It is called "The Night Watch," yet the scene takes place at the first light of dawn. That misnomer only became fixed in 1797—one hundred and fifty-five years after Rembrandt finished the work in 1642—and the entire world has viewed it incorrectly ever since.
Today, thirty researchers are working at the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam on the largest restoration project ever dedicated to a single painting: Operation Night Watch. They have discovered an unsuspected layer of lead, arsenic pigments that Rembrandt should not have used in a portrait, and a hidden sketch historians had sought for decades; they even used artificial intelligence to reconstruct fragments that someone had cut away with scissors in 1715.
In this video, we explore the full story: the original 1640 commission, the hidden symbols Rembrandt intentionally painted, the three acts of vandalism the work survived during the 20th century, and the latest scientific discoveries that continue to rewrite what we thought we knew about the painter and his masterpiece.
A painting that has survived scissors, knives, and acid... and which, 400 years later, continues to reveal secrets.
AI Generated·May contain errors
This is the story of a painting that has been deceiving us for nearly 400 years,
starting with the name. It is called, The Night Watch. The action takes place at first light of
dawn, and the title everyone repeats, did not appear until 1797, 155 years after Rembrandt
finished it. A thick, dark yellow varnish, had been darkening the image over the centuries,
someone assumed it depicted a night time scene, and the error calcified forever.
30 people are working right now inside the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, on the largest research
and restoration operation ever devoted to a single work of art. A project christened
Operation Night Watch, that has been rewriting since 2019, what we thought we knew about how
Rembrandt worked. Beneath the layers of varnish, paint, and centuries of assumptions,
they have located a lead layer no expert suspected, identified arsenic pigments
Rembrandt should not have applied in a portrait, unearthed a hidden preparatory sketch,
that scholars had been chasing for decades, and reconstructed with artificial intelligence,
the sections of the canvas that someone mutilated with scissors, in 1715. To understand why each of
these findings matters, you first have to understand what this painting depicts, and why,
for nearly four centuries, no one saw it as Rembrandt conceived it. Toward the end of 1640,
a militia company from District 2 of Amsterdam, contacted Rembrandt van Rijn,
to commission a group portrait destined for the new banqueting hall of their headquarters,
the Cloveniersduelen, leading the company were Captain Frans Banning Kock, and his lieutenant
Willem van Rutenberg, and what we know for certain, is that the commission arrived before December 1640,
because one of the guardsmen portrayed died around that date. The politics of the era,
explained the ambition behind the project. Spanish forces had retreated to Belgium,
Dutch independence from Spain was fast approaching, and although the Treaty of
Munster that would close the Eighty Years' War, would not be signed until 1648, the so-called
Dutch Golden Age, was at its most intense. The militiamen wanted to celebrate themselves and
see themselves immortalized on a wall. Three hundred guilders was what an average worker
earned in a year, and what Rembrandt charged for this commission, amounted to sixteen hundred,
a gap that gives the measure of the project. Eighteen commissioners funded the work,
and each paid roughly one hundred guilders to appear on the canvas, some a bit more,
others less, depending on the position they would occupy in the final composition.
The canvas turned out so enormous, that it did not fit in Rembrandt's Amsterdam studio,
and what is believed is that he completed it in a shed in the garden of his house.
When he finished it in 1642, the work contained thirty-four figures, of which only eighteen
corresponded to real people, while the remaining sixteen functioned as symbolic presences,
including a young woman in a pale yellow dress, traditionally considered the mascot of the guard.
A fact that gives the measure of what happened in that shed, Rembrandt, unlike many of his
contemporaries, never set foot abroad nor studied outside the Netherlands, and yet what he created
within those four walls altered forever the way a group portrait was conceived. Before Rembrandt,
militia group portraits obeyed a rigid formula in which the members posed in orderly rows,
or sat around a table during a banquet, all visible, all given the same visual weight,
fulfilling a strict function, that every person who had paid could be recognized immediately.
They did not function as works of art, they functioned as records.
Rembrandt dismantled each of those conventions, where before there had been a static composition,
he built a scene in motion where his masterful chiaroscuro bathed certain figures in light,
and plunged others into shadow, injecting dramatic action into a subject that until then,
had operated like a formal photograph. No artist before him had staged a group portrait as a
history painting, the most prestigious genre of the period, and that decision split the tradition
in two. What he hid inside the composition betrays a sense of humor and a visual intelligence that
deserves attention. From the belt of the girl dressed in yellow, the company's mascot, hangs
a chicken, and the conceit works like this. The arquebusiers, Koch's militia, bore two bird claws
on their coat of arms, because in Dutch, the sounds of, clover, arquebus, and claw, claw,
are similar. Rembrandt interwove that loaded symbolism with reality, by also placing the
company's silver drinking horn on the same figure. The captain's colors were not left to chance
either. Rembrandt dressed Banning Koch in the red and black of Amsterdam, when militia captains
typically wore a blue sash with gold lace, and the shadow of Koch's hand falls on Van Ruitenberg's coat,
precisely where the city's coat of arms appears subtly embroidered in the fabric.
An element that can no longer be seen with the naked eye once added drama to the scene,
a wisp of musket smoke that swirled around Banning Koch's head, completely erased by deterioration.
The Operation Night Watch scan showed that Rembrandt tried to prevent that degradation
with a brown quartz paint ground, an effort that failed but reveals how much the fragility of
certain materials worried him. And those materials deserve attention in their own right,
carmine produced by crushing cochineal insects, lead white, lead tin yellow that produced a
lemony tone, smalt made from crushed cobalt glass, and arsenic, to add depth to orange
and gold tones. We will return to the arsenic later, because that piece of data became one of
the most striking findings of Operation Night Watch. Certain art historians interpret the
entire scene as a light pictorial joke, a kind of pantomime in which 18 militiamen
gallantly perform the art of civic defense. The painting has come to symbolize European
democratic values, although Rembrandt's intention was unlikely to have aimed at anything so solemn.
In 1715, something happened that admits no repair. Someone decided to move the painting
to Amsterdam's town hall, the canvas did not fit through the doors, and the solution was
to cut it on all four sides. The strips of cloth apparently vanished. Two complete figures
disappeared from the left side, along with the upper part of the arch, the balustrade,
and the edge of the step, and what no one measured at that moment was the damage to
the composition. By trimming the edges, the figures of the lieutenants ended up centered
in the painting, when Rembrandt had deliberately placed them off-center, marching toward an empty
space that generated tension and movement, and that compositional dynamic ceased to exist with
each snip of the scissors. In 2021, the Operation Night Watch team tackled the problem
with artificial intelligence, using as a starting point a copy of the painting that
Gerrit Lundens had made before the mutilation. They trained an algorithm to convert Lundens'
style into Rembrandt's, and the recreation even corrected the perspective, since Lundens must
have been seated to the left of the painting when he prepared his copy, which slightly distorted
the proportions. Sixty centimeters added to the left side, twenty-two to the top,
and twelve to the bottom made up the printed extensions placed around the original canvas,
and the painting was displayed in this configuration from June to September 2021.
Taco Divitz, director of the Rijksmuseum, summed it up with a direct phrase,
Rembrandt would definitely have made it more beautiful, but this comes very close.
Regarding the original fragments someone cut away more than three centuries ago,
a slender hope remains. Divitz has stated that at least the left side may not have ended up
destroyed, because it contained three figures, and at the time of the mutilation Rembrandt's
paintings already commanded high prices. To this day, no one has located them.
Surviving the scissors of 1715, did not mark the last trial for the night watch,
because over the course of the 20th century, it suffered three acts of vandalism. And an
ironic detail connects the first two. The 13th of January 1911, an unemployed cobbler,
and former navy cook, tried to slash the painting with a cobbler's knife, as a protest against his
inability to find work, and the thick layer of varnish covering the work, absorbed the blows
without the canvas sustaining real damage. That varnish functioned as an accidental shield.
And that is where the irony comes in. That same protective varnish was removed in the 1940s,
leaving the painting unprotected just in time for the second attack.
On the 14th of September 1975, an unemployed teacher named Wilhelmus de Rijck,
slashed it with a bread knife, and inflicted 12 cuts on the canvas, with several zigzag incisions
up to 30 centimeters long. De Rijck suffered from mental illness, and declared he had done it for
the Lord, that he had been ordered to do it. Six months were consumed by the restoration,
and the painting returned to display in March 1976, although evidence of the cuts is still
visible up close. Without that thick varnish that had shielded it in 1911, the damage of 1975 became
far more difficult to repair. The third attack came in 1990, when an escaped psychiatric patient
sprayed the painting with concentrated sulfuric acid, and the quick reaction of a guard limited
the damage to the varnish. Scissors, cobbler's knives, bread knives, sulfuric acid, and the
painting still hangs in the same room. At least four documented relinings record how many times
it has needed intervention, in 1975 after de Rijck's attack, in 1945 when it returned from
its wartime hiding place, in 1851, during the first documented wax resin relining, and possibly,
in 1795, or even as early as 1758. The war itself tested its survival. In September 1939,
the work was evacuated from the Rijcksmuseum, along with 30,000 art objects, and hidden first
in bunkers near the coast, then moved in 1942, to a cave in the St. Petersburg, in Maastricht.
337 kilograms of canvas and paint waited in that cave until the war ended, and every one of those
kilograms has had to be protected, transported, concealed, restored, and defended over the course
of nearly four centuries. In the summer of 2019, the Rijcksmuseum launched Operation Night Watch,
the largest research and restoration operation ever devoted to a single work of art,
with a team of 30 people, equipped with the latest available technology.
What sets this project apart from any previous restoration, aside from scale, is that it
unfolds in full public view. A glass chamber designed specifically to house the night watch,
allows visitors to witness the microscopic precision with which the researchers address
every centimeter of the painting, and those visitors are not few. More than two million
people pass through that room each year, turning the restoration process into part of the museum
experience. AxoNobel serves as the principal partner of the project, and the collaborating
institution spans several countries, the University of Amsterdam, Utrecht University,
the University of Antwerp in Belgium, the Royal Institute for Cultural Heritage in Brussels,
and the DESY Synchrotron in Hamburg, Germany. The 13th of May 2020 brought the first public
milestone, when the Rijcksmuseum released a 44.8-gigapixel digital image of the painting.
528 separate photographs made up the final image, arranged in 24 rows of 22 shots each.
Digitally stitched together with the help of neural networks, and the result allows any
area of the canvas to be magnified, until the microscopic cracks in the pigment become visible.
That ultra-high-resolution image served as the starting point, the truly unexpected lay
waiting beneath the surface. The hidden preparatory sketch, published in 2021,
inaugurated the series of major findings. Scholars had long suspected that a work of this scale and
complexity demanded a preliminary drawing. A radiographic examination in the 1970s
tried to find it without success, and the breakthrough finally came through macro
X-ray fluorescence. 56 macro X-ray scans mapped the chemical elements present across the entire
painting, and the key lay in isolating the calcium contained in the beige paint Rembrandt
used to outline his composition. The only known instance of the artist applying this type of
preparation, a finding the team christened a calcium map. That same analysis uncovered another
surprise, the element maps revealed that Rembrandt painted decorative feathers into the image,
and then decided to suppress them. The reasons remain in the dark, what those changes do provide
is direct access to his thought process as he worked, editing the composition on the fly.
During the restoration, a finding of an entirely different nature emerged. Curator Ann Lenders
noticed that the dog appearing in the painting seemed modeled after an illustration by
and X-ray analysis confirmed the similarities between the two animals. Rembrandt copied the dog
from another artist. What no one anticipated arrived in December 2023, when the journal
Science Advances published what is probably the project's heaviest discovery. While analyzing
tiny paint samples, the researchers found that Rembrandt covered his canvas with a lead-based
mixture before laying down the first brushstroke, something that did not appear in any other work
by Rembrandt or his contemporaries. Frederik Broers, research scientist at the Rijksmuseum,
detailed it thus. They found large quantities of lead in the dark background, especially in
the upper part, where one would not expect these pigments to be present. And in the samples,
it was clearly visible that the lead appeared before the quartz clay ground. The hypothesis
is that Rembrandt mixed hot linseed oil with powdered lead oxide to shield the canvas against
mold and moisture, knowing the painting would hang on a damp wall in the town hall. He designed the
protection before he began to paint. July 2024 brought the fourth discovery, when the journal
NPJ Heritage Science published the detection of pararylgar and semi-amorphous pararylgar in the
work, pigments containing arsenic that until then had been used only in still lifes. Rembrandt
applied them in a portrait, and that makes him a pioneer of the use of arsenic-based pigments in
this genre. Professor Coen Johnsons of the University of Antwerp noted that this research
opens new avenues regarding the reactivity of historical pigments and the preservation of
heritage. And here is where the matter becomes even stranger. A compound that appeared in the
analysis had never been detected in a historical painting before, since lead formats had only been
reported once, in 2020, in recent model paintings, not in centuries-old works. Each of these findings
dismantles a different assumption. The lead layer demonstrates that Rembrandt thought about
long-term conservation before he began to paint. The arsenic pigments confirm that he experimented
with materials his contemporaries did not apply in portraits. The preparatory sketch proves that
the composition was planned with a level of detail no one had been able to confirm until now,
and the suppressed feathers reveal that he edited the painting as he worked,
making aesthetic decisions on the fly. November de 1924 marked the start of the second phase of
Operation Night Watch, with eight restorers dedicated to removing the varnish applied
during the 1975 restoration, the one carried out after the bread knife attack by Wilhelmus de Rijck.
The method involves placing a special type of tissue prepared with a solvent against the surface
of the painting for a short and limited time, and the team has warned that during the process,
the painting will look very gray and dull, regaining its vibrancy only when the new
varnish is applied. The 1975 wooden stretcher has already been replaced by an aluminum one,
and no completion date has been announced for the full restoration.
Tako Dibic, director of the museum, declared that removing the varnish will reveal the
eventful history of the Night Watch, and added something that gives the measure of what remains
to be discovered. Despite working at the Rijck's museum for 17 years, he had never seen the upper
part of the painting. Not even the director of the museum where Rembrandt's most celebrated work
hangs knew it in full. $410 million were consumed by the Rijck's museum renovation that culminated
with its reopening in 2013, after a decade of construction, and when the director described
the building, he defined it as a museum built around the Night Watch. Over a career spanning
nearly five decades, Rembrandt created approximately 350 paintings, 300 etchings,
and 100 drawings, and of all those works, this one is still releasing secrets. We began this
video by saying that, the Night Watch has been deceiving us for nearly 400 years. The name does
not match reality, it does not depict the night, it does not describe a watch, the central figures
did not occupy the center, the feathers he painted ceased to exist, the varnish that darkened it gave
it a false title, and the scissors that trimmed it altered its composition. Beneath all of that,
a lead layer no one suspected had been silently protecting the canvas since 1642.
Operation Night Watch, is stripping away layers of varnish, layers of paint, layers of assumptions,
and what appears underneath, outlines an artist more calculating, more experimental,
and more conscious of posterity, than 400 years of art history had assumed. See you in the next video.