Law School Limits Laptops as AI Transforms Work

Law School Tips
21 followers
1 Video View·Jul 25, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe University of Chicago Law School is banning laptops and smartphones in certain classrooms to prevent AI reliance and ensure students develop critical thinking and professional judgment. Dean Adam Chilton explains that while AI is transforming legal practice, students must first master \"essentially human skills\" to remain valuable in a market where AI can handle standard legal tasks.
Last week, the University of Chicago Law School announced that it would be banning laptops,
tablets, and iPhones, other smartphones, in an attempt to limit the use of AI tools
in the classroom. The school states the decision was designed to ensure that students learn how
to think critically, solve legal problems with sound professional judgment.
This comes at a time where cheating is being investigated at several schools and universities
across the country. Students are coming in with near perfect scores on exams that traditionally
brought in very different results. Joining us now is the Dean of the Law School at the
University of Chicago, Adam Chilton. Adam, thank you for making time. What prompted this,
and how big of a problem is this kind of AI crutch or even flat-out cheating for students now?
So, I am unaware of any of the AI cheating scandals happening at our law school. I haven't
heard of any, and I haven't seen any, although I've heard some of the news stories that you're
probably referring to that have been taking place at colleges across the country. Our concern is a
little different than that, which is the newest frontier models like Fable are just absolutely
fantastic. And it's not to say there's never hallucinations or there's never mistakes,
but these are models that now can get near perfect scores on the bar exam or on law school finals or
on other tests and legal benchmarking tools. So, the question as educators that we have to
be asking ourselves is, the students that we're admitting today are going to be graduating in
three years in a world in which AI models can answer standard legal questions extremely well.
And what then is the value that human lawyers are going to have beyond what the AI is able to do?
And so, what we're most focused on is ensuring that our students have the skills
to be the best possible lawyers while graduating into that market.
So, let's look at this in two ways. I guess there's kind of use of technology in the classroom,
and then there's the use of AI for the kind of work that your graduates are going to be doing,
yes, in three years' time and beyond that. Maybe I can start there and just ask you how
transformative AI has been so far in the profession, and sort of how it's altering the
prospects, yes, for jobs that your graduates could get, but also just the kind of need that
firms are going to have for graduates of a law school like the University of Chicago's
to do legal work going forward. Sure. So, we've spent a lot of time over the last year
working with our alumni and top law firms to try to understand what they're already seeing
and what they're already doing. And the legal profession is already changing quite dramatically.
There's both the standard AI tools like Chachi, PT, or Claude, but a whole range of models that
are designed specifically for legal tasks, like Harvey or Lagora, and a range of other companies
that are competing in this space. And at law firms, the pressure is real from clients to try
to find ways to use these tools to be more efficient. And many of the tasks that first,
second, third-year associates, new lawyers would do, are exactly the kinds of things that AI models
are extremely good at. So, for instance, go through the whole set of depositions for a trial
and try to identify all of the places where a particular topic was covered. AI can do that
in seconds. Or go through past contracts and find similar contract language that had been
used in other deals and see how it compares to the contract that you're working today.
Those sorts of things, companies can take their database to past contracts, past briefs,
past memos, and work with it pretty efficiently with AI. So, this is already happening. And
201, the law firms that we talked to, are just trying to do more to accelerate that process.
It's a little bit similar to our business, because tasks like that, they are what you get
when you go in the door. And for News, when we were starting out as an intern,
there was no software that could transcribe tapes for you. So, yes, you had to have a bunch of people
in there to type out these tapes. And it's annoying, and it takes forever. But you also
learn so much by listening to these really experienced colleagues do interviews over and
over again. You do absorb that. And I imagine it's the same thing when you're asked to, like,
go through case law or go through contracts. Like, there is a learning process that you're
getting there. So, how do you as a law school compensate for that if that's not something
they're going to do when they step into their first law school job? And how are you going to
try to enforce this ban on technology in the classroom? Yeah, so I should be clear. So, we
released a comprehensive AI strategy, of which the goal is to make sure that the students learn
to think without machines and with machines. And one piece of that was to limit the use of
technology in certain classrooms, mostly the first-year or class classrooms. So, that's part
of what the policy is doing. But then it's also outlining all of the ways that we're going to
integrate AI even further into what we're already doing. So, for instance, reworking our first-year
legal research and writing curriculum, which every law student in our law school and other law schools
in their first year learns how to write legal briefs, legal materials. And in that class,
we're directly integrating more AI into the curriculum. Or our clinics, which is where the
students in their second and third year work on real cases for real clients under the supervision
of clinical professors. The clinics had already been using AI in many of their cases and their
matters, but I think they're leading the charge thinking, how can we do more to ensure that the
students at our law school are using the same tools that they'll be using when they go off to
practice so that they're getting that experience early? But at core across all these ideas,
I think our philosophy is that we have to think about what's the essentially human skills
that the students are going to need in practice, at least we hope for a while. And so, for instance,
it's not just being able to answer a final exam question at the end of the class.
It's being able to sit, listen, and have a conversation with someone and think quickly.
That skill is going to be valuable if you're a law firm associate, talking to a law firm partner,
a law firm partner talking to a client, a lawyer talking to a judge, a law school dean talking to
a journalist, whatever it is, I think that that skill is not going out of fashion. And refocusing
on the classroom away from just like typing as fast as you can, sitting and listening and trying
to respond more, I think is going to help teach those sorts of skills. Very quickly, we have about
30, 45 seconds. Are we entering a world in which there are going to be fewer lawyers as a result
of this? How do you think about just the need for lawyers going forward as a result of the
advent of AI? So I think that AI is going to decrease the cost of many legal services. And
typically what we've seen is when the cost for something goes down, demand goes up. So I think
it's going to change the kinds of legal work that people do. But I'm not convinced that they'll
necessarily be fewer lawyers.
