me like she never wanted to be to write.
But during these days she felt like there is a need for her to just sit and write things
and express because also Najah came from Syria during the war in Syria.
So kind of this war also it reflect or it open up things on her where she before she
used to like hiding it to just express to just sit to say I could write.
I could I could say even she doesn't feel herself as a writer.
Yeah it's one of the things that I found very powerful about the monologue that this
project produced because it really zooms in on the sort of the micro impact of of war
and you know there's so much conflict at the moment.
So we report on what's going on in the Middle East but it's happening around the world and
you get lost in the numbers of death tolls and casualties and you know the numbers of
strikes and what was targeted and what was hit.
But the impact is so much wider than that on the people who are experiencing it and
how it how it affects your everyday life your family life your you know your children your
work.
And so I think the monologues do a really good job of just just landing that point and
allowing you to experience someone's reality living through conflict in a in a more personal
way.
I wanted to just finish by asking a just sort of macro question again if that's okay.
The death toll from this round of the conflict has been appalling more than 4,300.
The Lebanese Health Ministry said this week have died since the beginning of March.
That includes 392 women and 253 children another 12,200 wounded.
Those people have been killed by Israel but this round of conflict started after Hezbollah
fired on northern Israel right at the beginning of March in support of its patron Iran.
I'm just wondering how much are people in Lebanon we know they blame Israel but how
much are they blaming Hezbollah for the cost of this war?
Have you noticed a shift in how people are talking about Hezbollah since this conflict
started?
We know the war that started not now in Lebanon with Israel and also the Israelis were before
Hezbollah started also in Lebanon.
So I even if Hezbollah one day will leave I think there is another kind of what do you
call it military like the army in Lebanon don't have the right to stand against Israel.
So it's a circle that we're going to always come back to it and always if Hezbollah
gone today there is another someone who's going to come and defend Lebanon.
So because there is a lot of people like in Lebanon who don't want Israel to come to
this country because at the end of the day this is our country and I feel like from my
side as Lema I feel like for me how to defend Lebanon is by creating projects, creating
stuff through arts and I feel this is my weapon of doing this like how I created this project
during the bombing at night I used to put my headphones and zoom out from what is happening
and just say I want to do something meaningful to the people.
So I feel lots of people these days who are not armed to do what Hezbollah does but we
have our way of kind of defend our country in our way I feel.
So people and Lebanese people who well know in many places in the world who did so many
things like Gibran Khalil Gibran like Fayrouz is the sound of Lebanon and the grief of Lebanon
kind of. Khalil Gibran the famous Lebanese poet, Fayrouz the famous Lebanese singer.
So I feel these people like we could be these people from my opinion to defend Lebanon rather
to go to the political because like carrying a gun or something it's not the solution.
I think the solution is to find something through arts, through sports, through other
forms of arts who can really defend this country and keep it together also because
theatre can bring us all together, arts can bring us together so kind of this is my answer to you.
That was Lama Amin, Director of Arts at Scenario Charity.
So what is it like to be bombed, to be caught in the middle of a war,
to live under the shadow of conflict? Here are the experiences of people living in Lebanon
but they could apply to anywhere in the Middle East or indeed anywhere in the world and that's
why I wanted to share them with you. The first is by Iman Faisal Almodi, a Syrian teacher who
fled to Lebanon during the civil war and now lives in the Bekaa Valley. It's read by Irish actor
Jessie Buckley. The second is a compilation of WhatsApp messages between a group of Lebanese
women displaced in South Lebanon and that's read by British-Lebanese-Palestinian actor
Serene Saba.
Then there was an explosion that shook the walls and dust particles fell from the ceiling like the
ashes of a burning dream. My firstborn was clinging to me, her eyes wide open. I won't
forget her stares, too silent. She didn't ask me, she didn't even cry. She was just looking at me
as if she was waiting for an answer from me that I didn't have.
In that moment I felt helpless for the first time, not just out of fear, it was an inner breakdown
as if something inside me had silently collapsed. I tried to speak to tell her don't be afraid
but the words stuck in my throat. Silence is heavier than any sound. At 8.30pm the phone ran.
My sister's voice at the other end was far away as if it was coming from another world that does
not resemble this desolation. She was asking, trying to assure me I could barely hear her.
I was torn between her words and the sound of the approaching shelling,
between her instructions and the fact that death was all around us. For a moment
I felt completely alone, even though someone was trying to reach me through that thin line
of communication. I looked at my daughter, the one who was born under the roar of planes.
There was a voice inside me shouting protect them and another whispering how. Outside
danger was imminent. I vividly remember that moment when I had to choose,
leave or stay. It was not an ordinary decision, it was an uprooting.
No, no I couldn't go to the shelter this year. Last year, well last war, I tried to bathe my son
once. He'd been playing in mud, actual mud, head to toe and everyone suddenly descended on me. Why
do you need to do that? He showered two days ago, it's cold, he'll get sick. I said the child has
mud in places mud should not be. Should I let him get lice everywhere and infect you all? I mean,
yeah it would be it would be quite ironic if we all died of some infection while rockets are
flying over our heads. That'd be funny. I haven't showered in a week. I swear I just want to go
home. I just want to go home and I just want to bathe with flesh and dettol in my own bathtub.
Yeah, without committee approval, I would rather die clean than be humiliated like this.
At least at home, I can shower every day. Here, I've got to wait for my turn and on top of it all,
not every day. Now I know, oh I know, I know it's dangerous but I might as well die in the
comfort of my home since everything has gone to ---- anyway. God, I'm so dirty, I can't even pray
properly. Oh, congratulate you. Congratulate you for what? Wow, you showered yesterday.
Wow, well done Rima, congratulations. You better get on those scales right now,
you probably lost two kilograms of film. Oh, bravo. You know, I almost showered in my clothes
last night. Yeah, I'm serious. I'm so scared a rocket will kill me and they find me naked.
The humiliation of it, leaving your house is already like being naked. It's already
humiliating enough and I do not like being humiliated and I do not like anyone holding
a favor over my head. No, I'd rather die in dignity, in my own home, clean and dressed.
That's all for today's episode, we'll be back again on Monday. Until then, goodbye.