Clay Holmes | Profile & Projections | 867

Talkin Yanks
1 follower
Jul 25, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe discussion centers on New York Yankees closer Clay Holmes, analyzing his polarized performance from the previous season. The speakers debate whether his early-season dominance was offset by a late-season collapse due to fatigue or injury, and they suggest a more cautious approach to his usage in the upcoming season to ensure longevity.
Adobe
slash clay
Welcome back to throw profile projections and players
Clay homes the Yankees closer question mark
Yeah, Adobe
Yeah, like clay homes Adobe
Right, they'll be houses. Have you ever used that in a burn? I think so
I think it was one of the first from the first ones doubt it
I think no one's ever said that before no Jim clay homes. Let's zoom Adobe houses
Can I sit? Oh, hey Norm. Can I zoom out?
Yep, clay homes had an incredible year
kind of
did I
Mean if I think you zoomed out if you zoomed out too much I did Jim
That's kind of the whole exercise 62 games
63.2 innings pitch a 2 5 4 era 20 saves a 102 whip all-star year
75.8% ground ball percentage
What we know is it's kind of the tale of two kitties
One of the best first half so you can put together
Pre all-star break 41 games and maybe there's your problem
131 era and then post all-star
22.1 innings of 484 era and we saw his control leave and we didn't know if it was slot or fatigue or maybe it's
both
There's a lot to like but there is also a lot that put a big fear in us
Yeah, yeah, I think you can say an amazing first half
In a bad second half which like the first half covers up the bad half
Holistically stat wise so I don't know if that's zooming out or zooming in but
Didn't have a great year year to year
hold home
Yeah pole to pole did not have we're zooming in we're zooming in yeah
I think when you so when you zoom out, it looks good when you zoom in you're like, oh wait
The first half was great. The back half was actually not
Good at all from July 31st on he had a 5 7 9 era
He made he pitched in 18 games and gave up
12 runs
Control issues and all that now you want zoom in again?
It's really well in the
AL
DS against the Guardians, but then Jake if you want to like, okay, what's the full picture here?
Because he didn't do great in his Houston game. Well
maybe you pitched him too much in the first half and relied on him too much in the five game set and maybe this guy
needs to be spread out and
Maybe treat him like how you're treating all the other positions on the team and just like don't
Declare him the closer right away like you did last year and you give yourself wiggle room to
Not overuse him unless you think this year he's built up to be used that much
and maybe we should have started with the nastiness and the good stuff and the great vibes, but
Man, that it was a bummer and let's a little bit because he for the Yankees
Remember and it was a tale of two seasons for the Yankees, right?
Like and Clay Holmes was part of the reason they were as successful as they were man. I mean he was
Lights out games were over
And it's it's almost now putting together the picture and the shortstop conversation
We've had so much like Clay Holmes and Mike King
Covered up like they won the game was over those dudes were
Miraculous that it almost covered up which in a normal season or for another team
You're gonna lose a couple of those games
They were perfect. Like Clay Holmes was a cheat code man. You could almost zone out in the ninth inning
So let's let's give him credit for that. He obviously adapted to Matt Blake in the gas station and I
Don't know what injuries did or didn't occur
But either way there was injury or fatigue that came from him being so so good
In the first half of the season that it ended up putting the Yankees in a funky spot
That he and he should he deserves a little credit for how he pitched in Cleveland because it could have easily
You know the Yankees didn't he was rehabbing basically in the DS
And he survived enough that yeah it coming into this year. I kind of like where you're at like
He should have this the first hack at it
Because it's not like he was doing the same thing and getting crushed. He was wild
He was erratic and it wasn't the same guy
So if he looks like that, I think he should have the first hack at the closer roll with you know
Not too much promise to him shouldn't be like taken away from him, right?
But you can just say yeah Clay's our main closer, but we're not gonna overuse him to start the season because
when Chad went down last year and
Brin who else all went down that led to it being clay and King
Chapman did he go down or was he cute? I think he did go down at one point. It's a beginning right effective
kind of blanking bad and injured maybe
Zach Britton was out. Yeah, Brin was out
I mean Chad went down early and Chapman. Did he just lose the role right away or
They get at least one such a blank
And get in there, but either way
either way, I
Don't think because you shouldn't strip him of the closer or all but
Let's just be a little more cautious with his usage and all that because you're right
He did get used a lot when they were good. They needed him to but
You got all their arms or I don't know, I don't know
I don't know. It has to be something of note to keep keep him
Going the whole year and a lot of sinker pitchers. They they do better throwing a lot. But what what happened?
I hope they know I hope there's an injury. We don't know about there's something we don't know about
Because when he was on he's like just so
nasty a
Pitch that is just a demon
Demon spanker. So do you really fun to watch?
I just I want to would you count fatigue in that same bucket as injury? Like are you?
Putting that cautious of cautious of that like it was the most he was ever used, right?
It has to be yeah
Yeah, and it looks like Chapman if you remember Chapman actually got out to a good start to the year
He had a clean April. I think his first 13 games our first 12 games
It was at least like I think he was walking guys
But it was survive give up a run and then Chapman got gave up runs in
Six straight games and then I think that's when clay had and it looks like he missed all of June
So there's a little bit of that
Yeah, I mean it's as we record this March 2nd just being honest with the people yeah
It would be it would be nice to see him and and see you know
The demon sinker should still be there and he's he's gonna be 30 soon
Man he was so good. It's it's it sucks at that. Hey never do in August again, you know
Yeah, the Yankees
clean innings
For clay. He's this is how the Yankees use relievers and and versus other teams and stuff
And a lot of times they don't give their guys clean innings, but he's a clean in guy, I believe
He also the other like
worry sided and because talking about a
Good clay Holmes, there's not much to say it's almost
and this is not a comparison to
This the level of skill or pedigree, but just the repertoire of Mariana Rivera
I mean, it's just throw that good pitch
Like what more could you say if clay Holmes is good, and we just want to do a whole
20 minutes on hyping up clay Holmes
It's hey
his sinker is nasty and he should throw that good pitch when when the games on the line and
He's the closer so if I'm searching for things to watch for notice
He does have the potency
Chapman
Boy, if he's wild Yankee. Yeah, like instant like whoa
Whoa, and they started doing that
Yeah
And they started doing that with Chapman when when they needed to and and yeah
It's like if that first pitch goes over the catcher's head and hits the backstop
Which I believe he did in the postseason and then overcame it
But it is just like Oh clench your ball because this is gonna be a little scary
Yeah
You almost he almost gets two pitches like that
We saw a couple times the first one would go and then he'd be like, oh and then he'd bring it back and you say
Okay, let's let's go first batter. Yeah, but
Yeah, there's that and hey the one thing I want it. He would time his slider
Beautifully when he was in that rhythm like you'd see him
come on and be like first batter sinker sinker sinker next batter sinker and then like
When the batter would be all geared up for one of the better pitches in baseball
He dropped that slider and it would be beautiful. So it's timing it and in making it
effective when you use it and that was
That was when he was struggling. He'd sometimes hunt out that slider too much and that became a problem
That's it's a little Chapman feature as well
So
He's half horse half robot. Do you mention that in here?
You like talking about that. I mentioned the Adobe thing which is brand new so you can do the whole new ish
I'll work on my new my new ish
Matt Blake clay Holmes Brian Cashman, you know, this is one of the ones in the good bucket here
um, I
Don't know. I mean what else needs to be said?
Not much man, I hope he is stay is healthy and throws that one good pitch
Yeah
yeah, and I mean if if you're if you're gonna do things if you're the Yankees and you've got a you know, you're
99% gonna be in the playoffs. You're you know
50% or 25% chance
You're gonna be one of the better teams in baseball and you're gonna worry about
Nestor's pitch counts and stuff you kind of have to treat the bullpen the same way and and maybe we'll have frustrating moments in
April in May, but after seeing what happened at clay Holmes last year, like I'm I'm open to that
Like I if there's if there's a game when it's you know
Clay Holmes pitched two out of three days in May and they give Johnny or Mike King the closing shot instead
Like I I think we and the Yankees need to be okay with
It's easier to say now than in the moment
Yeah, but yeah divvy it up if you if you don't have Chapman when he was Chad
Moe when he was Moe like if you don't have one of those guys then don't pigeon your
pigeonhole yourself into
Having one of those guys because it's easier
to let other people get the experience and the chance and and trying it out in the regular season then
Then not
Which is why saves leaders numbers aren't the same like when Moe was leading in saves every year
I think every AL closer at 40 saves and Moe would lead them now
I think like if you have 40 saves and in the American League you are the saves leader
I don't know if those things that I just said are correct. Sure, but I believe them to be somewhat close
And speaking of somewhat close, why don't you get yourself some seat geek code John boy
Preseason 15% off whether you're a first-time buyer or not or not
So 15% if you're going to anything, why would you not want to save 15% on it?
And you should do it with seat geek download the app. It's so easy a Jake can use it their words not mine
Click the link in the description John boy preseason 15% off at Siki. Why not? Why not?
Why not? Do we have a yo ver yonder?
there was a
30-foot lead with 42. It's a nice number
What did you say it glitched out on me? They said games finished at 34. Oh
The old games feel James finished. That's how we measure players
Good arbitration stat, how many GF have last year?
32
That is 62 games
Well, it took a month and a half to get there and then the final month and a half was a mess. So
yeah, but let me like go look at like about this or all this like what what's the normal GF's for a
The closer
Okay, so Chapman had 46
in 2021
53 in 2019 43 42. So what number did they give us for clay 34? I'll
say over
It's been a little bit of an overfest which we don't like I'll go under just cuz I do think Jonathan Lewis ago
Mike King
have really good chances to get involved this year that even if
Like if clay Holmes gets off to a slippery April
Like it's open. Don't say that
But no, I'm not even saying that as a bad thing Jim
Like any reliever can get off to a slippery April just cuz I don't say slippery April. I mean it rains a lot
It's the number one rain month dude. Be careful. Take care of yourself. You're gonna be a father of two soon. No the months
April showers bring May flowers. I understand it, but you're acting like it's a bad thing you on May flowers
I think it can be a better thing for the team Jim and clay Holmes cares about the team
So I'll go 33 and a half this year for clay. I was actually doing 34 and a half taking the over
So we're very similar
Nice. All right. That's the episode. See you later cue the music. It's the Yankee
