NEW YORK STRIP STEAK | Medium Rare Perfection on a Weber Q Grill

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedJerry from The Chicago Griller demonstrates how to cook a thick, 1.5-inch USDA Prime New York strip steak using the direct grilling method on a Weber Q1200. He emphasizes the importance of using a meat thermometer to ensure a perfect medium-rare finish, regardless of the estimated cooking time.
Hey there, what's up you guys? I am Jerry, and welcome back to the channel The Chicago Griller.
This is the show where I share my favorite tips, tricks, and recipes for the Weber Q.
If you think that I could help you out, hit the like button and subscribe.
In the early days of this channel, I cooked up a New York strip steak on my Weber Q. However,
it was a pretty thin cut of beef. So today, I'm going to share how I cook up a much
thicker cut of New York strip. Now, there are a couple ways that you can approach this cook,
but today I'm going to share the direct grilling method. Come and check this out.
Today on the channel, I'm going to be grilling up this gorgeous looking one pound cut of New York
strip steak. And as you probably figured, this steak was graded USDA Prime. I mean,
look at that beautiful intramuscular fat. That fat equals flavor.
Now, I did also mention in the intro that this is a thick cut of New York strip steak.
And when I pull out my tape measure, you'll see this is one and a half inches thick.
That's about 3.8 centimeters. Normally for a steak this thick, I would prepare it with the
reverse sear method. That's a two-step process that begins with a low heat roast, followed by a
high heat sear. However, it's a cold winter day here in Chicago, and I'm not sure my grill can
hold a low temperature without blowing out. So direct grilling is the way to go today.
To prep the steak, the first thing I'm going to do is grab a paper towel and pat the steak dry.
Removing this excess moisture ensures that your steak will cook efficiently on the grill and
create great sear marks. Once the steak is patted dry, it's time to apply some seasonings. Today,
I'm applying a generous layer of Montreal steak seasoning to my steak. However, truth be told,
with a cut of steak this good, simple salt and pepper would do just as well. But I was in the
for Montreal steak seasoning today. No matter what you use though, apply generously to both sides.
Remember, this is a big cut of steak, and you want to make sure the seasonings can cut through
the entire thickness of the beef. Don't forget to also work some of the seasonings into the sides
of your steak. Once your steak has been seasoned to your liking, it's time to head on out to the
grill. Out here on my front deck, I've been preheating my Weber Q1200, and as usual before
grilling, you want to scrape your grill grates clean of any previous residue. And because I
didn't use any oil when preparing the steak today, I need to oil the grill grates. This will ensure
that the steak does not stick to the grill. I used just regular olive oil today instead of a higher
smoke point oil, but trust me, I ensure you the steak still won't stick to the grill. Now shut your
grill and let the grill come on up to a high temperature. Once your grill has been preheated
to a high heat, come on back with your steak and put it straight across the grill grates.
I prefer placing my steak diagonally across the grates like so. You'll see why in just a little
bit. Close the lid and cook for two and a half minutes. After two and a half minutes, open the
lid, grab a sturdy set of tongs, and turn your steak 90 degrees. Doing so will give your beef
steakhouse quality crosshatch grill marks. Shut the lid and continue cooking. After two and a half
minutes, or about five minutes of total cook time, it's time to turn our steak over. And with a firm
steady grip with these tongs this time, you'll see those awesome crosshatch sear marks. This
crosshatch searing isn't really essential for the cook, but it sure does look cool, doesn't it?
Anyways, once the steak is flipped, shut the lid and let it continue to cook. At the 10 minute mark
for a steak of this thickness, you do want to start checking for doneness. I'm not a professional chef,
so the finger poke method doesn't quite work for me. Instead, I'm going to use a meat thermometer.
For medium rare, I want about 125 degrees Fahrenheit. And as you can see, I'm actually
not even close to that. I'm actually not 100% sure why. There can be any number of reasons why the
steak is cooking slower today, but no matter what it is, just shut the lid and let it continue to
cook. I've been checking my temperature periodically, but finally, after 15 minutes of total cook time,
we finally reached our target temperature of 125 degrees F. This should now be a perfect medium
rare, so I'm going to pull this off of the grill. Now, I can't quite dig into this right away.
You need to let steak rest for about 5 to 10 minutes before cutting into it. So, after that
5 to 10 minute rest, let's finally carve into the steak and see how I did today. I'm using a brand new
Misen utility knife to cut today, and wow, is it sharp. But drum roll please, and check it out.
Pink throughout, a perfect medium rare. And another look at the reverse angle. So, in the end, my
time took a little bit longer than I expected, but as you can see, the results turned out
absolutely perfect. And this is a very important lesson when grilling steak. Weber grills,
professional chefs, or even YouTubers like myself and others may recommend certain cooking times for
certain types of meat, but at the end of the day, cook to temperature and not to time. Of course,
use our times as guidelines, but use a meat thermometer to verify doneness. I've got a link
to the exact thermometer that I use down in the description below. All right, all right,
enough talk. Time to try a bite of this delicious looking steak. Mmm, spectacular. But as always,
don't believe me, let's see what Huey thinks. Yeah, that's pretty tasty. Give this cook a try
for yourself and let me know how it goes for you. Thank you as always for watching today.
Don't forget to like and subscribe. I look forward to see you all again next week. Bye now.
