Why "Genuine Leather" Is the Worst Leather (Watch Straps Explained): Masterclass Part 4

Classic Watches & Style
2 followers
1 Video View·Jul 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis guide explains how to evaluate leather quality for watch straps, debunking marketing terms like \"genuine leather\" and explaining the differences between full-grain and top-grain hides. It covers tanning processes, construction techniques, and maintenance tips, while reviewing various brands from budget-friendly options to high-end artisan straps to help consumers make informed purchases.
Is genuine leather the best leather? What's the difference between full grain and top grain?
What is nubuck versus suede? Is a strap real alligator leather or cowhide embossed to look
like leather? Why is this strap right here around $950 and this strap right here about $40?
Where do I buy a quality strap? What tanneries are reputable? Why is Shell Cordovan so hyped up?
Between both parts of this video, I should answer all of those questions, so just stay tuned
and hopefully I'll answer everything you want to know about leather straps.
Welcome back. This is the leather video, the deepest category in this masterclass. If you
haven't seen the prior videos covering rubber, fabric, and bracelets, please check them out.
I've obviously spent a lot of time and money on all these different projects
to do these masterclass videos. Please also, if you could do me a favor and hit that subscribe
button down below, I obviously make these videos for you guys to watch for free,
and the only thing I ask is that you guys help support the channel. If you could,
it would be wonderful to help grow this whole thing. Just hit that button down below.
Obviously, a lot of money, time, and energy went into these. Otherwise,
hopefully you guys enjoy watching this video and you learn something by the end of it.
Now, quick honesty note before we start, the same as every video in this series,
a lot of these straps were sent to me. Every gifted strap is going to be marked on screen
and listed in the description. Nobody paid me money. Nobody previewed this. The whole point
here is to teach you how to judge straps for yourself, so it'd be pretty stupid for me to let
someone buy a good review. If your favorite isn't here of the brands, it's not a snub,
I couldn't buy all of them, so that's just how it is. That being said, I did buy several straps
from different companies in order to show what the whole spread looks like from expensive to
the more affordable end. Today, we're doing cowhide and calf. We're doing all those typical
sorts of leathers you're going to get out of most of the straps. This video was originally
broken down into three sections, cow and calf leather, and then suede, and then exotic,
and one big video, but it was an hour and 30 minutes. I asked you guys which one you'd prefer,
and you asked me to split the two separate videos, so today is just cowhide and calf leather.
Then in the next video, we're going to be covering parts two and three related to leather,
and that's suede and nubuck and exotic straps. We're also going to be covering lining in that
video, like this piece of Zermatt here, which is a calf lining that's done on most watch straps.
If you're interested in lining or suede or exotics, check out that video. It's going to
be linked down in the description down below. At the end, I'll tell you the ones I'd actually
buy or my favorites of the whole bunch. Every section is timestamped down below,
so jump to wherever you need, but the lessons do kind of build on each other,
so if you can watch it in order, it is better. First question from the top,
is genuine leather the best leather? No, it's near the bottom, and there's a law behind that.
The law about leather labeling. In the US, it's an FTC rule, and what it does stop companies from
selling is fake leather as real leather. What it does not do is define quality. There's no law
anywhere that defines full grain or top grain or premium. Those words are industry habits,
but they're not regulated standards. So here's the proof. The leather industry itself once asked
the FTC to add official definitions for those grades, and it never happened. So genuine leather
just legally means this contains real leather. It's the floor, not a ceiling. And in practice,
the products wearing that label are usually made from the leftover lower layers of the hide,
split off, and coated in a plastic finish and stamped with a fake grain pattern. Now,
one thing that the rule does draw a hard line on is bonded leather. That's scraps of leather
that's kind of glued together in this weird sort of mishmash sort of thing, and that's not called
genuine leather. That is bonded leather. Now, because the words are unregulated, it's important
that you trust two things instead, the named source and what you can see with your eyes,
and I'll give you both of those things. Now, the three things that grade actually means,
when people say leather has a grade, they're usually mashing together three completely
separate terms. System one is which layer of the hide. The hide is like a cake. You look at the top
layer, that's the full grain. That's what the whole top layer looks like intact, natural marks
and all those little scars and pores are the real feature. They're the proof of the real surface.
Top grain usually means that the very top got sanded down to make it uniform. Typically,
there's imperfections like bug bites or other things. The sanding helps make everything look
more uniform and therefore top grain is a more easy substitute, but it does get rid of the
strongest fibers right there along the top. A fair warning though, top grain is genuinely used in two
different ways in the industry though, so it tells you less than you'd hope. It doesn't always mean
that it was sanded down. Sometimes people use it interchangeably with full grain. Below that
though, you get the splits, which is the lower portion of the hide, and this is where suede
comes from, and then genuine, and then the leftover is blended up and used in bonded leather.
That's all the scraps and the glue we talked about earlier. Bonded is just like the particle board
of leather, so I would avoid bonded entirely on leather straps and in most leather goods that you
can possibly buy. When I talk about splitting leather specifically, I mean something like this
machine right here where you take a piece of leather, you set it in the machine. If I were
selling this leather, now Butter-O isn't typically like this. They'll usually use it in a more
full application, but this top right here, this is the full grain. This is the good stuff,
and you can see the grain pattern of what the top looks like versus what the bottom looks like.
This has a lot of loose grain. You can see it's starting to fall apart. The top grain's even
tighter. It's very solid. You can't see any differences between them. This right here
technically would be top grain leather. This right here is full grain leather, and this bottom side
right here is the flesh side is suede. That is the construction of leather when you're looking
at different grades. The other option is obviously sand this down into this. That's also top grain,
so you got rid of this top layer. You're down to the second layer. That is how the splits look like,
and if you're getting genuine leather, it's typically going to be taking this right here,
and it's actually going to be running it through a second pass. Now, if you look at this right here,
you can see the grain's even looser than it was before, so here we have what would be full grain
here on my left. This is top grain right here, and this is genuine leather on my right, so full
grain, top grain, genuine leather. Because this is made from the lower portion of the hide, you can
see how loose each of these grains is compared to this one, and obviously this one compared to this
one. This is solid. This is a little bit less solid, and this right here, I can even start to
stretch it, and you can see all that stretching happening because the grain just isn't as tight
lower down in the hide than it is as you look on top grain or especially something like full grain.
System two is tannery grades, A, B, C, D. Now, tanneries grade hides by cosmetic cleanliness,
how many scars, bug bites, brands. The A to C grade hide doesn't mean that the A is better.
It just means that there's less problems. It's more clean and has more usable area.
Most hides have some defects, which is exactly why corrected grain or top grain exists as a
category. When a brand says grade A leather, that's about the looks and the yield of the
actual hide itself, not about strength or quality of the tanning. A brand blurs grade A into sounding
like a durability claim, they're either confused or hoping that you are, so I wouldn't take that
to mean anything. System three is the finish. Aniline means leather dyed with transparent dye
only, no coating, every pore is visible. Only the cleanest hides can pull that off,
so it's the most premium and natural finish. It also is the most delicate. Semi-aniline adds a
thin protective coat. Pigmented means a heavier opaque coating, which is the most durable and
the most uniform, but it's the least natural. None of these are best. It's natural beauty versus
armor, but notice a brand will tell you when one axis flatters the product and stay silent about
the other two, so that selective silence I think is the tell. Now one more trap, the word grain
itself means two different things, but brands blur them, meaning that one of them is the hide layer,
full grain, top grain, meaning that we already covered, meaning two is the surface texture.
Pebble grain, scotch grain, saffiano, that's a pattern, not a layer. Now what it means actually
is that they sanded off that full grain we talked about earlier, usually this is what they do
because it was too damaged to use, and then they stamp an artificial grain back on the top, so if
you have something with a cool texture on it, like Epsom is a very common leather, this Epsom grain
doesn't mean that the grain is the quality, it just means that it's a grain in terms of feeling.
Now there are two balances on that. One is that embossed pattern itself is permanent, it's pressed
under a heated plate, it doesn't wear off, and it's usually done with like a wax coating as well.
It can even toughen the surface slightly and hide scratches. Now two, the honest thing is that
sometimes pressed grain like saffiano or crosshatch finish that you see on a lot of luxury
goods is openly known as a pressed and waxed texture. No one's pretending that it's a natural
full grain finish, but it is genuinely durable and scratch resistant. So the issue isn't that
pressed texture is bad, it's that pressed texture is used to disguise a cheap hide in some instances.
Now one refinement, embossing and correcting are two different operations. They don't have to
travel together. Correcting means sanding the natural surface away, embossing just means
pressing a pattern. You can emboss a full grain hide without sanding anything, the grain layer is
still there. Disguising sanded off cheap surface, that's the corrected grain and that's the trap.
So the difference is underneath and whether they tell you or not what is underneath I think is the
more important part. And the real one here is the durability catch. The heavy wax coating that's
used on these pressed textures can flex over time and crack. So usually what doesn't last is the wax
pattern, not the hide underneath. So you do need to keep that in mind that that wax can fail sooner
than the actual leather that would be there underneath it or is there underneath it. Okay,
so the next important part is how it was tanned. That's that part underneath that we're talking
about. Now two words that are used all the time, vegetable tanned and chrome tanned. Vegetable
tanning or veg tan takes a month or two. It uses tree bark tannins that gives you a firm leather
that starts stiff and ages into a more beautiful patina. It's also a bit more sensitive to water
and sun. Chrome tanning takes about a day. It gives you a soft, color fast, water resistant
leather right away and it's how somewhere around 90% of the world's leather is made. Now neither
of those is cheating. They're different tools. Heritage and dress straps lean veg tan and that's
because that aging character. Everyday and sports straps lean chrome tanned. That's for toughness
and color. And the in-between you see named on good straps is a combination or double tanning
like Horween's Chrome XL. They chrome first and then a heavy veg re-tannage and then it's hot
stuffed with oils. So you get a suppleness and you get patina. You get that pull-up effect where
the color lightens when you bend it. I bought a panel of the real thing for my bench. So watch,
the color pales across the bend. That's the oils migrating and then it buffs straight back with my
thumb. It's just a really cool leather and people like it a lot because it has that extra resilience
and it has some of the benefits of both those different options. Now one health note,
most leather is chrome tanned and the chromium used is chromium three. That's the safe kind.
The problem is that under heavy heat and aging, a tiny amount can convert into chromium six
or hexavalent chromium. That one is the one that's most common causes the itchy rash that
some people get from a leather strap. Europe takes it seriously enough that there's a legal limit.
Leather is sold and has to be under three parts per million chromium six and they're in the process
of tightening it further. So if a leather strap ever gives you a rash exactly where it touches
the skin, it's probably not an allergy to the leather itself. It's likely this or it's the other
usual suspect and that's the nickel that's in a cheap buckle. A reputable tannery or a veg tan strap
or better hardware is usually the fix to these issues. Now this is just another reason why you
need to check the specs on the strap and why the tannery really matters. Now the next step here to
look at is thickness. When it comes to leather thickness, it gets quoted in two ways. That's
and the ounces is just the thickness converted. One ounce is about four tenths of a millimeter.
So a leather listed as four to five ounces or this butter on this case is seven ounces is going
to be about 2.8 millimeters. So it's important to know thicker is not better. A dress strap wants
to be thin and supple around two millimeters so that it matches the case profile while a sported
or padded strap is built up four or five, even six millimeters for that chunky feel. The right
thickness suits the watch. It's not the quality score. The padding changes how the watch feels
on the strap. A padded strap fills the gap underneath the lugs and occasionally makes
the watch head look smaller. It's all about proportions here. An unpadded strap matches
slim watches best because it often can look too small for thicker sports watches. So neither is
right but if a watch feels top heavy on leather, a lack of thickness in the strap might be part
of the reason why. And two things the good makers do with thickness. One, where on the
Now the firm, dense, even leather is the back and what the tanners call the butt of the bend
while the belly is looser and stretchier. So quality strap is cut from the firm part,
not from the belly. And two, with thickness, you need to use a skiving tool here, a skiving knife.
This means that you use this to shave down the leather right around where the spring bars are
and the buckles are so that it bends cleanly and finishes off neat instead of fighting you
like a stiff slab. Now for the construction, most people assume that one solid thick piece
of leather is the best and it usually isn't. Almost every quality strap out there is actually
two or three layers. The top layer, that is what you see on top and then the lining underneath.
The third layer is typically either filling and sometimes there's a fourth layer as well,
we'll talk about here in a second. The fact that there's a layer in between is not a shortcut,
it's correct. The lining does real work as well on the bottom and that's for comfort and for sweat.
We'll talk about that in the second section. Now the two thinner layers flex better than one
stiff slab, which is why those thick solid one piece of leather options are definitely hunky and
they're harder to break in. But that doesn't mean they're wrong, it just means that they might be a
little less comfortable than one that had a really nice lining on the inside. Again, we'll talk about
in the suede section. Between the top and the lining, Goodmakers hide a thin stabilizer.
Classic one is this non-woven called Velodon. Its only job is to stop the strap from stretching
and deforming over years of buckling. For exotics that are thin leather as well, these can be great
to keep everything stable and avoid any stretching, pulling or problems that can come with thinner
leather. This stuff is solid and incredibly hard to stretch apart and I feel like it's something
most people don't even know exists. I certainly didn't until I started doing this video.
Now the cheaper alternative is something like this, this is Salpa. This is a bonded leather
and people can hide this as the padding inside a watch. The only problem with bonded leather is it
doesn't have that grain pattern and so it doesn't stay as tough. It doesn't stay together and so you
can get cracking and problems related to something like this. The correct actual padding material,
because this Velodon isn't a padding, this is a stiffener, is going to be actual veg tanned
leather. Now if they're padding it at all, that's what you want to have on the inside. Then the top
layer and then the lining underneath it. The ones that are a single thickness are also not crap,
they just might not be as comfortable as one that's lined like we talked about earlier.
Now a quick word on how to judge a strap. What you're going to notice right away if you look
at these two next to one another, these are supposed to be the exact same color, but you can tell right
away this one has a much waxier finish to it. You're also going to notice a difference here
on the edges. You see the stitching along the side. Stitching that runs in a line like this
is typically machine stitching, almost always machine stitching, whereas stitching that runs
on a diagonal like this is typically, although not always, done by hand. The difference between those
is machine stitching is basically the loop going one into the next, whereas hand stitching uses
something called saddle stitching. The reason why saddle stitching is nice is because each of
those stitches work sort of independent of the other stitch next to it, meaning each of these
loops operates independently. So it is a stronger, better stitch. Not to mention obviously it's done
by hand and therefore has that extra touch. The other thing you're going to notice on the inside
is the lining. That's important to know because on the inside here you can see where the lining
was sort of added on and you see the edge of it right here. This lining runs all the way to the
end. So this has a little edge that goes beyond. The lining also is two different types of leather
as well, which we'll talk about in the lining section. You can see even where the lining ends
solid at the top here and there's a little extra thickness, which is why you can see a little bit
of the grain texture of this top one poking through, but you can't see any of this one.
Now obviously this has been shaved down a little bit because I tried to use it on my Rolex Explorer.
I bought this a long time ago. The edges are also a giveaway. If you look at the edges of this strap
versus this strap, this looks like it was just like it's glazed on with this gel-like paint.
It's thick. You can feel it. It feels like latex paint in its thickness. This feels like the leather
itself. The edge painting is there, but it isn't standing in for the edge itself. This is kind of
glazed on and I can feel it flaking away. It's very plasticky and this edge right here feels
like leather underneath my hand. Those are really the only tells, but again this is a less expensive
strap. Now while the machine stitching is something you can choose if you want one machine
stitching versus another or you wanted something like this is a full grain leather strap from
Watch Gecko and this is in the Artisan straps. We'll talk about each of these brands a little
bit later and while this full grain strap here from Watch Gecko is machine stitched, it doesn't
make it bad compared to something like Artisan. It just means that they take a little extra time
to hand stitch each of these straps. Plenty of machine stitched straps hold up for a very long
time, but there is a difference between the two and it's important to notice them. The other thing
to mention here is the thread itself. Waxed linen, the famous one from Phila Chinois from France,
is rounded matte stitches. It's the traditional dress choice. Braided polyester is the famous
one from Ritza Tiger from Germany. It's flat, colorful, and basically bomb-proof. Neither is
better, but both of them should be even and unfrayed. But some of the stitching can be done
well and some of it can be done a little sloppy. This Hodinkee strap, like I mentioned, you can
see the stitching on there. It looks a little sloppy. While they tried to double back and do
these stitches into it multiple times, you can see that, like on this Watch Gecko, a little bit
clearer. You can see the double stitching back here and back here where it gets closer to the
spring bar where it actually carries the load. That makes sense, but it should be done cleaner than all
three of these being done in this sort of hodgepodge of mash stitching. I find this to be
not the best version of what stitching should look like. Obviously, this Watch Gecko is closer to what
stitching should look like in the best case. And then if you're going to buy something that's
hand-stitched, you also want to see double stitching up there at the top where it meets
the actual spring bar. All of that is important to see in either of these straps, that double
stitching is there because that's important. It shows you that they're taking the attention to
make sure that they have a really solid amount of load resistance on the stitching near where it
reaches the actual spring bar. Now, the last thing I didn't mention for edging is the actual different
ways you can edge it. Now, the typical way is that you actually just paint it so that it's the
same color, but it's just a smooth finish on the side. The other option is you actually burnish it.
This is where you take a burnisher, this is a rotary burnisher, and you basically run the wood
with this extra little coating on top and it helps finish everything off and give it a shiny texture
to it and give it a little protection. And it's very natural, like that's the cleanest way to do
it, but it is very uncommon to find that on watch straps because you want the color to be all the
through. And because it's layered, you want to hide the fact that there are layers to it
for most watch straps. So that one's not done very often. The best option is actually folded.
They'll take the top layer, wrap it around whatever filler they're using on the inside,
which should be veg tanned leather, and then stitch it underneath the lining. This is a
Jean Rousseau strap that I'll show you guys a little bit later when we talk about exotics.
And you can see the texture of the actual alligator runs along the inside and back
underneath the bottom layer of the lining here in the strap. And that right there is the hardest
thing to do because you can't sand it back down later. If you accidentally size it incorrectly,
the inside with the padding, and you glue it all up, and this is 0.2 millimeters too wide,
well then it's not going to work for the strap because one, it won't fit, and two, it'll wear
down over time as it rotates in the lugs. And so you're throwing it away and making a new one.
So folded is the best way to do it because it's both the structurally the best. It also has the
best look because it's fully correct all the way around. The problem is it's the hardest to do.
And so you typically only see this on really high end straps will actually fold it underneath
the lining. Now there are two things that no brand can fake though. And outside of all the
stuff we already talked about, and that's the brand of the tannery itself, a named tannery
in France is worth more than every other grade word combined because a tannery name is checkable.
There are reputations on the line and the willingness to name the source is the quality
signal. Brands that name nothing and just use adjectives is one of the things you should
probably avoid. You'll see the whole spectrum today, including brands that name the tannery
on like their best straps and then they're vague on everything else. So check the strap you're
buying, not the brand's best story and make sure that each of those straps says exactly which
tannery they're buying the leather from. The second is time. It's the only test you can really
run and that's to own something for a long amount of time and see what it looks like. This is a
collar up strap and you can see these deep creases as I basically wind it up and down. You can see
them on the inside as well. But the difference is as I stretch it all the way out, you'll see
there's no cracking whatsoever. While these decreases are forming, it isn't cracking at
those creases and that's because this is a solid piece of leather that was tanned at a reputable
tannery. And so you have, you know, a nice piece of leather here that while it is aging and you can
see the patina, you can see the marks, you can see the marring, you can see all the reactions to the
fact that it's stretched and has these creases, you're not seeing any of the cracking that would
occur of a lower quality strap. The only problem is the only way you're going to know that is
owning it for a long amount of time. Full grain develops character, but cheaper leather obviously
is going to crack and fall apart. Now this section is all about living with leather, knowing the fit.
So the standard length is about 115 by 75 millimeters. Most brands sell a long and a
short version as well. The tail should land a few holes in so the keepers actually catch it. If you
always end on the last hole, you need to go short. If you're on the first hole, you need to go long
and the hole you use every day will slowly oval out. That's normal. It's also the first place a
the same way the holes were the first thing to go on my nylon straps in the last video.
Leather and sweat are enemies. Sweat darkens leather, stiffens it, and eventually rots the
stitching. So three habits to fix most of it. Wipe the underside after a hot day. Give the strap a
day off between wears so it fully dries out. Rotation isn't just for fun. It genuinely helps
them last. In the middle of the summer, I moved to rubber and fabric because leather doesn't swim
unless you have something like a rubberized calf, which we'll talk about later, and it doesn't do
well in the middle of summer either. For me, leather is like a three-season strap and that's
fine unless it's not a hot day in the middle of summer. You get those cool days. The buckle also
matters. So if you don't want to have that sort of creasing problem over time, switch everything to
deployants. It's going to be the best way you make your leather straps last over time is to not use
a buckle and to use deployants instead. Everything I possibly can, I do switch to deployants. I'll
buy some from brands and I'll swap everything over to those. It's an easy swap and I highly,
highly recommend it. If you really want your straps to last, condition them once or twice a
year at most. Over-conditioning though, over softens the leather and darkens it. So store
straps flat, not on the watch, and suede and leather, make sure you brush it. And for normal
leather, condition it every so often, maybe twice a year. Now that's the foundation. Now let's talk
through the brands of Cow & Calf straps. So first here we have Artem. And I've talked about Artem
straps in both the leather and fabric videos. They make high quality straps at a high price point.
This here is their Bar-A-Nia leather straps. And Bar-A-Nia is a high quality calf leather that's
really supple. It's really oily and it's got a nice texture and look to it. It's used by Hermes
and that's where it got its big claim to fame. As far as I understand, it's tanned in Bar, France.
It is a high quality leather strap. I really like the way these things look. They bend nice. The
oils look good on the inside. This seems like a really high quality leather strap. It comes on
typical deployant clasp. I love the look of them. They're nice and padded and they have a nice
structure to them. And yet they have nice suppleness when it reaches the clasp. I really
love these straps. This is their Babel leather. It's a premium vegetable tan Italian leather
famous for its unique cloth-like rich texture and it's naturally woven style appearance. So it has
this interesting texture to it. This is in green. Really interesting application. It's unlike any
strap I've seen or any grain pattern that I've seen before. But this is another example of artisan
and I'll talk about them in a lot of these different videos. Really going out of their way
to name the tannery and I really appreciate that so you know exactly what you're getting on your
wrist here. This shows a side-by-side of two artisan straps that I've had for a while. The
tan one that I've had for a long time and the red one here on my Explorer 2. Both are really
different textures but you can see the same sort of hand stitching that they have on the entire
exterior. Here this red version on my Explorer is just a nice strap. You can see all the tannery
information down below. You can see the wear of the tan one and how the hole is ovaled out over
time because I don't wear it on a deployant. As I mentioned you should prior to this but it's a
nice looking one that I've always enjoyed. This right here is a Barton strap. This is no taper
on this thing so it's 21 mil and it looks like it's 21 mil at the end. This is a genuine calf
that's been embossed to look like alligator. The big thing here is going to be obviously the fact
that it's a top grain leather and it's advertised as top grain leather and it's coming at a good
price point. However I do not like the feel of this strap that much. It's very very stiff, hard
to break in. The padding was really rigid and I didn't really like the texture, the embossed texture
on the outside. It looked like it was a little over the top. The scales are not that realistic
and the taper that isn't there is not my favorite. Barton does do a nice strap in terms of the quality
of the leather that they're using at the starting point. There's obviously a price point to it so
you have to wonder where that price is coming from. This is Belang & Sons. Now I'm going to
cover a couple straps they do here. This is their bun strap and I think this is just a really cool
application of it. The original classic bun strap that Steve McQueen wore was actually a square shape
and the cool thing is you can actually take the bun strap off and now you have two straps. The
inside here you have nice lining on the inside. It looks like a zermatt lining. It wasn't called
out on their website that I saw but it does look like a really nice lining on the inside. The feel
of it is nice. I'm not a huge fan of bun straps in general because they don't fit my aesthetic
but this is a cool looking strap and it's a nice fit for the Speedmaster. You do have to worry about
size of the bun strap and the size of the watch you're putting it on to make sure the watch's
head isn't overwhelmed by the size of the square strap that it's sitting on. That is something to
consider when you buy a bun strap but I do really like the look of it and the concept of the style.
This is the Green Racing Strap also by Belang & Sons and I love here with their British Racing
Green the aesthetic of it. It isn't like your typical rally strap. I thought it had a nice
character to the way that the holes were punched and the way that the texture sits on the outside
face of the strap. It just was a unique look and the color of it is a very rich perfect British
Racing Green is what it felt like and I thought it was a great compliment to the speed timer here.
Really like the look of this strap. This is the original Cartier strap that came with my
Cartier or Santos to Cartier. You can see I've got a stain on it already that I probably need
to cure out but it's a nice high quality strap. You can actually see here that the stitching
looks like it's machine made. It isn't made by hand and that isn't totally wrong of most of
manufacturers. Almost everyone that you buy from of these high-end manufacturers get it machine
stitched. You can see that it's got a nice taper to it. It's nice and thin and you need to have
a thinness to match the Cartier buckle which you'll see when I show it on the exotic straps as
well but it's a nice application. It's got those unique integrations into the case so you can't
really try new straps. You have to buy from them or from someone who makes a version of their
integration. This is a collar strap. Now I've shown this earlier in the video so you saw what
wear looks like on a thick piece of leather on a strap that you've had for a long period of
time. I thought that the look here was really nice. You can see the wear obviously. The forend strap
here was something I originally found out about from TGV. It bought me into leather straps and I
really did enjoy this for a long period of time. It is a little too thick for my preferences these
days and I don't like the stitching and the line there where it meets the case. I also am not a
huge fan for how this leather patinas and the fact that every scratch shows up in this kind of rust
color. It isn't my aesthetic. It looks a little more on the casual side. I think it fits with a
more casual presentation which is not how I wear most of my watches these days. However, on the
Deployant Clasp here from Tudor, it's just a nice look and I think that there's nothing you can go
wrong with buying a strap like this particularly for the price point it's sold at. Now this right
here is the Fluco. This is the Rally strap. I've owned this for a really long time. It's a solid
piece of leather. It's what Fluco does really well which is just make a good strap at a decent
price point and I think this thing has served me well for a long time. I wore this originally on my
original Speedmaster Reduced about probably four or five years ago, maybe six years ago now.
This thing is worn in perfectly. It barely's aged. Now I haven't worn it like crazy but it still
looks almost as good as it did the day that I bought it. This right here is another strap from
Fluco. This is their Horween Shell Cordovan strap. I wore this thing on the Day-Date as soon as I got
and it is one of my favorite straps. These things are hyped up because of how
Shell Cordovan rolls. It doesn't crease the same way a lot of leathers do because it went through
both chromate tanning and veg tanning. It's got an amazing suppleness to it and yet a nice rigidity
meaning that it is going to last a long time and I think the way this thing just kind of moves and
shifts and doesn't bend and crease and cause the same sort of issues you see on like low quality
straps it gives you a really good indication of what a high quality piece of leather should feel
and look like and I think that is why everyone wears these straps. It's why everyone talks about
Shell Cordovan like it's a holy grail because it's just a really nice piece of leather that just
ages so well and the fact that it can bend without breaking without creasing I think is a huge reason
why. Not to mention it feels nice on the wrist. It's not as nice as if it was lined with Zermatt
or with pigskin lining but it is a nice leather strap. Now this right here is going to be a Hadley
Roma strap. This is the cheapest strap in the whole group that we're talking about here
and you'll start to notice that in some of the ways this thing creases. The oils move the same
way it does on the other straps but it tends to stay there in a different way. The creases tend
to stay on the strap and this is sort of what I'm explaining when I was talking about the
Collareb strap creases but doesn't crack long term and with this Hadley Roma while they make
great straps this is one of the more budget-friendly straps and what you find with budget-friendly
straps is that the age shows faster. The same thing happens with shoes as it does with this as
it does with all leather goods which is that when you spend more money you tend to get more use out
of it because it doesn't age or look like it's been worn in quite as early. This right here is
a Haviston strap. This is a single pass leather strap that goes underneath the watch. They have
a cool little buckle here with a double prong which I thought was just a unique look. This is
high quality piece of leather however the back here isn't backed at all it's just the leather
cut and spliced and then edge treated so it did feel a little thin on my wrist as I was wearing
it and I wasn't a huge fan of that however the aesthetic of this thing is awesome. The tail also
sticks out a little bit which I wasn't a huge fan of but the aesthetic is really cool if you're
looking for a vintage single pass leather strap. Now this right here is a Hurst strap. I talked
about this in several videos including my Day-Date review. I just love the lining on the inside here.
You'll see more of this thing when we go into the suede and nubuck straps in the next video.
The outside here has this nice embossed texture. It's machine stitching however it's done
really well. This is an example I think of a manufacturer who's been doing it a long time
and knows what they're doing. Even the buckle is really nice. This is their Kansas strap. This is
a budget version for Hurst. This is a much cheaper option than the other one that I showed you and
you can see that in the stiffness of the leather and how it feels. You can see even where you know
the keeper is integrated. There's a little space there. It's just not quite the same level. The
taper is not as aggressive and so it looks a little bit more utilitarian and so I wasn't as
big a fan of this strap but it does give you a good representation that Hurst obviously sells them
up and down the spectrum in terms of price point. I'm a fan of the more expensive ones. I would
recommend to you to always buy the more expensive one however the Kansas strap here is still a nice
aesthetic if you're looking for it. This one right here is just so nice. It's a beautiful strap. It
feels so different than the Kansas strap I just showed you before so when you wonder what you're
spending your money on frankly the feeling and you can see a little bit on an appearance end
of the two straps and how supple they are and how they look you get that same feeling when you wear
them and I think that this strap is just a beautiful integration. I've been wearing this
almost constantly on my day date here and I think it just looks the part and it's one of the straps
that's really stood out making this whole series is one of the ones I probably love the most. So
this right here is the IWC. This is their OEM strap. It's a solid piece of leather. It's got
these integrations that are really cool that IWC does where it just basically snaps on the top
which is neat because you can always take it off and put different straps on. You don't have to
use their system but when you do use it it's a really nice quick exchange system. This is the
typical flight looking solid piece of leather. High quality. I'm assuming full grain leather.
It's not advertised that way as far as I could find but the stitching here is very flight oriented,
pilot oriented. It's nice and thick. It wears in great. You notice that it ages well. It's just a
nice strap. These are REM straps and I'll talk about these because I love the fact that you
can customize straps these days that someone out there is doing it. These straps are so neat. I've
worked with them multiple times. They've made three straps for me and they've all come out
fantastic. This was made for my IWC with none of my input. This was a design that they had and I
really love the look of it. I love the fact that it's handmade up in Sweden and I just think that
the feel and look of this is perfect. The sentimentality here of El Tri is just why I love
it so much. You can customize these straps to feel like they belong to you. This is as far as I know
one of the few if not the only one that he made related to the Mexican soccer team and I absolutely
love it. Not because it's limited but because it means so much to me and the way these look like
this looks on my IWC with the rivets at the top and the little airplanes. It's just such a cool
look and I love the fact that you can get these customized straps like this. It's just something
you don't see all the time. One of the watches that I really want to wear the next World Cup
that comes around or the next time I get to see Mexico play. Hopefully if they beat England this
next time. This is an RSM strap. This is a calf skin that's been embossed to look like alligator.
However, this is the best version in this entire video that you're going to see of what that looks
like. Nice Zermatt lining or what looks like Zermatt lining on the inside. They've got the
branding. They've got the nice stitching. Quickly spring bars. Nice buckle integration. Now I've
talked about RSM multiple times but the way that this feels in my hand feels a lot more like actual
matte alligator than any of the other ones you saw earlier. It's not too padded. It's nice and supple
and the aesthetic of it. The way that the scales look. The way that it's nice and thin. All that
stuff looks very much like my actual alligator strap and that's what's cool about this particular
one is for the price point. The tannery is a nice tannery in Japan as well that does a really nice
job and it's a beautiful look. You get this cool gray tone on this strap and I just think if you're
going to buy a calf embossed strap, this is the one you should probably consider looking at or
one like this where they name the tannery and they're honest about where it came from. Now
this right here is a full grain strap from Watch Gecko. I mentioned it earlier in this video
but you can just see the stitching color and the pores in this particular piece of leather.
The padding integration. The keepers. The way that the buckle looks. All of this stuff I think
is the perfect example of what a vintage inspired solid full grain piece of leather should look like
when it's done in a watch strap. I absolutely love the aesthetic of this. This is again one of the
straps that stood out in this whole video as a really nice high quality looking and feeling
strap. The leather on the outside just looked perfect. It looked exactly like I'd want a strap
to look. This is another strap from Watch Gecko. Again, high quality piece of leather. Nice buckle.
Nice integration. You can see the oils move as I start to bend the strap which again is another
tell to show you when it's a nice piece of leather that you can see the oils move around
but the creases don't stay there. The lines and wrinkles don't remain within the strap.
This is another piece of leather that's just really nice. I like the look of it. I think it
leans more vintage so it's not one that I'm going to wear all the time but it's nice. It's another
Watch Gecko strap. This is their Safiano. Brixham Safiano strap. You can see the ingrained pattern
we talked about earlier so I'll mention it here again. Nice lining on the inside. I don't think
it's their matte but it does look like a decent lining on the inside. I'm not sure what exactly
it is however the pattern and color and stitching color that they did here I think were carefully
considered and it's again a nice high quality strap. I think they do some great stuff over at
Watch Gecko and I do appreciate getting to look at this particular strap and some of the other
ones that I purchased. Okay so if you guys are still watching congrats. Thank you so much. Let
me know in the comments below. It's crazy. This has been really a lot to put together. Now the
last two questions at the top. Who should you buy from and who do I prefer? So these are the picks.
So if you're trying to buy a strap and you want that full grain vintage look then get this Watch
Gecko strap. This thing has the best pores, the best look, the best stitching color. This thing
just really looks the part and I really enjoyed wearing it. I think that this is definitely what
you should go for. If you're looking for something more like a Horween and it's a different character
than something like a normal calf strap I would recommend something like this. This is the Fluco
strap for the price. This is just a beautiful strap and with Horween leather it's just really
supple and I think it's going to be a beautiful long lasting strap for you. If you want just a
standard calf style strap that has a nice texture on it this Hirsch strap is what I would recommend.
Absolutely love the texture on this outside. Nice stitching and on the inside this lining is
incredibly comfortable. I'm really a big fan of this and obviously a big fan of Hirsch in general.
I mentioned them in multiple videos that we did for this series. If you want to get something that's
a little more unique though still made out of cow or cowhide then get something like this strap right
here. This is REM. I absolutely love the fact that you can customize these straps. Big fan of soccer.
My father-in-law is a big fan of soccer as well and so I just really love the fact you can get
these custom straps that mean a lot to you. So that's been leather. That's been the whole video.
Hopefully this has been informational for you guys. If you haven't seen the other three videos
you should check them out. I am considering doing more videos in this series not related to straps
but more master class style videos of deep dives and different subjects around watches. If you guys
have suggestions for those types of videos let me know in the comments below. Then I know you really
made it to the end of the video but let me know in the comments below what you'd suggest for the
next deep dive I should probably do that's going to be 30 to 40 to an hour long. Other than that
thank you guys so much for watching and supporting this channel. I'll see you in the next one. Take care.
