DJ LeMahieu | Profile & Projection | 870

Talkin Yanks
1 follower
Jul 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
DJ 26 with another one. Bam. Not today.
Welcome back to Player Profile and Projections. David John goes long gone.
Your favorite homerun call as DJ LeMayhew comes back from an interesting 2022 where it seemed
like he wasn't going and then he got going and then we lost him and that also tied in heavily
to the part of the Yankee season that wasn't a lot of fun last year. DJ LeMayhew, a .357 on base,
a .734 OPS, third year of his six-year $90 million extension. Played some good third,
played some good second. Jamalope, we missed this guy when he was out at the end of last year.
We did. Boone said he was a shell of himself and couldn't play on the postseason roster.
I mean, I guess no one's disagreeing with that as the right decision, but
yes, guy's a big game changer for the Yankees just in what he can do at the top of the order.
They really seemed to want him at the five last year. I'm interested to see where he's
going to hit this year if he is healthy. But yeah, at the leadoff spot, what he provided
and then just like a different approach, they got him and then they traded for Benny to have
some different approaches in the roster lineup last year and they lost both. He's a big piece,
man. He's not going to go win the home run competition, which is what everyone calls it,
or outslug anyone, but just a different at-bat that can drive people crazy and
see pitches, some big homers and clutch spots. We need him to come back and be himself. There's
some quotes here about him and his injury that should be good, I think. There's also
something that should be bad. I don't know. Give me some quotes. What do you got quote-wise?
Well, D-Law, the Dylan Lawson, the Law of the D, the hitting coach, he said last year with the
injury that DJ couldn't load the way he wanted to. He couldn't stay on the backside, which is
where the power's generated from and the slugging numbers were down a lot. Maybe that's juice ball.
Maybe that's injury. But he said that none of that's there now. And at minimum, he's back
maybe a tick beyond where he was. So fully healthy. Those are the good quotes. DJ says he's
The weird quotes are that he didn't get surgery this offseason because he went to a bunch of
doctors and they all had not a difference of opinion on which surgery on if he should get
surgery or not. They had a difference of opinion on which surgery he should get. That's wild.
That's tough. What are doctors about, man?
I don't even understand. I need to deep dive into that so much more.
Should I ask Dr. Chris? I've been waiting for a reason to D.M. Dr. Chris Amat because now that
we're you know, I do a lot of stuff on Twitter. We're insta friends like and that's a tighter net.
So I'll message him. I don't think I'm going to get a response now, but I'm not going to mess.
I'm so scared of him. He's like treating people and stuff like he's going to diagnose me.
Yeah, I mean, I remember we were doing December episodes and, you know, you you're normally a
little more conservative on the injury timeline and we were having some talks. Are we going to be,
you know, going into May without DJ LeMay? Like, are we going? That was our original like,
oh, Glaber definitely can't get traded because DJ's hurt. I remembered we did a couple on those.
So it's glad to hear he's in spring training healthy. Is he playing in his first game
as we record this? I think yesterday yesterday this was didn't he play the good lineup? That
was the last thing last year's lineup. Wasn't he in that? Yes, he was batting leadoff. So yeah,
I'm I'm it's the position stuff, man, which I know we feel like we're we're cycling on.
I was tough on DJ playing third base last year. I, you know, watching when I was in Colorado,
seeing Arenado live like change change my perception of the position, obviously seeing
Manny Machado and some of the great third baseman, even Josh Donaldson, you normally need a special
arm to play third base. I don't think DJ necessarily has that. What he does have,
he has a quick release, which a lot of middle infielders have that he makes the play in
defensively. He graded out fantastic at third that I like him at third base. I like him at
second base. Feels like he's okay at first. The Yankees kind of forced first on him when they
need it and it feels like he hates being over there and talking to the base runners. My sister
had that first. It's just with this current infield construction and how important DJ is to the team
and the lineup in the offense. Is he going to be in there? Is DH going to come into play if we're
um, if DJ Lemay, he was healthy. He has to be in the lineup, especially over some of the other
options. He has to, I mean, it's the second year we've been saying this and he asked you and,
and God, I don't know what Donaldson provides that we don't already have. Even if Donaldson's
playing to his 70% of his abilities as a hitter, we get a lot of thump and pop and walk from other
guys. You know what I mean? Like even if Donaldson's at 75% of what he is when he's at his
best, I still think the versatility and the different look that DJ provides is, is more
valuable just from lineup construction. Um, so he needs to be in the lineup. I found some quotes
to go deeper into the whole surgery thing. Uh, DJ said, and this is an article on ESPN with uh,
Marley Rivera, one of our favorites. He said foot surgery was definitely under consideration,
but we weren't sure if we wanted to do surgery on the big toe, the second toe or both.
So we chose rehab. I think it's the right decision. How about, I mean,
yeah, I mean, DJ, DJ, close your eyes. I'm going to tell, I'm going to pinch you and you tell me
if it hurts. That doesn't hurt. Okay. That was your second toe. I mean, am I Dr. Ahmad or what?
I just pinpointed it. It's his big toe, not to quote John Sterling, but how do you like that?
We don't know what toe it is. Um, wait, hold on. Also in this article,
there's just some quotes here that sounds like not DJ Lemay. You, uh, cause he, he opened,
he started both sentences. He started one sentence here with I'm excited,
which had to sound like this. I'm excited. And then the next sentence is I'm so excited.
I'm excited. I'm so excited. I'm excited. I like bouncing around kind of the same role I've had
the last few years here. I really like playing different positions and moving around. I think
it fits with my skillset and our team. Well, yeah. Lion. Um, just a reminder. So Jim, you know,
it's funny as we get disconnected from the baseball season, we're like, you know, we're
remembering Domingo Hermon starts and you're trying to picture one and it's, you just feel
so disconnected from last season. I'm now remembering DJ had a little bit of a funk
and then he started drawing a ton of walks and then we're, I was wanting him to start hitting
more. I was like, wow, he's done so many walks. He needs to start. Why are you on his ass so much?
Sounds like you're just always on this guy. I have high expectations. We're such similar guys,
kind of muted, silent guys that can play a lot of positions tall. Um, from May 31st, 31st of May
to August 8th, which is around the time he got injured. DJ LeMayhew three 17 batting average.
Good, good. Four 35 on base. Great. Good. Nine 10 OPS. Great. He had 46 walks and 30 strikeouts.
That is elite elite stuff that when he was right last year, he was that good. Like
MVP vote DJ LeMayhew that when he got hurt and when it started to go bad, it really hurt the
team and it stunk for him. I mean, he tried to come back at the end of the year. Uh, it clearly,
it was affecting his hitting, not his defense. We had some of those weird quotes, um, that I'm,
man, I'm really excited for DJ LeMayhew cause he was a big part of the missing recipe for the
that was May 31st to when August 8th and his slugging was four 75. So that's a great sign.
So if that's his healthy stretch, which is, is, uh, you know, 59 games COVID season,
the sluggings up four 75. So, cause a lot, a lot of, well, some of the questions are like, is,
was it the juice ball that helped his slugging and those line drives got to the wall?
Some got over or was it, um, or is it his health that's hurting the slugging? And
I think we'll see. But if the fact that that stretch, which is decently long enough exists,
I'm saying juice balls, go screw yourself. He can hit anything. I also had three stolen bases
in that time period. So he was so healthy. Dude can hit anything. Um, you get hit by a pitch
around that time or something. How'd he hurt himself? Um, I don't know. I mean, they still
don't even know what toes hurt, man. They, they got nothing, man. I do. You think the doctors
were like, give me anything. He's just like, it hurts. I almost, I almost DMed Chris again.
I can't almost, it hurts, doc. It hurts where down there, doc. Where toes my foot.
I've got it down to two toes. DJ doesn't feel limbs. He just feels high or low. Everything's
just below or above the belt. Yeah. He just points. Well, I mean, all right. Say he's healthy,
Jake, which they're saying he's healthy. Is he the lead off batter? They don't really have
a lead off hitter. We saw them just play him before we record this in spring training at
the lead off spot with kind of like the a lineup for the homo home opener. But if you remember the
game one last year, it was not DJ in the lead off spot. It was Josh Donaldson.
And, and it seemed like they wanted to try and get DJ, um, down a little like in the fifth spot.
Yeah. I mean, he ends up hitting lead off a lot. He ends up hitting lead off in 90 games out of his
125 games played. I think the Yankees and you and I have always been a little differing on this. I
think the Yankees were looking for another option. I don't think that was a shot fired at DJ. I think
they wanted more lineup options. Cause the Yankees love lineup options. DJ is a fantastic
lead off hitter. Um, that I think it's absolutely his gig. Um, and especially like I, there was a
conversation when Benny was there. Cause Benny has lead off hitter qualities. He get, he was getting
on base. He was slapping it around like of all the other options it would have to be for me,
it would have to be if Glaber has fully clicked and it looks awesome. Or it would be like if
Volpe's the boy wonder, but they won't even give him the call. So for me, it's not even a question.
I agree. But I mean, you have to admit that, you know, in the first two weeks,
DJ was the five hole hitter last year. They tried, I think like three guys before they were
like, all right, **** it. Let's go back to DJ. Um, it feels like anytime they want to like try
something new with the lineup, it involves getting DJ somewhere in the middle there and
getting somebody else. Let me pull it up. Um, first 14, first 13 games, he batted lead off
once they tried Rizzo there twice, Donaldson five times Hicks four times before being like,
all right, it's DJ. And then he stayed. But what do the Yankees do in the first two weeks every
year? They don't, they don't take it in real life. And then when real life happens, they went
back to him. So I think they wanted options. They, they would have loved if Hicks was good
and he could lead. So do you think they're going to try to do that again this year? I mean, I've
never seen him do that before, but I think DJ is a lead off guy. I just think, I think they like
Bader as the five who came out and actually said that he likes him at the five. They asked him if
they like Bader lead off. And he was like, nah, I like him. He said middle to the back of the
lineup, which is just like backup lineup. Yeah. Or, or that's just five or six.
If he's healthy, he's the lead off guy. Yeah. I mean, I don't, I can't even see you could give
me a Rizzo argument, but we use him so much as balance in the lineup. If they had other lefties,
you believe outside of that, like, you know, I'm not in the court of law anymore. I'm a doctor
with Chris Ahmad. We have a practice. I don't want that diagnosed DJ. There's nobody who has
an argument to lead off. They just don't it Bader's judge. I mean, I mean, judge can do
whatever he wants. Bader. I mean, I, I just got a little sad because how cool would it have been
if DJ was setting the table for judge during the home run race last year, you know, the, those
lead off at bats. If DJ was starting games with singles and then the stadium was erupting,
that would have been dope. Um, I mean, Bader has an, like, I, I see where you're coming from with
Bader. He's, he can kind of be the, the new age lead off hitter. That's got a little bit of pop
and he has speed, which DJ doesn't, but he's got a career three 17 on base and that's, you know,
judge, they want judging that two or three hole. And it feels like DJ needs to be one of the guys
before him. Yes. I mean, I'm not, I want, I'm saying DJ is the only option. I'm just presenting
the conversation. I don't want it to be spewed as a me calling for a different lead off guy.
I thought it was weird. They did it last year. I think it was just a hunt for options. Yeah.
Oh, I do disagree there. I think they wanted to lengthen the lineup DJ five and get someone else
up top, but it didn't work out. I don't think they tried this year cause there's no other options.
Um, and then DJ says he likes playing all over the infield. So I guess he's going to play all
over the infield. Um, maybe he just knows. I don't know why he should just play third.
Well, that was, that was what I was going to do. And maybe this isn't our over under,
maybe it's our secret question of the day for John boy, John boy, preseason seek geek
code. John boy, preseason 15% off whether you're a first time buyer or not. So if you're going to
anywhere where seats are sold, concerts, spring training games, the real regular season games,
download the seek geek app. They show you on their green, good, red, bad,
bomb. You figured it out. Code John boy, preseason 15% off your next order. Download
the app or click the link in the description. If DJ Lemay who Jim plays 140 games and I'm going
to Matthew a little bit here, so I'm sorry, but it's what we do on this show. If DJ Lemay who
plays 140 games next year, at what position does he play those games? Uh, okay. He played 125
last year and played like 40, 40, 30. Same thing. So that's 50, 50, 30. How many games you won? 30.
Did you say? Yeah. One, I said one 40, but I'll, you know, any number will do 52, 52. The rest
that was second and third. Yes. But 52 games at second base means that labor Torres is not
playing between Glaber being 52 games and that's ignoring the kids, which we can't even talk about.
I get, that's where it just, it gets funky. Obviously injuries take course and you can't
plan that. And that's where DJ is an incredible weapon, but yeah, it's a funky split with the
roster. Um, one 62 minus one 40 equals 22, 22 games at second base for DJ one 40. How many
games did you give me one 40? I gave you one 40 and uh, you just did, I guess I wish I made it
50. I don't know if that would even help. And we're 118, 118, not at second base.
I see what you did there. I'm with you. I'm in lockstep so far.
That means he's got, uh, 80 games at third base. That's huge. That's big.
80 plus, that'd be one Oh two. So 38 at first. And maybe I can even chop 10 off that with 10
DH days. He had seven last year, five DH days. He's going with five. So for those at home,
um, give us your, you know what we we're supposed to do more of this. Subscribe to the channel,
leave comments, podcasts, YouTube, wherever. Give us your 140 game positional DJ LeMay.
He was split because I'm, I'm copy and paste with Jimmy. He had my exact numbers,
which were remind them. It was 22 games at second base. It was 80 games at third base.
That's a lot of games. Yeah, that's great news. And then it was five games at DH,
which I believe left 33 games at first base. I was paying attention.
Who's getting the other 82 at third Donnie and Ozzie. Yeah, probably.
I have an aside. It's March 2nd. Volpe just hit a home run and the official Yankees,
a Twitter account, uh, referred to him as AV. His name's Volpe. I mean, we don't need to do
an AV situation here. Like we have JD and DJ, like it's, it's don't need everyone's nickname
to be there. Volpe is Volpe is a good name. We don't need an AV Volpe. I mean, if he really
starts going Tony V, like we've got so many options before we get so many options before
we go acronym on them. All right. It doesn't strike me as a very acronym name. Doesn't need it.
Not a lot of syllables there anyway. I'm like DJ LM. Be the best DJ. Do we have an over under
from hats? No, I think we did a John boys positional question of the day. Great. So
that's good news. Oh,
final take, Jim. Don't eat bugs. Save your lungs. Wow.
