food, vegan food, vegan, healthy food, diet food In the description, the creator (Mic the Vegan) introduces this as a video analyzing a study that followed patients with metastatic breast cancer (which has spread to other organs) who adopted a whole-food vegan diet. The 5-year survival results showed a significant difference, raising the question: "Could it be due to the diet?" Additionally, the description includes numerous resources and links to original scientific studies on platforms like PubMed, Springer, AMA, etc., regarding the correlation between plant-based diets, fiber intake, soy consumption, and cancer mortality risk, allowing viewers to verify and cross-reference the information for themselves.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video discusses a study on the impact of a two-month whole-food plant-based (WFPB) diet on the survival rates of patients with metastasized breast cancer. Five years after the initial intervention, the WFPB group showed a significantly lower mortality rate compared to the control group, suggesting that short-term dietary shifts and subsequent long-term habits may improve survival outcomes.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hey, it's Mike here.
And today, what happens when you do a shorter
two-month dietary intervention study
and then come back five years later
and see how many people survived?
Well, those are exactly the results we have,
which were recently released
from a whole food plant-based trial
on metastasized breast cancer five years later
in terms of survival.
These are people that were randomly assigned
to one group or another.
They didn't choose to eat a certain way.
You already know that the results are positive,
so we're gonna learn about the details of the study,
how it adds up in terms of other research that exists.
Is it a valid finding?
Because this study is certainly sparking some hope
and a major need for future research.
Let's go.
Lightning fast, some basics.
You already know that breast cancer
is the most common cancer for women.
It's a quarter of all cancers.
Metastasized just means that it's spread
past the breast tissue.
This is where it gets more concerning, of course.
Right off the bat, obviously,
this is a very sensitive topic.
Because this is such a common cancer,
virtually everybody has been touched by this,
whether a friend or a loved one or another person.
So there's a lot of woulda, coulda, shoulda
around people that didn't do well, of course.
And so I really don't wanna evoke a sense of guilt in people.
I just wanna say this is some news that has just occurred.
I think it is hopeful.
And still, it is a smaller sample.
So we have to investigate and see what this really means.
Because yeah, we need to stay abreast
of potential treatments that could help people.
Yes, I made a pun anyway.
Okay, enough rambling.
We have two studies here.
One, the original one, which was published in 2024.
Of course, that means it took a while
to get all the data together.
They were eating their diet about five years ago.
And then, of course, the follow-up
that was recently published that looked at the mortality.
But looking to this 2024 study,
yes, it was done by Dr. Campbell,
which is T. Colin Campbell's son,
as well as a team of other researchers.
And we are talking about an eight-week
or two-month whole food plant-based diet intervention,
or people who were randomly assigned to a controlled diet.
And this is where whole food plant-based diet
equals healthy vegan diet.
Obviously, none of the ethics are applied here,
of veganism, but it's no meat, no dairy,
no eggs, no animal products.
You know, it's a fully plant-based diet,
and then less processed foods
than your average vegan is gonna be eating as well.
And then the controlled diet
was just continuing their usual diet.
We'll talk about that more in a little bit.
But the study itself had some goals,
like lowering biomarkers,
and then, of course, increasing survival.
But this was a two-month study,
so they would have to come back later.
And while the results didn't improve
every single metric during that time period,
they still had some pretty solid outcomes,
such as decreased body weight, better insulin,
and therefore insulin resistance,
like a 40% drop in the insulin resistance index,
which is huge, as well as a 22-point drop
in LDL or bad cholesterol, among other things.
And I should mention that the weight loss
that they saw in that trial initially is also huge,
because weight is heavily tied
to breast cancer survival as well.
So that's great, some solid results,
pretty expected for a plant-based diet intervention.
Based off the views and citations of the study itself,
this was not being pushed far and wide.
So the researchers just quietly waited
until five years to look at what was going on,
not just in terms of mortality,
but also in terms of what these people
were eating five years later.
But we have to get to those mortality stats,
because they're actually remarkable.
The intervention group itself was 20 people.
Of those 20 people, only two passed away,
which is a 10% mortality rate.
Of the control group, there were 10 people,
half of them, five of them, yes, 50% of them passed away,
which is a five-fold difference in death rate,
five-fold lower death rate for the intervention group
eating a whole food plant-based diet
for two months, five years ago.
What is going on here?
We're about to check their diet changes in a bit,
but I just wanna say intuitively,
or just logically at first glance, this is quite dramatic.
If you just imagine these two groups of people
there in front of you, 10 in which half are gone,
and 20 in which only two are gone,
you can tell that there's something majorly different
that happened between those two groups.
Intuition and knee-jerk logic is nice though,
but what about statistics?
It didn't seem that they did a statistical analysis on this,
which makes sense because the study
wasn't actually continuing during that time.
Of course, I was tempted to ask the question,
were these results statistically significantly different?
And yes, it turns out that they were,
looking at various types of analyses, they all were.
The researchers being a bit bashful say, quote,
"'The intervention group had lower mortality
"'than the control group, although reasons for this
"'are unknown.'"
It's like I know as researchers
in the peer-reviewed literature,
they sort of have to say stuff like that,
but I feel like if you were to catch
any of these researchers at the bar alone late at night,
which probably none of them drink,
but they probably behind closed doors say,
yeah, I do believe it had something to do with the diet.
So what were the dietary changes here?
Well, we have table one in which we have the baseline diet,
their whole food plant-based diet
that they ate for two months,
and then what they were eating five years later.
And we can see that compared to baseline,
five years later, they're having twice
their original amount of whole grains.
They've halved their dairy, a two-thirds reduction
in red and processed meat,
and halved their fats that were added, like butter.
So we have the more plant-forward diet five years later,
but we also have to wonder,
is it possible that changes made
from such a dramatic dietary shift for two months
could have done this as well?
And we have hints of it being a maybe,
for example, epigenetic changes,
which of course can turn keys for diseases off and on,
for, for example, people who were starved
in famines for five months,
60 years later still have epigenetic changes from that.
And then we have people that might've been overfed,
a high-fat diet for five days had epigenetic changes
that remained mostly unchanged after a couple of months.
Notable, and we have to look to Ornish
for the best parallel after his three-month
plant-based lifestyle intervention for prostate cancer.
He did a five-year follow-up as well,
which found a lengthening of telomeres,
protective caps on the DNA,
only in the intervention group,
and that's a process that is epigenetically driven.
So maybe the two-month dietary change had some influence,
but we have even more information
on the change at five years.
Who changed, who didn't?
Well, it turns out that 75% of the people
in the intervention group reported
eating a more plant-based diet than at baseline.
As the study mentions, quote,
75% of intervention participants reported
that they had made changes positively aligned
with a whole food plant-based diet
while largely maintaining quality of life over five years.
And then they broke it down for the 25% of people
that didn't change their diet from baseline,
and we can see why they didn't do it is interesting.
A third of them say that they had an inability
or a dislike of cooking,
which some people might not be able to
from their condition,
but this does emphasize that cooking can save your life
in a lot of circumstances in terms of lowering disease,
and it might do so in this case as well.
And then we have a quarter of them saying
that their family would not eat whole food plant-based diet
as a reason for not doing it.
That's unfortunate.
I feel like if they wanted to,
it'd be great if their family supported them,
but then we have to ask,
does this match up with other research around?
Is this just a fluke for a small plant-based diet study?
Well, first of all,
this is on the heels of that meta-analysis,
finding that vegans had a 23% lower risk
of total cancer combined, which is incredible.
And this super new study also found
that higher healthy plant-based diet index
was associated with half the risk
of obesity-related female cancers.
That's huge.
That is, of course, the risk of getting it at all.
What about survival?
Well, we have some studies in this area.
Higher versus lower fiber intake
was associated with 30% lower breast cancer mortality,
and we had the same 30% relationship
for high versus low soy intake as well.
And that's pretty dramatic.
My guess is if we got the larger study,
which I would absolutely call for,
a study of hundreds of people trying this same regimen
and then coming back five years later
and seeing how many people have survived,
would we have gotten the same results?
I think there's something to be said
about a small group of people
with people that are really passionate
in the intervention group, showing them how to eat
and teaching them about the lower disease risk of that diet.
And then that also brings me to the part
where this control group was just eating
as they normally were,
which would knock out any placebo effect
from a dietary change
that they weren't put on some other breast cancer diet.
However, those are also generally recommended
to be more plant-inclusive as well.
But it still would have been interesting
to have some at least sham lifestyle intervention.
But that being said, I do not think that placebo alone
would lower the breast cancer death by this much.
And then while keeping a level head,
this was a very small group,
but the researchers say that over and over again as well.
And then in terms of conflicts,
this was done by, as they admit,
one of the authors is potentially making money
from a plant-based lifestyle for book sales.
That's a motivator.
And from what I know of the Campbells,
they're very no-nonsense.
They seem pretty straight-laced.
I don't think that they would just be cooking the books
on a cancer survival study like this,
especially it's a randomized trial as well.
And then we have some roundabout funding
from the Center for Nutrition Studies,
which is, of course, Campbell Senior Center,
though they say they had no role
But this is where as a vegan,
I'm once again reminded of how I view things.
I haven't really talked about this on my channel,
but we have this typical three legs of veganism
where it's like animal ethics, human health,
and then environment.
And so that makes the triangle.
But for me, it's like,
I almost wanna make it into a diamond
in the sense that I feel like I am ethically driven
to promote the human health results
from a, at least, unprocessed vegan diet.
Of course, drinking 100% Coca-Cola
would actually be a type of vegan diet.
So of course, not all vegan diets
are gonna lead to a lower disease risk.
But for me, I feel like there's this intersection
of ethics for animals and humans being animals
and their health, and then promoting that
is almost like a whole nother leg for me.
I know for other people it's not,
but that's just the way I feel about it.
Because if this study is repeated,
and it's not five times lower risk of mortality,
maybe it is just 30% lower,
that would still be, to me, a massive reason
that this should at least be made available
as an option for people that would want to do it.
But instead of a bunch of funding for studies like that,
we have RFK Jr. heading the FDA,
dipping his turkey in a vat of tallow,
trying to change everything to higher saturated animal fat,
which is, in the literature,
associated with increased breast cancer mortality as well.
I should probably mention that.
There's a lot more that we don't need to mention here,
getting a little off topic with the FDA,
but that's how I feel.
Anyway, let me know down below
what you think about all this.
Do you think the study is too small
and the results should be just thrown out
and completely ignored, or what?
Again, I personally hope that we get
even a fraction of the benefit here
for the sake of people that are trying
to fight this disease.
And of course, feel free to like, subscribe,
all that good stuff, and I'll see you in the next one.
Thanks for watching.